New guidelines urge later, less frequent mammograms
Source: Boston Globe
Most women should wait until age 45 to start getting annual mammograms and should cut back to every-other-year testing at 55, the American Cancer Society advised Tuesday in a major shift in its guidelines for breast cancer screening.
Until now, the group one of the most respected voices on cancer urged women to get yearly mammograms from 40 onward. But studies have shown that mammograms, even when they detect tumors, have little effect on whether a young woman will die of breast cancer.
About 85 percent of women in their 40s and 50s who die of breast cancer would have died regardless of mammography, Drs. Nancy Keating and Lydia Pace of Brigham and Womens Hospital wrote in an editorial accompanying the new guidelines published in the Journal of the American Medical Association.
The cancer society also recommended for the first time that women forgo breast exams performed by their doctor because they are not as effective as mammograms at finding tumors.
Read more: https://www.bostonglobe.com/lifestyle/health-wellness/2015/10/20/american-cancer-society-advises-women-start-mammograms-later-and-get-fewer-tests/bccqMFKgZ8sg43BUbuSXqJ/story.html
canoeist52
(2,282 posts)So no manual breast exams AND half the amount of mammograms - Sounds to me like insurance companies don't want to pay f them, now that they're free through the ACA law. It's always about cost-cutting.
Recursion
(56,582 posts)That's the whole point: despite much, much higher levels of early detection the death rate from breast cancer hasn't actually gone down in the past 4 decades, so the panel decided it's not worth the risks of the excess procedures that come with it (i.e., some non-zero number of women die from complications from the follow-ups).
sybylla
(8,509 posts)It's what I told my doctor when they wanted to go to yearly mammograms. I have no family history of it nor lifestyle factors. I saw no reason to have them more often than the NIH recommended.
On the other hand, the medical industrial complex probably has a pretty big sad today.