Foreign Affairs
Related: About this forumChinese Scientist Who Created CRISPR Babies Could Face the Death Penalty, Fellow Geneticist Warns
Source: Gizmodo
George Dvorsky
Yesterday 4:10pmFiled to: BIOETHICS
A British geneticist is worried that He Jiankuithe Chinese scientist responsible for the birth of genetically modified human twinscould face the death penalty for corruption and bribery charges.
When He Jiankui went missing back in early December, we suspected big trouble ahead for the rogue scientist, but as Sarah Knapton reports in the Telegraph, his predicament is even worse than we thought.
The embattled scientist is reportedly living under armed guard at a state-owned apartment in Shenzhen, China, according to geneticist Robin Lovell-Badge of the Francis Crick Institute in London, who now worries that He could face the death penalty for his indiscretions.
-snip-
The Telegraph reports that scientists in the UK close to the situation said that He could face corruption and bribery charges, both of which carry the death penalty in China. In addition, He may face charges of violating established research guidelines, which he did by implanting the genetically modified embryos in the mother instead of destroying them as per convention. In China, state guidelines carry the same legal weight as established laws, according to the Telegraph.
-snip-
Read more: https://gizmodo.com/chinese-scientist-who-created-crispr-babies-could-face-1831553751
______________________________________________________________________
Source: The Telegraph
By Sarah Knapton, science editor
7 JANUARY 2019 2:42PM
The Chinese scientist who created the worlds first genetically edited babies is living under armed guard and could face the death penalty, colleagues believe.
He Jiankui shocked the world in November when he announced he had altered embryos for seven couples during fertility treatment to protect them against contracting HIV, leading to the birth of two twin girls with engineered DNA.
Since then he has received death threats and the Chinese government has launched an investigation into his work. He has been confined to a state owned apartment in the city of Shenzhen since December.
-snip-
Read more: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/science/2019/01/07/chinese-scientist-genetically-edited-babies-armed-guard-amid/
RockRaven
(15,002 posts)the public thus far, IF (big if, since there's also the possibility of bullshittery for the sake of publicity/grift behind this story) the details of the couples/embryos/babies involved in this episode would mean he committed ABSOLUTELY EGREGIOUS UNETHICAL behavior.
The details of the couple in question to whom the two babies were born prove that the justification/premise of their inclusion in the experiment is entirely bogus/unjustified. There was literally no upside to justify the risk. And both now-children are now subject of some unknown, life-long consequence.
Even in a nation with no capital punishment, this was so beyond the pale as to warrant permanent loss of license/credentials and some sort of restraining order at minimum, and likely some manner of incarceration. What is the appropriate penalty for a premeditated, callously indifferent, indeterminate maiming of a newborn (or two)?