General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsKilling North Korean civilians 1950-1953
I hear we killed more North Korean civilians during the Korean War than we killed Japanese civilians during WW2. Is that true? I am not bringing this up to excuse the current NK leadership.
Dreamer Tatum
(10,926 posts)Iggo
(47,566 posts)atreides1
(16,093 posts)But US forces did kill South Korean civilians at No Gun Ri, under orders from their command!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Gun_Ri_massacre
Dirty Socialist
(3,252 posts)malaise
(269,157 posts)to North Korea or her citizens - and apparently most don't care.
Dreamer Tatum
(10,926 posts)It's nice to see all the Hannah Bells come out of the woodwork, finally.
EX500rider
(10,858 posts)Dreamer Tatum
(10,926 posts)is to toss millions of one's own citizens into work camps, don't you?
EX500rider
(10,858 posts)countryjake
(8,554 posts)https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/the-us-war-crime-north-korea-wont-forget/2015/03/20/fb525694-ce80-11e4-8c54-ffb5ba6f2f69_story.html?utm_term=.2655b99b151e
~ snip ~
The hate, though, is not all manufactured. It is rooted in a fact-based narrative, one that North Korea obsessively remembers and the United States blithely forgets.
The story dates to the early 1950s, when the U.S. Air Force, in response to the North Korean invasion that started the Korean War, bombed and napalmed cities, towns and villages across the North. It was mostly easy pickings for the Air Force, whose B-29s faced little or no opposition on many missions.
The bombing was long, leisurely and merciless, even by the assessment of Americas own leaders. Over a period of three years or so, we killed off what 20 percent of the population, Air Force Gen. Curtis LeMay, head of the Strategic Air Command during the Korean War, told the Office of Air Force History in 1984. Dean Rusk, a supporter of the war and later secretary of state, said the United States bombed everything that moved in North Korea, every brick standing on top of another. After running low on urban targets, U.S. bombers destroyed hydroelectric and irrigation dams in the later stages of the war, flooding farmland and destroying crops.
Although the ferocity of the bombing was criticized as racist and unjustified elsewhere in the world, it was never a big story back home. U.S. press coverage of the air war focused, instead, on MiG alley, a narrow patch of North Korea near the Chinese border. There, in the worlds first jet-powered aerial war, American fighter pilots competed against each other to shoot down five or more Soviet-made fighters and become aces. War reporters rarely mentioned civilian casualties from U.S. carpet-bombing. It is perhaps the most forgotten part of a forgotten war.
~ snip ~
Since World War II, the United States has engaged in an almost unbroken chain of major and minor wars in distant and poorly understood countries. Yet for a meddlesome superpower that claims the democratic high ground, it can sometimes be shockingly incurious and self-absorbed. In the case of the bombing of North Korea, its people never really became conscious of a major war crime committed in their name.
(credit goes to Warren DeMontague for finding this piece)
malaise
(269,157 posts)They don't want the facts. USA USA!!!
Yet for a meddlesome superpower that claims the democratic high ground, it can sometimes be shockingly incurious and self-absorbed. In the case of the bombing of North Korea, its people never really became conscious of a major war crime committed in their name.
EX500rider
(10,858 posts)....the US was there under the flag of the UN with other countries defending S Korea.
UN Forces:
United States
United Kingdom
Canada
Turkey
Australia
Philippines
New Zealand
Thailand
Ethiopia
Greece
France
Colombia
Belgium
South Africa
Netherlands
Luxembourg
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korean_War
Warren DeMontague
(80,708 posts)If he had just listened to Truman and stayed away from the Yalu, the Chinese likely wouldn't have gotten involved, and peace negotiations would have taken place with Kim Il Sung in hiding, and UN Troops occupying something like 80% of North Korea.
North Korea as the totalitarian, paranoid shithole it is today probably wouldn't exist.
uponit7771
(90,364 posts)... river and history would be different on that peninsula.
In many ways McArthur reminds me of Trump; thinking he knows more than he does ... and fucking shit up while living.
http://www.fsmitha.com/h2/ch24kor4.htm
Warren DeMontague
(80,708 posts)The Chinese bear some responsibility, as well, of course. They are the only ones who could conceivably still go a ways towards fixing this.
countryjake
(8,554 posts)...or what we've done to any other nation on this planet, either!
Dreamer Tatum
(10,926 posts)countryjake
(8,554 posts)and "stopping" the advance of communism must never be criticized.
Collateral damage is such a lovely term!
EX500rider
(10,858 posts)...from N Korea.
Dreamer Tatum
(10,926 posts)With Russian signoff and Chinese support.
Odd how I don't see anyone asking how many N Koreans were killed by Greek or Ethiopian soldiers.
countryjake
(8,554 posts)...a positively brilliant amerikan term.
Dreamer Tatum
(10,926 posts)countryjake
(8,554 posts)Dreamer Tatum
(10,926 posts)EX500rider
(10,858 posts)Or is just the US the evil one? lol
malaise
(269,157 posts)at imperialists posing as Democratic folks.
Some are quite selective at which slaughters of innocents are important.
I think Mark Twain should be required reading.
Response to malaise (Reply #41)
Dreamer Tatum This message was self-deleted by its author.
countryjake
(8,554 posts)that nearly slay me when I see any attempts to justify.
Destroy a nation's people to save it.
Mark Twain?
Dreamer Tatum
(10,926 posts)Since 1953, show me one instance of even a whiff of a threat to take N. Korea, let alone "destroy" it.
Democrat or Republican, please show me a credible instance of this Yankee Imperialism.
EX500rider
(10,858 posts)....the only one guilty of that during the Korea War was North Korea.
whathehell
(29,090 posts)For some, it can only be Big Bad 'Murica to blame.
whathehell
(29,090 posts)He was 23 years old at the time and suffered from PTSD for the rest of his life, until he died at age 59
War does bad things to everyone involved.
sarisataka
(18,773 posts)With the price of kimchi in Daegu?
Dreamer Tatum
(10,926 posts)when Bush and Ahmadinejad were jawing at each other, there were a few (just a few) DUers who (maybe jokingly, maybe not) wished that Iran and the US could swap leaders.
sarisataka
(18,773 posts)Of sympathy for countries that started Wars. Surprisingly there isn't any mention of Sympathy for the countries they invaded just complains about casualties taken when un Nations, yes led by the United States, freed the nation's they conquered.
Warren DeMontague
(80,708 posts)I don't think that asking questions and being open and honest about what really went down has to have an agenda.
Dirty Socialist
(3,252 posts)I think the Korean War was justified, even though MacArthur screwed up.
Are you trolling here?
Dreamer Tatum
(10,926 posts)No.
EX500rider
(10,858 posts)Casualties and losses:
Allies
Total: 178,405 dead and 32,925 missing
Total wounded: 566,434
NK & China
Total dead: 367,283750,282
Total wounded: 686,500789,000
Total civilians killed/wounded: 2.5 million (est.)
South Korea: 990,968
373,599 killed
229,625 wounded
387,744 abducted/missing
North Korea: 1,550,000 (est.)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korean_War
Revanchist
(1,375 posts)Think about it: Japan mainly consisted of naval battles (few civilians), reclaiming occupied islands (few civilians), and bombing missions (greatest chance of civilian casualties) while Korea was a land war with our forces pushing northward towards the Chinese border. If either type of conflict were to produce large amounts of civilian casualties it would be the second one.
B2G
(9,766 posts)Hmm?
Warren DeMontague
(80,708 posts)the WaPo not that long ago, on this topic:
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/the-us-war-crime-north-korea-wont-forget/2015/03/20/fb525694-ce80-11e4-8c54-ffb5ba6f2f69_story.html?utm_term=.ea967b297cdb
Short answer, yes, we bombed North Korea mercilessly during the Korean war.
I believe the war itself was justified- and actually, if MacArthur had just listened to Truman and kept UN troops a reasonable distance from the Yalu, the outcome would likely have been very different- however, the massive bombing may not have been necessary, to put it mildly...
Regardless, I think it's important to understand what actually went down as part of grasping the psyche of the people in North Korea.
Dirty Socialist
(3,252 posts)BainsBane
(53,069 posts)That seems improbable to me.
I did a brief google search and I wasn't able to find numbers of Korean casualties or civilian casualties. I did see good sources for US military casualties, which range from 36,000-55,000, depending on how the military counted them.
Warren DeMontague
(80,708 posts)casualty count than, say, the firebombing of Tokyo.
Curtis LeMay claimed the bombing killed 20% of NK's population. Basically, the idea was to bomb everything - carpet bombing - in North Korea much bigger than a shack. LeMay's statement may have been exaggeration, but most estimates seem to put the # of civilian dead in NK at at least 1 Million. By comparison, Hiroshima killed between 100,000-150,000, and Nagasaki around 80,000.
http://www.newsweek.com/us-forget-korean-war-led-crisis-north-592630
https://www.quora.com/US-carpet-or-saturation-bombing-resulted-in-the-destruction-of-every-significant-population-center-in-N-Korea-resulting-in-several-million-deaths-Why-do-Americans-know-so-little-about-this
some grim shit, right here:
http://necrometrics.com/20c1m.htm#Ko
None of this, of course, is to excuse the NK's regime's behavior, not from my perspective at least, but I do think understanding the psychology of the people is important when we talk about why the country is so isolated, paranoid, and fucked up.
BainsBane
(53,069 posts)Just awful.
Dreamer Tatum
(10,926 posts)They got bombed 70 years ago. Ergo, work camps. Perfect sense.
Warren DeMontague
(80,708 posts)Naaaaah, actually, I'm pretty fucking sure it isn't.
I'm not sure why we have to ignore history to be able to formulate a cogent moral critique of the atrocious regime in Pyongyang. Are we allergic to historical facts, now?
HELP! SAVE ME FROM THE DANGEROUS AND SCARY FACTS!
Dreamer Tatum
(10,926 posts)when that family has been murdering millions of its own for generations now.
Warren DeMontague
(80,708 posts)But I don't see the problem with having a historically accurate conversation about the history of the place. It's like the creationists who wet themselves at a mention of geological history beyond 4,000 years ago. Breaking out in hives at any information which might prod thinking beyond the most base level.
I'm not on some moral tear around the Korean war. I think the difference between North and South Korea today is all the proof anyone needs to show how justified the thing actually was. I think the bombing may not have been a good idea, clearly- but denying it or pretending it didn't happen doesn't solve anything.
Honestly the only judgment I put on the whole thing, retroactively again, is to say fuck, I wish MacArthur would have listened to Harry Truman.
Dreamer Tatum
(10,926 posts)especially when it appears that some are trying to sanitize the N Korean regime just because they
hate the dickhead in the White House.
Warren DeMontague
(80,708 posts)it drives me bonkers, too. I hear what you're saying.
Dreamer Tatum
(10,926 posts)but I don't need to be in this matter.
Dirty Socialist
(3,252 posts)Dreamer Tatum
(10,926 posts)Honestly, what?
Are you trying to make a point, or are you playing the most obscure game of Trivial Pursuit ever made?
Response to Dreamer Tatum (Reply #48)
Post removed
Dreamer Tatum
(10,926 posts)Dirty Socialist
(3,252 posts)LexVegas
(6,095 posts)Bullshit.
Dirty Socialist
(3,252 posts)LexVegas
(6,095 posts)LexVegas
(6,095 posts)hrmjustin
(71,265 posts)Blue_Tires
(55,445 posts)Codeine
(25,586 posts)Not Ruth
(3,613 posts)Generic Other
(28,979 posts)He summed up their reaction to the South Korean snack in one word: "Ecstasy."
Much like what Twinkies are to Americans, South Korea's Choco Pies -- two disc-shaped, chocolate-covered cakes, sandwiching a rubbery layer of marshmallow cream -- are ubiquitous, cost less than 50 cents and are full of empty calories.
But on the other side of the Korean border, the snacks are viewed as exotic, highly prized treats, selling on North Korea's black markets for as much as $10, according to analysts. Their rising popularity in the north reveals an unexpected common ground between the two Koreas, despite their fractious relationship -- a shared sweet tooth.
http://www.cnn.com/2014/01/27/world/asia/choco-pie-koreas/index.html
Its the battle of the Choco Pie.
Under normal conditions, the South Korea-produced Choco Pie is more or less available to North Koreans thanks to the Kaesong Industrial Complex, where South Korean businesses employ thousands of North Korean workers on the cheap. Since the complex opened in 2004, South Korean businessmen have parceled out untold thousands of Choco Pies as bonuses to the North Koreans. And the workers, in turn, have created a burgeoning Choco Pie black market.
Its difficult, according to analysts, to overstate the Choco Pies cultural impact in North Korea. Its not just two chocolate cakes hugging a marshmallow mixture its capitalism, delicious capitalism.
Former North Korean defectors living in South Korea prepare balloons containing snacks called "Choco Pie" and anti-Pyongyang leaflets before releasing them towards the North near the demilitarized zone separating the two Koreas in Ganghwa, northwest of Seoul April 24, 2012. REUTERS/Lee Jae-Won (SOUTH KOREA - Tags: POLITICS MILITARY FOOD) - RTR31531 Former North Korean defectors living in South Korea prepare balloons containing snacks called Choco Pie and anti-Pyongyang leaflets before releasing them towards the North near the demilitarized zone separating the two Koreas in Ganghwa, northwest of Seoul on April 24, 2012. (Lee Jae-Won/Reuters)
By some estimates, as many as 2.5 million Choco Pies were traded monthly though its unclear who exactly was so assiduously following Choco Pie markets.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/morning-mix/wp/2014/07/01/north-korea-has-reportedly-banned-choco-pies/?utm_term=.89f36d6c2363