Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

exboyfil

(17,865 posts)
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 08:18 PM Dec 2020

Had to talk my son in law down regarding aliens

He asked me about the recent report by the former head of the Israeli Space program of the existence of aliens and our cooperation with them.

I gave him the Carl Sagan quote of extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

Not sure it did any good.




https://www.jpost.com/omg/former-israeli-space-security-chief-says-aliens-exist-humanity-not-ready-651405

33 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Had to talk my son in law down regarding aliens (Original Post) exboyfil Dec 2020 OP
My teenage son has been talking about this too. MontanaMama Dec 2020 #1
Why would the existence of aliens disturb him? Renew Deal Dec 2020 #2
Not disturb him but accepting the claims of an individual exboyfil Dec 2020 #3
That of course, means you are an atheist right? Ferrets are Cool Dec 2020 #4
I am a Christian because of my family exboyfil Dec 2020 #7
And all I have to say about that is Ferrets are Cool Jan 2021 #29
Your advice about extraordinary evidence is good. Renew Deal Dec 2020 #15
Ask US Air Force pilots off the record the stuff they have seen. nt Irish_Dem Dec 2020 #5
That is the key - Off the record exboyfil Dec 2020 #9
Some of the retired guys have gone on record. Irish_Dem Dec 2020 #10
I'd be interested in checking out this YouTuber. Chiyo-chichi Jan 2021 #31
See the link exboyfil Jan 2021 #32
Interesting. Thanks! Chiyo-chichi Jan 2021 #33
If Trump is going to babble endlessly, why can't he blab something interesting? nt Irish_Dem Dec 2020 #6
That might be one of the biggest indications of no broader conspiracy exboyfil Dec 2020 #11
If there were aliens, I would think CIA/Pentagon would keep it away from Trump? nt Irish_Dem Dec 2020 #13
Are you suggesting that aliens are real and... ret5hd Dec 2020 #12
Even aliens know GIGO. (garbage in, garbage out). Irish_Dem Dec 2020 #20
Although I agree with Carl Sagan... AmyStrange Dec 2020 #8
Terrestrial UFO Theory StClone Dec 2020 #24
I have also read "Passport to Magonia"... AmyStrange Dec 2020 #26
I really don't want to be correct. StClone Dec 2020 #28
That might not work, because... AmyStrange Dec 2020 #14
Good analysis SCantiGOP Dec 2020 #21
That's also true... AmyStrange Dec 2020 #23
Unless Einstein is completely wrong SCantiGOP Dec 2020 #16
I agree that Faster Than Light is most likely impossible exboyfil Dec 2020 #18
I don't disagree SCantiGOP Dec 2020 #22
Still trying to determine... mbusby Dec 2020 #17
Why not? AmyStrange Dec 2020 #19
Because it's fun!!! ret5hd Dec 2020 #25
Heh heh heh... AmyStrange Dec 2020 #27
the ALIENS need to help us get rid of COVID 19 trueblue2007 Jan 2021 #30

Renew Deal

(81,877 posts)
2. Why would the existence of aliens disturb him?
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 08:19 PM
Dec 2020

Aliens are likely. I can only see someone being shaken by that if it would rattle their belief in religion. Otherwise, it is plainly logical that aliens exist.

exboyfil

(17,865 posts)
3. Not disturb him but accepting the claims of an individual
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 08:24 PM
Dec 2020

based upon his prior position versus real, hard evidence.

Even if Neil deGrasse Tyson or Francis Collins for example claimed there were aliens, I would demand to see the evidence. I don't want him to be fooled by any charlatan coming along.

exboyfil

(17,865 posts)
7. I am a Christian because of my family
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 08:41 PM
Dec 2020

Faith and science are two non-overlapping and different magisteria as Stephen Jay Gould stated.

I study the Christian Bible and participate in Bible studies. I attempt to live out the spirit of what Jesus taught us as recorded in the scriptures.

That is about all I have to say about that.

Ferrets are Cool

(21,110 posts)
29. And all I have to say about that is
Fri Jan 1, 2021, 09:43 AM
Jan 2021

since NEITHER aliens or god is provable, one should have the same measure of skepticism. Have a great 2021.

exboyfil

(17,865 posts)
9. That is the key - Off the record
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 08:44 PM
Dec 2020

Those videos that have recently surfaced are far from convincing. In fact there is a Youtuber out there who understands the instrumentation and duplicated some of the effects with standard military cameras.

I would love to be proved wrong though.

Irish_Dem

(47,456 posts)
10. Some of the retired guys have gone on record.
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 08:47 PM
Dec 2020

Retired military are the ones who speak out for active duty.

I grew up with pilots and other flight crew members.
They talk a lot when they have a few beers in them.

Chiyo-chichi

(3,586 posts)
31. I'd be interested in checking out this YouTuber.
Tue Jan 5, 2021, 09:49 PM
Jan 2021

Do you have a channel name or a link?
I searched but had no luck finding it.

Chiyo-chichi

(3,586 posts)
33. Interesting. Thanks!
Tue Jan 5, 2021, 10:16 PM
Jan 2021

I subscribed to Mick West's channel. It looks like he has lots of videos that go into even greater detail on these.

exboyfil

(17,865 posts)
11. That might be one of the biggest indications of no broader conspiracy
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 08:50 PM
Dec 2020

because there is no way he would keep his mouth shut (unless he could make money from his silence).

Of course it can be like the President in Independence Day, only given the information when the aliens are on the front door and knocking.

ret5hd

(20,524 posts)
12. Are you suggesting that aliens are real and...
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 08:52 PM
Dec 2020

have super advanced technology similar to (but more advanced than) our own "auto-tune", but instead of making a singers voice in tune with a song, it would make a speakers (such as trumps) incoherent ramblings into something coherent and interesting???

I submit, kind Irish_Dem, that such a technology could NEVER exist! The computing power needed, even utilizing advanced quantum computers only speculated about in the most obscure sci-fi writings, would outstrip the available power in the entire universe!

And besides, the aliens are far more interested in the development of even more advanced anal probes. Everyone knows that. Pffft!

Irish_Dem

(47,456 posts)
20. Even aliens know GIGO. (garbage in, garbage out).
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 09:30 PM
Dec 2020

Right, any attempt to make Trump make sense would meet with failure.

 

AmyStrange

(7,989 posts)
8. Although I agree with Carl Sagan...
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 08:42 PM
Dec 2020

-

I've been researching and investigating UFOs for a long time (40+ years) and the probabilities are really, really low that they are from other planets, but then again, science doesn't know everything.

If it did, all scientist would be out of work.

That said, it's interesting how UFOs seemed to grow in sophistication, almost mirroring our progress in air travel. From the airships of the 1890s, flying saucers of the 1950s, all the way up to the triangle ships of today.

It kind of gives credibility to the belief that most (if not all) of these sightings are not ET, but the result of foreign and domestic defense programs, or even private individuals. Look at the Wright Brothers.
=========

StClone

(11,688 posts)
24. Terrestrial UFO Theory
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 10:02 PM
Dec 2020

And the most ardent and likely earliest proponent of the"Terrestrial Alien Theory" is the very smart and accomplished Jacques Vallée. His classic work "Passport to Magonia" is a must read and re-read introducing the fascinating connection of Folklore and modern Ufology. YouTube has recent talks he has given. Now in his 80's, he provides an astounding breath of knowledge on many topics with Ufology at its core. His genius is to follow tales of UFO reports track them down and spend all the time needed, even in the remotest parts of the world, to investigate. But his main goal is to interview the witnesses in visceral depth and detail. I admit to being a big devotee of Vallée.

But I have my own pet Theory on the side. The Universe is about 14 Billion years old. Investigations of evolution of The Universe indicate life could have evolved somewhere there in the first 5 billion years. Given that huge 10 billion year head start (life on Earth is 4 billion years old), it is my belief The Universe not only contains life, it is teeming with it. There are multitudes of highly, to super-highly, advanced cultures. WE are visited by many races, cultures, tribes whatever you want to call them.

There may likely be some sort of agreement among these entities on how to handle contact (with lower tribes, us). That would explain the incredible varieties of entities and vehicles seen. Since each group may have its own motivation for interaction with us there could be some animosity or conflict between these groups which could explain some oddities. Physicists today have some pretty deep discussions about this stuff (especially time travel) and can see some support in their research.

You stated: T

hat said, it's interesting how UFOs seemed to grow in sophistication, almost mirroring our progress in air travel. From the airships of the 1890s, flying saucers of the 1950s, all the way up to the triangle ships of today.
The flip side of this is the vintage observer was describing an aerial anomaly with the language of the day.
 

AmyStrange

(7,989 posts)
26. I have also read "Passport to Magonia"...
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 10:14 PM
Dec 2020

-

and his investigations ARE incredibly detailed.

The flip side, language of the day, is also very true.

Your personal theory may prove to be correct, but because current science can't do the same thing (travel long distances through space in a practical amount of time), folks will say it's impossible.

Unfortunately, those folks keep forgetting that science doesn't know everything.

After all is said and done, I secretly hope you're right.
==============

StClone

(11,688 posts)
28. I really don't want to be correct.
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 10:33 PM
Dec 2020

I liked the old notion of us alone in a vast wonderful Universe. Contrary to beliefs of every age, we are not the Center of anything and often on the edge of everything.

 

AmyStrange

(7,989 posts)
14. That might not work, because...
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 09:04 PM
Dec 2020

-

it didn't work for me.

The beginning of the end for me was when I found out that the government had lied about marijuana, and that made me doubt anything they or anyone in authority said from that day forward.

Carl Sagan is right, but the problem is that I've been researching and investigating UFOs for a long time (40+ years) and the probabilities ARE really, really low that they are from other planets, but then again, science doesn't know everything.

If it did, all scientist would be out of work.

If your son-in-law is interested enough, he will also do his own research and find that there are some things that can't be easily explained. I wonder what his reaction will be to what you said then.

That said, it's interesting how UFOs seemed to grow in sophistication, almost mirroring our progress in air travel. From the airships of the 1890s, flying saucers of the 1950s, all the way up to the triangle ships of today.

It kind of gives credibility to the belief that most of these sightings are not ET, but the result of foreign and domestic defense programs, or even private individuals. Look at the Wright Brothers.
==============

SCantiGOP

(13,874 posts)
21. Good analysis
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 09:31 PM
Dec 2020

Your concept of how the sophistication of UFOs paralleled our increasing technology also applies to science fiction.
Frankenstein’s monster was brought to life in the 19th century by a new, mysterious force that people didn’t understand called “electricity.”
A hundred years later, even low budget movies had to use radiation as the cause of unexplained phenomena.
Now, it is black holes and other aspects of deep space that are used to allow writers and thinkers to transcend the known world.

 

AmyStrange

(7,989 posts)
23. That's also true...
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 09:42 PM
Dec 2020

-

sci fi and horror have been in step with our scientific discoveries, but you have to agree that sometimes sci-fi drives science, instead of the other way around.

Look how the sci-fi of Star Trek has guided where some of our research is headed.

The transporter, for example.
============

SCantiGOP

(13,874 posts)
16. Unless Einstein is completely wrong
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 09:09 PM
Dec 2020

(and more of his theories are proven by experimental results as the years go by),
Then faster than light travel is impossible no matter how advanced a society is.
This means that we may be able to exchange messages with lag times of decades or centuries, but traveling to visit will be impossible.

exboyfil

(17,865 posts)
18. I agree that Faster Than Light is most likely impossible
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 09:16 PM
Dec 2020

Still with sublight you could colonize the galaxy in under 100 million years which is a blink of an eye in even terrestrial geological time.

Of course by the time you are done there will be aliens if there wasn't before because humanity as a species will have split.

SCantiGOP

(13,874 posts)
22. I don't disagree
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 09:33 PM
Dec 2020

But while “humans” might be able to reach other stars, it would take many generations, so no one “human” would be able to accomplish that.

mbusby

(823 posts)
17. Still trying to determine...
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 09:11 PM
Dec 2020

...why aliens travel multiple light years to shove probes up our... just don't get it.

 

AmyStrange

(7,989 posts)
19. Why not?
Thu Dec 31, 2020, 09:20 PM
Dec 2020

-

We do stuff like that to the lower species all the time.

Although, I do wonder about the anal probing part.
===========

Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»Creative Speculation»Had to talk my son in law...