Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

mahatmakanejeeves

(57,457 posts)
Fri Sep 11, 2015, 12:22 PM Sep 2015

We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets

Hat tip, Google group sci.electronics.repair: Right to repair article in WSJ

We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets

People can fight back against planned obsolescence by fixing the tech we already own, but the consumer electronics industry isn’t making it easy

By Geoffrey A. Fowler
Geoffrey.Fowler@wsj.com
@geoffreyfowler
Updated Sept. 8, 2015 3:04 p.m. ET

We don’t have to keep buying new gadgets. In fact, we should insist on the right to keep old ones running.

Who hasn’t experienced a situation like this? Halfway through a classic Jack Lemmon DVD, my colleague Shira’s 40-inch TV conked out. Nothing showed up on the screen when she pressed the power button. The TV just hiccupped, going, “Clip-clop. Clip-clop.” ... This was a great excuse to dump her old Samsung and buy a shiny new TV, right? But before heading to Best Buy, Shira gave me a call hoping for a less expensive option, not to mention one that’s better for the environment.

We ended up with a project that changed my view on our shop-till-you-drop gadget culture. We can fix more technology than we realize, but the electronics industry doesn’t want us to know that. In many ways, it’s obstructing us.

There’s a fight brewing between giant tech companies and tinkerers that could impact how we repair gadgets or choose the shop where we get it done by a pro. At issue: Who owns the knowledge required to take apart and repair TVs, phones and other electronics? ... Manufacturers stop us by controlling repair plans and limiting access to parts. Some even employ digital software locks to keep us from making changes or repairs. This may not always be planned obsolescence, but it’s certainly intentional obfuscation.

Full disclosure: I gave away a TV last year that had a problem I could easily have fixed. It had a whopping 12" screen, and I figured that since I could fix a newer, bigger set with the same amount of effort, the small TV wasn't worth my time. I don't feel guilty; I left it out on the front sidewalk, and someone helped himself to it. I even left attached a note to it that described the problem and said what parts were needed.
16 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
We Need the Right to Repair Our Gadgets (Original Post) mahatmakanejeeves Sep 2015 OP
My 40" Samsung conked out like that. Gidney N Cloyd Sep 2015 #1
The set I gave away was a fairly recent Magnavox. mahatmakanejeeves Sep 2015 #2
How do you feel about Micro USB ports seabeckind Sep 2015 #3
Scored a free 65" Projection TV Years Ago kracer20 Sep 2015 #4
I had a 42 inch Sony Trinitron... awoke_in_2003 Sep 2015 #14
So why aren't components designed to be interchangeable? seabeckind Sep 2015 #5
Have to add a Header to make it interchangable One_Life_To_Give Sep 2015 #8
"no standard for the interconnect" seabeckind Sep 2015 #10
Standardized at what level and cost? One_Life_To_Give Sep 2015 #11
Standardization at the interface layer. seabeckind Sep 2015 #12
Your Router links the WAN to your LAN One_Life_To_Give Sep 2015 #13
But you see, once you hardwire combine devices seabeckind Sep 2015 #16
Then become a member of ifixit.org!!! retrowire Sep 2015 #6
Great resource IDemo Sep 2015 #15
There is a reason TV repair shops are going out of buisiness One_Life_To_Give Sep 2015 #7
I agree we should demand the repair plans peasant one Sep 2015 #9

Gidney N Cloyd

(19,835 posts)
1. My 40" Samsung conked out like that.
Fri Sep 11, 2015, 12:40 PM
Sep 2015

Googling the symptoms pointed to the power supply. I ordered a new one-- if you can handle a screwdriver you can install a power supply. Helluva lot easier than taking all the tubes down down to Walgreens to test them.

mahatmakanejeeves

(57,457 posts)
2. The set I gave away was a fairly recent Magnavox.
Fri Sep 11, 2015, 12:45 PM
Sep 2015

Last edited Fri Sep 11, 2015, 03:22 PM - Edit history (3)

I Googled the usual newsgroups. It was notorious for capacitor failure. I mean, 91 days after you bought it, out they'd go. Its screen size, though, made fixing it a bad investment of my time. You fix a 12" set, and you've got a really swell paperweight. I could fix a bigger set in the same amount of time, for the same expense, and have something useful.

I should add that I plucked it off the curb where it had been left by its previous owner, who was unsuccessful at unloading it at a yard sale, so I had nothing in it to begin with.

seabeckind

(1,957 posts)
3. How do you feel about Micro USB ports
Fri Sep 11, 2015, 03:06 PM
Sep 2015

Perfectly usable kindle but the port is screwed up.

Replacement costs couple bucks.

Special tool needed to open case and remove parts to get to it.

Soldering is impossible.

Laptop magnetic switch went out and laptop couldn't tell when the lid is up. Took the screen off with cutters and pliers and use it as a desktop.

kracer20

(199 posts)
4. Scored a free 65" Projection TV Years Ago
Fri Sep 11, 2015, 03:10 PM
Sep 2015

A friend had this TV in their garage sitting dead for a couple years and asked if I wanted it. This would have been around 8 years ago, so it was still decent. I Googled this TV and found they had a bad run of capacitors, and it could be repaired with some new capacitors and a little soldering skill. I ordered 11 capacitors from Digi-Key, so $5.29 and an hour of soldering later I had it working. Still use it in my basement, but I'm thinking it's days are numbered since the new flat TV's are getting cheaper all the time.

I might have a hard time giving this TV away now, it is a monster!

 

awoke_in_2003

(34,582 posts)
14. I had a 42 inch Sony Trinitron...
Fri Sep 11, 2015, 06:50 PM
Sep 2015

that started, intermittently, switching to black and white. I replaced it with the same size flat screen (weighing less than 30 pounds). I got a couple people over to help me get the Sony out to the curb (had to weigh 200 lbs) the day before trash day. An hour later it was gone. There is scrap value for them, and if people cruise your neighborhood like they do mine, someone will take it off your hands.

seabeckind

(1,957 posts)
5. So why aren't components designed to be interchangeable?
Fri Sep 11, 2015, 03:11 PM
Sep 2015

My cell phone wants to be a camera but takes lousy pictures.

My tv wants to be an internet machine. So does my blueray player.

My camera wants to talk wifi when it would work much better with Bluetooth. In either case the only way to send a picture is to put it on the pc, then send it to the Verizon mother ship and pretend it came from my phone.

Each of the different corporate entities is trying very hard to make it impossible to use someone else's technology.

One_Life_To_Give

(6,036 posts)
8. Have to add a Header to make it interchangable
Fri Sep 11, 2015, 03:40 PM
Sep 2015

Size constraint is the main reason followed by the cost of the connector. In many cases the connector can be larger than the component. And at the moment there is no standard for the interconnect so we couldn't mix and match anyway.

seabeckind

(1,957 posts)
10. "no standard for the interconnect"
Fri Sep 11, 2015, 04:39 PM
Sep 2015

Why not? There are RFCs that deal with all kinds of interchanges but why none when it comes to electronics after around the late 90's.

Oh we still have many RFC's but it seems like components should be modular.

Why pay for an internet comm system for your tv when the Blueray player plugged into it has the same capability? Or the PC that is linked into your audio system?

It seems like each gadget wants to do everything but ends up doing nothing well.

A QR code reader would be awesome for personal inventory control but you have to have proprietary software to use it.

One_Life_To_Give

(6,036 posts)
11. Standardized at what level and cost?
Fri Sep 11, 2015, 05:08 PM
Sep 2015

Comms interface between devices is settling on a version of Ethernet with IoT devices. In the above if your BlueRay player needs to comm over the internet how would it do that thru the TV? Again I think Internet of Things (IoT) is going to drive each device being able to control it's own comms with the internet over a variation of Ethernet (wired or WiFi) within each home and business.

There are products out there in the Commercial market where plug in devices for various comm protocols are supported. But the people who implement them have a system with many nodes already on a different protocol or other technical/availability reasons for using other protocols such a Hartt or ModBus.

seabeckind

(1,957 posts)
12. Standardization at the interface layer.
Fri Sep 11, 2015, 06:06 PM
Sep 2015

Why would the Blueray need to talk to the tv to get to the internet?

Why would the tv need to go thru the Blueray to get to the internet?

They are both essentially dumb boxes that get an input. Cost of each device will go down as soon as that module is no longer needed.

A router today provides an interface between multiple different function devices that provides peer-to-peer as well as connection to a modem -- whether it's a cable modem or a cell modem or a POTS modem.

The router includes software modules for each of those devices.

My camera does WiFi. My phone does WiFi. My phone will even function as a cell modem.

Cost comes down as soon as standardization is maintained because it ensures competition.

Long ago when consumer electrics was standardized at 115AC, we suddenly had thousands of devices. It meant people could mix and match and be confident of operability.

Same same.

One_Life_To_Give

(6,036 posts)
13. Your Router links the WAN to your LAN
Fri Sep 11, 2015, 06:42 PM
Sep 2015

It's a link between the Wide Area Network put up by your ISP and your Local Area Network. Since that usually means putting in two Ethernet ports, the cost to add a couple more is relatively low. And yes many add WiFi Transceivers although that could be done as a separate module that plugs into an open Ethernet port on your router, or a router with only WiFi could also be done. It is a bit cheaper to put it all in one box as that eliminates a second case and separate AC/DC power converter. The router itself does not need seperate software to talk to the various modems as their output is already on a standard comm protocol, usually Ethernet 10/100/1000t.


The promise of IoT is that of a cheap communications module which can be embedded into everyday items. That will allow your Smartphone to know that the Iron is still on, and if you have the right App it can tell you to go back and turn it off. Or combined with an actuator in a switch, allow you to turn it off remotely.

However that interface is not going to be cost effective to insert between a CCD and the Processor. At-least not on something the scale of a smartphone. There is a reason you are not buying a Car Chassis separately from the Coach anymore. Some things are still best done by connecting at the lowest possible layer.

seabeckind

(1,957 posts)
16. But you see, once you hardwire combine devices
Sun Sep 13, 2015, 08:08 AM
Sep 2015

you eliminate modularity.

Which means a change in the interface is much more expensive.

By using an easily switched module it adds adaptability.

For an example, refer to the explosion of the PC industry when IBM introduced a common interface and standards in their PC. Suddenly there were hundreds of 3rd party modules that added functionality. Of course that was offset by the stupid O/S interface that the folks at Microsoft foisted on us. They never have grasped the idea of compartmentalization.

For another example there's the USB.

And from a software standpoint there's the communications layers in networking.

retrowire

(10,345 posts)
6. Then become a member of ifixit.org!!!
Fri Sep 11, 2015, 03:18 PM
Sep 2015
http://ifixit.org

an organization dedicated to preserving our rights to maintain and alter our own property!

and its a fantastic resource to figure out how to fix everyday things.

One_Life_To_Give

(6,036 posts)
7. There is a reason TV repair shops are going out of buisiness
Fri Sep 11, 2015, 03:19 PM
Sep 2015

Just like your auto repair shop the small appliance repair shop has to cover their overhead, like liability insurance against burning down a customers home. When all is said and done you are looking at $100/hr just like your car repair shop. And if you could keep a steady stream of repairs coming thru the door you could manage to make a middle-class income doing this. For myself I would be like so many others not wanting to spend an hour troubleshooting someones TV, just to have them walk out the door when I tell them what it is going to cost to actually fix the problem.

Those handful of cases where it's one component associated with an infant mortality may be enticing but is not the norm in my experience. Oh and by the way for all you who want to try it. Aside from the hazards of line voltage. If you find one of the old Picture Tube sets. That is one of the worlds best capacitors. Can hold a charge for years. Voltage is roughly 1000V per diagonal inch of screen size.

edit spelling

peasant one

(150 posts)
9. I agree we should demand the repair plans
Fri Sep 11, 2015, 03:49 PM
Sep 2015

My washer stopped agitating and I was on the verge of getting a new washer--cause it would cost so much to have someone come out and fix my twenty year old one (I live fifteen miles out of town). But I thought, what would it hurt if I tried the repair? So I got online and watched a video of a guy repairing his washer and thought it wouldn't be that hard (but I did watch the video 10 times--and paused it as I made the repair.) I went to the manufacturer for the part that the video stated probably needed to be replaced (it was eight times more expensive than I found it on another site). Anyway to make a long story short-repaired the thing for $2.98. I have never done anything like this before or since but boy was it empowering!!!!

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Editorials & Other Articles»We Need the Right to Repa...