The COVID-19 Crisis Is an Indictment of American Exceptionalism
Americans have long considered their nation a shining city upon a hill, with the eyes of all people
upon us, as the Puritan lawyer John Winthrop put it almost 400 years ago. Now those eyes are riveted on the United States for all the wrong reasons. The country is consumed by the worst COVID-19 outbreak on the planet, and the beacons of light are popping up elsewhere in the world.
R. Daniel Kelemen, a political scientist at Rutgers University who has studied what the United States could learn from European public policies, told me that those who subscribe to the ideology of American exceptionalism, or as he described it, the notion that the United States is fundamentally different from and superior to other nations, have traditionally resisted seeking out lessons from other countries experiences. At the very least, this view leads many to think that the U.S. is simply so different that policies that might work in other countries could simply never work here, he wrote in an email.
American exceptionalism has been pronounced dead numerous times, from the Vietnam War through the global War on Terror, and nevertheless managed to stick around through those difficult periods. But the coronavirus crisis may pose the greatest threat yet to the belief that America has little to learn from the rest of the world.
https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2020/05/coronavirus-could-end-american-exceptionalism/611605/