Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
21 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
What country is the original Aladdin from? (Original Post) Bucky Oct 2013 OP
Hint: It's not Arabia, Mesopotamia, or Persia Bucky Oct 2013 #1
I don't know... Iraq? Xyzse Oct 2013 #2
Iraq and Iran are relatively new. Post British Paulie Oct 2013 #3
LOL Xyzse Oct 2013 #4
Mesopotamia also happens to be in Iraq Paulie Oct 2013 #6
I know! I know! CJCRANE Oct 2013 #5
The land of Imagination Angry Dragon Oct 2013 #7
England? France? Could be one of those totally made petronius Oct 2013 #8
This is a possibility, actually cemaphonic Oct 2013 #21
Syria I think HarveyDarkey Oct 2013 #9
France Tom Ripley Oct 2013 #10
Poland bigwillq Oct 2013 #11
The original tale from the Arabian Nights was set in China, of all places. Aristus Oct 2013 #12
That is correct! kentauros Oct 2013 #13
I grew up reading a children's version of "The Arabian Nights" that set Aladdin in China. Aristus Oct 2013 #14
That sounds familiar, kentauros Oct 2013 #16
You win. To the Arab authors, China was a fabulous, exotic location for a story. Bucky Oct 2013 #18
Mississippi. MiddleFingerMom Oct 2013 #15
That's easy: Benghazi!!! pinboy3niner Oct 2013 #17
BROOOOKLYYYYNNNN! Callmecrazy Oct 2013 #19
Some interesting info on 1001 Arabian Nights Tanuki Oct 2013 #20

Paulie

(8,462 posts)
3. Iraq and Iran are relatively new. Post British
Fri Oct 25, 2013, 02:45 PM
Oct 2013

My guess Assyria (which happens to reside in Iraq).

Paulie

(8,462 posts)
6. Mesopotamia also happens to be in Iraq
Fri Oct 25, 2013, 02:49 PM
Oct 2013

But it wasn't a correct answer either.

Watch the answer be Sumer. LoL

petronius

(26,602 posts)
8. England? France? Could be one of those totally made
Fri Oct 25, 2013, 02:58 PM
Oct 2013

up 'Orientalist' tales...

(And now I will wait patiently for the actual correct answer. )

cemaphonic

(4,138 posts)
21. This is a possibility, actually
Fri Oct 25, 2013, 08:41 PM
Oct 2013

(although I think the OP was talking about the setting of the story, instead of its original source)

The French translator that produced one of the earliest European translations added it into his version - it doesn't have any antecedents in the original Arabian Nights, or in the Arab/Persian/Indian storytelling tradition they came from. He claims to have gotten the story from a Syrian storyteller, so that is it's most likely source. But it is quite possible that he made the story up on his own.

kentauros

(29,414 posts)
13. That is correct!
Fri Oct 25, 2013, 03:27 PM
Oct 2013


Still, there are some fine Arabian folktales out there. Look for the book "Arab Folktales" by Inea Bushnaq

Aristus

(66,379 posts)
14. I grew up reading a children's version of "The Arabian Nights" that set Aladdin in China.
Fri Oct 25, 2013, 03:43 PM
Oct 2013

But the illustrations were unmistakeably Arabian in style. When Aladdin is transformed into a prince, it depicts him in a turban, Arabian brocade, fine, high riding boots, and mounted on a magnificent Arabian stallion. The backgrounds were all vast, sweeping desert vistas, and Mogul-style architecture with onion domes, etc.

kentauros

(29,414 posts)
16. That sounds familiar,
Fri Oct 25, 2013, 03:57 PM
Oct 2013

but I may not have read that version until well into my adult years. I also got read a child's version of Aladdin that wasn't the Disney version (they changed the hell out of the story, and I continue to see people quote the genie's "rules" as if it was an authentic source.)

One of the best renditions of the story was from Fairytale Theater, with James Earl Jones as the genie, Leonard Nimoy as the evil wazir, and Robert Carradine as Aladdin.

Oh, I just read that this episode was also Tim Burton's directorial debut.

Bucky

(54,013 posts)
18. You win. To the Arab authors, China was a fabulous, exotic location for a story.
Fri Oct 25, 2013, 04:58 PM
Oct 2013

of course all the tales take place in a China where everyone has an Arab sounding name and the king utter Muslim moral precepts.

Another "exotic" element is the fact that the ancient sorcerer who starts all the action is from "the Maghreb", meaning the West. It's never clear in the story if the sorcerer is from Morocco or Europe.

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»What country is the origi...