Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

thomhartmann

(3,979 posts)
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 09:45 AM Apr 2016

Bernie Sanders Needs to Get Back to Leading the Movement

Thom Hartmann says it's time for Bernie Sanders to go back to leading the movement against the system and for Hillary Clinton to start embracing Bernie's positions and courting his supporters.

39 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Bernie Sanders Needs to Get Back to Leading the Movement (Original Post) thomhartmann Apr 2016 OP
He's essentially right. Though, Hillary cannot embrace his more radical ideas. Moderation is best. Trust Buster Apr 2016 #1
Right. Moderation like the 40 years of rightwing moderation that put us where we are today! KPN Apr 2016 #3
I haven't seen anything the Occupy, Democracy Now or Sanders has done that has translated Trust Buster Apr 2016 #4
Probably because the system has been able to squash them thus far. KPN Apr 2016 #8
No, I'm just a realist. Those efforts you listed have not translated into grass roots efforts to Trust Buster Apr 2016 #11
OK, you are right about that to some extent. KPN Apr 2016 #13
And I'm just saying that moderation is necessary until the proper pieces are in place. Trust Buster Apr 2016 #14
We disagree then. KPN Apr 2016 #15
You misunderstand me. Until we have the political clout at the state and federal levels, you can Trust Buster Apr 2016 #17
I understand that ... to an extent. KPN Apr 2016 #18
Wrong. These movments are necessary to even start the process. Libralism has been so cut out FighttheFuture Apr 2016 #20
Oh, like the Fight for $15.00 didn't work and will probably set way nationally? glowing Apr 2016 #21
Trans-Canadian Pipeline was stopped... the level of acceptence for the BS is dropping... these FighttheFuture Apr 2016 #19
She certainly cannot astrophuss42 Apr 2016 #5
Sure, that's how the game is played. Trust Buster Apr 2016 #6
If Bernie (or Hillary) is not the Democratic nominee Frances Apr 2016 #2
I couldn't agree more. There are no shortcuts. Trust Buster Apr 2016 #7
There we go with the Nader crap again. KPN Apr 2016 #10
Your post was a deflection. I was responding to a poster who suggested that a long term grass roots Trust Buster Apr 2016 #12
The problem is the DNC zalinda Apr 2016 #23
Well, if you're looking for someone else to affect change, you'll be waiting a long time. Trust Buster Apr 2016 #24
If the DNC controls the money zalinda Apr 2016 #31
This is painfully true. Its also why we need a new party for progressive FDR Democrats. RiverLover Apr 2016 #38
You don't get what a grass roots movement is Frances Apr 2016 #30
No, that is not how it happened in the Republican Party zalinda Apr 2016 #32
You are correct Frances Apr 2016 #33
+1 The DNC is satisfied and will do just that, only support centrist candidates appalachiablue Apr 2016 #36
April 6, CLINTON CAMP LEAKS PLAN TO BURY Bernie, "Disqualify Him". He fought back appalachiablue Apr 2016 #39
I tend to agree that we have to work on the local level also. jwirr Apr 2016 #9
I really respect what you're doing gwheezie Apr 2016 #27
Dear Thom Thespian2 Apr 2016 #16
Thom doesn't get it yet Geronimoe Apr 2016 #22
Agreed. She cannot move to the Left just as you say. Democratic Party must nominate Sanders DhhD Apr 2016 #26
Thom Hartman needs to open his eyes ciaobaby Apr 2016 #25
THIS! nt antigop Apr 2016 #28
Thom is just flat-out wrong on this one. platitudipus Apr 2016 #29
This is all the ugly reality. Any who hope otherwise are pretending. appalachiablue Apr 2016 #34
Reality, corporate entities are owed & she can't disappoint. Plus the extra gravy's nice. appalachiablue Apr 2016 #37
"Frederick Douglass said it right. Freedom is never given to you, it has to be appalachiablue Apr 2016 #35

KPN

(15,646 posts)
3. Right. Moderation like the 40 years of rightwing moderation that put us where we are today!
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 10:17 AM
Apr 2016

Occupy, Democracy Now, the Bernie movement ... when people get pushed far enough, stuff happens. Moderation is a pacifier at best. The movement will go on, with or without Hillary, and stuff will happen.

 

Trust Buster

(7,299 posts)
4. I haven't seen anything the Occupy, Democracy Now or Sanders has done that has translated
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 10:26 AM
Apr 2016

Into legislation.

KPN

(15,646 posts)
8. Probably because the system has been able to squash them thus far.
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 10:46 AM
Apr 2016

It seems to me that you obviously feel secure with the current situation, including your own.

 

Trust Buster

(7,299 posts)
11. No, I'm just a realist. Those efforts you listed have not translated into grass roots efforts to
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 10:53 AM
Apr 2016

elect like minded individuals at the state and federal level. Heck, even the Tea Party knew that much.

KPN

(15,646 posts)
13. OK, you are right about that to some extent.
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 11:06 AM
Apr 2016

I wouldn't say though that there have been none elected at State and Congressional levels, but they have been largely in blue States.

What I'm saying is moderation is ineffective at dealing with our socio-economic problems meaningfully and will ultimately fail. Time will tell whether I am right or you. We shall see.

KPN

(15,646 posts)
15. We disagree then.
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 11:17 AM
Apr 2016

Moderation is a good thing when the long term trend is progress. We are in a regressive long term trend socio-economically that has largely been a result of popular ignorance and the Democratic Party's moderation in the face of GOP excess. The time for moderation has passed.

I believe the Democratic Party will always moderate unless and until its viability is threatened. What you are seeing today is its viability potentially being threatened.

 

Trust Buster

(7,299 posts)
17. You misunderstand me. Until we have the political clout at the state and federal levels, you can
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 11:20 AM
Apr 2016

be as progressive as you wish but it won't amount to anything. President Obama wanted to be more progressive but he knew he didn't have the votes in Congress to be successful. He had to moderate out of political necessity. This has always been the case in government.

KPN

(15,646 posts)
18. I understand that ... to an extent.
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 11:35 AM
Apr 2016

President Obama moderated also out of personal ideology. He ran on one thing, but did another -- right out the chute.

 

FighttheFuture

(1,313 posts)
20. Wrong. These movments are necessary to even start the process. Libralism has been so cut out
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 11:38 AM
Apr 2016

of our society, so demonized, for so long it will not make its reappearance at the level you are wishing for overnight. So, you need these movements to cut through the BS in order to make more visible progress.

 

FighttheFuture

(1,313 posts)
19. Trans-Canadian Pipeline was stopped... the level of acceptence for the BS is dropping... these
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 11:36 AM
Apr 2016

movements are adding to the general formation of the Zeitgeist that has made possible a very successful campaign by a Democratic Socialist Jew name Bernie Sanders! They are all vital if we are to ever cut through he corporatist/oligarchic firewalls injected into the system and to start moving the country back to its liberal foundations.

Frances

(8,545 posts)
2. If Bernie (or Hillary) is not the Democratic nominee
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 09:58 AM
Apr 2016

I hope the "loser" and followers do build a movement starting at the local level

I think that is what the anti-abortionists did and, as much as I hate it, they have built a movement so powerful that Planned Parenthood is no longer available for thousands of women who used its services for medical reason other than abortion

I am not sure why Democrats have ignored the local and county and state level offices when they are so important

I don't want to see the "loser" become a Nader whose followers accomplished no important political changes after 2000.

KPN

(15,646 posts)
10. There we go with the Nader crap again.
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 10:51 AM
Apr 2016

What some don't get is that others simply won't vote for Hillary because of her personal character (as they perceive it) and her record (as the facts show) regardless of the guilt trips you lay on them.

Look, we disagree. I happen to believe Bernie is a stronger candidate for the GE and will, be a more effective President as far as accomplishing progressive goals. So from my perspecxtive, if the GOP takes the White House, it's on you not me. Get over it already.

 

Trust Buster

(7,299 posts)
12. Your post was a deflection. I was responding to a poster who suggested that a long term grass roots
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 10:57 AM
Apr 2016

effort needs to be undertaken to address change at the local, state and federal level. You respond with your selfish thoughts about Hillary and assign blame for an election that hasn't happened yet. Get over yourself.

zalinda

(5,621 posts)
23. The problem is the DNC
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 12:19 PM
Apr 2016

If Hillary is the nominee, the DNC will stay exactly the same. It is all about the money. They will fund their own local hand picked candidate and not let progressives in. Any one who has been paying attention should realize this.

Z

 

Trust Buster

(7,299 posts)
24. Well, if you're looking for someone else to affect change, you'll be waiting a long time.
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 12:35 PM
Apr 2016

Change happens at the grass roots. Not at the DNC.

zalinda

(5,621 posts)
31. If the DNC controls the money
Fri Apr 22, 2016, 02:06 PM
Apr 2016

then the problem lies with the DNC. And, we have people here who have worked in the state Democratic Party who can attest to it. It has happened for years.

Z

RiverLover

(7,830 posts)
38. This is painfully true. Its also why we need a new party for progressive FDR Democrats.
Sat Apr 23, 2016, 07:34 AM
Apr 2016

This election has really shown how deeply the corruption goes within the party & its done so on a national level for all to see. But there are examples of progressives being snuffed out by the DNC in local elections going back years & years, all across the country.

At some point, we have to stop the abuse & leave.

Frances

(8,545 posts)
30. You don't get what a grass roots movement is
Fri Apr 22, 2016, 01:51 PM
Apr 2016

The DNC has nothing to do with the school board or the city council

Running in those races means working in the community to build a name for yourself, enlisting friends to help you by inviting their friends to their home so you can talk with them, knocking on doors, etc.

Unfortunately, a lot of Republicans understood the importance of local politics and that's how they got their conservative agenda in the schools and towns

Don't look up; look at yourself and your friends to make changes at the local level

zalinda

(5,621 posts)
32. No, that is not how it happened in the Republican Party
Fri Apr 22, 2016, 02:20 PM
Apr 2016

The Republican Party had churches to get their people in. The Republican party also helped fund the runs. And, it started in the 70's, not recently. I know because my ex-in-laws quit the Republican Party in the early 80's because too many evangelicals were in power positions in the party. It was a stealth movement.

Whether or not you want to acknowledge it, only those who have well paying jobs can run for anything. If you are working 2 part time jobs, tell me how you can run for anything. Tell me how you can have your friends over when they too are scrambling to make ends meet. If you have the time, you don't have a job. It is not the 70's any more, where someone like Bernie can mount a grassroots campaign. Now, if you don't have a job, you are labeled a freeloader, lazy or just too dumb to get a job.

Wake up and smell the coffee, time is running out for this planet. Just because you have it made, there are tons of people out there that don't, and soon it will affect you too. It is not time for incremental steps.

Z

Frances

(8,545 posts)
33. You are correct
Fri Apr 22, 2016, 05:40 PM
Apr 2016

in that churches were important in the anti-abortion movement. And the Koch brothers and their ilk funded state races.

But the Republican National Committee did not fund any local school board races or local small town city council members.

If you or your friends cannot afford to run for those type positions, maybe you can vote for someone on that level who will support your ideas. I personally cannot run for any thing myself because I have too many caregiving duties. All I can do is try to find out who the good guys are who are running for city council and school board.

appalachiablue

(41,140 posts)
36. +1 The DNC is satisfied and will do just that, only support centrist candidates
Sat Apr 23, 2016, 06:17 AM
Apr 2016

who tow the Third Way neoliberal agenda, not progressives.

appalachiablue

(41,140 posts)
39. April 6, CLINTON CAMP LEAKS PLAN TO BURY Bernie, "Disqualify Him". He fought back
Sun Apr 24, 2016, 01:06 PM
Apr 2016

and was correct. Bernie's self defense did Not cause him to loose New York. Besides, Bernie and followers have been abused and attacked for months and will respond, not be bullied and beaten like a wimp, coward.

~ A Coward Dies A Thousand Deaths ~

- 'Young Women want to be with Bernie, Where the Boyz Are", Gloria Steinem.

- Women who don't support Hillary are Doomed, Madeline Albright.

APRIL 6. ••BREAKING•• Clinton Campaign LEAK - Plan to Bury Bernie, "DISQUALIFY HIM" - Running out of Patience
http://www.democraticunderground.com/1017350521

jwirr

(39,215 posts)
9. I tend to agree that we have to work on the local level also.
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 10:48 AM
Apr 2016

I attended an official county committee meeting yesterday. Two young people and the rest of us were over 60 and most over 70. I am not saying that it wasn't a good group because at least 3 Union reps were there. But there were also older members who were definitely status quo. As I walked in one woman was declaring victory for Hillary in the primary. She is also one of the few who knows the working inside and out of how things work.

IF there were other Bernie supporters at this meeting I did not know it. I wanted to discuss the 33 state deal but just shut up and let it go.

There was no doubt that I was setting in the middle of the establishment in my county. The only thing good about it is that I met a young coordinator of my representative to the House in DC. He was looking for volunteers. He has a tough campaign this year against a billionaire.

The 33 state deal was made at the state level - nothing will change unless we get involved with the nitty gritty on the lower levels.

I am not looking forward to attending more Hillary locals. But if I want change sometime in this year I am going to have to speak up. Problem is I am not sure what I need to say. When I get to the state convention I am going to try to find out what committee deals with rules and see if change can happen there.

gwheezie

(3,580 posts)
27. I really respect what you're doing
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 12:55 PM
Apr 2016

1st off I support HRC and will enthusiastically support Bernie if he is the nominee. I am haphazardly involved in my local dem party. I am an old fart but we don't have many young progressives showing up here. Not saying the old farts aren't progressive because some of us were pretty radical in our younger days but I watched our local tea bags organize grass roots and started getting on county boards lime the school board and planning board and they took over the local GOP party.
Some people will choose to work outside the party structure and I see their point because I think inside party politics don't always represent the people so I have no argument there. But, if you want to change the dem party, you have to show up there.

Thespian2

(2,741 posts)
16. Dear Thom
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 11:19 AM
Apr 2016

please don't hold your breath until Her Royal Highness adopts progressive policies...HRH v the Donald is a huge win for the Oligarchs...they win no matter who the president is...

 

Geronimoe

(1,539 posts)
22. Thom doesn't get it yet
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 12:01 PM
Apr 2016

Hillary can not move to the left because she is owned by big corporations. Bernie has pushed her as far as she can go and even that is not believable to most voters. We know she'll pivot right in the general, anad to the radical right if elected. Just like her husband and Obama.

So do we say not this time and vote Dr Jill Stein, Trump, or not vote? Because voting for the lesser of two evils has destroyed the nation and is destroying the planet.

The clock has run out on kicking Climate Change down the road. Hillary worked with Obama to get a non binding agreement with other nation on climate change.

DhhD

(4,695 posts)
26. Agreed. She cannot move to the Left just as you say. Democratic Party must nominate Sanders
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 12:41 PM
Apr 2016

to go up against the Republicans to win the 2016 General Election. Obama abandoned his 2007-2008 Progressive Campaign Promises after the November 2008 General Election. His New Democrat/Third Way agenda was not accepted in Nov 2010 by the Democratic voters.

Hillary abandoned her Centrists Promises, soon after her April 2015 Primary Announcement (its a Primary first). The Delegates, Superdelegates and Republicans are paying attention. IMO, Progressive voters are not now, going to go for Clinton in 2016, either.

 

ciaobaby

(1,000 posts)
25. Thom Hartman needs to open his eyes
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 12:40 PM
Apr 2016

1. Bernie is still and will continue to lead the movement - that's who he truly is.

2. Hillary may "embrace" Bernie's positions during the primaries, but if elected she will govern according to those secret talks she gave to the wall street crowd. Her friends in big pharma, private prisons, bankers, hedge fund and super pac types will not see their money go to waste. That's who she truly is.

 

platitudipus

(64 posts)
29. Thom is just flat-out wrong on this one.
Thu Apr 21, 2016, 07:29 PM
Apr 2016

He's been slowly and steadily singing Hillary's praises more and more with each new day. His daytime show is starting to sound like Stephanie Miller's. I only watch his night show now.

appalachiablue

(41,140 posts)
34. This is all the ugly reality. Any who hope otherwise are pretending.
Fri Apr 22, 2016, 05:43 PM
Apr 2016

HRC's path is certain, like night follows day..

appalachiablue

(41,140 posts)
35. "Frederick Douglass said it right. Freedom is never given to you, it has to be
Fri Apr 22, 2016, 11:05 PM
Apr 2016

fought for." ~ Referenced by Bernie Sanders. And Bernie is the Fighter we desperately need now, as President not only the leader of a movement. If Bernie wanted to start a movement he could have done that, without the tremendous, sincere effort he's put into a rocking successful campaign. The results of the New York primary are not an out, an end to his presidential campaign, at least for supporters, and it's premature to say so. Anything can happen.
Even with vote registration abnormalities, widespread new voting restrictions and suppression, election tampering and the DNC's and Mainstream Media's lack of support and disparaging, Bernie has managed to reach many hearts and minds, mobilize millions and win large primary support with his resonating message as you are aware.

Unlike any candidate I've ever seen, and that's many, and as others agree, Bernie has clearly laid out practical policies, concrete steps and alternatives to improve the nation now in distress. He's also informed, inspired and provided hope for the lives of millions of Americans who are in serious need now and demand real movement for change. The vulnerable and those age 45 and younger will face an unprecedented life road that is likely unrelenting and filled with challenges until systems and solutions are developed to handle major changes taking place particularly computer automation and record unemployment.
~ If there must be trouble, let it be in my day, that my child may have peace. ~ Thomas Paine.

Waiting on 4-8 more years of status quo moderation and incremental effort absent genuine fight against obstruction- what Hillary will deliver along with lack of spirit and innovation is not what is needed now. Many serious issues including the dismantling of our democratic institutions are now converging on the US; further unabated deterioration and decline this country cannot afford. We must also push immediate, aggressive measures to handle the TPP and Climate Change crises. The backlog is truly daunting.
In terms of electability, Hillary has the highest unfavorable ratings EVER since 2001, according to the newest NBC News/WSJ poll. In contrast, Bernie beats Trump and every GOP contender in all polls for months. Bernie can defeat Trump from the wide appeal and support he holds among Democrats, Independents and some Republicans based on his powerful message, feasible plans, call for progressive populist change and to "Think Big."

'Another Bernie will come along' is hard to hear for obvious stated reasons. Qualified advocates and public figures who can campaign for many of the same issues exist, but where are they? I see few on the scene now or in the near future, and none have come forward, at least of Bernie's caliber and determination to run for the presidential office. Would they bring the fortitude, background, strength and special attributes Bernie possesses? Above all Bernie's steadfast progressive record, courage and integrity. The only other progressive who comes to mind that is well known, valued, very respected and less controversial maybe, but not as persuasive and not running is Sherrod Brown. ~ Respectfully ask that you not comment on Bernie's known religion. Four mentions in two months from the left leaves issues. >As six-year followers we're grateful we found you, and Bernie through Brunch. Your amassed knowledge, unique perspectives and gift of effective communicating are appreciated and an education. Keep up the great work, the campaign battles will be surmounted to make a stronger country! All the best to you and yours.

Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»Video & Multimedia»Bernie Sanders Needs to G...