Venezuela: Tens of thousands march in anti-government protests
Source: LA Times
Tens of thousands of students and other opponents of the Venezuelan government filled the streets of the capital Sunday, putting a damper on President Nicolas Maduros hopes that a mandated holiday might bring a respite to weeks of protests.
The march originated at four points near universities in Caracas that have been opposition hotbeds and converged on the Chacaito barrio where opposition leader Leopoldo Lopez was arrested Feb. 18 for alleged incitement to violence.
Opposition leaders say the charges against Lopez are politically motivated and have demanded his release from the military prison where he is being held in isolation.
Each of the four feeder marches Sunday had a theme built around a complaint against the Maduro administration: justice, scarcities, freedom and censorship.
Read more: http://www.latimes.com/world/worldnow/la-fg-wn-venezuela-protest-marches-caracas-20140302,0,4840308.story
reformist2
(9,841 posts)joshcryer
(62,276 posts)Archae
(46,328 posts)Maduro can do no wrong, everything that goes wrong is the fault of the CIA...
Yo_Mama
(8,303 posts)if we suddenly discovered that we couldn't reliably buy the basic necessities of life. We'd be demonstrating too!
Of course the scarcity is hardest on the poor that don't have workarounds.
http://www.eluniversal.com/economia/140213/venezuelas-food-shortage-in-january-the-highest-in-five-years
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-01-08/hunt-for-food-sends-venezuelans-to-colombian-border-towns.html
Nor is the government's rhetoric about capital strikes and plots helping any - food is being bought at subsidized prices and then being sold across the border.
The goods are then loaded onto trucks and taken to Colombia. Many of these professional shoppers are native Guajira Indians dressed in bright floral-print dresses who have double nationality and are exempt from border controls.
More than 300 trucks with everything from rice to car tires made the 130-kilometer drive from Maracaibo to the border through eight army and police checkpoints when a Bloomberg reporter did the journey on Nov. 10. Drivers of cars carrying food pay those staffing the checkpoints anywhere from 20 to 300 bolivars for quick passage, according to Sotomayor.
It's no surprise that there is so much conflict in Tachira - the shortages in the border states have been building for a while. With inflation so high, it's one of the few ways the poor can provide for themselves. This is from June of last year:
http://finance.yahoo.com/news/food-rationing-begin-big-venezuelan-state-215524026.html
I think if the monetary issues could just be controlled, the protests would die down rather rapidly. But it remains to be seen if the administration is able to do that. Due to the inability to import components, the auto factories have shut down. The economy is crumpling under the strain of this.
joshcryer
(62,276 posts)Physical shortages, psychological.
davidpdx
(22,000 posts)Lies, lies, lies
joshcryer
(62,276 posts)The US is so fucking exceptional every damn conflict in every damn country or city of the world is influenced by the almighty American intelligence and meddling power.
Archae
(46,328 posts)zeemike
(18,998 posts)"Dear Leader"...did you borrow it from them?
juxtaposed
(2,778 posts)DRoseDARs
(6,810 posts)denem
(11,045 posts)His father Kim Il-sung was/is the 'Great Leader' or 'Eternal Leader'
The supposed spiritual immortality of both men draws upon Korea's Buddhist traditions.
DRoseDARs
(6,810 posts)The problem is some people are unaware that the "Dear Leader" label has been tossed around in other contexts as well.
Judi Lynn
(160,542 posts)So odd to hear anyone claiming it now.
George W. Bush was called a lot of things, but never heard him being called "Dear Leader," especially considering he wasn't elected, and certainly never heard Clinton called "Dear Leader," at least among ordinary people.
Can't speak for right-wingers.
DRoseDARs
(6,810 posts)Jesus, not you too Judi...
Anyway, use of the mocking term against Clinton predates our modern Internet and I've no clue how to go about mucking the primordial swamps of pre-technological rightwingdom to find examples.
http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=104x3950625
http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=104x3969615
http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=132x3254134
http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=104x5472918
Took all of 1 minute to find these.
Common Sense Party
(14,139 posts)Your facts and evidence were preemptively struck down by withering opinion and faulty memory. Mission Accomplished.
smokey775
(228 posts)Guess I better self delete.
Common Sense Party
(14,139 posts)That damned Google is simply a tool of the pro-oligarchs, anyway.
Judi Lynn
(160,542 posts)I am limited by time to the threads I feel a need to see, since I spend the rest of my available time looking for articles, reading important posted articles from other posters as time allows.
Common Sense Party
(14,139 posts)were wrong.
Bacchus4.0
(6,837 posts)s
smokey775
(228 posts)call that insane North Korean leader, Dear Leader, in other words, it's not just the RW that uses that phrase.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)But not as a pejorative
And the right wing co-opted it to insinuate that Obama was a dictator...and now we have it used here...so it was borrowed from the right wing...and they wore it out before they gave it to us.
DRoseDARs
(6,810 posts)zeemike
(18,998 posts)And I have been around and have been paying attention ...do you have a link to where Bush was called Dear Leader?
DRoseDARs
(6,810 posts)...don't think you were paying as close attention as you think you were. Popquiz, did you ever see any of THESE nicknames for Bush: The Chimperor, Il Dunce, Bush* (yes, with the asterisk), Commander Bunnypants, the Idiot Son, Chimpy McStagger (those are just the ones off the top of my head... 8 years is a long time for *that* man to earn nicknames...).
Also, you're welcome. Now you have more names to call him than just "motherfucker."
zeemike
(18,998 posts)To answer your pop quiz.
But I may not fly in the same circles as you do...and tend not to pay attentions to threads where it is all name calling and no substance...there were far too much substantive posters here to waste my time on that kind of garbage.
And for your information I don't ever recall calling him motherfucker...but do a search to see if you can catch me on it if you like.
smokey775
(228 posts)zeemike
(18,998 posts)Out of 65 million post you found 4 or 5 that proved it was pervasive and I should have seen it.
I am so humiliated that I was not paying attention.
smokey775
(228 posts)Took me all of 1 minute using google to find those 5, something you could've done instead of dismissing it off hand.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)But out of 65 million posts my guess you could find any combinations of words you chose to look for.
But after being here a month you are now an expert on DU...and have looked into it's archives and seen it's soul.
Bacchus4.0
(6,837 posts)booooooo! that's what dear leader Maduro does.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)And if the shoe fits wear it...Maduro was elected in a fair and open election and to imply that he is like an appointed dictator is unfair and wrong...something that the right wing practices all the time.
But in defense of calling Bush Dear Leader, (which I don't agree with at all)...Bush WAS appointed to the job by the SCOTUS and lost the popular vote.
What a beautiful function to disprove statements.
All I did was type in "dear leader bush", something you could have easily done before making your comment.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)I said I never saw it, and I have read a lot on DU over the past decade, that means it was not pervasive enough for a long time member to have seen it...not that it was never said in 65 million posts.
But if you searched 65 million post on right wing sites you would find thousands, tens of thousands of post that said Dear Leader Obama...so what does that prove?
smokey775
(228 posts)before making your comments.
I know I'm new here, but even I figured that out, so, as a veteran of DU, why couldn't you?
zeemike
(18,998 posts)Not was said or not said on 65 million post on DU.
And why? because I don't go looking for things to discredit people with or to justify right wing memes...I am hear for the intellectual stimulation not the angst.
Oh and BTW, Du especially in the early years was the absolutely best place on the net for intellectual stimulation and substantive conversations...and it is still here, but often you have to dig through a bunch of shit to find it.
smokey775
(228 posts)Even after the evidence that it's used by both sides?
But you attacked another poster claiming that they were using RW slogans, but didn't even bother to do a little bit of research to see that it's not just a RW meme.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)that makes it even I guess.
And calling attention to facts is not an attack unless you are just being defensive of the misinformation.
smokey775
(228 posts)Just google "dear leader bush" and you'll find there are many, many more posts on DU.
I only posted 5 thinking that would be enough to disprove your comment, but, I guess I was wrong.
It sure sounds like you're the one being defensive here, not me.
It really is ok to admit that you might have been wrong and move past this, but I guess for some people, that's not an option.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)And project right back to me.
I am seeing that all the time now on DU...which is what I mean by digging through the shit.
But you are right you are not being defensive at all...offence is the best defense.
smokey775
(228 posts)just not this one, so, let's call it even and move on from here. Ok?
Judi Lynn
(160,542 posts)smokey775
(228 posts)Judi Lynn
(160,542 posts)smokey775
(228 posts)and do some research.
Those 5 links took me all of 1 minute to find and there are lots more there.
Bacchus4.0
(6,837 posts)who is inaccurate a lot.
bitchkitty
(7,349 posts)to mock and disparage the people they fear and the leaders they wish to destroy. I'm not saying the left does not mock and disparage (with Chimpie, who among us could help himself?) but it is a standard practice for the right - in the playbook, so to speak.
That's why you saw Chavez called names like Fatso, why you see them calling Maduro "Dear Leader" and other such amazingly creative names. They can't help themselves. It's what they are.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)Why not buy a coup?...it is cheap these days.
MADem
(135,425 posts)jzodda
(2,124 posts)The students are neocons? How much do you want to bet that none of them even know what that US political term means. Stop looking at everything through the prism of US politics. It sounds so elitist.
reformist2
(9,841 posts)dotymed
(5,610 posts)and the Real News (which I depend on) the students are mostly from the private universities (elites) and even if I supported the goals of my govt. As a poor person, I too would have to protest the food shortages/inflation, etc.
That has been caused by the elite hoarding to destabilize Socialism. They(elites) want their crony capitalism back.
Wall St. has begun hoarding commodities in America now to drive the prices up along with their PROFITS.
When this affects you....
EX500rider
(10,849 posts)Says people who know zero about economics or have ever owned a business.
Government sets artificial price too low to keep up with inflation so business's can either lose money when they sell locally or sell across the border or hold on to the stock and see if any thing changes. Doesn't take any right wing plot, just businessmen who don't want to lose everything and go out of business.
Comrade Grumpy
(13,184 posts)MADem
(135,425 posts)Water cannon as well...courtesy of the twitter feed of Anonymous Venezuela:
:large
:large
zeemike
(18,998 posts)If it was OWS that were throwing stones an burning things in the street you would say they derserved what they got...and in fact some say they deserved what they got even when they were peaceful.
And suddenly people become experts in a south American country and believe any and all propaganda they see put out...but one side only... and you seldom see the other side presented and when it is it is dismissed as propaganda.
If you google this you will find tons of this Maduro is evil dictatory stuff and little of the other side...why is that?
Just as people are now an expert on the Ukrain and know all about it....and 2 weeks ago they could not find it on a map.
The internet is a wonderfull tool for information and disinformation...and if you can't tell the diference you become thier fool.
MADem
(135,425 posts)That's why they get support -- because they tell us what they are protesting about and they get up off their asses and MOVE every day.
Camping isn't protesting. Standing around handing around a talking stick and waving fingers in the air led to what?
The Venezuelans are asking for some basic things, here--we know what they want. They want security--both in terms of protection from crime, to incude 25K murders a year, and FOOD security; they want the shelves of the grocery stores stocked, they don't want rationing, shortages, and Maduro telling them to just eat less, they want a reduction in inflation which is at the runaway stage--the economy is near collapse; they want the police to stop shooting students, they want the hundreds of prisoners taken released, they want the censorship of the media and the internet to cease. For STARTERS....
My grandfather helped to build Caracas, but thanks for your "concern." I've been able to find it on a map for longer than most people are alive.
This isn't "disinformation" either. This is happening, and it's going to keep happening, no matter how often Maduro tells people to "go to the beach." They're organized, they're determined, they're not afraid, and they're doing this the right way--everyone knows what they want, hell, THEY know what they want (unlike huge swathes of OWS, who were not unified in their goals), and they are keeping up the pace, not hanging around in tents all day. So yeah--funny how that actually WORKS when there's competent leadership at the helm:
That's just a few of the protests scheduled for TODAY. I assume, since you're lecturing me with Ye Olde Finger Wag, that you can read all that, if not, let me know what you're having trouble with and I can translate. That is not an all-inclusive list. There will be another list posted tonight to direct people where to go and what to do tomorrow. Amazing how organization and effort can achieve results...! The only solid demos that OWS was able to muster had UNION help and leadership.
This isn't a "Nothing to see here, move along" game. The people are pissed off, quite justifiably, they aren't asking for the moon, they want BASICS. In a country sitting on the most oil reserves in the world they aren't out of line. Maduro and his corrupt cronies have FUCKED Venezuela, and Cuba is extracting as much as they can before the gravy train goes off the tracks. Maduro has made bad bargains with China to get loans he'll be paying back forever in oil--if he can get it out of the ground because the equipment is broken and no one will give him credit because he's a sleaze who doesn't pay his bills. His "friends" are robbing the joint blind. The place is a mess, and it's HIS fault. He's made a bad situation much, much worse. The frigging presidential palace has peeling paint, Chavez's kids won't move out and they're partying like it's 1999 up in there. The country is going to hell. That's why we're seeing this kind of thing, now:
It's not about Chavismo anymore. That died three months before they buried Hugo.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)Last edited Mon Mar 3, 2014, 07:08 PM - Edit history (1)
And burning shit in the streets?...and had violent leaders?...and should have come from the 1%.
Good luck with that, if it had come from the 1% in this country it would not be protesting against Wall Street...they would have been protesting against Commie Obama like the Tea Party and like the Tea Party the cops would do nothing.
The 1% want that oil back, and I am sure they will get it by force if nessesary...and things will go right back to where it was before Chavez which was not so good for the people as it was for the rich.
But the country with the highest murder rate right now is Honduras, which is twice as high as VZ...and they had their coup to depose an elected president...and the right wing are in firm control.
And it is noted just how much propaganda you have for the oppisition...not surprising sense they have plenty of money to spend on it...some of it from the CIA.
Tarheel_Dem
(31,234 posts)http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/feb/20/venezuelas-poor-protests-chavez-revolution
"The poor neighbourhood of Petare in western Caracas is not an obvious hotbed of anti-government sentiment. In the past, its residents have been among the major beneficiaries of Venezuela's public health and education campaigns, and an economic policy that resulted in one of the sharpest falls in inequality in the world.
But as demonstrations sweep several major cities, even the people of Petare have taken to the streets to protest again surging inflation, alarming murder rates and shortages of essential commodities.
Jorge Farias, a self-employed motorcycle taxi driver, once voted for the late president Hugo Chávez, but this week he joined opposition rallies.
"This country can't stay like this for much longer. If it's not lack of food, it is the fear of being killed when you step out of your house to go to work", he said. "I would like to wake up without this fear," he added. "I have never seen this country in this state of total collapse. We are going from bad to worse, and we are losing faith". "Ya esta bueno ya", is phrase which Venezuelans are hearing with increasing frequency. Roughly translated as "Enough already", the slogan captures a wide-spread sense of discontent and growing uncertainty over the country's future."
Is the Guardian in on it too?
zeemike
(18,998 posts)OWS should take a clue from the opposition in VZ....and tear up the place, then maybe you will support them...
William Briceño barely escaped the government building in Chacao where he works before it was ransacked by protesters last week. "I came to work the next day and someone had stolen my computer and several of my belongings," he said, speaking through a shattered office window. "These protests are not the solution. Students say they want dialogue but they destroy everything around them."
Inside the office, his colleagues were working on makeshift desks and kitchen tables: the furniture was looted or destroyed during the protests. The sign outside had been torn down, and in its place graffiti read: "SOS Venezuela".
"Dialogue would be the best way out but the government has refused to acknowledge our problems. Still I can't support or understand where this violence takes us," Briceño said.
Obviously peaceful protest gets you nowhere.
In case you don't know.
Tarheel_Dem
(31,234 posts)your WRONG thesis about who the protestors are in VZ. Occupy (RIP) went out with a whimper, and no one even noticed, and you can blame it on whoever the hell you want. As for VZ, you'd probably throw a rock or two, if you had to resort to dried leaves. Now pass the talkin' stick.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)It was an attempt to peacefully bring change, and as you said it did not work.
And violence apparently will work if you have the backing of big money and the eliet...the rule of power is respected by many even here.
Democracy and peace are so overrated.
Common Sense Party
(14,139 posts)zeemike
(18,998 posts)(One of my favorite songs and artist)
Tarheel_Dem
(31,234 posts)Ron Paul movement at its roots, and I've seen nothing to change that assessment.
ddddemarco
(7 posts)clock is right twice a day*
*unless it has one of them am/pm doo-hickies.
Tarheel_Dem
(31,234 posts)EX500rider
(10,849 posts)Makes me wonder if you can find it on a map since Honduras (I assume that's what you were going for) is in Central America which is not the same thing at all as South America unless you fell asleep in geography class.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)I changed it.
ChangoLoa
(2,010 posts)Judi Lynn
(160,542 posts)your throat! Cool, isn't it?
They've been fooling some too long to turn back noooowwww. They've been channeling it into Venezuela for years, throughout the Bush pResidency.
Then there are the trolls who come here and pitch fits when people don't really want to see it all again, the same old stories they've been dragging around all this time. We have to pay for them, (propaganda orts engineered to replace the truth) then we have to keep hearing them over and over, and then people want to scuffle with us because we won't believe them.
Takes all kinds, unfortunately.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)You would think they would come up with something new once in a while but I suspect they lack imagination.
And the give away for me is when they defend the protesters throwing rocks at the cops and burning stuff in the streets and then criticize OWS for doing peaceful demonstrations....it leaves no doubt as to their goals and intent...
Judi Lynn
(160,542 posts)joshcryer
(62,276 posts)OWS did set fire to things.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)But a few agent provocateurs sure tried their best to get them too...and failed
But every little thing that could be thought up or made up was used to accuse them... and even here on a progressive site there was constant criticism.
And then the same people praise the opposition in anther country that does all of those things and more.
reddread
(6,896 posts)damn! Thats the first crucifixion Ive seen.
What a rush!
unfortunately, these zombie vampires keep going.
no brains or hearts necessary.
and they love silver.
30 pieces at a time.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)and in fact am against any punishment for expressing any opinion even if it is from the most blatant of propaganda spin.
But I can understand how they might feel crucified if people call them on it, because everyone feels sorry for someone hanging on the cross of exposure.
reddread
(6,896 posts)lying politicians and public officials.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)IMO
MADem
(135,425 posts)MADem
(135,425 posts)Look, you can try playing games all you'd like, telling falsehoods and attempting with desperate invective but no damn proof to put an imprimatur of veracity on your rantings, but those OWS protesters were not protesting rampant inflation, the worst crime rate in the world, scarcity of basic goods, and they weren't up against a police force, a national guard, and a bunch of assholes on motorbikes running around shooting people and provoking them.
The watchword for the protesters is "PAZ" and "nonviolencia" but you want to play games, you go right ahead--you aren't coming up with anything but "Nanny nanny boo boo."
The beaches are empty, the streets are full. Actions speak louder than words.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)And OWS tried to break away from that, knowing full well the history of the infiltration of the leadership of past movements...perhaps you don't know about that.
But who in the hell in this country is causing our economic problems if it is not Wall Street?...commie liberals?...the Democrats?...the president?...to imply that OWS was not about economic issues is just silly.
And it is NOT the worst crime rate in the world as I have pointed out and you could fact check that if you will...in the Americas it is Honduras which is twice as bad and has a dictatorship that came from a coup that deposed a democratic elected president...and I assume you supported that too?
And you blame the violence on the government when it is the students throwing rocks and tearing stuff up...and which would imply that you think that OWS should have had leaders like that in order to be sucessful?...and if they did you would be the first to say that they deserved to get the shit beat out of them for their violent ways.
You can't have it both ways.
And you suggest then that we here in the US should take to the streets like VZ...throw rocks at the cops, burn some cars, break into public buildings and trash the place if we want change...and then overthrow our elected president because it is his fault and not Wall Street and the elite banksters...got it...that is what you do when the vote does not go your way.
MADem
(135,425 posts)Last edited Tue Mar 4, 2014, 04:39 PM - Edit history (1)
You can't have it both ways.
2nd worst crime rate in the world...Puh-LEEZE. Like that makes a diff. Also, the gov't of VZ lies when they report these things. Most murders are UNSOLVED, too.
The students are not inciting violence--if you knew anyone down there in the thick of it, you'd know that. But you don't, so you don't. And you make stuff up to try to justify an unsupportable position.
Your last paragraph is a load of strawman bullshit. I suggest no such thing.
That's what people do when they got nuttin'--make stuff up and falsely ascribe it. No sale.
Stop making this about OWS--they're dead and buried. They had a moment, they changed the conversation, but they aren't out in the streets, like the people of VZ are today, and will be tomorrow, and the next day, and the next....SOS Venezuela.
Look what happened today: https://twitter.com/apocaliptico777/status/440920935546118145/photo/1
And look what ELSE happened:
zeemike
(18,998 posts)You are on the side of those who want to depose a democratically elected president and install someone who will give back the oil to private individuals and I am not.
You support violent protest (and don't give us the bullshit that they are not because some of your own propaganda photos show them throwing rocks at the cops)...and I do not.
And you believe anything that the elite media says about it and reject any evidence by the government as lies and I do not...and if I posted again the recorded conversation of the elite leaders piloting this to be like the April 11 2002 attempted coup you would call it government lies because you don't want to hear it...and I do.
So don't you worry about a thing, they will win and take back the rich oil fields for the 1% and that will make you happy and it will make me sad that once again money and power trumps people...and once they have what they want and will eliminate any opposition with death squads...and you will say they deserved it because the elite are just worth more and the commies must die to make the world safe for them.
So when it happens you can post your joy here in a post saying that you were right and that you won and I lost.
Sound pesimistic?...well it is, but my pessimism is your optimism and we are so different in that respect.
MADem
(135,425 posts)I am on the "side" of people who want a reduction in the murder rate, an improvement in physical security, a halt to people in the Maduro regime robbing the country blind and making bad deals that don't benefit the people, food on the supermarket shelves, a halt to the rampant inflation that is making the currency useless, and an end to rule by decree out of Havana.
If Maduro shapes up, he doesn't have to ship out--but of course that wouldn't fit your anxious "coup" scenario; because you've got to be dire about stuff.
Only someone who has NO clue would be babbling about "oil fields for the one percent" when that asset is nationalized and there's no turning back on that score -- you plainly haven't been paying ANY attention to what is happening in VZ. It's not ABOUT that. It IS, though, about wasting that asset, about the "Boligarchs" stealing the treasure of the people and socking it away in Swiss banks and spending crazily on stupid shit.
The people from the SLUMS are joining those protests. They see the handwriting on the wall. Maduro is giving all that "One Percent" oil to the Chinese in exchange for cash, and he's indebting the people of VZ for YEARS with bad deals. He's also giving away the treasure of the people to Cuba, and getting precious little (except for shitty advice) back for what he gives away.
The "elite media" isn't reporting SHIT. Anonymous VZ and the people who are out on the streets with their cameras are the ones who are getting information out, despite the desperate attempts by the government to silence people with roving gangs of shooters, police and NG firing on protesters, shutting down the internet, and arresting people by the hundreds.
This isn't just a few disgruntled people:
Try actually reading those emails. The regime is CORRUPT and you're the only one who hasn't gotten the memo. You're so wrapped up in ideology that you just aren't grasping that this isn't a "rich" thing, it's middle class, working class, students, and even the poor are getting up off their asses and joining the crowds. The situation is dire, and these people would just like to go to the store, not have to worry about getting killed on the way, not have to stand in line for three hours for rationed items, not be told by Maduro to "just eat less," and go home without being robbed/killed. They'd like to be able to buy basic medicines when they become ill or have chronic conditions. That is NOT too much to ask--and if you think it is, your priorities are messed up.
Pay no attention to the National Guard beating up CSM reporters...
https://twitter.com/photolarte/status/440633919290245121/photo/1
Andy Rosati of Christian Science Monitor in Venezuela, punched in face by Vzla police AFTER ID'ing himself as journo
A good day at the grocer:
These people do not want their country run by Cuba, and I can't say as I blame them:
That's what this is about.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)that repeats everything you said before?...Is it that you just must have the last word?
Or you think by repeating your points you will convince me or anyone who reads it?
We disagree and I don't believe the propaganda no more than I believe Tea Party propaganda put out by Brightbart or Fox...sorry but I don't...I have seen this movie before.
MADem
(135,425 posts)Here, don't listen to me --- open your eyes, watch and learn:
zeemike
(18,998 posts)But it was made by a independ source.
The Revolution will not be tellivised...
MADem
(135,425 posts)That material I offered to you is DAYS and hours old. It's current.
You're flopping up old stuff from three years ago as a retort. Hint: Chavez is dead. He died in Cuba well before the nation was told of his demise, but he's well and truly dead. This is not about Chavez. If you watched the VICE pieces, you'd figure that out.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)In April of 2002...which the video I posted shows to be created as propaganda to blame it on Chavez to give the military an excuse to oust him.
And if I were to post the video that shows the leaders of this present opposition talking about doing the same thing again now you would dismiss it as government propaganda.
But that is how things go, you believe what you want and insist that only one side has the truth...the side you side with.
MADem
(135,425 posts)Don't watch, don't learn.
Those Chavistas from the poor neighborhoods are participating in these demos with the students. It has nothing to do with "sides" unless you are not on the side of
--Freedom from crime and murder and oppression
--Ending rampant inflation, rationing and shortages
--Keeping VZ's oil profits for Venezuelans, instead of giving away vast amounts to Cuba for little return;
--Stopping censorship, rule by decree, and attacks by the armed forces and paramilitaries against these students, along with rampant arrests.
But hey--play a binary game. That's not what these students are about, and that is why the people who identify as "Chavistas" are turning out and participating with them.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)This is a binary game...and you are one side I so I have no choice but to be on the other.
And then repeat your charges as if I had not already given my side of it, because repeating it seems to make you think it will be accepted as the truth.
Really it reminds me of the Tea Party tactics, the GOP shut the government down and then says Obama shut the government down because he would not submit to our demands...it is always the ones you are opposition's fault...and you are meanly the victims.
And they put out pictures like you have posted about OWS...showing them shirting in the streets, burning and looting, and accuse them of raping women and all other manner of crime...and we are supposed to fall for it?
Well sorry I don't...I know if you have millions to spend you can create any image you want to create, and they defiantly have more money than they need to do it...at least 5 million from our own government.
MADem
(135,425 posts)Who shut the buses down? Maduro.
Who declared a five day fiesta? Maduro. Go to the beach, he said! He also said "Eat less," in response to rationing. He doesn't look like he has missed a meal.
Maduro shut down the country--all by himself, by decree. The students aren't doing what he demanded they do, though. Oh well.
I guess the VICE producers work for "the opposition," too...is that your logic?
zeemike
(18,998 posts)The mass shootings in this country are Obama's fault because he did nothing to stop it...and he needs to resigne...so let us take to the streets, burn cars, throw rocks and attack the cops and tear up stuff until he does.
The poor economy is Obama's fault and though he was elected he needs to step down.
Obama shut down the country all by himself by refusing to compromise...and the Tea Party is not doing what he said they should do...oh well.
And I guess the Wall Street investors and the Mafia work for Obama too...(which is kind of funny because the truth is he works for them)
See, when you apply the same standards to us hear in the USA it sounds more like Brightbart than DU.
MADem
(135,425 posts)You do not stand in line with a ration book for groceries, for hours. You don't endure shortages of basic goods, continuously.
You do not live in fear of being murdered every waking moment.
You do not suffer from food insecurity, and Obama didn't tell you and everyone else to "eat less."
You aren't constrained from travel because Obama shut down the buses, you can post on DU because Obama isn't censoring your internet access.
You weren't told to "go to the beach" in order to try to mitigate nationwide protests in every major city where the streets are filled to the brim with students.
A dictator to whom Obama is handing over huge sums of American national treasure isn't visiting to be kowtowed to by Obama.
The police, national guard and paramilitaries are not shooting at students in the streets.
Students are not being arrested, tortured, beaten and bullied in USA.
So, let's NOT "apply standards" that are, well, nonsensical. And how curiously bizarre that you think that VICE is Breitbart....says a lot about your (lack of) discrimination skills when it comes to news coverage.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)that gives you permission to judge them different than we judge ourself?
So where is that line when we say it is OK to judge them diferent?...what murder rate triggers " fear of being murdered every waking moment"
And what triggers an insult statement by the president?...is saying "you can keep your insurance" not an insult and "go to the beach" is?...well the right wing in this country are insulted by the "keep" statement, do they have a point then?
But Obama is not handing over billions to his friends on Wall Street but Maduro is?
And peeper spraying students in peaceful protest is OK because no one got killed?...just badly injured?...but no we don't beat and torture people in the US...we send them to Gitmo for that...so we don't cross that line to where we have to judge ourself like we judge others.
Obviously you don't understand the moral principles I am talking about and I can't make you see it.
MADem
(135,425 posts)And it has been for some time. You don't know what's going on there, plainly, because you wouldn't keep trying for false equivalencies if you did.
If you speak Spanish, this might help you "get" it. Listen to the protesters at the 2nd half of this video telling you WHY they are protesting.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)And dictatorships do not have fair and open elections...and your claim that Maduro is, is different than the claims of the tea party that Obama is a dictator...and the fact that you believe one and not the other makes no difference at all.
But here you go...a tea bagger telling you why they protest...that makes it the truth...and justifies what they do.
MADem
(135,425 posts)No.
Sale.
If Maduro can fix the problems I've outlined, he'll be a hero. If he can't, he'll be a goat.
Stop thinking in childish, binary terms.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)And it is an act of violence not an accident.
And if someone would have been shot at OWS you would demand conclusive proof that it was TPTB that was behind it, and may have even suggested that they caused it thyself to gain support for the cause...but no evidence is required at all for you to declare Maduro behind the killings and tell us that this is the reason we should support the oppositon...and completely overlook the history of who was behind it the last time...and how they used it as an excuse for the military to depose Chavez.
Morality does not have two standards just one, is it right or is it wrong...and degree makes no difference.
MADem
(135,425 posts)There's been more demonstration in the last month in VZ than there ever was, sea to shining sea, by OWS. And no, camping doesn't count.
Get off the OWS bandwagon. It's just not an apt comparison.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)They were peaceful and did not attack the cops and destroy property...so it don't count?
But they are bad and the ones that do the violence things are good?...and justified?
The comparison I am making is about the double standard.
RobertEarl
(13,685 posts)Madem supports the overthrow of a democratically elected government.
And Madem supports using violence to do so.
I guess it's ok as long as it is somewhere else and Madem can just sit back and laugh at the deaths and injuries Madem supports.
Were this situation in the US, Madem would be banned from DU. But since it is in a country that his grandfather worked and made lots of money 'building Caracas', Madem is fine with the violence and destruction and overthrow of duly elected government.
You are morally correct. Madem is not.
zeemike
(18,998 posts)and if there is enough money in it nothing is to immoral for some people...and there is nothing that cannot be rationalized.
cprise
(8,445 posts)of protesters at events most infotainment media didn't think was newsworthy... because we were demonstrating here in the US.
Judi Lynn
(160,542 posts)by Democrats and other progressives altogether. They did it abruptly, too. Very conspicuous.
Loved the facts that during one right-wing turnout in Washington, for Glenn Beck, they actually published, in actual newspapers, photos of a crowd which were actually taken at another time of the year, in the summer, when the trees were wearing their best green leaves, although when this right-wing cluster-#### was held, it was during the fall, or winter, and there were NO leaves.
We have to remind ourselves of who is actually controlling corporate media, after all the mergers, etc. Not a pretty picture, is it?
cprise
(8,445 posts)By and large we choose not to break them up or prevent other industrial interests from buying into them.
And when the left contemplates the media problem, it focuses on the "glory days" of the Fairness Doctrine. This to me explains why we get nowhere, because in my mind FD was the vehicle for how we got here. Becoming preoccupied with FD has left us with a media reform concept that is a non-starter and, IMO, would hurt progressives more than help because the right has become expert at fabrication and misdirection.
We should never take our eyes away from the money/ownership issues: They should remain paramount.
Anyway, its clear as of now the 1% have lined up the media against a progressive advance in the midterms. This could make 2000 look like a love fest.
Do you remember the union/NAACP march on Washington, October 2010 to rebut Beck's rally that year? It was the one almost no one paid attention to but the turnout was at least 50% higher than Beck's event. Then John Stuart got in the act and did a rally that was even larger (though I hear it was a load of snark).
JackRiddler
(24,979 posts)smokey775
(228 posts)JackRiddler
(24,979 posts)The pro-oligarchic movement of Venezuela is known for producing a constant stream of falsely attributed images and outrageous fabrications and exaggerations. Sorry, after their performance so far, that's just a track record that's hard to get away from. It's the baseline. Too many of these stories fall apart after examination, so there can't be a presumption of honesty. It requires authentication.
But quite independently of that, there are really quite simple conventions for citations of visual material on the Internet (where it is intended as evidence of something).
Do you need a guide? Okay:
- Link to the outlet where this was published?
- Credit for photograph?
- Location? Descriptive caption?
While I have no reason to doubt the authenticity of your picture -- the Venezuelan pro-oligarchy movement does have a strong street presence, even if over the years on average much smaller than the pro-government rallies -- your merely fronting a photo without these simple conventions to back it up doesn't help.
Not required but also helpful would be:
Better image of the signs? Nowadays, there's probably a whole album, right?
Any overhead shots, by chance? Or something very high resolution.
Also, a link to the organizers of the march. They probably have an online presence, organizational names, no?
Thanks so much.
EX500rider
(10,849 posts)Gosh is that what they call themselves or did you make that up yourself?
JackRiddler
(24,979 posts)They call themselves by nicer names but I also didn't make up that they are the pro-oligarchic movement. The rank and file of the Tea Party and the large Republican voting public in this country also do not think of themselves as the supporters of oligarchy, but on this board it would not be controversial to say that objectively, this is what they are.
freshwest
(53,661 posts)They were made by either conquest or influences such as religion and things that could be construed as populist movements of a former time.
Those who descended from that older populism, even the poor (and I'm really stretching the term for something that does not fit the common term) are just as wedded to them as Catholics are to the Vatican.
These are social movements that preceded the governments in the Americas for centuries. Just putting that there, because I don't think we grasp how deep the roots of oligarchy go, from before nation states.
Not all countries and cultures have gone the feudal > capitalist > socialist or the infected 'capitalism that wouldn't die' version we have now. Agrarian societies were and are natural oligarchies.
That we had a homestead act (problematic to social justice for natives) and the creation of what some refer to as populist movements from Granges and other organizations that turned into unions is not the same as the history of the SA.
Some are trying to create that but it's only worked in a few instances. I hoped Chavez or Maduro would do something of that sort, to bring equality to those who had lived under the centuries of oligarchy in VZ. With global markets creating what I'd call a super oligarchy is coming to bear and is not able to be resisted one nation or region at a time.
The solution to combat this for this day and age?
I don't know. But many are suffering from being kept in competition with workers in other nations and social stratification is building. There is here is no way to bring them to account.
While I have no desire to say, 'If you can't beat 'em, join 'em' that may what is making Venezuela so unstable now. And I think a lot of young people are going to go with the flow and not hold onto the ideology we thought of as the solution.
joshcryer
(62,276 posts)You only get that in the wealthy neighborhoods or with more effective propagandists who can afford the equipment to show off the crowds in a way conductive to the narrative and accessible to western tastes that require "high quality production":
In most areas you only get low quality stuff:
Just search YouTube for "marzo 2014 venezuela" for recently uploaded videos. Look for low view count stuff, not stuff from official news channels (some are spam, some are propaganda). The low view count stuff will be stuff uploaded from peoples' phones.
Oh, and don't be disturbed when you come across many videos of GNB violence, which, btw, isn't happening.
MADem
(135,425 posts)Go check them out...unless they are a "buncha liars" too. Everyone is a liar except Maduro and his puppetmaster, Raul, apparently.
I guess the Christian Science Monitor journalist who was beaten after he identified himself as a journalist is one of those big fat liars, too....!
Why is it that people who are on the ropes like to accuse others of being liars? It's something I've never understood.
Here--do you believe THESE guys? Or are these "falsely attributed images?" Yeah, I'll bet these guys photoshopped this report, somehow....
Nothing to see here, move along, is that it?
Zorra
(27,670 posts)Last edited Mon Mar 3, 2014, 04:09 PM - Edit history (1)
opposition sponsored protests have ever had in one day.
JackRiddler
(24,979 posts)The scale of protests almost anywhere in the world outside the U.S. (short of permanent martial law places like Korea) tends to be far greater. The point in Venezuela is not absolute but relative size: the street is obviously more often crowded with Bolivarians than with the (nevertheless plentiful) pro-oligarch movement.
Zorra
(27,670 posts)Last edited Mon Mar 3, 2014, 07:18 PM - Edit history (1)
and underestimates the size of left wing protests, I can find no information that there have been any opposition protests with over 30,000 protesters.
In fact, the most I have found is 20.000 so far since the beginning of the current protests.
The Keystone protest had 40,000 protesters.
If you can find any credible information that there have been 40,000 or more opposition protesters protesting in a single day during the current spate of protests, would you please post it? I don't like posting false information, so if you believe that I am error, I would appreciate you, or anyone else, posting credible information that proves me wrong.
Thanks!
Common Sense Party
(14,139 posts)by government-sponsored biker gang goon squads when they tried to congregate together, would you please post it?
20,000 is a huge number in Venezuela, and you know it.
freshwest
(53,661 posts)Zorra
(27,670 posts)...land.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/world/asia_pacific/us-forces-killed-8-civilians-most-of-them-children-in-new-incident-karzai-says/2014/01/15/939e3244-7e17-11e3-97d3-b9925ce2c57b_story.html
KABUL Relations between the U.S. military and Afghan President Hamid Karzai are being tested once again after he accused American troops of killing eight civilians, including seven children, during a military operation in eastern Afghanistan on Wednesday.
According to Karzai and the governor of Parwan province, the incident occurred about 1 a.m. when U.S. Special Forces attempted to enter a home. A gun battle ensued, resulting in a coalition airstrike that killed the children and a female relative in the house, they said.
http://www.cnn.com/2012/09/25/world/asia/pakistan-us-drone-strikes/
The number of civilians plus those individuals whose precise status could not be determined from media reports -- labeled 'unknowns' by NAF -- reported killed by drones in Pakistan during Obama's tenure in office were 11% of fatalities," said Bergen. "So far in 2012 it is close to 2%. Under President Bush it was 33%."
Occupy: There have been at least 7,765 documented arrests in 122 U.S. cities as of September 17, 2013
freshwest
(53,661 posts)The replies that you have taken to directing at me and others may make you feel superior, but don't advance your cause:
53. SAN CRISTÓBAL... That's the place josh cryer talks about. Maybe he'll chime in with some news. nt
http://www.democraticunderground.com/1014737822#post53
Your reply was:
56. Can't wait! nt
http://www.democraticunderground.com/1014737822#post56
To which I replied:
69. From his comments, I believe he has family there and is concerned. BTW, I am not in favor of coups.
In both this case and Ukraine, the issues could have been dealt with politically.
A parliamentary system could have changed the situation in Ukraine. Although it appears that the Fatherland party is more socialist than would first appear by this description of their platform which includes reversing privatization. They don't appear to as far right as the Svoboda group, who are a horrorible party.
Venezuela elected Maduro, but at this time he is using the wrong methods to maintain power, like the Ukrainian guy.
I have Russian and Ukrainian friends and family in my extended group, and from Latin America - well, let me amend that - Mexico - but they have very, very strong opinions. The Russians I know are extremely emotional and fearful now.
They, like me, want a peaceful resolution and for all sides to work together.
It's likely some of the most fevered posts here have family there or in Venezuela, which I think josh cryer has.
http://www.democraticunderground.com/1014737822#post69
I had wanted clarity from a person who appears to know and care about the area and you left me an insult, I guess.
I then gave a thoughtful and sincere answer to your reply, and you did not reply to it.
Now you seem to intimate that I am an authoritarian, no? Or are you trying to school me on the wrongdoings in foreign policy and history like I'm some kind of idiot for asking for clarification from a person who has something to lose in that region of the world?
I do not use such techniques with others at DU, as I respect other members as Democrats, progressive and liberals and those who have lived different lives from myself, may have come to different conclusions in their life struggles.
I don't respect RWNJs or bullies and am not associated with such, if that is your meaning. I've been respectful and humane in my opinion on these tragic situations, and you are tossing comments at me that don't advance your view, which I am not against.
I am not expecting a reasoned reply from you now on the issue at hand - that anyone who is using biker gangs instead of lawful authority, and not police or military - as I have stated before in these threads, is not doing the right thing as a government.
A question for you, if you choose to discuss it:
Do you think that such things are acceptable governmental response, even in response to an attempted coup?
As I have said before, and have gotten considerable heat for it, Maduro has a right to be paranoid about Lopez, who was part of the coup attempt against Chavez. A coup is the wrong way to change things and does not usually increase democracy anywhere. We have our own RWNJs who are constantly calling for a coup against Obama and Democrats and threatening to kill all liberals and progressives. Why would I be in favor of that in any other country?
I am not anti-Maduro, nor was I anti-Chavez, nor am I in favor of oligarchial rule. But I'm not so blind as to not see its power and how it has been accomodated from both sides, and that in some nations, and sadly in our own as well, it is supported by large groups in the popuation.
We can deny that members of the GOP, Libertarian and Tea Party don't approve of the US Chamber of Commerce, what we call bad trade pacts or the Koch brothers. But we would living in a fantasy. Such groups will always have supporters in any country. After all, they are the ones paying them.
I don't like it, but it's foolish to deny its reality, and it does not mean that everyone of those people is a devil who should be eliminated from the planet. That would be the ideology of a rabid form of authoritarian personality. They must be worked with.
Peace Out.
Zorra
(27,670 posts)100,000 Rally for Besieged Chavez in Venezuela
http://articles.latimes.com/2004/mar/01/world/fg-chavez1
President joins 100,000 supporters in protest march
http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2002-08-25/news/0208250349_1_president-hugo-chavez-show-faith-coup
EX500rider
(10,849 posts)And the pictures above seem to have some pretty large crowds.
Response to Zorro (Original post)
Name removed Message auto-removed
BillZBubb
(10,650 posts)The "makers" want Maduro gone. The "takers" want Maduro to stay.
Which side are you on?
COLGATE4
(14,732 posts)In Venezuela the makers (the common citizens and studens, those that work and make the country) want to get rid of Maduro while the takers (the government power brokers and the boligarchs) want him to stay. Good analysis.
freshwest
(53,661 posts)joshcryer
(62,276 posts)Chavez saw that he had to do deals with rich Venezuelans to get things done in Venezuela after the oil workers went on strike (whether their strike had good intentions is irrelevant). He lamented that these deals were leading to a rise in "Bolivarian Oligarchs." (Chavismo is based on the concept of "Bolivarian Revolution."
Al Jazeera has a good overview: http://www.aljazeera.com/news/americas/2010/05/201052242911266217.html
They exist within the import/export industry and within the contract deals done under the Fonden Fund as well as with Currency Exchange. It would have been OK had the rich people being dealt with were outside of Venezuela (if you need BP to sell you some oil rigs, OK, fine, that's not a big deal), but instead what happened were Venezuelans themselves became enriched by being part of these deals, and only through shady deals where the Venezuelan people were over charged for services rendered. The Aban Pearl comes to mind, where the Venezuelan government paid for an offshore lease of an oil rig at $1.4 billion which in reality costed $700 million. $700 million, gone, disappeared, never to be seen again.
freshwest
(53,661 posts)COLGATE4
(14,732 posts)the 'Bolivarian Revolution', i.e. Chavez's political cronies.