Israel/Palestine
Related: About this forumNo abuse or torture under interrogation - no matter what
Published:
23 Dec 2015
Over the past few weeks, right wing circles have been protesting the use of special measures by the Israel Security Agency (ISA) in its interrogation of the Jewish suspects in the arson in the Palestinian village of Duma. They are suspected of torching the Dawaabsheh home while the family was at home, killing three: a one-and-a-half year old toddler and both his parents. Over the years, dozens of testimonies and affidavits given by Palestinians to BTselem and human rights organization HaMoked: Center for the Defence of the Individual indicate that abuse and even torture are used routinely in ISA interrogations of Palestinians.
Below are excerpts illustrating this state of affairs. These measures have been used in the interrogation of thousands of Palestinians, including methods much harsher than those reportedly undergone by the Jewish suspects. The interrogation system that relies on the use of such methods, in direct interrogation and in the conditions of incarceration, was formulated by Israels law enforcement authorities. It is not the initiative of an individual interrogator or prison guard. The use of these measures in interrogation is wrong. People under interrogation be they Palestinian or Jewish must not be subjected to abuse and torture, no matter what.
Mazen Abu Arish, 22, a surveyor from Beit Ula:
I spent 20 days in total solitary confinement. Psychologically, being alone is like living in a toilet. If something happens to you, no one will notice. You could die and be discovered days later. You could die in a toilet and no one would notice. Youre dumped in a corner and forgotten, you can bang on the door for all the good itll do you you wont get any help.
L.H., a 20-year-old florist from Hebron, was interrogated most of the day and night for 22 days running:
The chair is small and low, with a low backrest. Three of the legs are the same length and the fourth is shorter. Its tough, because if you nod off or grow tired and fall over to the short side, the handcuffs tying you to the chair behind your back pull at you and it hurts your bound arms and hands terribly. There was another chair, the same size and height but with two shorter back legs instead. When you sit on it, it makes you lean back but the interrogator yells at you to stay straight. To do that, you have to lean forward. It hurts your hands and back. The pain in my arms and hands, and especially in my left arm, became unbearable.
http://www.btselem.org/press_releases/20151223_abuse_and_torture_prohibited
bemildred
(90,061 posts)Jefferson23
(30,099 posts)of those targeted have been Palestinians time will tell if any significant change
will result in ending said practices.
Personally, I wouldn't hold my breath.
Jefferson23
(30,099 posts)By Amira Hass | Dec. 28, 2015 | 12:46 AM
The horror expressed by the Israeli mainstream at the blood wedding video is more repulsive than the clip itself. The shock is at the messianic, disruptive representation of the settlement enterprise, the handiwork of successive generations of the Israeli mainstream.
The police are shocked. Every month on Rosh Hodesh, the start of the Hebrew month, a sivuv shearim is held in the Muslim Quarter of Jerusalems Old City. The ceremonial circling of the gates of the Temple Mount, accompanied by shofar-blowing and reading of Psalms, is organized by El Har Hamor, a nonprofit association that seeks to rebuild the Temple. The Israel Police provide security for the event, which takes place between shuttered Palestinian stores. Men in white kippot dance, sidelocks bouncing just like in the video and pound on the closed doors.
According to documentation from October, they also sing songs similar to the ones in the video (Burn down the mosque and We will avenge one of the two eyes of Palestine, curse them), and while the Arabs shut themselves into their homes, the dancers chant Death to Arabs. Not only are the police there, they also try to prevent leftists from recording the events.
Open and shut cases
The Judea and Samaria district police are shocked. This is the police district that systematically closes investigations of Israeli violence against Palestinians. Out of 1,104 investigations opened after Palestinians complained of violent injury or property damage over a 10-year period, from 2005 to August 2015, 940, or 91.6 percent, were closed without charges being filed, according to the Yesh Din legal defense NGO. In 85 percent of the cases, the closure was due to failure of the police investigation. The reason given in 624 of the cases was offender unknown, while in 208 cases it was insufficient evidence.
Examples? On Passover Eve 2011, a group of Israelis injured Bruce Lee Eid of Burin, a village south of Nablus. One of the Israelis shot Eid, wounding him severely in the abdomen and right hand. This attack was one of many designed to prevent the villagers from building on their lands. Soldiers fired tear gas at Palestinians who came to defend their neighbor. The incident was filmed, the origin of the assailants (the Givat Ronen outpost) was known, but the case was closed.
In another case, from October 2011, a few Israeli Jews from Combatants for Peace accompanied Palestinians from the village of Jalud on their first olive harvest in 10 years. In all those years the Israel Defense Forces (were they also shocked by the wedding video?) had kept them from working their land to avoid friction with the messianists from the local outposts (such as Esh Kodesh).
Masked Israelis, accompanied by an armed, unmasked Israeli in civilian clothes (perhaps the security coordinator) came, threw a stun grenade, fired into the air and attacked the harvesters with clubs, injuring three Israelis and two Palestinians. Soldiers and Border Police officers who were there fired tear gas and stun grenades at Palestinians. The case was closed despite the wounded Israelis and the presence of soldiers who were witnesses.
The culture of unknown offenders, insufficient evidence and do-nothing soldiers nurtured the atmosphere of we can run riot and no one will touch us seen in the wedding video.
Heres a less-than-wild guess: The justices of the High Court of Justice are also shocked by the video. Two out of three justices last week allowed a person who was convicted of assaulting a Palestinian youth to continue to offend against a different Palestinian, by cultivating a vineyard on private Palestinian land. With the High Courts approval, five years after appropriating land that did not belong to him, Zvi Strock, son of Habayit Hayehudi MK Orit Strock, can continue to keep Fawzi Ibrahim off his land for another year.
Strock did not return the land, a full year after an IDF appeals committee ordered him to do so. Now he is requesting an additional one-year extension so that the process can be done peacefully. That sounds like a clear threat: If he is removed earlier, it will not be peaceful. The mainstream (the state and the High Court) heard the threat, and knuckled under.
Netanyahu shocked, too
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is shocked, and the Defense Ministry is shocked. With their approval, dozens of bulldozers continue to nibble with the avarice of real-estate sharks at the land of dozens of Palestinian villages, in order to build homes for Jews. Go to Modiin Ilit, to Alei Zahav, Barkan, Ariel. Without dancing or bouncing sidelocks, the state is doing much more than the blood wedding dancers could.
Thanks to the mainstream, the West Bank has become the land of unlimited possibilities for the average Israeli Jew. Its a substitute for the welfare state that they ground down with a devotion that would do honor to Milton Friedman. This is the soil that gave rise to those young dancers with their bouncing peiyot and their guns.
Their messianism was born of the incessant secular Israeli disregard for international law and justice, which prohibit settlements in occupied territory. Their deranged messianism is fed by the consistent, deranged political objective of the settlement enterprise: to thwart the possibility of living in equality and peace with the Palestinian people in this land. Fed by and feeding.
http://www.haaretz.com/misc/article-print-page/.premium-1.694136