Army vet sues VA over scalpel left in body after surgery
Source: Associated Press
Updated 3:45 pm, Monday, January 15, 2018
NEW HAVEN, Conn. (AP) An Army veteran who says someone left a scalpel inside him after surgery is suing a veterans affairs hospital.
Bridgeport resident Glenford Turner says the scalpel was only discovered years later, after he suffered from long-term abdominal pain. He sued the VA in U.S. District Court last week, seeking unspecified compensatory damages.
Court papers say Turner had surgery at the VA hospital in West Haven in 2013. Nearly four years later, he went back to the VA with dizziness and severe abdominal pain. An X-Ray showed there was a scalpel inside his body.
Turner had to undergo surgery to remove the scalpel. His lawyer, Joel Faxon, said doctors confirmed it was the same one. Faxon called it "an incomprehensible level of incompetence."
Read more: http://www.chron.com/news/medical/article/Army-vet-sues-VA-over-scalpel-left-in-body-after-12499014.php
PoliticAverse
(26,366 posts)on occasion it seems like a comprehensible level of incompetence to me.
jberryhill
(62,444 posts)Yes, it is a mistake but, no, it doesn't fall into the "you ain't gonna believe this" category of mistake.
harun
(11,348 posts)on people before closing up.
marble falls
(57,093 posts)and I have nothing but HIGH praise for the treatment I received. Mistakes happen in all hospitals VA and civilian. They are regrettable but never in my experience with VA endemic. I've had "Cadillac" health care in my professional career and the care I get from VA is better than any other insurance program I ever had. Scott and White here in Texas has partnered up with VA not to teach VA but to learn from VA particularly how to keep records up to date with patients who move move all around the states. The VA makes mistakes but they do the very best they can and they learn from their mistakes. t may be hard to believe but the care I received turned my colon cancer surgery into one best experiances of my life (after the first two days) and they are after my bladder cancer aggressively.
Thank G*d for the VA. The best thing I ever did was join the Navy.
Old Vet
(2,001 posts)At Buffalo and Syracuse VA in NY. I have nothing but the utmost trust in the VA, Between the free tuition for college and lifetime healthcare(100% military disabled) I too am glad I did my time in the army.
marble falls
(57,093 posts)not fooled
(5,801 posts)Whenever I see stories like this, it smells like anti-VA propaganda laying the groundwork for privatization efforts. You just know dump and his handlers are itching to destroy the VA. Would be too bad for all those deluded old veterans who supported dump.
The story does not include any stats on what % of surgeries include an error of this magnitude and whether the VA has higher rates. That's the only information that would enable a reader to draw any conclusions as to whether the VA deserves any criticism above and beyond the unavoidable occasional surgical error of this type. Of course whenever it happens it's unfortunate, but as long as humans are involved this kind of thing is going to happen.
I just smell a rat re trying to demonize the VA. Otherwise, the paper needs to report every time a local hospital does something like this and gets sued.
marble falls
(57,093 posts)who repeat unverified and misunderstood third hand stories.
There is no doubt there are problem VA hospitals but sometimes the problems derive from Congress cutting budgets, having unrealistic goals for administrators, and political appointments of VA officials who have no experience or competence at their jobs.
When I got out in '73 I went to work at VA hospital at Brecksville, Ohio and the first day I told my wife whatever happened to me, she was not to put me in a VA hospital. Ten years ago as I got over 55 and the contract jobs started petering out she talked me into going to VA. What a difference 40 years have made. And doing it saved my life.
Is there room for improvement? Sure but offhand I can't think of anything significant but that Congress might built one less Carrier or FBM sub and spend the money to involve more younger vets into getting their care from VA.
I know that there are two hospitals in my home town of Akron, Ohio that have significantly higher rates of MSR infection than the VA gets.
Thanks for your service, brother.
Judi Lynn
(160,542 posts)Codeine
(25,586 posts)a scalpel is by far the scariest. Just think of it cutting into tissue and organs every time you move.
Judi Lynn
(160,542 posts)paleotn
(17,918 posts)Probably a blade and not an entire scalpel. A rarity, but a monumental fuck up when it happens.
Sunlei
(22,651 posts)WTF is the matter with Doctors? "long-term abdominal pain" means you x-ray, use ultrasound, scope, biopsy, send specimens to the lab.
It's hell to be sick, "long-term abdominal pain" in America especially if you're stuck with a shitty Doctor.
Javaman
(62,530 posts)basically he said, "that is a horrible doctor. A good doctor accounts for everything before he closes up".
lagomorph777
(30,613 posts)and smuggling it out of the hospital inside his body.