Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

brooklynite

(94,727 posts)
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 12:02 PM Oct 2018

Judge Denies Request to Block Presidential Cell Phone Alert

Source: Bloomberg

Americans will get a cell phone alert from President Donald Trump Wednesday as planned.

A U.S. judge in New York rejected a request to block the alert from three New Yorkers who claim it’s a violation of the constitutional protection to be free from government-compelled listening.

A test of the alert system is scheduled for 2:18 p.m. New York time on Wednesday.

Read more: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-10-03/u-s-judge-denies-request-to-block-trump-s-presidential-alert



Why people are freaking out about this non-story is beyond me...
62 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Judge Denies Request to Block Presidential Cell Phone Alert (Original Post) brooklynite Oct 2018 OP
It's a test of the emergency messaging system, I think it's actually from FEMA. The Velveteen Ocelot Oct 2018 #1
Usually, I agree with your sober and intelligent posts PJMcK Oct 2018 #4
I don't think he has control over it. The Velveteen Ocelot Oct 2018 #5
Really? atreides1 Oct 2018 #13
If trump is involved TEB Oct 2018 #10
+1 Anon-C Oct 2018 #26
Don't text DownriverDem Oct 2018 #16
Good question... IthinkThereforeIAM Oct 2018 #17
My wife got it on her phone, christx30 Oct 2018 #40
Okay, I admit I was wrong PJMcK Oct 2018 #42
It's the beginning of Big Brother Broadcasting bucolic_frolic Oct 2018 #2
True that. nt zanana1 Oct 2018 #49
I'm not freaking out PJMcK Oct 2018 #3
HE'S NOT SENDING YOU A MESSAGE! brooklynite Oct 2018 #6
People seem to have a hard time understanding this. bearsfootball516 Oct 2018 #8
Will it have the test screen with the Native American/Indian chief in it... IthinkThereforeIAM Oct 2018 #18
For those that don't know what you are referring to, Wikipedia to the rescue... PoliticAverse Oct 2018 #56
Thank you... IthinkThereforeIAM Oct 2018 #60
Okay, thanks PJMcK Oct 2018 #19
One other point PJMcK Oct 2018 #20
I guess you should apologize now, john657 Oct 2018 #28
Thanks, I will (n/t) PJMcK Oct 2018 #32
That was only the first one. zanana1 Oct 2018 #50
Apologize for having an opposing opinion? nt zanana1 Oct 2018 #55
Maybe you missed the part where poster said that if he/she was john657 Oct 2018 #58
I'm sorry, I was wrong PJMcK Oct 2018 #33
You weren't wrong. nt zanana1 Oct 2018 #52
YET nt zanana1 Oct 2018 #51
It's a 2006 law which later on had RWers freaked out because they didn't want The Velveteen Ocelot Oct 2018 #15
I think the problem is BumRushDaShow Oct 2018 #7
People are peeved because it is Trump. avebury Oct 2018 #9
It's a prelude to this... Duppers Oct 2018 #30
I can happen. zanana1 Oct 2018 #53
Simple solution is to turn your phone which is what I've underthematrix Oct 2018 #11
Which way did you turn it: right or left? PJMcK Oct 2018 #21
LOL That's pretty much everyone's standard response to Trump underthematrix Oct 2018 #22
I was wrong PJMcK Oct 2018 #43
I do not understand the need for this. Lonestarblue Oct 2018 #12
Every once in a while... reACTIONary Oct 2018 #38
I think you should demand that the entire national warning system be abolished asap MichMan Oct 2018 #57
This is based on a 2006 law. In 2013, right-wingers freaked out abt having 'Obama in their phone'... Princess Turandot Oct 2018 #14
This test is mandated by a 2016 amendment to the WARN Act onenote Oct 2018 #25
The odds of that cockamamie lawsuit succeeding were zero. onenote Oct 2018 #23
Just posted about this in the Lounge Bayard Oct 2018 #24
Jesus Christ!!!! john657 Oct 2018 #27
No shit, get a life people! It's a phone message - deal with it Baclava Oct 2018 #29
"Deal" with it? zanana1 Oct 2018 #41
oh stop it, invade your privacy? from a weather alert? Baclava Oct 2018 #45
It's called a Presidential Alert. zanana1 Oct 2018 #46
Whatever, I have bigger things to worry about n/t Baclava Oct 2018 #47
i got one here in the Tx Panhandle onetexan Oct 2018 #31
I was able to delete it without having to look or listen to it. Tikki Oct 2018 #34
Got it on XM, but noting on the cell. I agree with you, this isnt some big deal. 7962 Oct 2018 #35
This Alert can be dangerous while driving Blueplanet Oct 2018 #36
didn't get on my work cell whistler162 Oct 2018 #37
I get the history and backstory of this alert... but... BlueIdaho Oct 2018 #39
Don't Get The Whole Concept ProfessorGAC Oct 2018 #44
I think you just changed my mind... BlueIdaho Oct 2018 #48
"And if someone launches a nuke at Chicago and i get this extra special warning, what am i supposed EX500rider Oct 2018 #61
No Thanks ProfessorGAC Oct 2018 #62
. underpants Oct 2018 #54
One more reason to not carry a blasted phone around with me every hour of the day and night - Kashkakat v.2.0 Oct 2018 #59

The Velveteen Ocelot

(115,836 posts)
1. It's a test of the emergency messaging system, I think it's actually from FEMA.
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 12:04 PM
Oct 2018

It's called a "presidential" message, which Trump probably wanted it to be called to make himself seem more important, but it's just a test and will not contain a personal message from Trump.

PJMcK

(22,048 posts)
4. Usually, I agree with your sober and intelligent posts
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 12:06 PM
Oct 2018

But with this, I think you're wrong. I think Trump will mess with this system somehow.

If I'm incorrect, I will apologize!

atreides1

(16,093 posts)
13. Really?
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 12:39 PM
Oct 2018

I don't see Brock Long telling Trump, he can't use the system, do you?

Trump controls the FEMA director, therefore Trump controls the system!!!

IthinkThereforeIAM

(3,077 posts)
17. Good question...
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 12:53 PM
Oct 2018

... I am tempted to shut off my texting on my iPhone for the next 8 hours. I still got email if it is an emergency!

You may be on to something!

christx30

(6,241 posts)
40. My wife got it on her phone,
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 11:41 PM
Oct 2018

and I got it on my old phone, but not my new one.
It wasn't a big deal. Message came, I cleared it, and that was it. People are making way more of out of than it needs to be. Ignore them, unless something has been happening. But, really, anything that's going to matter to you is going to show up on the news anyway.
I did picture getting random messages like "No Collusion!" at 3am. I know it won't happen, but it's a funny thought.

PJMcK

(22,048 posts)
42. Okay, I admit I was wrong
Thu Oct 4, 2018, 07:58 AM
Oct 2018

In the Era of Trump, I expected the worst with this FEMA system.

I was wrong. Sorry.

bucolic_frolic

(43,282 posts)
2. It's the beginning of Big Brother Broadcasting
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 12:04 PM
Oct 2018

Trump News Network

Anything that exists was spawned somewhere

PJMcK

(22,048 posts)
3. I'm not freaking out
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 12:05 PM
Oct 2018

I simply hate Trump and I do not want him to send me a text or any other communication.

Fuck him.

I just set an alarm on my phone for 2:10 pm so I can shut my phone off and not receive the message. When I restart the phone, the first thing I'll do is delete the asshole's message.

Fuck him.

brooklynite

(94,727 posts)
6. HE'S NOT SENDING YOU A MESSAGE!
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 12:09 PM
Oct 2018

It's coming from FEMA. It's a basic "this is a test" message. Trump has nothing to do with it.

IthinkThereforeIAM

(3,077 posts)
18. Will it have the test screen with the Native American/Indian chief in it...
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 12:55 PM
Oct 2018

...?? Sorry, I used to watch those while waiting for Saturday morning cartoons with Deputy Dawg to come on.

PJMcK

(22,048 posts)
20. One other point
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 12:58 PM
Oct 2018

As I wrote in another post above, if I'm wrong and Trump doesn't mess with this system, I'll honestly apologize.

 

john657

(1,058 posts)
28. I guess you should apologize now,
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 02:41 PM
Oct 2018

it was just like a weather warning, didn't even have Trump's name.

PJMcK

(22,048 posts)
33. I'm sorry, I was wrong
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 03:12 PM
Oct 2018

In the Era of Trump, my paranoia isn't unreasonable.

However, I admit my expectation was wrong.

Peace.

The Velveteen Ocelot

(115,836 posts)
15. It's a 2006 law which later on had RWers freaked out because they didn't want
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 12:43 PM
Oct 2018

Obama in their phones (see other post in this thread). I don't want to get messages from Trump either but that isn't what this is. I will leave my phone on and report back.

BumRushDaShow

(129,444 posts)
7. I think the problem is
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 12:11 PM
Oct 2018

that he personally uses twitter for all sorts of nonsense and policy positions. However I and others have posted over and over that this "alert" thing involves the use of a COMPUTER SYSTEM that someone logs into, goes through a series of steps, and after verification, sends a templated (standard) "message".

Edit to add - I posted elsewhere but here is what is basically required to actually get in and send a message -











The disastrous false alarm issued by Hawaii over the weekend has raised concerns about what safeguards the state had in place. The state-wide alert, which told people a ballistic missile was about to hit, terrified residents and visitors, as the state scrambled for 38 minutes to issue a correction.

Officials soon released a timeline of events, saying the state’s software contained a menu option that allowed a live alert to be sent in place of a test, a problem that several people quickly categorized as a design failure. The state released an image that showed a list with options for test and live alerts next to each other. Officials later said the image did not accurately portray the system, and released what it characterized as a “representation” of the system, but said that it could not share an actual screenshot.

While the state has not named its software provider, evidence suggests it is an Idaho-based company called AlertSense, a FEMA-approved company that says it works with clients in states around the country. The audio version of the alert broadcast in Hawaii was posted on the company’s website. The first image released by Hawaii also appears similar to example software provided to The Verge by AlertSense. For instance, the word “templates” appears above the alert options in AlertSense’s software, and is barely visible in the first image issued by the state. (A local TV station in Hawaii independently came to the same conclusion.) The Verge’s review of the program suggests that functionally there is only a one-click difference between sending a test and a live alert.

https://www.theverge.com/2018/1/18/16905512/hawaii-missile-software-false-alarm-emergency-alert

avebury

(10,952 posts)
9. People are peeved because it is Trump.
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 12:22 PM
Oct 2018

As I told Senator Langford (yes I know it is a waste of time but I do try from time to time): While I may not have always agreed with who sits in the White House, I would have always expected a sitting President to use such a warning system such as this appropriately. But I cannot say the same for Trump due to his lack of impulse control and tendency to rage tweet. People do not trust Trump to have access to any type of countrywide tweet platform because you just don't know what he is truly capable of.

I indicated that I would prefer to opt out as long as he in the WH.

You may call it a non-story but with the way this country is going:
1. Racist, misogynist, lying, etc. POS in the Oval Office
2., Dominionist in the VP office
3. Republican Controlled Congress not willing to uphold the law, routinely ignores the Constitution
4. Judicial System being taken over by the hard right, political extremists
5. Continued to privatize the prison system
6. Immigrant children being permanently ripped away from their families
7. Poor people stuck in poverty
8. Middle Class perpetually struggling
9. Wealth continually turned over the 1% and Corporations at the expense of clear air, clean water, safe food, protection of endangered species and so on.
10. Etc. Etc. Etc.

What could possibly go wrong?

Duppers

(28,127 posts)
30. It's a prelude to this...
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 02:50 PM
Oct 2018

"This is President Donald J. Trump. My Administration and I have found it necessary to declare martial law. Stand by for further instructions."


Think it can't happen?!!

PJMcK

(22,048 posts)
21. Which way did you turn it: right or left?
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 12:59 PM
Oct 2018

Just kidding.

I've set an alarm for 2:10 to remind me to power down my iPhone. Later, when I power up, the first thing I'll do is delete the test message.

Fuck Trump.

PJMcK

(22,048 posts)
43. I was wrong
Thu Oct 4, 2018, 07:59 AM
Oct 2018

I expected Trump to fuck with the system somehow.

Amazingly, he didn't.

I apologize for expecting the worst from Trump.

Lonestarblue

(10,064 posts)
12. I do not understand the need for this.
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 12:39 PM
Oct 2018

I already get text message alerts for local weather-related issues such as tornado sightings or flood warnings. Why do I need an alert from FEMA telling me that a hurricane is coming toward the East Coast when I live in Texas? I keep thinking of the War of the Worlds broadcast, though the claimed panic has been debunked. The potential to cause mass disruption is there with such a nationwide system. And a lot of the distrust relates to Trump because FEMA staff report to him and they will do what he tells them to do.

reACTIONary

(5,771 posts)
38. Every once in a while...
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 09:37 PM
Oct 2018

.... radio stations broadcast a buzzing sound as a "test of the national emergency broadcast system". I believe it is a relec of the cold war civil defense. It seems to me this is justan extension of that.

MichMan

(11,971 posts)
57. I think you should demand that the entire national warning system be abolished asap
Fri Oct 5, 2018, 08:12 AM
Oct 2018

Repeal the entire 2015 law and demand that these warnings are to be prohibited. That way you don't have to be concerned with them in the future. Of course some day there may actually be a national emergency, but people will figure it out anyway

Princess Turandot

(4,787 posts)
14. This is based on a 2006 law. In 2013, right-wingers freaked out abt having 'Obama in their phone'...
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 12:39 PM
Oct 2018

The law was called the Warning, Alert and Response Network (WARN) Act. It was passed in 2006; the 'Wireless Emergency Alerts system' itself became operational in 2012. I believe they were mandated to eventually do a test of it. Thus today's event which, in normal circumstances, would be perfectly logical.

When the FCC put out information about this in 2013, right-wingers like Alex Jones freaked out. Here's a MaddowBlog post on the 2013 version of this hysteria: http://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/remember-who-passed-the-warn-act

They'll probably change the name eventually, and hope no one notices.

onenote

(42,759 posts)
25. This test is mandated by a 2016 amendment to the WARN Act
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 02:33 PM
Oct 2018

passed unanimously by the House and Senate and signed by President Obama.

It expressly requires that the nationwide system be tested within 3 years of the law's enactment. We've been justifiably critical of FEMA for not being prepared, so I'm not going to dump on them for actually testing the system to see if it works properly.

onenote

(42,759 posts)
23. The odds of that cockamamie lawsuit succeeding were zero.
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 02:31 PM
Oct 2018

Waste of time and resources by those who filed it.

Bayard

(22,149 posts)
24. Just posted about this in the Lounge
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 02:32 PM
Oct 2018

Before I saw this discussion.

I received the text, and its as loud and obnoxious as he is. I understand it's not coming directly from him, but if it has his name on it (which it does), then I hate it.

 

john657

(1,058 posts)
27. Jesus Christ!!!!
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 02:36 PM
Oct 2018

People here are having conniption fits over this?

Just got it on my cell phone, it was the same as a weather alert.

 

Baclava

(12,047 posts)
29. No shit, get a life people! It's a phone message - deal with it
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 02:49 PM
Oct 2018

"Its' an Amber Alert! OMG we're all going to DIE!"

LOL

zanana1

(6,128 posts)
41. "Deal" with it?
Thu Oct 4, 2018, 06:10 AM
Oct 2018

It means that Trump can invade our privacy anytime he so chooses and can text whatever he chooses. Do you really think we should put up with his Twitter posts on our phones? It's bound to happen.

zanana1

(6,128 posts)
46. It's called a Presidential Alert.
Thu Oct 4, 2018, 01:42 PM
Oct 2018

You really don't think he'll take advantage of that? It's not paranoid if it's Trump.

onetexan

(13,058 posts)
31. i got one here in the Tx Panhandle
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 03:03 PM
Oct 2018

didn't like it. I'm sure the damn guy will usurp this alert system for his con purposes as well.

Blueplanet

(253 posts)
36. This Alert can be dangerous while driving
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 03:59 PM
Oct 2018

It was Very loud. I worry about young drivers who pay very close attention to their phones. You're tempted to reach for it to turn it off.
An alert on the TV is fine, but not while driving.
(Posted this comment on another thread)

BlueIdaho

(13,582 posts)
39. I get the history and backstory of this alert... but...
Wed Oct 3, 2018, 10:35 PM
Oct 2018

Why not change its title? Presidential Alert is stupid and bound to piss off half the population regardless of who’s in the White House. Just about anything else would be more acceptable.

ProfessorGAC

(65,168 posts)
44. Don't Get The Whole Concept
Thu Oct 4, 2018, 11:26 AM
Oct 2018

As someone said above, a terrorist attack in LA while i'm driving my car in northeast Illinois is not likely to change my plans, as horrible as such an attack might be.

And if someone launches a nuke at Chicago and i get this extra special warning, what am i supposed to do? There isn't time to get away from it, and actually it might be wiser to drive under the warheads. 100 microseconds of bright light and i'm an ion cloud.

Also as someone said above, this is a silly holdover of the cold war where people actually thought a nuclear war was easily survivable and the absurd notion that the USSR would attack first as if they had no self-preservation instinct of their own.

The whole idea just seem stupid and pointless.

EX500rider

(10,856 posts)
61. "And if someone launches a nuke at Chicago and i get this extra special warning, what am i supposed
Fri Oct 5, 2018, 03:31 PM
Oct 2018

...to do?"
If you really want a answer, find a manhole cover, get it open, climb down, close lid, after the blast has past you have up to a hour before radiation levels start to rise dramatically as the radioactive dust starts to fall to the ground, use that time to get out of the area or into a deep basement with several floors above you or anything that will have 3 feet of dirt above you. Even crawling deep into a culvert might get you thru the blast also depending on the breaks. Obviously if you are withing the crater range of ground zero you will be toast but further out this will save you.

(2 bolts wired together with a space in between them is what you need to get the manhole cover open, stick one thru the hole in the manhole cover and lift with the other one.)

ProfessorGAC

(65,168 posts)
62. No Thanks
Sat Oct 6, 2018, 06:18 AM
Oct 2018

Highly educated in sciences. Understand how to avoid hyperdosing of radiation and preventing burns etc.
Wasn't really my point

Kashkakat v.2.0

(1,752 posts)
59. One more reason to not carry a blasted phone around with me every hour of the day and night -
Fri Oct 5, 2018, 11:25 AM
Oct 2018

I used to, but stopped when I realized I couldn't possibly pull it out of my bag and answer it in five rings so what's the point.

Now I only carry it if Im travelling or have some reason to have it. Otherwise it SITS on the bedside table.

Nope sorry there's time you cant reach me.

Yeah I know Im a freak but whatever.

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Judge Denies Request to B...