Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Fla Dem

(23,691 posts)
Tue Apr 26, 2016, 11:37 AM Apr 2016

MSNBC Town Hall: Bernie Sanders offered no plans for his revolution if elected

Here is an excerpt from the MSNBC Town Hall with Bernie Sanders last night (4/25/15). He was responding to a question from the audience. In full disclosure I have removed applause/laughter indications to keep the transcript condensed.

Question from audience member...
HERBERT: So much of your campaign rhetoric is about revolutionary politics. But so much of a president's job is inherently tied to institutions and bureaucracies as they exist.

So, how do you keep the revolutionary spirit alive despite these constraints?

SANDERS: OK. Thank you.
Um, you're right in saying that a lot of the day to day work is going to take place in Capitol Hill and it's messy and there's a lot of negotiating. What I will tell you is that when I was in the House, in a given number of years, I ended up passing more amendments on the floor of the House working with Republicans than any other member of the House. I can work with Republicans.

Just a few years ago, I helped pass, as chairman of the Senate Veterans Committee, the most comprehensive veteran’s legislation in modern history working with John McCain and a number of other Republicans. So if the question is, can I sit down, you know, with conservative people like Chris here and negotiate with them yes, I can do that.

But let me also say this, and this is important. At the end of the day, the powers that be, the powers who control -- people who control the Congress, the big money interests and Wall Street, they are not going to allow the kind of real change that this country needs, raising the minimum wage to $15 an hour, ending our disastrous trade policies so that corporate America starts investing in this country rather than China, making sure that women do not continue to earn 79 cents on the dollar compared to men, aggressively addressing climate change, making sure that public colleges and universities are tuition-free.

That is not going to be done by Congress itself. That requires a political revolution. And as president of the United States, what I would do is use the bully pulpit in an unprecedented way to rally the American people to demand that the Congress listens to their needs, not just the needs of wealthy campaign contributors.

HAYES: -- President Obama, when he came into office, had this new, unprecedented thing called Obama for America, right, where they basically preserved the campaign organization...

SANDERS: Right.

HAYES: -- and full disclosure, my brother worked for them. He was an organizer. Um, and that proved tough, in a lot of ways, for it to work. Um, part of that, I think, had to do with the inherent tension between being the president of the United States and outside power.

What have you learned from that?

What is the model, if that -- if that seemed to not do what you're talking about.

SANDERS: Actually, I talked to the president about that. And from what he, you know, indicated, it's tough. And it is tough. It is really tough.

Uh, but I think that one of the most important things that a president can do is to help ordinary people come together in a variety of grassroots organizations to put the pressure on the Congress to counterbalance the pressure that Wall Street and wealthy campaign contributors now exert.

For example, let me just give you one example and on this one, I am 100 percent sure that I'm right.

If the young people of this country stood up and were very loud and clear that they are sick and tired of leaving college $30,000, $50,000, $70,000 in debt, that they want public colleges and universities tuition-free, and if millions of them stood up, started emailing, writing and demonstrating, without the slightest doubt, that is exactly what would happen.
So the question is, this is what the American people want.
The question is, how we put together...

HAYES: Right.

SANDERS: -- that type of grassroots organization...

HAYES: But that's a hard thing to do.

SANDERS: It is a hard thing to do. But for the future of this country, that is exactly what has to be done.
Let me say this about the president...

HAYES: Yes.

SANDERS: -- somebody I love and have enormous respect for. I think because he is such a decent guy, in many respects, he actually believed that he could walk into the Oval Office and sit down with Republicans and negotiate in good faith. He was wrong about that. Republicans had no intention of ever negotiating in good faith. What they wanted to do was obstruct, obstruct, obstruct in an unprecedented way.

And it took the president a number of years to learn that lesson. He knows it now and that's why his pen (ph) and executive orders are flying out. I have learned that lesson. I will know that when I get into the Oval Office.

HAYES: Do you predict that would -- whoever the Democratic president, should there be a Democratic president elected in January of next year, do you believe they will be met with functionally that same attitude?

SANDERS: Yes. I think the Republican Party, as I mentioned a moment ago, has moved very, very far to the right. Obviously they are beholden to the wealthy corporate interests, but they are now also beholden to an extreme right wing base, you know, people who are active in the horrific, you know, Trump ethic, on the birther movement, people who are very hostile to immigrants.

You see Trump talking about and referring to Mexicans as racists and criminals, wanting to ban Muslims from coming into this country. And those concepts do have a certain support.

So do I think if I became president that we'd run into that type of obstructionism? Yes, I do.

http://info.msnbc.com/_news/2016/04/25/35464706-full-transcript-msnbc-town-hall-with-bernie-sanders-moderated-by-chris-hayes?lite


Nowhere did he say WHAT HE WOULD DO to effect all the wonderful promises he has made to his supporters. He just keeps saying Grassroots organizations. "He will use his bully pulpit to rally the American people." Well we saw how well that worked for President Obama. All those "new" voters and "young people" who rallied behind him went back to their humdrum lives after Obama was elected, never to be heard from again. In the mid-terms elections, the Republicans took over control of the House of Representative.

Bernie Sanders, Smoke and Mirrors. No Plan

16 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies

Cha

(297,322 posts)
1. Thank you for this, Fla Dem.. ol bernie.. true to form.. nothing of substance..
Tue Apr 26, 2016, 11:44 AM
Apr 2016

why is it more and more aren't noticing? Or are they?

hamsterjill

(15,222 posts)
2. This has been my biggest issue with Bernie.
Tue Apr 26, 2016, 11:44 AM
Apr 2016

In MY opinion, Bernie offers big ideas without explaining how those ideas will be put into practice.

The Office of the President of the United States is, no doubt, a very powerful authority. But it is not a dictator and a lot of what MOST candidates offer is not possible without the consent of the Congress. However, I feel that Bernie has promised the moon and back, and I still don't understand how he's going to pay for it all. In MY opinion, while his ideas sound worthy, I simply don't believe it's possible at this point in time.



stopbush

(24,396 posts)
13. I wish one of these moderators would ask him directly
Tue Apr 26, 2016, 12:43 PM
Apr 2016

whether kids in college right now would benefit from his free tuition policy.

The answer, of course, if no, because it would take at least a couple of years to institute such a policy. And who knows what it would look like after going through the political process.

I wonder if his support among today's college kids would hold up when they learn help is not on the way for them.

hamsterjill

(15,222 posts)
14. That would be a great question.
Tue Apr 26, 2016, 01:06 PM
Apr 2016

Doubt he'd answer it directly, but like you, I wish the question would be asked.

I don't know if his support would dwindle among college kids. In all honesty, the few that I have contact with don't seem to have a clue. I'll not brand "all young people", but the ones that I have normal, ordinary contact with in my own circle of friends and activities - say, the 18 to 25 year olds, seem utterly clueless that in order to get something, you have to PAY for it.

Part of it, in MY opinion, is the fact that they don't handle actual money. They don't hold it in their hands. They don't count dollars and cents like those of us who are older have done. The millennials' concept of money is nothing more than electronic transfers off a page, and I'm not sure some of them understand that there is a finite amount of money (i.e., revenue from taxes, etc.) and all needs must be met from that revenue. They seem to believe that if Bernie says it, it will happen.

I think most of us old farts understand that it's not that easy.

SharonClark

(10,014 posts)
4. He contradicts himself
Tue Apr 26, 2016, 11:50 AM
Apr 2016

1. He can work with Republicans and 2) they are totally obstructionist.
But, but , but they won't dare obstruct Sanders because of the revolution.

 

Her Sister

(6,444 posts)
5. So these young people are going to be available for the whole of his presidency
Tue Apr 26, 2016, 11:56 AM
Apr 2016

to just rally after rally and protest and protest and go complaining 24/7 and really be parked at most Senators and Congress' offices all year round and during the winter. Giving up their lives and jobs, and education. Are they getting payed or trained? Who will coordinate them?

All this because BS has not done the work to get people elected down the ballot.

I am passing on the whole whatever this is....

HRC READY!

Satch59

(1,353 posts)
10. 100% agree Her Sister
Tue Apr 26, 2016, 12:28 PM
Apr 2016

All these protests Bernie thinks will bring the revolution will fall on deaf GOP ears... They don't care about protests, they just want power and you're right, it's up to Bernie to get more Dems elected and he hasn't lifted a finger, which is actually easy for him to "do do"...

Seems he wants everyone else to do the work...young people to protest, Hillary to take on his pie in the sky ideas...and if all these years in the senate hasn't progressed his revolution, why would it now??

Seems the jig is up Bernie...

stopbush

(24,396 posts)
11. Chris Matthews asked Sanders this question months ago.
Tue Apr 26, 2016, 12:40 PM
Apr 2016

Said you might get a million people to DC once to stand outside Mitch McConnell's window and demand change, but what do you do after that one time? What do you do if he doesn't listen? Sanders got flustered and turned red.

Fla Dem

(23,691 posts)
16. And he still doesn't have an answer. Just knows how to sidestep it better. "Look, look over here!"
Tue Apr 26, 2016, 01:45 PM
Apr 2016

pandr32

(11,588 posts)
6. Interesting
Tue Apr 26, 2016, 11:56 AM
Apr 2016

Not only did he not really answer Herbert's question, he again managed to throw in his single significant achievement (other two things were naming Post Offices) to pat himself on the back.

That achievement was a joint effort, and not Sanders alone, and in order to get it passed the needed reform (cautioned as necessary by two major veterans groups) was stripped out and the funding went ahead (no wonder it got Republican support, because it leaked like a sieve into all the waiting hands that pulled the money away from actually helping veterans, and we wound up with a huge shortfall). So, Sanders takes credit for something that did not turn out to be helpful to veterans and was enormously wasteful to taxpayers.

Not only that, but on one hand he says he is able to work with Republicans, and on the other he acknowledges that Republicans "have moved very far to the right...are beholden to the wealthy corporate interests...", so what is he really saying?

I see a hot mess with Sanders.

Fla Dem

(23,691 posts)
8. Here's an example of the "People" overwhelming demanding change. But it didn't happen.
Tue Apr 26, 2016, 12:07 PM
Apr 2016


85% - 92% of Americans from all political groups wanted to tighten background checks on gun purchases. But the congress would not let that happen. Groups marched on congress, there were protests, rallies to no avail. Nothing will change until we have the WH, senate and a good share of congress. There also needs to be a retaking of state and local governments. This is where the Republican have dominated in the last 20 years. At least HRC is working with the DNC to support down ticket candidates. That's the real "grassroots".

Rose Siding

(32,623 posts)
9. omg Obama didn't quite know what he was doing
Tue Apr 26, 2016, 12:10 PM
Apr 2016

But this back bencher WILL.

And now for a smilie making its first ever debut in one of my posts

Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»Hillary Clinton»MSNBC Town Hall: Bernie S...