The inside story of MIT and Aaron Swartz
More than a year after Swartz killed himself rather than face prosecution, questions about MITs handling of the hacking case persist
By Marcella Bombardieri
CAMBRIDGE The mysterious visitor called himself Gary Host at first, then Grace Host, which he shortened for his made-up e-mail address to ghost, a joke apparently, perhaps signaling mischievousness or menace. The intruder was lurking somewhere on the MIT campus, downloading academic journal articles by the hundreds of thousands.
The interloper was eventually traced to a laptop under a box in a basement wiring closet. He was Aaron Swartz, a brilliant young programmer and political activist. The cascade of events that followed would culminate in tragedy: a Secret Service investigation, a federal prosecution, and ultimately Swartzs suicide.
But in the fall of 2010, Swartz was still a stranger in the shadows, and the university faced a hard question: How big a threat was the ghost downloader? And a harder one: What should be done about him?
Answering those questions would prove a particularly knotty puzzle for the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, a place long supportive of the free flow of information and so famously friendly to pranks, known in MIT lingo as hacks, that a book published by the MIT Museum in the 1990s offered pranksters such tips as always have two ways to run.
more
http://www.bostonglobe.com/metro/2014/03/29/the-inside-story-mit-and-aaron-swartz/YvJZ5P6VHaPJusReuaN7SI/story.html?s_campaign=sm_tw
struggle4progress
(118,290 posts)known only to himself, he repeatedly went to the MIT campus and without permission left a personal computer connected to the MIT network in a utility closet to circumvent the JSTOR user agreement by downloading millions of articles -- an activity that could have cost MIT access to JSTOR, or could have cost JSTOR access to journal articles, or both
By sneaking into the MIT closet, instead of operating from Harvard, and by repeatedly creating false MIT user accounts, which MIT repeatedly shut down, instead of an account reflecting his real identity, he engaged in behavior that would convince any reasonable person that he knew what he was doing violated existing a number of rules and that he was attempting to conceal his actions
It's an interesting irony that he was a fellow at Harvard's Safra Center for Ethics at the time:
... The Edmond J. Safra Center for Ethics stands at the core of what is now a well-established movement at Harvard that is giving ethics a prominent place in the curriculum and on the agenda of research ...
IIRC prosecutors offered him a deal with a six month jail term -- which corresponds to 2 or 3 seconds of confinement per stolen document. He declined the deal and ultimately committed suicide
This was a sad story, since he was obviously a bright young man, but not a story about MIT railroading a poor waif to suicide: it's a story about the peculiar psychological problems of Aaron Swartz
MannyGoldstein
(34,589 posts)struggle4progress
(118,290 posts).. and instead were pushing for a trial ... Swartz pleaded not guilty Sept. 24 ... Peters and prosecutors were still engaged in a heated legal battle on Friday the day Swartz killed himself ... The evidentiary hearing on the defenses motion to suppress had been set for Jan. 25 ...
MIT hacking case lawyer says Aaron Swartz was offered plea deal of six months behind bars
01/14/2013 4:42 PM
By Kevin Cullen and John R. Ellement
So Swartz's attorney said the 6 month plea deal was offered and that Swartz rejected it because he wanted to go to trial
struggle4progress
(118,290 posts)Im too much a student of human nature to ascribe a 26-year-olds suicide to any one thing, <Elliot Peters, the San Francisco lawyer who took the case over from Weinberg> said ...
On humanity, a big failure in Aaron Swartz case
By Kevin Cullen
January 15, 2013
So Swartzs lawyers knew from the beginning Swartz had psychiatric issues and was a suicide risk. This really is a story about the peculiar psychological problems of Aaron Swartz: it's sad he didn't get the help he needed