Environment & Energy
Related: About this forumExxon (So Oppressed!! Sad!!) Claims That Climate Lawsuits Hurt Its 1st Amendment Rights
EDIT
After the California cities filed suit, Exxon brought a petition before the Texas 2nd Circuit Court of Appeals claiming the lawsuits were part of a conspiracy intended to waylay the companys right to free speech and force it to change its position on climate change. Yes, you read that correctly. Exxon argued that the cities were trying to make the company agree to a number of truths about climate change, which, in effect, violated Exxons First Amendment rights to say whatever the hell it wants about climate change.
Yeah, sounds crazy! But the Texas judge, R.H. Wallace Jr., bought the argument and handed Exxon a victory in April. That means the company can now grill California city officials about whether the climate suits, from the Bay to New York City, have been one big conspiracy to violate the companys right to free speech.
Michael Burger, Executive Director of Columbia Universitys Sabin Center for Climate Change Law, doesnt think Exxons free speech argument holds up under scrutiny. Exxon already tried a similar tactic in a New York Court. Former Attorney General Eric Schneiderman, who recently resigned after four women accused him of sexual assault, started investigating the company over climate change in 2015. Exxons lawyers argued Schneiderman tried to silence and intimidate one side of the public policy debate on how to address climate change by launching the probe.
The New York judge dismissed the case this year. When Exxon tried to edit, or amend, its original complaint, the judge denied the amendment as futile, which is a fancy way of saying the judge kicked Exxon in the gnads. The fact that Exxon already tried and failed to invoke its First Amendment rights doesnt bode well for the companys latest attempt in California. The idea that these lawsuits could infringe on First Amendment rights is, as the judge in New York said, implausible, Burger says.
EDIT
https://grist.org/article/exxon-says-climate-lawsuits-violate-its-right-to-free-speech-seriously/
dlk
(11,569 posts)Trial lawyers are some of the most imaginative fiction writers on the planet.
sweetroxie
(776 posts)Poor babies.