Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

TexasTowelie

(112,395 posts)
Mon Dec 24, 2018, 07:17 AM Dec 2018

This is not what Vladimir Putin wanted for Christmas

Vladimir Putin won’t find many great presents under the Christmas tree this year.

Orthodox Christian religious leaders worldwide are weakening an important institution that gave him outsize power and legitimacy.

The Russian Orthodox Church is being broken up, and an independent Ukraine Orthodox Church will be established. The Ukrainian flock soon will be led not by the Moscow-based church and Patriarchate, but rather by its own independent church and youthful leadership. Ukraine and its political class are suddenly freed from an influential Russian institution that has been fiercely loyal to Putin.

This was not on Putin’s Christmas list. Instead, the news is like a lump of coal in his stocking.

Read more: https://www.mcclatchydc.com/opinion/article223378975.html

12 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
This is not what Vladimir Putin wanted for Christmas (Original Post) TexasTowelie Dec 2018 OP
kick & rec. nt Ilsa Dec 2018 #1
He deserves more than a lump of coal. saidsimplesimon Dec 2018 #2
Good 47of74 Dec 2018 #3
Wow. That's a big turn. underpants Dec 2018 #4
Yeah well.. US president Donald Trump gave Syria to Putin, that's a pretty big Xmas gift KelleyKramer Dec 2018 #5
The Holy Sees for the Ancient Christians modrepub Dec 2018 #6
The Russian Orthodox Church has generally sided with LuvNewcastle Dec 2018 #10
I Agree modrepub Dec 2018 #12
Thank you very much! orangecrush Dec 2018 #11
Good for them, as they march on to independence. nt Honeycombe8 Dec 2018 #7
Every time Putin frowns paleotn Dec 2018 #8
Merry Christmas.... orangecrush Dec 2018 #9

saidsimplesimon

(7,888 posts)
2. He deserves more than a lump of coal.
Mon Dec 24, 2018, 07:53 AM
Dec 2018

I would love to gift him a few years of vacation time at a prison resort in Crimea. While we are at it, can we deport that lump occupying our WH to join him?

KelleyKramer

(8,982 posts)
5. Yeah well.. US president Donald Trump gave Syria to Putin, that's a pretty big Xmas gift
Mon Dec 24, 2018, 08:54 AM
Dec 2018


So he at least got that

And I think Trump just lifted sanctions on one of Putins billionaire pals, that's a nice stocking stuffer to add to the big Syrian gift

Plus Trump just installed a Putin apologist as US Sec of Defense, so that gives Putin the military green light ...

maybe Trump will let Putin take over Ukraine as a New Years gift


modrepub

(3,502 posts)
6. The Holy Sees for the Ancient Christians
Mon Dec 24, 2018, 09:04 AM
Dec 2018

were Alexandria, Constantinople and Rome (some would argue for Ethiopia but this area was on the fringe of the Roman Empire). Those ancient cities always struggled to place themselves above the other Bishops in Late Antiquity. Prior to the rise of Islam, all of these Sees were somewhat subservient to the Roman Emperor as he was the final arbiter of any dispute. With the collapse of the Roman administration in the west, Rome found itself surrounded by hostile German kings who practiced a different version of Christianity (under Arius) or pagans. The Popes in Rome eventually aligned themselves with Charlemagne but set precedent by crowning the Holy Roman Emperor thus establishing Rome in its current prominent role within the Catholic faith. Alexandria and much of the Levant fell to Islam in the 7th century and operated under their own guise eventually becoming a minority faith (Coptic Church). The Orthodox faith along with the remnants of the Roman Empire centered in Constantinople would survive the initial Islamic surge and eventually convert the Slavs and areas that would become Russia. When Muhammet II captured Constantinople and disposed of the last remnants of the Byzantine Empire in the 15th century, Russia would claim to be the "New Rome" even though the Bishop of Constantinople has carried on to this day (Bishop Bartholomew I who is still considered first among equals in the Orthodox faith).

The Russian Orthodox Church lingered through the Communist rule and was reinstituted when the USSR broke up. Putin has been a strong supporter of the Orthodox church seeking to use it for state support (much like the old Roman emperors did). Bartholomew may be the last Pope to sit in Constantinople due to harsh treatment by the Turkish government. Bartholomew's somewhat close relationship with the Catholic Popes (there was talk of reconciliation with the west) has probably not helped him in the eyes of the other Orthodox Bishops and is probably helping the Russians lay claim to the mantle of Orthodox leadership if Bartholomew is truly the last Bishop of Constantinople. I'm not surprised Ukraine is trying to break itself from Russia since the Orthodox faith has historically been more decentralized than either the Roman Catholic or Coptic churches.

LuvNewcastle

(16,855 posts)
10. The Russian Orthodox Church has generally sided with
Mon Dec 24, 2018, 09:52 AM
Dec 2018

the people in power through most of its history. They helped to keep the czars in power all those years, but when the communists came along they went underground, more or less. After the fall of communism in Russia they once again aligned themselves with the elite and powerful. The Russian Orthodox Church is not a people's church, which I think is why the Ukrainians chose to separate themselves from them. Good luck to the Ukrainians, and I hope they're able to create a church that cares more about their common members rather than the rich and powerful in their ranks. i hope they have a church that can stay out of politics and won't get involved in the power plays of the ruling class.

modrepub

(3,502 posts)
12. I Agree
Mon Dec 24, 2018, 10:27 AM
Dec 2018

but the ancient Christian churches have for the most part always been part of the elite if not the only elite. They can be a mixed bag, at times representing civilization in the face of barbarism and other times surpassing the will of the people in the name of "order". Like most institutions, it's only as "good" as the people who run it.

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Foreign Affairs»This is not what Vladimir...