ABC News' careful excerpts from the President's speeches
Today an ABC news local station aired a taped report from ABC network news dept. which had a very short extract which was supposed to give a representative and meaningful shapshot of President Obama's campaign message. They clipped part of sentence, that part where the president stated, with a critical sound in his voice, saying 'they' (his GOP opponents) want to give another tax cut of 5 trillion dollars - and it stopped there. NOw, that sounded more like a campaign pitch FOR the Romney - who would not be in favor of a $5 trillion dollar tax cut!?
But what ABC they left out was President Obama pointing out that the tax cut would go mostly the wealthiest people and would, in part, be paid for by raising taxes on middle class taxpayers with children about $2,000 a year. They just 'forgot' to leave that part the President's statement in there. Of course, in their selection, ABC news ended up with a part of a statement that really didn't convey anything of what the President's point was. This is an excellent example of biased reporting (i.e. disinformation) in action. Good Work ABC. I'm sure the GOP will be pleased.
Here are more complete excerpts from two speeches (pretty much the same speech) the President gave over the week-end which give a better indication of what the point the President was making:
(emphases are all my own)
Remarks by the President at a Campaign Event -- Oskaloosa, Iowa
"Look, the centerpiece of Governor Romneys entire economic plan -- the centerpiece of it, his main idea -- [font size="+1"]his one big idea is to give another $5 trillion tax cut on top of the Bush tax cuts that hes keeping -- he wants to keep in place -- $5 trillion[/font]. To give you some sense of perspective, our entire defense budget is about half a trillion dollars a year. So this tax cut would be the equivalent of what we spend on the national defense every single year for the next 10 years -- $5 trillion. [font size="+1"]Last week we found out that he expects you to pay the tab. Governor Romneys tax plan would actually raise taxes on middle-class families with children by an average of $2,000 to pay for this big tax break thats going mostly to the wealthiest folks.[/font] "
~~
~~
"Understand, this is not asking you to pay more taxes to reduce our deficit or to help kids get an education or to rebuild some roads and bridges and ports around the country. This is asking you to pay more to give an average $250,000 tax break to folks making $3 million a year or more. That is his big idea."
"Now, they have tried to sell this kind of trickle-down fairy dust before. (Laughter.) And frankly, they tried it as recently as 2001, 2002, 2003. And what did we get? The most sluggish job growth in generations, incomes and wages going down, jobs going overseas, and a huge economic crisis -- and, by the way, the deficits kept on going up so by the time I walked into office we had a trillion-dollar deficit.
~~
~~
So they dont have a plan to cut the deficit. They dont have a plan to create jobs. They sure dont have a plan to revive the middle class. We dont need more tax cuts for folks like me -- folks who are doing fine. We need tax relief for working Americans." (Applause.)
<more>
Remarks by the President at Campaign Event -- Boone, IA
Now, look, over the weekend my opponent chose as his running mate the ideological leader of the Republicans in Congress. And I've gotten to know Congressman Ryan. He's a good man. He's a family man. He's a very articulate spokesperson for Governor Romney's vision. The problem is it's the wrong vision for America. It's a vision that I fundamentally disagree with. (Applause.)
Their main recipe for solving Americas problems is getting rid of regulations on big corporations and big banks, and then giving more tax breaks to the wealthiest Americans. And their theory is that somehow thats going to lead to jobs and prosperity for everybody. In fact, the centerpiece of Governor Romneys entire economic plan is a new -- you heard this from Dave -- is a new $5 trillion tax cut, a lot of it going to the wealthiest Americans.
[font size=+1"]Now, keep in mind, these are the folks who say the deficit and the debt are the biggest problem weve got. And yet, they now want to give a $5 trillion tax cut. I know the numbers get so big, but I just want you to get a sense -- our entire defense budget annually is $500 billion. So what this means is, a $5 trillion tax break over 10 years, thats the equivalent of the entire defense budget going out as a tax cut every single year.
Now, keep in mind that this is going disproportionately to the wealthiest Americans. Last week, we found out that Governor Romney expects you, middle-class families, to pick up the tab for this big tax cut.[/font]
AUDIENCE: No!
THE PRESIDENT: [font size=+1"]And please dont take my word for it. You can go to their website and look at their plan. And then independent economists have looked at this thing and they said that Governor Romneys tax plan would actually raise taxes on middle-class families with children by an average of $2,000.[/font]
AUDIENCE: Booo --
THE PRESIDENT: Now, keep in mind, this is not $2,000 to reduce the deficit, or to grow jobs, or to invest in education, or make college more affordable, or to rebuild our roads. This is $2,000 to give another $250,000 tax cut to people making more than $3 million a year.
<more>
pacalo
(24,721 posts)Bill USA
(6,436 posts)BrainMann1
(460 posts)I've been watching Yahoo homepage and they always have a picture of Romney in good favorand nothing in the presidents favor.It doesnt matter, Prezzy B got this election.
Scuba
(53,475 posts)... they're complicit.
Uncle Joe
(58,405 posts)Thanks for the thread, Bill USA.