Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

NickB79

(19,258 posts)
Thu Dec 24, 2015, 11:24 AM Dec 2015

Wild bees losing out to corn in Minnesota and Upper Midwest, says U of Vermont study

http://www.startribune.com/wild-bees-losing-out-to-corn-in-minnesota-and-upper-midwest-says-u-of-vermont-study/363166631/

It’s not just honeybees that are in trouble. Wild bees are disappearing from much of the nation’s farmland — especially in Minnesota and much of the Upper Midwest.

Overall, wild bees declined across nearly one-fourth of the country between 2008 and 2013. But some areas are now so inhospitable to wild bees that the nation’s crops, including soybeans in western Minnesota, are probably not getting the pollination they need for peak production, researchers at the University of Vermont found in the first nationwide study to map the abundance of wild bees.

“Those farmers are going to be looking at inconsistent yields,” said Taylor Ricketts, a professor at the University of Vermont, and one of the lead researchers on the study.

Wild bees provide $3 billion worth of pollination services to the nation’s food system. Some crops, like almonds, blueberries and other fruits, are totally reliant on either domesticated honeybees that are trucked at a high cost, or wild insects that live around the fields. The researchers found that 39 percent of the croplands that need insects face a threatening mismatch between rising demand for pollination and a dwindling supply of wild bees.


Modern, monocrop farming strikes again. GPS-guided tractors allow for plowing fencerow-to-fencerow with no buffer zones, and conservation land is being plowed under left and right to increase corn production.
3 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Wild bees losing out to corn in Minnesota and Upper Midwest, says U of Vermont study (Original Post) NickB79 Dec 2015 OP
Frankincrops that make they own pesticide are not helping any at all. -none Dec 2015 #1
Loss of habitat is behind the decline NickB79 Dec 2015 #2
I agree with the previous poster, this has little to do with GMO crops... happyslug Dec 2015 #3

NickB79

(19,258 posts)
2. Loss of habitat is behind the decline
Thu Dec 24, 2015, 11:44 AM
Dec 2015

Bees do fine in conjunction with modern crops as long as they have sufficient reservoirs of wild habitat to shelter in and feed upon when the crops aren't in flower.

Hence why the study found bee declines as corn production went up: bees don't even feed upon corn, GM or non-GM. Cornfields are wildlife deserts.

 

happyslug

(14,779 posts)
3. I agree with the previous poster, this has little to do with GMO crops...
Sat Dec 26, 2015, 01:51 AM
Dec 2015

It has more to do with larger and larger farms with less and less fences and hedgerows between farms. In the days before tractors, the average farm.

The altered role of farming in the overall economy reflects changes at the farm and farm household level. Since 1900, the number of farms has fallen by 63 percent, while the average farm size has risen 67 percent (fig. 3). Farm operations have become increasingly specialized as well (fig. 4)— from an average of about five commodities per farm in 1900 to about one per farm in 2000—reflecting the production and marketing efficiencies gained by concentration on fewer commodities, as well as the effects of farm price and income policies that have reduced the risk of depending on returns from only one or a few crops. All of this has taken place with almost no variation in the amount of land being farmed.

http://www.ers.usda.gov/media/259572/eib3_1_.pdf


The above report also says that the average size of a farm went from 147 acres in 1900 to 441 Acres in 2015. Rural population has dropped as a percentage of total US population, but the number of people living on a farm has dropped even further. Many farms no longer have people living on them, the workers on those farms commute from "Urban Clusters" or small farms that produce very little produce for sale but the farmers on those farms feed their families (i.e. more a "Hobby Farm" then a farm set up to sell farm products). Thus you have a lot of 50 acres or less farms, the number of those farms have stayed about the same since WWII, it is the farms of 50 to 1000 acres that have seen a decline in numbers, while the farms of over 1000 acres have increased in number and size.

http://www.agday.org/media/factsheet.php

Tractors only surpassed horses on farms in the 1960 census, thus till the 1950s the horse remained more important then the tractor, but that all changed in the 1950s.

Thus in areas like the Central Valley of California, the Southern Cotton, Rice and Soybean crops and the Midwest Grain fields, where you have millions of acres of farmland of one crop. That crop is planted and harvested by contract workers, with a smaller number of employees working between planting and harvesting. This has lead to larger and larger farms in these areas:

Although the Great Plains region of North America was largely settled by 1900, farm numbers continued to grow during the first third of the twentieth century, peaking at nearly 1.7 million in 1935. Average farm size was 355 acres in the U.S. Great Plains, and 221 acres (in 1941) in the Canadian Prairie Provinces. During the ensuing six decades, farms grew larger and fewer in number. By 1992 only 646,000 farms remained; there were 502,000 farms in the ten U.S. Plains states, averaging 1,020 acres, and 144,000 Prairie Province farms averaging 952 acres in 1991.

http://plainshumanities.unl.edu/encyclopedia/doc/egp.ag.032

It is this change since WWII, accelerated since the 1970s, that is killing the wild bees. Wild bees need something in flower all year around, or at least from spring to frost. If you plant five crops, as was common in 1900, that and a flower garden would provide such wild bees flower to feed off all year around. This was the pattern before WWII. It started to change in 1900, speed up after WWII, and then accelerated even more since the 1970s.

People forget the the Horse was NEEDED on the farm till the widespread adoption of the three point hitch post WWII. The Three point hitch was invented in 1939, but WWII delayed its adoption. The three point hitch finally permitted Tractors to plow between the rows of crops AFTER the crop has been planted. Such plowing was needed but only able to be done with a horse PRIOR to the three point hitch.

With the horse no longer needed on the farm (Post WWII) tractors could do the job horses use to do. As farm became larger, larger tractors would cut down time plowing, spraying and harvesting thus cutting costs. To use those larger tractors that required larger fields, cutting back on fence lines and hedgerows. Thus less places for wild bees to live and to find flowers to live off of.

Thus the problem with wild bees is the larger and larger farms we have today. People will oppose my solution to this problem, increase regulations on farms over 50 acres. Including forbidding farming near creeks and streams (a problem in my home State of Pennsylvania, farming to the side of such creeks and streams have lead to massive influx of fertilizer into the Susquehanna River and the Chesapeake bay causing problems in the bay (The Susquehanna River is the single largest river that flows into the bay). Similar problems exists for the other rivers flowing into the Chesapeake Bay. Forbidding farming within six feet of such streams may be all that is needed.

Similar restrictions will help other bees. Some compensation MAY have to be paid, but denial of PLOWING or PLANTING in some areas of farms MAY be done if it can be shown no overall loss of value of such land. The better option would be to take over such streams of water and turn them over to the state with a restrictions that it can not be sold without federal permission. This would cost more than just a regulation forbidding plowing but would make it clear WHAT is NOT open to farming or other activities that harm such waterways (Hunting and fishing would be permitted, cattle and other animals could graze, provided trees along the waterways are protected).

The Federal Government has to do something to protect wild bees and the above is by far the best method, but it requires commitment to solving the problems of wild bees not just month service and I suspect the later is what we will hear when we need actual actions.

Please note, the report I cite, ignore an observation reported by Admiral Richover in a speech in the 1950s. While US production per crop per field had increased for decades by that date and were higher on larger farms then smaller farms, total production of crops per acre was much higher in smaller farms than larger farms. The reason for this was simple, smaller farms were noted for planting three or more crops in the same field. Total production of EACH crop was less then on the one crop per field larger farms, but since you had three compatible crops in the same field, you had almost three times the TOTAL crop production. I.e. if you planted Beans, Corn and Pumpkins in the same field, you cut out anything by hand hoeing of weed, but while the Corn Production per acre was less then Corn production on larger farms, larger farms did NOT produce the beans and pumpkins in the same field. These three crops had been planted together on small farms since the days of the First Americans. More labor intensive but higher TOTAL production of all THREE crops per acre. Such farming techniques are NOT profitable at the present time, given the huge farms sheer volume of the one crop they do produce, but such productively is the product of the same system that is killing off the native bees.

My point is it is NOT farming that is the problem, but the tendency to larger and larger farms that are hurting small hobby farms AND the bees.
Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Environment & Energy»Wild bees losing out to c...