What Do We Really Know About Osama bin Laden’s Death?
Source: The New York Times
by Jonathan Mahler
.....
Its hard to overstate the degree to which the killing of Osama bin Laden transformed American politics. From a purely practical standpoint, it enabled Obama to recast himself as a bold leader, as opposed to an overly cautious one, in advance of his 2012 re-election campaign. This had an undeniable impact on the outcome of that election. (Osama bin Laden is dead and General Motors is alive, Joe Biden was fond of boasting on the campaign trail.) Strategically, the death of bin Laden allowed Obama to declare victory over Al Qaeda, giving him the cover he needed to begin phasing U.S. troops out of Afghanistan. And it almost single-handedly redeemed the C.I.A., turning a decade-long failure of intelligence into one of the greatest triumphs in the history of the agency.
But bin Ladens death had an even greater effect on the American psyche. Symbolically, it brought a badly wanted moment of moral clarity, of unambiguous American valor, to a murky war defined by ethical compromise and even at times by collective shame. It completed the historical arc of the 9/11 attacks. The ghastly image of collapsing towers that had been fixed in our collective minds for years was dislodged by one of Obama and his senior advisers huddled tensely around a table in the White House Situation Room, watching closely as justice was finally brought to the perpetrator.
.....
The official narrative of the hunt for and killing of bin Laden at first seemed like a clear portrait, but in effect it was more like a composite sketch from multiple perspectives: the Pentagon, the White House and the C.I.A. And when you studied that sketch a little more closely, not everything looked quite right.
http://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/what-do-we-really-know-about-osama-bin-laden%e2%80%99s-death/ar-AAftW0F?li=AAa0dzB&ocid=ASUDHP
CJCRANE
(18,184 posts)about so much we see in the media?
Adsos Letter
(19,459 posts)One of the oldest questions around.
NV Whino
(20,886 posts)Adsos Letter
(19,459 posts)I always like it when they actually give me something to read.
NV Whino
(20,886 posts)Adsos Letter
(19,459 posts)Demeter
(85,373 posts)The story stunk from Day 1, (investigative reporter Seymour) Hersh told me. It was a miserably hot summer day in Washington, and we were sitting in his office, a two-room suite in an anonymous office complex near Dupont Circle, where Hersh works alone. Theres no nameplate on the door; the walls of the anteroom are crowded with journalism awards. I have a lot of fun here, he said, amid the clutter of cardboard boxes and precariously stacked books. I can do whatever I want.
Within days of the bin Laden raid, Hersh told me, I knew there was a big story there. He spent the next four years, on and off, trying to get it. What he wound up publishing, this May in The London Review of Books, was no incremental effort to poke a few holes in the administrations story. It was a 10,000-word refutation of the entire official narrative, sourced largely to a retired U.S. senior intelligence official, with corroboration from two longtime consultants to the Special Operations Command. Hersh confidently walked readers through an alternate version of all the familiar plot points in a dispassionate, just-the-facts tone, turning a story of patient perseverance, careful planning and derring-do into one of luck (good and bad), damage control and opportunism.
Hersh, who is 78, was reluctant to cooperate when I told him that I was interested in writing about his article. (Ive gotta bunch of problems with your request, his first email to me began.) He wanted me to follow up on his reporting instead and suggested that I might start by looking into Pakistans radar system, which he said was far too sophisticated to allow two U.S. helicopters to enter the countrys airspace undetected. (Those dimwitted third-world guys just cant get anything right, he wrote sarcastically, meaning of course the Pakistanis would have been aware of two military helicopters flying into the heart of their country.) Hersh, who worked at The New York Times for seven years in the 1970s, didnt think the paper would allow me to take his claims seriously. If you did so, he wrote, you better be sure not to let your wife start the car for the next few months. But after a little prodding, he relented and spent the better part of a day with me, describing his reporting as thoroughly as he felt he could without compromising his sources...
IN ESSENCE--WE WAS LIED TO, AND STILL ARE BEING LIED TO, BY THE OBAMA MILITARY/INDUSTRIAL/ESPIONAGE COMPLEX....
Adsos Letter
(19,459 posts)I wish I were this outspoken.