Federal ruling calls future of Diablo Canyon reactors into question
Federal ruling calls future of Diablo Canyon reactors into question
Posted May. 21, 2015 / Posted by: Kate Colwell
Friends of the Earth: Decision is beginning of the end for troubled nuclear plant
WASHINGTON, D.C. In a major victory that could mark the beginning of the end for the Diablo Canyon nuclear reactors, U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commissioners have ruled that an Atomic Safety Licensing Board will decide whether Pacific Gas & Electric Co. was allowed to illegally alter the plant's license. This alteration is an attempt to hide the risk from powerful earthquake faults discovered since it was designed and built. The Commissions referral of the issue to the licensing board parallels a move that presaged the shutdown of Southern California Edisons San Onofre nuclear plant two years ago.
This is a major victory that could be the turning point for a nuclear-free future for California, said Damon Moglen of Friends of the Earth, which had petitioned the NRC, saying that the secret amendment of the license was an illegal maneuver designed to avoid holding a public hearing on the issue as required by federal law. PG&E now is following the same path that forced Southern California Edison to pull the plug on San Onofre, Moglen said.
<snip>
Todays decision is all but identical to that by the Commission in November 2012 in response to a similar petition from Friends of the Earth regarding the damaged nuclear reactors at San Onofre. In that case, the licensing board ruled in May 2013 that public hearings should be held as part of a formal license amendment proceeding to assess the safety of San Onofre. When Edison announced the closure of San Onofre a few weeks later, they referred to the ASLB decision.
This decision is indeed the beginning of the end for Diablo Canyon, said Dave Freeman, former head of the federal Tennessee Valley Authority, the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power and the Sacramento Municipal Utility District. PG&E is not going to get away with running Diablo Canyon when the plant can not withstand the ground motion from the earthquake faults we now know surround these reactors, said Freeman, a special advisor to Friends of the Earth.
<snip>
dixiegrrrrl
(60,010 posts)We simply cannot afford to be wrong on this issue.
blondie58
(2,570 posts)We don't need another Fukishima schale disaster. End nukes now!
FBaggins
(26,748 posts)The "federal ruling" went clearly against FOE... yet they want to call it a "major victory".
Similarly, they're trying to claim that this could lead to the shuttering of the plant because SONGS shut down just after this stage in a different proceeding. The problem with that (of course) is that SONGS was already shut down... and the owner was trying to determine whether or not it was worth spending billions of dollars to replace faulty steam generators while not knowing how the ASLB would rule.
In this case, they don't need to shut down and even a poor ruling from the ASLB (highly unlikely) wouldn't close the plant. So how does FOE spin that into a victory?