The DU Lounge
Related: Culture Forums, Support ForumsWho were the greatest of the old-time comedy teams?
Burns and Allen?
Abbott and Costello?
Three Stooges?
Laurel and Hardy?
For me, the best of them all were the Marx Brothers.
pangaia
(24,324 posts)mucifer
(23,548 posts)RKP5637
(67,109 posts)shraby
(21,946 posts)demosincebirth
(12,537 posts)LisaM
(27,813 posts)Gracie Allen's airy lack of concern with reality was unmatched.
edbermac
(15,940 posts)L&H then the Stooges, haven't really seen a lot of the other two.
Chipper Chat
(9,680 posts)Very dated (early 1900s) but they were very popular.
Laffy Kat
(16,382 posts)I turned my two sons on to the Marx Brothers when they were pretty young. We still enjoy watching them together when we can.
Abbot & Costello
Then
the Marx Brothers
Laurel & Hardy
Bowery Boys
Three Stooges
brush
(53,784 posts)No mention of Martin and Lewis. When Jerry Lewis (or is it Louis) was funny.
GP6971
(31,164 posts)I also thought the old Bob and Ray radio show was great with all their skits. Wally Ballou, Mary Backstage Noble Wife (a play on the Broadway show Mary Noble, Backstage Wife.
LisaM
(27,813 posts)Just my personal opinion, though. I know some people liked him, but that voice always made me want to run screaming from the room.
brush
(53,784 posts)LisaM
(27,813 posts)However, I am a huge fan of Dean Martin, and I guess I thought he was better by himself.
brush
(53,784 posts)LisaM
(27,813 posts)and just quietly eating dinner and leaving.
rogerballard
(2,885 posts)OriginalGeek
(12,132 posts)Had no idea lol
brush
(53,784 posts)wryter2000
(46,051 posts)No contest
TexasBushwhacker
(20,194 posts)longship
(40,416 posts)Witness, The Dreaded Batter Pudding Hurler of Bexhill-on-sea
https://m.youtube.com/watch?list=PLhjIx4h0pcy1fz1iVlNetJqd8xLMgbbfq&v=xyUIt2vVQ2E
BAD!!! Bad Auntie Beeb! Not allowing Goon Shows on the Internet!
Also tops, The Marx Brothers.
benld74
(9,904 posts)ALL were great in their own respects
FuzzyRabbit
(1,967 posts)My mother hated them, so of course I loved them.
Richard D
(8,754 posts)Genius.
bdtrppr6
(796 posts)really stupid elmer fudd.
all four acts mentioned were great for their own reasons. we watch abbott & costello meet frankenstein every halloween, my kid loves it.
rogerballard
(2,885 posts)lastlib
(23,242 posts)Tim Conway, Harvey Korman, and Carol Burnett! OMG, they were hysterical to watch!!
Of the older ones, I'd take the Marx Brothers.
pressbox69
(2,252 posts)after that was Abbott & Costello, The Three Stooges and Laurel and Hardy.
argyl
(3,064 posts)Groucho tips the scale. Marx Brothers it is.
TeamPooka
(24,228 posts)People forget they were more popular than FRIENDS and BIG BANG THEORY, combined.
Hoyt
(54,770 posts)Cheech and Chong were good too.
alfredo
(60,074 posts)FSogol
(45,488 posts)Bob Elliot and Ray Goulding were on the radio and early tv for 5 decades.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=1&v=gZEyvwhjcFk
Bob: Now with todays final hard luck story, here is Mr. Farley
Plummer of Tulsa, Oklahoma. And I understand you spent your
life savings on a trip to New York to have some dental work
done.
Plummer: Thats right. As you may have noticed, Im only ten-
and-a-half inches tall. So, of course, I have a very small mouth
and tiny little teeth in there. I couldnt find a dentist in Tulsa
who had the right equipment to handle my case. So I figured Id
better come to a specialist in New York.
Bob: I see. And now you need the money to pay for a dental
specialist here in New York to work on your teeth. Is that it?
Plummer: No. Now I need the money to go on to Dublin,
Ireland. I found out theres no dentist in New York who
specializes in people my size either. But one of them told me
Im about the same height as a leprechaun. And he assumed that
those little guys all commute into Dublin to have their teeth
fixed. So I want to give it a try. Ive got one cavity thats really
killing me.
Bob: Well, theres nothing more tragic to behold than the
suffering of a fellow human or whatever you are, sir. So from
our generous Bob and Ray organization, here is this fine gift for
you. Its a deluxe racing bike from Klingman and Klingman of
Denver.
Plummer: Gee. I dont know what to say. Being ten-and-a-half
inches tall, I get a lot of inappropriate gifts. But this really takes
the cake.
Bob: No thanks are necessary, sir. Just seeing the smile on your
little face is reward enough. And now back over to Ray at our
main anchor desk.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bob_and_ray
Shrike47
(6,913 posts)I never enjoyed acts where people (appear to) physically injure each other.
Smothers brothers.
Cartoonist
(7,317 posts)Marx Bros for the old, Firesign Theatre for the modern.
donco
(1,548 posts)Trump and Sarah.
Bleacher Creature
(11,257 posts)It's not something I've thought about much, but the OP certainly triggered the question. Maybe Penn and Tellar, but that's about it.
DFW
(54,403 posts)Bouncer: Hey, Baravelli!
Baravelli: Whadaya want?
Bouncer: Watch the door for a few minutes. And don't let anyone in without the password.
Baravelli: Alright, what is it?
Bouncer: "Swordfish" is the password, d'ya understand?
Baravelli: Okay, I got it.
Bouncer: Well, what is it?
Baravelli: Password.
Bouncer: Swordfish! Swordfish!
Baravelli: Alrighta! Swordfisha! Swordfish!
Bouncer: Aahh...
Baravelli: (roughly interpreted) Piazza mosco santa rumbolla fatcha duzzi patsi!
There's a knock at the door. Baravelli opens the peephole.
Baravelli: Who are you?
Wagstaff: I'm fine, thanks. Who are you?
Baravelli: I'm fine too, but you can't come in unless you give the password.
Wagstaff: Well, what is the password?
Baravelli: Oh no, you gotta tell me! (pause) Hey, I tell you what I do...I give you three guesses...It's the name of a fish...
Wagstaff: Is it Mary?
Baravelli: Ha, ha! Atsa no fish!
Wagstaff: She isn't? Well, she drinks like one. Let me see...Is it sturgeon?
Baravelli: Hey, you're crazy! A sturgeon, he's a doctor cuts you open whena you sick. Now I give you one more chance.
Wagstaff: I got it! Haddock!
Baravelli: Atsa funny, I gotta haddock too.
Wagstaff: What do you take for a haddock?
Baravelli: Well now, sometimes I take aspirin, sometimes I takea calomel.
Wagstaff: Say, I'd walk a mile for a calomel.
Baravelli: You mean chocolate calomel. I like that too, but you no guess it. (Slams door. Wagstaff knocks again. Baravelli opens the peephole again.) Hey, whatsa matta? You no understand English? You can't come in here unless you say swordfish! Now, I give you one more guess.
Wagstaff: (thinking) Swordfish...swordfish...I think I got it! Is it swordfish?
Baravelli: Ha! That's it! You guess it!
After the two settle themselves at the bar, the following conversation ensues.
Wagstaff: Well let's get down to business. I'm looking for two football players who always hang around here.
Baravelli: We always hang around here, but we don't...
Wagstaff: (interrupting) Well, that's all I wanted to know. I'm Professor Wagstaff of Huxley College.
Baravelli: That means nothing to me.
Wagstaff: Well, it doesn't mean anything to me either. I'll try it over again. I'm Professor Huxley of Wagstaff College.
Baravelli: Well you didn't stay at the other college very long.
Wagstaff: You're heading for a breakdown. Why don't you pull yourself to pieces?
Baravelli: I'll talk it over with my partner.
Wagstaff: In case I never see you again, which would add ten years to my life, what would you fellows want to play football?
Baravelli: Wella first we wanna football.
Wagstaff: Well, I don't know if we've got a football. But if I could find one, would you be interested? I don't want a hasty answer, just sleep on it.
Baravelli: I no think I can sleep on a football.
Bartender: Who's gonna settle for these drinks?
Baravelli: (Flips coin and hides the result. To Wagstaff, he says,) Your stuck.
Wagstaff: (To bartender.) Can you cash a check for fifteen dollars and twenty-two cents?
Bartender: Sure. (Opens drawer and counts out money.) Five, ten, fifteen, and twenty-two.
Wagstaff: Thanks. As soon as I get a check for fifteen dollars and twenty-two cents, I'll send it to you. (Flees with Baravelli.) Swordfish!
Still Blue in PDX
(1,999 posts)Bob and Ray
The Smothers Brothers
Carl Reiner and Mel Brooks
My mom loved the Bowery Boys, but I don't remember them and should revisit.
Boris and Natasha, Rocky and Bullwinkle
ailsagirl
(22,897 posts)geardaddy
(24,931 posts)Franken and Davis
Stiller and Meara
rurallib
(62,420 posts)they had the physical comedy and also had some great lines of dialogue that often got missed in all the physical stuff.
Curly was hard to top.
Burns and Allen and the Marx brothers tie for 2nd for me.
ETA:
Monty Python should get a message someplace.
When I think about it they were actually probably the all around best.
Generic Brad
(14,275 posts)Bob Elliot and Ray Goulding. Comic geniuses on radio and the stage!