Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

FiveGoodMen

(20,018 posts)
Tue Mar 5, 2019, 03:10 PM Mar 2019

California transit agency allows ad from Holocaust denial group

Source: The Guardian

A San Francisco public transit agency has approved adverts from a group that promotes Holocaust denial and antisemitic views, claiming the organization has a “free speech” right to buy train station billboards.

Bay Area Rapid Transit (Bart) officials defended their decision to allow ads for the Institute for Historical Review (IHR), which the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) has classified as a hate group that aims to “defend Nazism” and spread Holocaust denial propaganda.

The electronic billboards, which say “History Matters!” and provide the name of the California-based organization, are in rotation at two Bart stations in San Francisco. They come at a time when antisemitic incidents have accelerated at alarming rates in the US and across the world, and as far-right groups and neo-Nazis have increasingly pushed racist and fascist views under the guise of advocating for free speech.

“We cannot deny the ads,” a Bart spokeswoman, Alicia Trost, said in an interview on Tuesday, noting that the agency does not endorse the message or group. “You have to look at it for exactly what words are used and what images are used … There is plenty of case law and court rulings that show if you deny the ad, you can be taken to court, and you’ll lose, and that’s obviously costly.”


Read more: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/sep/12/california-transit-agency-bart-ad-antisemitism

20 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
California transit agency allows ad from Holocaust denial group (Original Post) FiveGoodMen Mar 2019 OP
That sucks. But since BART is a public agency, they have to allow it. Aristus Mar 2019 #1
Correction: they are now "electronic billboards subject to vandalism" (n/t) Auggie Mar 2019 #2
Do we have a Constitutional right to spread hate? And lies? I'd be willing to go to jail ... marble falls Mar 2019 #3
Yes. NT mahatmakanejeeves Mar 2019 #5
I've once asked the same question. saidsimplesimon Mar 2019 #12
Today's lesson in "The first amendment, what it compels". n/t PoliticAverse Mar 2019 #4
I wonder when the Klan's ad starts? ripcord Mar 2019 #6
From 2016 - KKK wins "Adopt-a-Highway" lawsuit in Georgia PoliticAverse Mar 2019 #7
This just baffles the hell out of me... Hulk Mar 2019 #8
Just deny it. Then deny it again. JustABozoOnThisBus Mar 2019 #10
Did you know there are peoole that think the earth is flat?... PoliticAverse Mar 2019 #13
Oh, sure...but are they a serious threat to anyone with a sound intelligence Hulk Mar 2019 #16
Just permit riders to paste over them. Hulk Mar 2019 #9
Why have advertising in the BART stations at all? PSPS Mar 2019 #11
How much are you willing to pay for a transit fare? brooklynite Mar 2019 #18
As more of the survivors die, this will become worse. Behind the Aegis Mar 2019 #14
Free speech is one thing. Haggis for Breakfast Mar 2019 #15
No, free speech is THE thing... brooklynite Mar 2019 #19
When did free speech become an ad buy? Mosby Mar 2019 #20
Hate speech is not free speech. jcmaine72 Mar 2019 #17

Aristus

(66,462 posts)
1. That sucks. But since BART is a public agency, they have to allow it.
Tue Mar 5, 2019, 03:13 PM
Mar 2019

I just hope civil rights groups will counter with public displays of their own decrying the Holocaust-deniers.

marble falls

(57,240 posts)
3. Do we have a Constitutional right to spread hate? And lies? I'd be willing to go to jail ...
Tue Mar 5, 2019, 03:39 PM
Mar 2019

for tearing one of those down.

saidsimplesimon

(7,888 posts)
12. I've once asked the same question.
Tue Mar 5, 2019, 05:21 PM
Mar 2019

The response was as other members have already posted. Freedom of Speech is a pillar for our Constitutional Republic, so I'm told, that means even the most racist, bigoted, misogynistic, or antisemitic speech is protected.

There is also nothing to prevent anyone from protesting such speech, shaming the behaviour and attempting to inflict financial damage upon those who abuse others.

 

Hulk

(6,699 posts)
8. This just baffles the hell out of me...
Tue Mar 5, 2019, 03:55 PM
Mar 2019

How can someone deny the activities of Nazi Germany during World War II? This doesn't even make sense. They think it didn't happen??? Might as well deny the sun comes up and goes down each day.

By the same token, having this mythical belief seems to be of little threat to anyone who is a rational human being. Of course it happened. Documentation as well as first person verification should be enough proof to make these deniers look like bat shit crazy fools.

Please let me know what I am missing.

 

Hulk

(6,699 posts)
16. Oh, sure...but are they a serious threat to anyone with a sound intelligence
Wed Mar 6, 2019, 02:13 AM
Mar 2019

I know there are all sorts of religious wackos...the earth is 6 million years old, etc, etc, etc, etc. Some pretty crazy shit.

I guess my point is they are nuts. I know it's an insult to reality...but ...I just thinks its so asinine. Like if I drink gasoline I'll be able to run faster.

Guess I have no point other than it is so damned absurd to even give them attention.

 

Hulk

(6,699 posts)
9. Just permit riders to paste over them.
Tue Mar 5, 2019, 03:56 PM
Mar 2019

Can the transit system be held liable if patrons chose to do that??

PSPS

(13,614 posts)
11. Why have advertising in the BART stations at all?
Tue Mar 5, 2019, 04:22 PM
Mar 2019

In other words, they'll do (allow) anything for money.

brooklynite

(94,737 posts)
18. How much are you willing to pay for a transit fare?
Wed Mar 6, 2019, 08:02 AM
Mar 2019

Transit agencies charge customers 50% or less of the actual cost.

Behind the Aegis

(53,989 posts)
14. As more of the survivors die, this will become worse.
Tue Mar 5, 2019, 05:54 PM
Mar 2019

As it is, many don't understand the Holocaust, and too many (IMO) don't even know about the Holocaust, so revisionism and denialism are going to become more prevalent. Then, there is the anti-Semitism of it all, which is on the rise and barely gets noticed until a bunch of us are gunned down, then it is quickly forgotten and it is back to business as usual hoo-hooing about anti-Semitism being called out, until it leads to the inevitable..."The Jews did it!"

Haggis for Breakfast

(6,831 posts)
15. Free speech is one thing.
Tue Mar 5, 2019, 09:36 PM
Mar 2019

This is another altogether.

It is the complete denial of an historical event that is so well-documented that there is no sane, rational or intelligent argument that can be made to refute what happened. It is an attempt to diminish the barbaric savagery that one group of deranged people visited upon another group of people they considered inferior and therefore treated them without any human compassion or empathy.

I look upon such people who deny the Holocaust as deeply mentally- or emotionally- disturbed people who do not deserve to be engaged or validated in any way. I refuse to waste even a nano of my time on such intentional stupidity. I feel the same way about these Q Anon buffoons.

There will come a time when we will be forced to stop the proliferation of this garbage.

brooklynite

(94,737 posts)
19. No, free speech is THE thing...
Wed Mar 6, 2019, 08:05 AM
Mar 2019

If you're not willing to accept free speech that you disagree with (or even despise), you're applying a personal subjective standard on what's acceptable, and if you can do that, so can others. If a pro-Palestinian ad (yes, they exist) was blocked for being politically controversial, how would you feel?

Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»California transit agency...