Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Coventina

(27,195 posts)
Wed Jan 2, 2019, 09:42 PM Jan 2019

Watched 1st ep. of "Man in the High Castle" not sure if I want to continue. (possible spoilers)

The first episode was fascinating, in a grim way.

But, I don't know if I want to continue watching it. It's so bleak.

I "spoiled" it for myself, because I wanted to know what I might be getting into, and that only increased my doubts.

It doesn't look like there's a happy ending for any damn body, and, ultimately, I don't know why I should care about characters who are all headed for a grisly end.

It's a really fascinating "what if" but beyond that, what's the merit?
Any fans want to enlighten me?

I also read about the original novel. I find it interesting that Philip K. Dick had originally planned a sequel, but never ended up writing it because it was such a dark headspace to be in. I can certainly understand that.

28 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Watched 1st ep. of "Man in the High Castle" not sure if I want to continue. (possible spoilers) (Original Post) Coventina Jan 2019 OP
I love period pieces and found it quite a fascinating premise... hlthe2b Jan 2019 #1
I agree with all your positives. But for me, the big negative is Coventina Jan 2019 #11
Well, without giving away anything marylandblue Jan 2019 #2
His main complaint was having to be intimate with Nazi philosophy and the personal Coventina Jan 2019 #4
I'm in the same boat True Dough Jan 2019 #3
****spoiler**** Coventina Jan 2019 #12
Oh well True Dough Jan 2019 #15
I've watched all 3 seasons. It is excellent TV. CottonBear Jan 2019 #5
I started the book three times left-of-center2012 Jan 2019 #6
I could not get into it but.., Dr Vegas Jan 2019 #7
Song from Resistance Radio, Sharon Van Etten - The End of the World Dr Vegas Jan 2019 #8
Resistance Radio, Sam Cohen - The House of the Rising Sun Dr Vegas Jan 2019 #9
I like shows with good character development and moral dilemmas. bluedigger Jan 2019 #10
A lot of bad shit, as I understand. Coventina Jan 2019 #13
Are you sure you aren't confusing this with The Handmaid's Tale? bluedigger Jan 2019 #16
Haha! No, I haven't watched The Handmaid's Tale. Coventina Jan 2019 #17
Now THAT is one I could not make it through one episode... hlthe2b Jan 2019 #19
My wife and I gave up on Handmaid's after season 1. Dave Starsky Jan 2019 #18
That's pretty much how I feel as well. Coventina Jan 2019 #21
Don't watch or read fictional things that are going to "bring you down". Dave Starsky Jan 2019 #24
I couldn't go on w/ The Handmaid's Tale. smirkymonkey Jan 2019 #28
There's intrigue, politics, mystery. Is this any different than any other fictional movie/series? Fla Dem Jan 2019 #20
Well, I had a moment of abject horror ***spoiler*** Coventina Jan 2019 #22
Resistance Radio: Explaining "The Man in the High Castle" (Spoilers) Dr Vegas Jan 2019 #14
I've read most, not quite all, of PKD's work. "Man in the High Castle" was a big disappointment. eppur_se_muova Jan 2019 #23
Stick it out! I didn't watch II and III until a few months ago. You won't be disappointed. Floyd R. Turbo Jan 2019 #25
It's gets way better. The costume and direction is excellent JDC Jan 2019 #26
I can't wait for the next season! Nictuku Jan 2019 #27

hlthe2b

(102,408 posts)
1. I love period pieces and found it quite a fascinating premise...
Wed Jan 2, 2019, 09:48 PM
Jan 2019

Einstein was a proponent of parallel universe as theory, so I found it worth considering.

It has a very good cast and I'm a fan of the clothing of the 40s and that is well done.... Different strokes for different folks, though...

Coventina

(27,195 posts)
11. I agree with all your positives. But for me, the big negative is
Thu Jan 3, 2019, 12:01 AM
Jan 2019

that it looks like it's just bleak, with moments of horror.

Nothing good happens to the good guys, so why care?

I don't want to care about characters who are all going to die horribly.

marylandblue

(12,344 posts)
2. Well, without giving away anything
Wed Jan 2, 2019, 09:48 PM
Jan 2019

It is not as bleak as it first appears. There's no pot of gold at the end, but hope and even some salvation comes from surprising places.

The novel is worth a read, but very different from the series. I didn't know that Dick though a sequel would be too dark, considering he wrote some of the darkest science fiction ever.

Coventina

(27,195 posts)
4. His main complaint was having to be intimate with Nazi philosophy and the personal
Wed Jan 2, 2019, 09:50 PM
Jan 2019

biographies of the high-ranking Nazi officials and speculating on what they would have done, if victorious.

At least, that's what I read on the internets.

True Dough

(17,337 posts)
3. I'm in the same boat
Wed Jan 2, 2019, 09:49 PM
Jan 2019

except I didn't even finish the first episode.

I'd heard and read so many great things about this series. Was very eager to finally give it a go. But I'm a fickle viewer. Once it ran about 15 or 20 minutes, bullets were being sprayed and the main character came out of it unscathed, very James Bond-esque.
I can't stand that sort of thing. Too implausible, so I quit.

Just. Like. That.

Coventina

(27,195 posts)
12. ****spoiler****
Thu Jan 3, 2019, 12:02 AM
Jan 2019

The reason Joe improbably gets away is because he's really a Nazi agent, and he was meant to get away in order to make the connection and net more of the resistance.

I found it really implausible as well that he would get away with it, but at the VERY END of the first episode, he phones in to report his success.

CottonBear

(21,596 posts)
5. I've watched all 3 seasons. It is excellent TV.
Wed Jan 2, 2019, 09:53 PM
Jan 2019

I love science fiction, although I’ve not read the novel. I do plan to read it.

The cast, writing & cinematography are excellent. I love the costumes and set design.

Dr Vegas

(456 posts)
7. I could not get into it but..,
Wed Jan 2, 2019, 11:43 PM
Jan 2019

I have found the Promotional Marketings for this show fasicating,
One year they developed a campaign called "Resistance Radio" and many Trump-pets went on Twitter to bitch about it (Thinking it was all about Trump). The show is based on a book that was written years before the "Age of Trump".

This year there was an simple ad that featured the Nazi flag slowly breaking into Peace Doves/Birds and again Trump-pets came out onto the Internet to bitch about it

bluedigger

(17,087 posts)
10. I like shows with good character development and moral dilemmas.
Wed Jan 2, 2019, 11:50 PM
Jan 2019

A lot of shit happens to these folks. Keep watching.

Coventina

(27,195 posts)
13. A lot of bad shit, as I understand.
Thu Jan 3, 2019, 12:05 AM
Jan 2019

I just don't see the point of watching people get murdered and whatnot when there's no point to it all.

I'm not someone who needs lollipops and rainbows all the time, but relentless bleakness is a bit much.

bluedigger

(17,087 posts)
16. Are you sure you aren't confusing this with The Handmaid's Tale?
Thu Jan 3, 2019, 01:56 AM
Jan 2019

Now there's some relentless bleakness. Where the story starts is not necessarily where the story ends, but I haven't gotten there, yet.

hlthe2b

(102,408 posts)
19. Now THAT is one I could not make it through one episode...
Thu Jan 3, 2019, 09:08 AM
Jan 2019

Ironically, it seems even darker to me than ''High Castle"

Dave Starsky

(5,914 posts)
18. My wife and I gave up on Handmaid's after season 1.
Thu Jan 3, 2019, 08:40 AM
Jan 2019

I don't know why people seek out such bleak entertainment. If I want to experience misery and hopelessness, I'll just get up and go to my job like I usually do.

Coventina

(27,195 posts)
21. That's pretty much how I feel as well.
Thu Jan 3, 2019, 12:03 PM
Jan 2019

I don't hate my job that much, but I have enough sorrows in my own life to deal with.

Having watched the first episode, I am profoundly thankful in a new way that we won WWII.

I also had to stop watching "The Sopranos" because it just brought me down.
I don't need to watch shows that actually put me in a bad mood.

Dave Starsky

(5,914 posts)
24. Don't watch or read fictional things that are going to "bring you down".
Thu Jan 3, 2019, 04:05 PM
Jan 2019

We get enough misery in life.

You don't need to be a Pollyanna. Life isn't perfect. But it's not horrible, either. Choose entertainment that gives you hope to meet the next day, whatever it is.

 

smirkymonkey

(63,221 posts)
28. I couldn't go on w/ The Handmaid's Tale.
Thu Jan 3, 2019, 09:47 PM
Jan 2019

It was just too depressing for me. I have the Man In The High Castle on my list, but am still a little wary about watching it. I don't need my films/TV shows to be all rainbows and puppy dogs either, but I can only handle so much misery before I just give up altogether. There has to be some chance of redemption or victory.

Fla Dem

(23,768 posts)
20. There's intrigue, politics, mystery. Is this any different than any other fictional movie/series?
Thu Jan 3, 2019, 11:29 AM
Jan 2019

Probably not your cup of tea. Not sure anything said will change your mind. But it's a period piece about a fictional period of time and people's efforts to set things right. Definitely not a feel good story.

Coventina

(27,195 posts)
22. Well, I had a moment of abject horror ***spoiler***
Thu Jan 3, 2019, 12:06 PM
Jan 2019

when the ash of incinerated people were floating around two of the characters.

Most shows don't do that (at least the ones I watch).

Yes, I understand that actually happened in Nazi Germany. I don't mean to downplay the horrors of the Holocaust at all.
I just don't know that a fictionalized continuance of them is at all edifying.

eppur_se_muova

(36,301 posts)
23. I've read most, not quite all, of PKD's work. "Man in the High Castle" was a big disappointment.
Thu Jan 3, 2019, 12:18 PM
Jan 2019

After years of hearing so much about how great a writer he was supposed to be, and how great that particular novel was supposed to be, I had actually read the book, but years later, could remember much of the story but not how it ended. So I re-read it, and realized why I had forgotten the ending. Basically, it's nothing. What was the point of the whole thing ? Just that little puff of misogyny at the end, and then everyone goes their separate ways ? It's like you're following an absorbing plot when suddenly the book just ends, like he ran out of paper. The novel is famous for its intricately detailed "world-building", but the ending is unworthy of the effort expended on the preceding pages.

Dick was married five times, and apparently tried to murder two wives, one of whom he later had involuntary committed to an asylum (the other was a murder-suicide attempt). It is not hard to find misogynic elements in many of his works, and I am not the type of person to make accusations of misogyny lightly -- I believe that inappropriate use of accusations weakens the effectiveness of those accusations when they are really deserved. But a quick read of any PKD bio reveals recurring psychiatric problems in his life, and problematic (to say the least) relationships with women. His last novel, Radio Free Albemuth, in which the protagonist mentally picks up signals from a distant civilization around the star Albemuth when the Santa Ana winds blow, was, ahem, "semi-autobiographical", and the voices in the head were on the wrong side of "semi".

Having said that, I understand the series is very different from the book. That could well constitute an improvement.

JDC

(10,135 posts)
26. It's gets way better. The costume and direction is excellent
Thu Jan 3, 2019, 04:36 PM
Jan 2019

It gets squirrelly in S3 imo, but its worth the watch.

Watch.

Nictuku

(3,617 posts)
27. I can't wait for the next season!
Thu Jan 3, 2019, 04:39 PM
Jan 2019

I had no interest in watching it because the concept was so disturbing.

I'm glad I went back and tried it again. There are some very interesting (and big) twists in the story.

This shouldn't be too much of a spoiler, but the author of the original book, Philip K. Dick, is a renowned Sci Fi writer.

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»Watched 1st ep. of "Man i...