Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

n2doc

(47,953 posts)
Fri Sep 25, 2015, 10:11 AM Sep 2015

The Good Soldier: Why a Suicidal Officer Had to Go AWOL to Save His Life

BY JANET REITMAN

That Sunday night, March 29th, 2009, after the dinner dishes were done and put away, Lawrence Franks took out a bottle of Jameson and turned to his roommate, Matt Carney: "Ya wanna shot?" He asked this every night. Carney, like Franks, an officer in the Army's 10th Mountain Division, lifted his glass and made the first toast. Here's to the two of them and all that their lives now entailed: to surviving their first miserable winter at Fort Drum, to navigating the labyrinth of rules, regulations and duties that they, as newly minted second lieutenants, were still trying to make sense of. Here's to figuring it out.

Franks downed his drink, feeling the slow, soothing burn of the whiskey. He poured another shot. Take care of yourself, buddy, he thought. I'm sorry you're going to have to deal with my mess. "To you," he said to Carney.

Franks was consumed by what he was about to do: He was going to fuck over his unit, abandon his post, unfulfill his duty, shame his family, his friends, West Point, the Army, the country, God. He was deserting. Franks was 22, with the square-jawed good looks and chiseled physique that reminded at least a few of his friends of a gladiator. A meteorically high-achiever all his life, he'd graduated near the top of his West Point class of 2008, and now, less than three months into his first official posting, Franks was considered to be one of the best young lieutenants in the 2-22 Infantry Battalion, known as "Triple Deuce." All his life he'd been able to hold it together.

But it was a lie. Finishing his drink, Franks waited until he heard Carney turn on the shower, and then picked up the phone and ordered a taxi for 4 a.m. He set three alarms. He didn't want to pull a "Bay of Pigs," as he called it, by snoozing through his wake-up call.

In a matter of days, Lawrence Franks would be someone else — who, he didn't know. But he was tired of being himself. He hated being an officer. More than that, he felt unworthy. Every day was a struggle to maintain the facade, to find reasons not to die. It had been that way nearly as long as he could remember, and it had gotten worse since he arrived at Fort Drum in upstate New York. "I just need to get away," he'd written Carney that night. "I'm too weak inside." He'd hidden his agony from everyone. Still, it was a miracle that no one had realized it — or maybe they had, he wasn't sure. What he did know was that if he stayed one more minute on base he would shoot himself.



Read more: http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/the-good-soldier-why-a-suicidal-officer-had-to-go-awol-to-save-his-life-20150924#ixzz3mlA3dYoR

2 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
The Good Soldier: Why a Suicidal Officer Had to Go AWOL to Save His Life (Original Post) n2doc Sep 2015 OP
Context has meanings 4Q2u2 Sep 2015 #1
Clearly, you must have more information than the chief investigating officer considered.... xocet Sep 2015 #2
 

4Q2u2

(1,406 posts)
1. Context has meanings
Fri Sep 25, 2015, 11:48 AM
Sep 2015

This article is a pant load.

The family accuses the Army of a one sided prosecution, ( that is what a prosecution is supposed to do). It is up to the defense to propose the other side. At any time Franks could have had a Military or Civilian Lawyer for his Court Martial.

A: The GOOD SOLDIERS are the ones that stayed did their jobs and took care of their fellow troops.
B: There are plenty of services for Active Duty troops to get help, (it is when you leave that you get fucked). Stating that if Franks used those resources would have ruined his career is a no go, for what he did is far more damaging than getting the help one needs.
C: That Army study that keeps on getting referenced about Suicide has lots of Facts in Context that are left out.
1: Suicide among st Troops was rising, yes. Rising to the level of the General Population. Up until that time, Military Suicide was far below the rate of the General Population. This is even more of an eye opener when one figures that the largest group that commits Suicide in America is Young Males with access to firearms.
2: The Troops with the LOWEST instances of Suicide were the Troops that had MULTIPLE Combat Deployments.

Mental Illness is the leading cause of Military Suicide. Which is exactly what Franks had, and did not disclose to West Point, The Army, nor any of his Commanders. Which is a Fraudulent Enlistment and a crime per the UCMJ.

Now if you want to argue that because of increased tempo there were people unsuited for service taken in, I agree.
If you want to say that different Spanks for different Ranks is crap, I agree. Bergdahl is waiting to see.
If you want Professional Soldiers to believe this article, not going to happen. Franks did not have to go AWOL to save his life, they are just counting on this article fitting like a nice pair of Rose Colored Glasses on Civilians who do not know what is REAL.

xocet

(3,872 posts)
2. Clearly, you must have more information than the chief investigating officer considered....
Sat Sep 26, 2015, 12:20 PM
Sep 2015
The Good Soldier: Why a Suicidal Officer Had to Go AWOL to Save His Life

...

At his Article 32 hearing (essentially the same as a civilian grand jury) in the summer of 2014, Maj. Kevin Kilbride, the chief investigating officer, recommended that the Army consider Franks' mental state in 2009, and not subject him to a court-martial, but simply discharge him "in the most timely manner."

...

http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/the-good-soldier-why-a-suicidal-officer-had-to-go-awol-to-save-his-life-20150924



"Now if you want to argue that because of increased tempo there were people unsuited for service taken in, I agree."


Can you elaborate on how this "increased tempo" would affect the application process that the military academies use?



Lastly, if you have not read it, you might enjoy reading "The Authoritarians" by Bob Altemeyer:



It might provide some insight.




Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Editorials & Other Articles»The Good Soldier: Why a S...