The DU Lounge
Related: Culture Forums, Support ForumsProgressive Rock: The Show That Never Ends
Retweeted by Erik Wemple: https://twitter.com/ErikWemple
You can now read that New Yorker essay here: http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2017/06/19/the-persistence-of-prog-rock And buy my book here:
Link to tweet
Stand by for some long paragraphs:
June 19, 2017 Issue
The Persistence of Prog Rock
Critics think that the genre was an embarrassing dead end. So why do fans and musicians still love it?
By Kelefa Sanneh
In April, 1971, Rolling Stone reviewed the début album by a band with a name better suited to a law firm: Emerson, Lake & Palmer. The reviewer liked what he heard, although he couldnt quite define it. I suppose that your local newspaper might call it jazz-influenced classical-rock, he wrote. In fact, a term was being adopted for this hybrid of highbrow and lowbrow. People called it progressive rock, or prog rock: a genre intent on proving that rock and roll didnt have to be simple and sillyit could be complicated and silly instead. In the early nineteen-seventies, E.L.P., alongside several more or less like-minded British groupsKing Crimson, Yes, and Genesis, as well as Jethro Tull and Pink Floydwent, in the space of a few years, from curiosities to rock stars. This was especially true in America, where arenas filled up with crowds shouting for more, which was precisely what these bands were designed to deliver. The prog-rock pioneers embraced extravagance: odd instruments and fantastical lyrics, complex compositions and abstruse concept albums, flashy solos and flashier live shows. Concertgoers could savor a new electronic keyboard called a Mellotron, a singer dressed as a batlike alien commander, an allusion to a John Keats poem, and a philosophical allegory about humankinds demiseall in a single song (Watcher of the Skies, by Genesis). In place of a guitarist, E.L.P. had Keith Emerson, a keyboard virtuoso who liked to wrestle with his customized Hammond organ onstage, and didnt always win: during one particularly energetic performance, he was pinned beneath the massive instrument, and had to be rescued by roadies. Perhaps this, too, was an allegory.
....
In the past twenty years, though, a number of critics and historians have argued that prog rock was more interesting and more thoughtful than the caricature would suggest. The latest is David Weigel, a savvy political reporter for the Washington Post who also happens to be an unabashed fanor, more accurately, a semi-abashed fan. His new history of prog rock is called The Show That Never Ends, and it begins with its author embarking on a cruise for fans, starring some of the great prog-rock bands of yore, or what remains of them. We are the most uncool people in Miami, Weigel writes, and we can hardly control our bliss.
Almost no one hated progressive rock as much, or as memorably, as Lester Bangs, the dyspeptic critic who saw himself as a rock-and-roll warrior, doing battle against the forces of fussiness and phoniness. In 1974, he took in an E.L.P. performance and came away appalled by the arsenal of instruments (including two Arthurian-table-sized gongs and the worlds first synthesized drum kits), by Emersons preening performance, and by the bands apparent determination to smarten up rock and roll by borrowing from more respectable sources. E.L.P. had reached the Top Ten, in both Britain and America, with a live album based on its bombastic rendition of Mussorgskys Pictures at an Exhibition. Bangs wanted to believe that the band members thought of themselves as vandals, gleefully desecrating the classics. Instead, Carl Palmer, the drummer, told him, We hope, if anything, were encouraging the kids to listen to music that has more qualityand quality was precisely the quality that Bangs loathed. He reported that the members of E.L.P. were soulless sellouts, participating in the insidious befoulment of all that was gutter pure in rock. Robert Christgau, the self-proclaimed dean of American rock critics, was, if anything, more dismissive: These guys are as stupid as their most pretentious fans.
The story of this reviled genre starts, though, with the most acclaimed popular music ever made. If you dont like progressive rock, blame it on the Beatles, a philosophy professor named Bill Martin wrote, in his 1998 book, Listening to the Future, a wonderfully argumentative defense of the genre. Martin is, in his own estimation, somewhat Marxist, and he saw progressive rock as an emancipatory and utopian movementnot a betrayal of the sixties counterculture but an extension of it. Martin identified a musical turning point in 1966 and 1967, when the Beach Boys released Pet Sounds and the Beatles released Sgt. Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band, which together inspired a generation of bands to create albums that were more unified in theme but more diverse in sound. Using orchestration and studio trickery, these albums summoned the immersive pleasure of watching a movie, rather than the kicky thrill of listening to the radio.
calimary
(81,267 posts)DAYUM progressive rock radio was fun!!!
Still In Wisconsin
(4,450 posts)Looks like her insufferable "emo" phase is over. Goodbye My Chemical Romance/ Fall Out Boy/ Panic at the Disco, hello Yes/Rush/ELP.
I love Prog rock...always have, always will.
mahatmakanejeeves
(57,446 posts)Last edited Sun Jun 18, 2017, 08:26 AM - Edit history (1)
Please don't ask me who Goodbye My Chemical Romance, Fall Out Boy, and Panic at the Disco are. I get that they are groups, okay, but beyond that....
Thanks for writing.
Still In Wisconsin
(4,450 posts)My best analogy for those "bands" would be The Cure, but way more sucky and morose, with an extra helping of angst and whiney.
And yes, it was my (new) vinyl copy of Fragile, although she has their whole catalog pretty much on her phone. Ah, kids.
Loki Liesmith
(4,602 posts)The Black Parade is a decent album.
Still In Wisconsin
(4,450 posts)I can't STAND Gerard Way. But lots of people say the same about some of the things I listen to, so who am I to talk?
msongs
(67,406 posts)iwillalwayswonderwhy
(2,602 posts)Would Frank Zappa and the Mothers of Invention be considered Prog Rock? Loved them.
ms liberty
(8,576 posts)Initech
(100,076 posts)Some of my all time favorite bands!