Pretending Away The Nakba Only Perpetuates The Conflict
When the Czechs prefer to keep silent and repress their history, its a problem, but it is not an imminent danger to the country. When Israelis prefer to pretend there was no ethnic cleaning here, its a wholly different question: the conflict wont end unless Israel admits to the injustice it caused.
By Yossi Gurvitz
A few weeks back I watched The Gatekeepers, a movie which interviews six of the chiefs of Shin Bet, from Avraham Shalom to Yuval Diskin. The movie is shocking and well worth your time. The most surprising character was Diskin, who obviously underwent a great change upon leaving the service: at the end of the movie he adamantly agrees with Yishayahu Leibowitchs famous dictum that the occupation will turn Israel into a Shin Bet state. And over the weekend we learned Diskin went through another metamorphosis: he recommended to the Turkel Committee that the Shin Bet start video-taping its interrogations, which the service has long resisted.
Diskin is merely the latest in a series of senior security officials who, as soon as they leave office, see the light and understand just how ruinous the office they headed was, and how they represented positions that were damaging to the country. The last great show in this genre was the bunch of senior commanders of the IDFs Northern Command, who upon retirement were astonished to find out that the Security Zone in Lebanon was a huge mistake often, after defending it in uniform as vital to security just a few weeks prior.
In that regard, the most interesting speaker is certainly Avraham Shalom, the oldest interviewee. Shalom thinks strategic errors were made, particularly by the politicians, but he himself regrets nothing. When asked about moral problems, he laughs. Morality? He asks, Morality? Look for it first among the terrorists. One assumes former chiefs, assuming they would even bother to be interviewed, would supply similar remarks. Its very hard to see Issar Harel, for instance, the closest thing weve got to J. Edgar Hoover, providing the camera with anything aside from a mocking, world-weary grin, saying in effect youll never understand, so dont even try.
MORE...
http://972mag.com/suppressing-injustices-hold-onto-that/65949/