Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
The DU Lounge
Related: Culture Forums, Support ForumsCats are perfect
From Scientific American, so you know it's ... well, at least worth reading
Cats Are Perfect. An Evolutionary Biologist Explains Why
Anjali Goswami thinks cats are perfectnot in the same way that the average cat person might admire their beauty, athleticism and independence of spirit but from a scientific standpoint. Goswami is an evolutionary biologist at the Natural History Museum in London who studies large-scale patterns of evolution in vertebrate animals through time. She contends that catsfrom tabbies to tigersare quintessential products of evolution. I sat down with her to find out why. Her explanation reveals cats, and the meaning of evolutionary success, in a fascinating new light.
InfoView thread info, including edit history
TrashPut this thread in your Trash Can (My DU » Trash Can)
BookmarkAdd this thread to your Bookmarks (My DU » Bookmarks)
7 replies, 509 views
ShareGet links to this post and/or share on social media
AlertAlert this post for a rule violation
PowersThere are no powers you can use on this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
ReplyReply to this post
EditCannot edit other people's posts
Rec (7)
ReplyReply to this post
7 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Cats are perfect (Original Post)
CloudWatcher
Oct 2023
OP
elleng
(131,123 posts)1. Perfectly capable to get me out of the house ASAP,
due to misery due to allergies. SO glad to be back @ MY house, after 4 days with my daughter and grandkids. Saddens me.
Ocelot II
(115,858 posts)2. Of course they are!
They have different coat colors, sure. But they all have the same baby heads. Theyre round, and they dont elongate as the animal matures, which is the standard developmental pattern for mammals. Dogs have short, round faces as puppies but long, snouty faces as adults. An adult cat looks pretty much like a baby cat but bigger. With dogs, breeders play off of that developmental variation to create breeds with different face shapes. But because cats dont have that developmental variation, there isnt much to play around with other than coat color.
This all goes back to the fact that cats are extremely specialized. Every member of the order of mammals known as the carnivorans, including cats and dogs, has an upper fourth premolar and a lower first molar that form what we call the slicing pair, which slices meat. A lot of carnivorans retain molars behind the slicing pair that can grind up stuff such as vegetation. But cats have lost pretty much everything behind their slicing teeth. They might have a little nub, a peg tooth, but it cant process stuff. This is why foxes are perfectly happy going through garbage, whereas leopards will kill livestock instead.
...
Cats have nailed this one thing so well that they all do it and just come up with slightly different sizes. Thats why theyre perfect, evolutionarily. They dont need variation. They might get bigger or smaller, but they dont change anything else because theyre doing it just right otherwise. Theyre not jacks-of-all-trades; theyre masters of one.
...
There are lots of things that have tried to be catsother groups of mammals that have evolutionarily converged on cats. Marsupials have tried to be cats. An extinct group of carnivorans called creodonts have tried to be cats. Weasels have tried to be cats. Theres all kinds of stuff that has tried to be a bit catlike in different waysmongooses, things like that. But they kind of dip in and dip out of being cats, and they cant really outcompete cats in their space. They havent lasted. All of those things that have tried to be cats, they do other things, too, and those things are fine. But there arent a lot of things that are around today that do a very good job of being a cat.... You cant just casually try to be a cat. You have to commit. Cats have committed to being cats. Everything else is just sort of dabbling, and it doesnt work.
This all goes back to the fact that cats are extremely specialized. Every member of the order of mammals known as the carnivorans, including cats and dogs, has an upper fourth premolar and a lower first molar that form what we call the slicing pair, which slices meat. A lot of carnivorans retain molars behind the slicing pair that can grind up stuff such as vegetation. But cats have lost pretty much everything behind their slicing teeth. They might have a little nub, a peg tooth, but it cant process stuff. This is why foxes are perfectly happy going through garbage, whereas leopards will kill livestock instead.
...
Cats have nailed this one thing so well that they all do it and just come up with slightly different sizes. Thats why theyre perfect, evolutionarily. They dont need variation. They might get bigger or smaller, but they dont change anything else because theyre doing it just right otherwise. Theyre not jacks-of-all-trades; theyre masters of one.
...
There are lots of things that have tried to be catsother groups of mammals that have evolutionarily converged on cats. Marsupials have tried to be cats. An extinct group of carnivorans called creodonts have tried to be cats. Weasels have tried to be cats. Theres all kinds of stuff that has tried to be a bit catlike in different waysmongooses, things like that. But they kind of dip in and dip out of being cats, and they cant really outcompete cats in their space. They havent lasted. All of those things that have tried to be cats, they do other things, too, and those things are fine. But there arent a lot of things that are around today that do a very good job of being a cat.... You cant just casually try to be a cat. You have to commit. Cats have committed to being cats. Everything else is just sort of dabbling, and it doesnt work.
Eko
(7,359 posts)5. Hony Badger says "I dont care".
&t=20s
rsdsharp
(9,202 posts)3. Just ask them!
sl8
(13,889 posts)4. If not perfect, at least good enough to get published in Scientific American.
Faux pas
(14,690 posts)6. Kickin' & Rec'n
I had to laugh at the "baby heads" part because it's so true I love it
ailsagirl
(22,899 posts)7. They absolutely are...
except when they wake me at 2:00 am to feed them. There's no escaping it-- they will scratch at my door until I cooperate.
Leonardo is quoted as saying: The smallest feline is a masterpiece, and cats appear in at least eleven of his drawings.
I can't argue with him.