Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Orrex

(63,224 posts)
Tue Feb 6, 2018, 10:02 AM Feb 2018

I'm not looking for pity, but last night I watched The Cloverfield Paradox (spoilers)

In one this tepid film's "climactic" and improbable scenes, a crew members is trapped in an airlock while broken water pipes flood the compartment.

Other crew members naturally look on through the interior hatch's viewpoint, watching helplessly as the crew member faces an unexpected drowning in deep space. The chamber fills floor to ceiling, so that the crew member struggles at the hatch, wide-eyed and with puffed-out cheeks.

Not to worry, though, because the exterior hatch ruptures, and the entire mass of water instantly freezes solid! The crew member is of course caught directly in front of the viewport, frozen for posterity.

Wait a minute...

Water in a vacuum boils at something like -70° C. The water in the scene is presumably between 5° and 20° Celsius, so the entirety of it is instantly at the boiling point, no?

The chamber is probably 10 x 10 x 8 feet, minimum, and it's shown completely filled, so that's close to 6,000 gallons. Could that volume of water bleed off all of its heat so quickly into a near-perfect vacuum?

I call BS on this otherwise 100% factually accurate ( ) movie!

13 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

EarlG

(21,967 posts)
1. You know, if they hadn't screwed up that one detail, the movie would have been perfect
Tue Feb 6, 2018, 10:12 AM
Feb 2018

Although I was also curious about how the sentient arm knew that the gyroscope was inside Volkov

Orrex

(63,224 posts)
2. Russians are always hiding gyroscopes in their stomachs. And worms.
Tue Feb 6, 2018, 10:19 AM
Feb 2018

It was impossible for me to watch Mundy without seeing him as Roy from The IT Crowd.[

EarlG

(21,967 posts)
12. I must admit
Tue Feb 6, 2018, 05:24 PM
Feb 2018

I was also a bit suspicious of how they managed to deorbit that escape pod by performing a radial burn using RCS thrusters only, but maybe I'm just being pedantic.

procon

(15,805 posts)
3. It's science fiction, so I expected some literary license.
Tue Feb 6, 2018, 10:31 AM
Feb 2018

There were other things that stuck out for me... remember those worms? How the hell did they get there! And the creeping arm with a mind of its own... that was a reincarnation of "Thing", the disembodied hand stolen from the Addams Family. I thought the stowaway was contrived, and why would the crew trust an alien stranger?

Anyway, it was OK for the syfy genre and the sets looked pretty good, but I thought the plot was thin and the premise was sketchy. Still, it was moderately entertaining with spots in unintentional comedy and some suspenseful bits, even though it ended with a lackluster fizzle.

Orrex

(63,224 posts)
4. I'm leery of the "but it's sci-fi" excuse
Tue Feb 6, 2018, 10:50 AM
Feb 2018

I mean, sure it is, but if the film makes a basic nod toward the "science" part of it, then glaring errors need to be accounted for, at least in broad terms.

Explosions don't make a sound in space, of course, but we accept those flashy booms as a conceit of the genre. The current film's bit about "free energy" is a mulligan that we accept just as we accept the otherwise dubious jump to a neighboring dimension. The quasi-sentient magnetic putty grabbing and violating Mundy was a little weird, but ok. I guess.

I was also happy to see that when Kiel detached the maintenance ring, it drifted away from the ship in a straight line, rather than continuing to orbit it like the debris from the earlier explosion was shown to do.

But there's no precedent in film, nor any explanation offered, for the insta-freeze, nor do they explain how a ~6000 gallon chamber could flood in ~45 seconds, given the output of the pipes as shown onscreen! However, they could easily have explained the freeze as an "anomalous energy drain" or something equivalent due to the action of the collider. But because they didn't say it, and since it happened exactly when the outer hatch blew, we can conclude that it was supposed to be due to the sudden vacuum.

procon

(15,805 posts)
9. Syfy is one of my fave genres, and I enjoy most of the different subsets.
Tue Feb 6, 2018, 11:54 AM
Feb 2018

I like them all, from Hard Science to Soft Science Fiction, Space Operas and Steampunk, alternate histories, most are good reads for an little escape. Science fiction stories frequently jump around several subgenres, so it didn't really bother me if the storyline switched from hardcore science to grab a startling visual for effect. The unexplained plot discrepancies were more distracting for me. Compared to many syfy films -- and to be honest, there's a disproportionate number of howlers out there -- like I said, this one wasn't that bad, especially for a film that went straight to the internet.

Orrex

(63,224 posts)
10. Well, here's my problem with it
Tue Feb 6, 2018, 12:28 PM
Feb 2018

Without downplaying the plot discrepancies (which are many and profound), the flooded airlock scene in particular demands that we question what else might be "wrong" in the setting.

What other well-established scientific principles should we ignore? We can kind of throw gravity out the window, because the crew are shown walking on a flat surface with apparently Earth-normal gravity throughout the ship (rather than occupying the rotating rings, which would simulate gravity). Hell, they actually jump down to the the damaged (and soon to be jettisoned) maintenance ring, directly perpendicular to whatever gravity they might be creating!

How can we know how to gauge any situation in the film, once the writers have shown that they don't give a shit about the underlying physics?

I've been a sci-fi fan for decades, so I "get" the need to make certain concessions when watching/reading the genre. But suspension of disbelief isn't some panacea for curing all bad writing; it's meant to allow the viewer to accept certain "facts" necessary to enjoy the story.




FSogol

(45,527 posts)
5. Engineer Ron Wilkerson writes a column about how movies get HVAC and electrical issues wrong
Tue Feb 6, 2018, 10:51 AM
Feb 2018

An overview: http://www.hpac.com/galleries/hvac-popular-movies-did-hollywood-get-it-right

From Jurassic Park:

Near the end of the film, our heroes make their way back to the park’s visitor center, where they think they are safe, but come under attack from two Velociraptors. In this sequence, Lex, Tim, and Drs. Grant and Sattler take to the nether regions of the visitor center to escape the peckish raptors. Lucky for them, the suspended ceiling is supported by a framework strong enough to support a herd of Dilophosaurus. Apparently constructed from 2-in. tool steel angle, the ceiling does not so much as flex under the weight of the thrashing refugees. The only obstacle that slows them down is the bane of all HVAC engineers: flex duct! There is yards of it, duct-taped together in a vain attempt to get makeup air to the T. rex omelette bar. It would not have been long before Hammond learned his lesson: The pressure drop of long lengths of flex duct makes air balancing harder than a Parasaurolophus pedicure.


From the TV show 24:
In Episode 12, the terrorists break into CTU headquarters and release a canister in the electrical room. Oddly, the electrical room is being used as an air-supply plenum for the entire building. Only the rapid closure of multiple space-age, bullet-proof, explosion-proof, airtight doors saves those in the main control room (the series’ stars). The situation worsens in Episode 13, as a corrosive agent that had been added to the gas is slowly eating away at the space-age seals. The plucky group devises a daring plan: Bauer will enter the VX-saturated area and fix the seals. Lucky for Bauer, the gas eats space-age seals, not humans. He holds his breath, runs to the failing seals, opens his official CTU emergency seal pack, and pulls out … DUCT TAPE! He quickly sticks down the duct tape, and the room is purified with fresh air in about 30 seconds. (HVAC engineers, if you don’t have a roll of duct tape in your desk, get one immediately. Be prepared.)


Mission Impossible:
In this oft-parodied scene, the wily spook short-circuits the crisscrossed laser beams protecting the ventilation duct with mirrors. As his accomplice (Reno), lowers him into the room by rope and pulley, the ductwork does not so much as flex under their combined 300-pound weight. Even as Hunt falls to within inches of the floor, the duct holds. Meanwhile, the room thermostat is set to alarm at the slightest temperature increase. Although it is hard to see how the room temperature would increase much with the huge exhaust duct, a radiant-temperature sensor would have been much more effective. The government could have saved a lot of money on lasers simply by installing a sheet-metal duct that would collapse under the weight of a man.


More at: http://www.hpac.com/author/ron-wilkinson-pe-leed-ap-cpmp

PS, wasn't going to watch the new Cloverfield Debacle, (my kids were excited about the 1st Cloverfield Film, but I convinced them it was a gritty reboot of the Gamera Franchise) but now I have to. Thanks a lot.

Orrex

(63,224 posts)
6. Lol! I love it!
Tue Feb 6, 2018, 11:16 AM
Feb 2018

Two big ones for me are the way films handle lava and (at the other extreme) cold water.

Lava can apparently melt metal and rock, but regular folks can stand by as an entire river of the stuff flows by at arm's reach. Ambient temperature would probably be bout 700° or so, yet people are hanging out like it's no big deal.

Other movies will go to lengths to explain that the cold water will kill someone in minutes, yet when it becomes convenient for the plot, people can swim or wade chest-deep through that exact same water without harm. James Cameron did this in both The Abyss and Titanic.

I'm not a scientist nor an engineer, but these things really jump out at me. I would imagine that it's much worse for audience members with actual technical expertise!

FSogol

(45,527 posts)
8. My fav is how someone who bumps into an electrical panel or switch gear is immediately electrocuted.
Tue Feb 6, 2018, 11:31 AM
Feb 2018

Or the impossibly huge exhaust fan that is running at 10 RPM.

DarthDem

(5,256 posts)
7. Good Stuff!
Tue Feb 6, 2018, 11:19 AM
Feb 2018

The engineers of that room in MI could have also invested in a few cameras to see if anyone was, y'know, dangling from the ceiling.

exboyfil

(17,865 posts)
13. I would like two hours of my life back
Wed Feb 7, 2018, 12:10 AM
Feb 2018

I also had the misfortune of watching The Cloverfield Paradox. Remember the name Oren Uziel, and, if you see anything written by him, run the other way as quickly as possible. Great sets, relatively good actors, and quite possibly the worst science fiction script since Plan 9.

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»I'm not looking for pity,...