Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

babylonsister

(171,070 posts)
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 06:06 AM Aug 2017

I Am the Alt-Left, Mr. President

http://johnpavlovitz.com/2017/08/15/im-alt-left-mister-president/

john pavlovitz
Stuff That Needs To Be Said


I Am the Alt-Left, Mr. President
August 15, 2017 / John Pavlovitz


Mr. President,

Thank you for giving me a name today.

I wasn’t quite sure until now, but you helped me find myself.

“Alt-Left.”

That’s what you said.

That’s what you called me, what you called us.

Apparently of the two supposedly equally hateful sides in all this—I belong to that one.

Opposite us in Charlottesville this week (on the other side), I saw men with torches and handguns, men screaming “blood and soil”, men intimidating clergy, men beating people with pipes, men screaming anti-Semitic slurs, men so fueled with rage for strangers, that one of them plowed his car into a crowd of them.

Heather Heyer was among that crowd, Mr. President.

Heather Heyer died there in the street.

That was her name, since you couldn’t be bothered to learn it.

She was 32 years old.

Heather was apparently on this side.
She was among the Alt-Left you condemned today.
She was one of us; the supposedly equally hateful ones, the alleged partners in this carnage, those you claim to be equivalently culpable for the bloodshed.
She was to blame.

Heather marched on behalf of people she didn’t know, but valued greatly.
She spoke for people who are so often silenced by people like you.
She stood for those who are pushed to the margins of this life by people like you.
She declared the worth of all people, regardless of the color of their skin or their sexual orientation or their religious beliefs.
She lived this way; open-hearted, generously, sacrificially, humbly.
She died proclaiming that another life was as precious as her own; that every human being is intrinsically valuable, that every person is worth dying for.

And if that is the Alt-Left, Mr President—you can count me in.

That’s the side I choose. That’s the side I will live and gladly die with.

I want to be on Heather Heyer’s side.

I want to be on the side of equality.
I want to be on the side of justice.
I want to be on the side of compassion.
I want to be on the side of decency.
I want to be on the side of love.

I want to be on the side that stands opposite men with torches and contorted faces and taunts and pipes, and weaponized vehicles targeted at strangers.

I want to be on the side that stands opposite those screaming “blood and soil”; those consumed with rage for people because of their pigmentation or their God or the person they love.

I want to be on the side that stands opposite the preachers spewing venom and damnation upon those who are working to make this country as diverse as Heaven is supposed to look.

I want to be on the side that stands opposite those who believe their bloodline or their place of birth makes them superior to anyone.

I want to be on the side that stands opposite racists and Nazis and radicalized Christian terrorists.

And I want to be on the side opposite you, Mr President, because you’ve made it clear where you stand.
You’ve made it clear your allegiance.
You laid it out in black and white.
You shown us all which side you’re on.

You are on the side of the men with torches and contorted faces and taunts and pipes, and weaponized vehicles targeted at strangers—and I find that unacceptable.

You are not worthy of this country, you aren’t worthy of leading our people, you aren’t worthy of the beautiful lives you endanger with every second of your hateful, fraudulent, toxic tenure. And most of all you aren’t worth the grief hateful people emboldened by you produce here.

And so yes, thank you for crystallizing it for me today; for all of us.

Thank you for aligning people of every race and religion, every age and orientation, every native tongue and place of birth; the millions who will not stand by you or with you—but against you.

Thank you for showing me where I want to be in all this.

Thank you for choosing the sides for me.

Yes, I am the Alt-Left, Mr. President.

If those opposing bigotry, discrimination, and dehumanization are Alt-Left, then I will be that too.

And I’m in good company.
51 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
I Am the Alt-Left, Mr. President (Original Post) babylonsister Aug 2017 OP
kick for visibility....n/t bluecollar2 Aug 2017 #1
Yes! Many of us agree Scarsdale Aug 2017 #2
+1!!! THIS Dustlawyer Aug 2017 #3
K&R tweeted yuiyoshida Aug 2017 #4
+1 lark Aug 2017 #5
K&R! Docreed2003 Aug 2017 #6
K to the R! Ligyron Aug 2017 #7
That alt-left is the Antifa. Not everyday people or Democrats. nt Honeycombe8 Aug 2017 #8
I don't believe that's true. Per dt, babylonsister Aug 2017 #12
People that support single payer.. disillusioned73 Aug 2017 #19
Wrong. kcr Aug 2017 #34
Well.. disillusioned73 Aug 2017 #43
I'll just let that post speak for itself n/t kcr Aug 2017 #45
Bingo-Bango disillusioned73 Aug 2017 #46
There are a spectrum of people on the Left willing to go out and confront the alt-right... AntiFascist Aug 2017 #44
That's what I read in CNN article about the Antifa. I was looking for definitions & clarification... Honeycombe8 Aug 2017 #48
Based on one Antifa website I ran across... AntiFascist Aug 2017 #49
Wise words.......antifa? Your chosen name is interesting. nt Honeycombe8 Aug 2017 #51
Kick... Saving this to share and read every morning. N_E_1 for Tennis Aug 2017 #9
Count me in. Butterflylady Aug 2017 #10
I'm happy to be called a Democrat, I don't need a new name FakeNoose Aug 2017 #11
+1 ToxMarz Aug 2017 #14
I am simply anti-Trumpism, period. Moostache Aug 2017 #13
I had never heard of this "alt left" before Trump said it. Stellar Aug 2017 #15
Where have you been hiding?? disillusioned73 Aug 2017 #18
Trying to stay out of trouble here, that's all. Stellar Aug 2017 #21
That's because Cheeto made it up - "Alt-Left" doesn't mean anything FakeNoose Aug 2017 #20
In Trumps mind, if there is an alt-right, there must be an alt-left. Stellar Aug 2017 #23
Sorry, not true.. the "alt-left" part anyway disillusioned73 Aug 2017 #24
Whatever FakeNoose Aug 2017 #25
Its been used here frequently, usually to denigrate Bernie Sanders supporters nt riderinthestorm Aug 2017 #28
I am glad others are pointing this out as well.. disillusioned73 Aug 2017 #29
Call me whatever you want. . . Borchkins Aug 2017 #16
I am alt-left as well.. disillusioned73 Aug 2017 #17
He can take that bdamomma Aug 2017 #22
Trump will never define me Politicub Aug 2017 #26
shitler essentially declared war on the "alt left" yesterday. Far right AM radio has been clamoring The_Casual_Observer Aug 2017 #27
The silence on this thread from a certain DU contingent Flying Squirrel Aug 2017 #30
Never-mind, I just noticed you did. LanternWaste Aug 2017 #32
Calling out specific DU members is against the TOS. So I'm not. Flying Squirrel Aug 2017 #33
Nothing divisive about your post? kcr Aug 2017 #35
Um, I think you just put some words into my mouth. Flying Squirrel Aug 2017 #37
Well. That's what happens when you make implications like that. kcr Aug 2017 #38
I've already made myself clear elsewhere in the thread. nt Flying Squirrel Aug 2017 #40
You have it backwards. There is an alt.left that has done everything in its power... Expecting Rain Aug 2017 #36
No point arguing with you.. but I will say this anyway. Flying Squirrel Aug 2017 #39
Alt.left is divisive, but attacking Democrats isn't? Expecting Rain Aug 2017 #41
Welcome to DU. nt Flying Squirrel Aug 2017 #47
The DU who comes to mind that I saw use the term frequently is no longer with us! m-lekktor Aug 2017 #50
I'm just a Democrat. LanternWaste Aug 2017 #31
K&R for Truth LongTomH Aug 2017 #42

Scarsdale

(9,426 posts)
2. Yes! Many of us agree
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 07:18 AM
Aug 2017

with your ideals. Far more than the hateful alt-right. Any politicians who wish to side with tRump should be taken out of office. They are elected to represent ALL people, not just nazis and Russian sympathizers. tRump is as ugly inside as he is outside, and that ladies and gentlemen is U_G_L_Y.

Dustlawyer

(10,495 posts)
3. +1!!! THIS
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 07:31 AM
Aug 2017

I would add that Mr. President needs to look at the horrible viral picture showing people knocked up in the air by this murderer's car. On either side of the car are peaceful signs. To the right you can see one sign of the "Alt Left" that simply says "Love" and on the other side of the car a sign says, "Black Lives Matter." BLM was founded to state that black lives are just as important as any other. They are fighting for EQUALITY. The Alt Right are fighting and demanding SUPERIORITY over everyone else. That is the key difference.

The Alt Right are playing the victims, not personal responsibility, which is supposed to be a mantra of the Republican Party. They are wearing boots, tell them to grab their boot straps and yank!

babylonsister

(171,070 posts)
12. I don't believe that's true. Per dt,
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 08:28 AM
Aug 2017

the alt-left is anyone not in sync with the alt-right, aka the haters, white supremicists, KKKers, etc.

kcr

(15,317 posts)
34. Wrong.
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 03:33 PM
Aug 2017

I'm a staunch supporter of single payer and have never had anything to do with the alt-left nor have I been called a member.

AntiFascist

(12,792 posts)
44. There are a spectrum of people on the Left willing to go out and confront the alt-right...
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 04:43 PM
Aug 2017

just as there is also a spectrum of different people among the racists.

Honeycombe8

(37,648 posts)
48. That's what I read in CNN article about the Antifa. I was looking for definitions & clarification...
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 06:16 PM
Aug 2017

of the Antifa. Seems like Antifa may be a type of group (self-described) groups consider themselves. "An antifas group" one leader described his group.

Personally, I don't know. Here's that article:
http://www.cnn.com/2017/08/14/us/what-is-antifa-trnd/index.html

It could be that alt-left is a derogatory term coined by the right. I thought it was an alternate term for Antifa, but maybe not.


AntiFascist

(12,792 posts)
49. Based on one Antifa website I ran across...
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 07:14 PM
Aug 2017

it's ideology is modeled after the militant resistance groups that existed during WWII. My father, who served in that war, brought back a Nazi pin from a building that had previously been raided by local anti-fascist forces in Sicily, for example.

Of course the "militant" aspect is what has everyone's panties in a wad, and if the White Supremacists can't wage a race war, then a war against an opposing militant group is probably the next best thing for them. I would urge people to: keep your powder dry, be smart, and don't draw unnecessary negative attention to the Left. Our DOJ is currently headed by Jeff Sessions, enough said.

N_E_1 for Tennis

(9,734 posts)
9. Kick... Saving this to share and read every morning.
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 08:02 AM
Aug 2017

Yes thank you for giving us a name.
Thank you for uniting us.
We will be one, one that you will never beat down.

FakeNoose

(32,641 posts)
11. I'm happy to be called a Democrat, I don't need a new name
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 08:22 AM
Aug 2017

Everything that is written here is true for me, but I don't want to be called "Alt-Left."
That name doesn't mean anything, and it implies acceptance of the term "Alt-Right."
False equivalence!

The opposite of Nazi is not Democrat and it's not Alt-Left either.
The opposite of Nazi is "normal, sane free-thinking person."

Just sayin' - thanks for listening.

ToxMarz

(2,169 posts)
14. +1
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 08:50 AM
Aug 2017

Just fuel for false equivalence and both siderism

The alt-right named themselves, I choose not to be labeled by their ilk along their naming convention.

Alt-right came about in an attempt to sanatize their vile ideology and make it more palatable to a new generation. Democrats, progressives, liberals don't need their reputation cleaned up and their true motives obscured.

Now that the alt-right name is being exposed and repudiated, they need something on the other side to repudiate in a simple equal dog whistle way.

Moostache

(9,895 posts)
13. I am simply anti-Trumpism, period.
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 08:37 AM
Aug 2017

That transcends political party affiliation to me, it also transcends directional labels as well.

We all know who is on which side, and the OP and the POTUS's statements make that crystal clear.

FakeNoose

(32,641 posts)
20. That's because Cheeto made it up - "Alt-Left" doesn't mean anything
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 09:09 AM
Aug 2017

The "Alt-Right" started calling themselves that because they don't want to be called what they really are - neo-Nazis.
Now they want to justify their terms by calling resisters (us) by a falsely equivalent name - Alt-Left.

None of this makes sense because these names don't mean anything. So we need to keep calling them Nazis or neo-Nazis and make sure everyone understands that's exactly what these Trump supporters are.

The opposite of Nazis are normal, sane free-thinking people. We're liberals and we're Democrats, but we're not "Alt-Left."

Thanks for listening!

Stellar

(5,644 posts)
23. In Trumps mind, if there is an alt-right, there must be an alt-left.
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 09:14 AM
Aug 2017

Makes sense...the alt-right are the evil players and the alt left are the good.

 

disillusioned73

(2,872 posts)
24. Sorry, not true.. the "alt-left" part anyway
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 09:32 AM
Aug 2017

there have been folks using this term for months now to smear a certain sect of the left.. it has been well documented.. and the right just picked it up from them.. it is now a useful tool for the right on their false equivalency gambit.. unfortunately

And yes they(the Nazis & bigots of this country), created the "alt-right" term, the media went right along with their re-branding which has been dispicable (of the media).. just like they went along not pointing out how muh of a bigot Trump was & always has been during the campaign..

 

disillusioned73

(2,872 posts)
17. I am alt-left as well..
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 09:07 AM
Aug 2017

I've been told this not only by the President, but a variety of other people on the internets..

bdamomma

(63,868 posts)
22. He can take that
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 09:14 AM
Aug 2017

"alt-left" expression and shove up his a$$.

He is so fucking delusional. No names should be given to us we are Americans, fuck him.

 

The_Casual_Observer

(27,742 posts)
27. shitler essentially declared war on the "alt left" yesterday. Far right AM radio has been clamoring
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 11:37 AM
Aug 2017

for this shit for years.

 

Flying Squirrel

(3,041 posts)
30. The silence on this thread from a certain DU contingent
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 03:18 PM
Aug 2017

Which is often very vocal elsewhere

is deafening.

Not a single rec, not a single reply.

Same goes for a similar thread by kpete.

NYT - "There is no such thing as the 'alt-left.'"

 

LanternWaste

(37,748 posts)
32. Never-mind, I just noticed you did.
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 03:23 PM
Aug 2017

Gosh... you should read something both vague and nefarious into that, and then cower behind implication rather than stating outright your actual convictions.

Never-mind, I just noticed you did.

 

Flying Squirrel

(3,041 posts)
33. Calling out specific DU members is against the TOS. So I'm not.
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 03:31 PM
Aug 2017

But that doesn't mean I shouldn't call it like I see it. The term "alt-left" has been used recently on DU to further divide us - which weakens us. It's a matter of record who has been using the term, and has not recced or otherwise responded to these two threads.

Calling out their divisiveness is not a cowardly move.

kcr

(15,317 posts)
35. Nothing divisive about your post?
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 03:35 PM
Aug 2017

Your claim of avoiding TOS doesn't mean you aren't dividing like crazy. You think people like being compared to neo-Nazis?

 

Flying Squirrel

(3,041 posts)
37. Um, I think you just put some words into my mouth.
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 03:42 PM
Aug 2017

I have compared nobody on this site to the Neo-Nazis, nor would I.

kcr

(15,317 posts)
38. Well. That's what happens when you make implications like that.
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 03:49 PM
Aug 2017

If you meant to imply good things about the people you were comparing to Trump, then, by all means, please clear the air.

 

Expecting Rain

(811 posts)
36. You have it backwards. There is an alt.left that has done everything in its power...
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 03:41 PM
Aug 2017

to weaken and divide the Democratic Party (despite being outside our coalition) and the alt.left actively aided Trump's rise to power as a way to advance "the revolution" in the Leninist tradition of heightening the contradictions.

This forum has been used by alt.leftists for this purpose.

We can't ignore the Jill Steins, the Susan Sarandons, the JPRs, and their ilk. They exist.

Just because the deplorable racist Donald Trump embraced the term doesn't change the reality that alt.leftists helped get Trump into office.





 

Flying Squirrel

(3,041 posts)
39. No point arguing with you.. but I will say this anyway.
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 03:57 PM
Aug 2017

We disagree on who helped Trump into office the most. However, that's over and done. It's unlikely the establishment will again get behind someone so unpopular that they could lose to Donald Trump, so it's unlikely the people you are demonizing could exist in high enough percentages to sway the next election. People who remain fixated on blaming that very small percentage of the population, and doing their best to make it seem that it's a higher percentage and lump more people into it, and acting like they were and are the real problem, are being counterproductive.

Which goes back to the point of the OP (and the one by kpete.)

The term "alt-left" is divisive and not something anyone within the Democratic Party should be helping to promulgate. It weakens us. End of story.

 

Expecting Rain

(811 posts)
41. Alt.left is divisive, but attacking Democrats isn't?
Wed Aug 16, 2017, 04:04 PM
Aug 2017

Please. This is utterly disingenuous.

More attacks on our party, more fabrications about "the establishment," and a non-recognition that these tactics helped elect Trump in the first place.

Yet you claim to be against being "divisive."

Good grief.

Latest Discussions»General Discussion»I Am the Alt-Left, Mr. Pr...