Religion
Related: About this forumAn Atheist’s Case for Talmud
Sating a New Hunger With an Ancient Book
Not Her Fathers Talmud: Leah Vincent is collaborating with two artists to create illustrated Talmud stories for children. (Courtesy of Leah Vincent)
By Leah Vincent
Published July 02, 2014, issue of July 04, 2014.
When I recently wrote my memoir of leaving ultra-Orthodoxy, I spent days ravaged by sobbing fits, debilitating chest pain, and migraines as I reencountered the trauma my 17-year-old self had experienced after I was pushed out of my yeshivish family for my rebellion.
Shaken, I was fearful that when I went even further back to confront my fervent 11-year-old yeshivish self, the experience would be far worse. For years, I had struggled to keep that powerful incarnation of myself at bay, afraid of her rage, afraid that she would demand, with all the fury of an abandoned child, that I return to yeshivish life.
To my surprise, when I finally immersed myself in recording the memories of that girl, there was none of that. Instead, the sweet love that girl had channeled toward her faith flowed, without judgment, into my battered heart. This gentle reconnection with the neglected religious piece of myself inspired me to try and reclaim the Judaism that had once defined me in a way that could please both my childish devotion and my adult atheistic and progressive values. The solution was clear: I would become a cultural Jew. The problem was, I wasnt quite sure what that meant.
Every phenomenon is defined by what it is not, the contours of its negative space, and by what it is, the texture of its positive space. As Jews, we are not the gentile majority, a distinction that has had catastrophic consequences. I quickly embraced the way progressive Judaism taught me to approach this aspect of my Jewish identity: commemorating the Holocaust, empathizing with the suffering of other peoples, and championing a country that might help us stave off future tragedy (in stark contrast, within ultra-Orthodoxy this negative space seemed to have been poorly processed, paralyzing aspects of that community).
http://forward.com/articles/200784/an-atheist-s-case-for-talmud/?p=all#ixzz36MwZONou
http://knopfdoubleday.com/book/231660/cut-me-loose/
genwah
(574 posts)running after the election, I might have something to chip in.
MannyGoldstein
(34,589 posts)The Talmud is so quintessentially Jewish. A big discussion, it shows us clearly that nobody has a monopoly on the truth.
AtheistCrusader
(33,982 posts)From an idea. Wow, that is depressing.
Isn't there enough suffering in the world without inflicting that shit on our children?
rug
(82,333 posts)She's regaining that.
AtheistCrusader
(33,982 posts)That is truly vile.
rug
(82,333 posts)AtheistCrusader
(33,982 posts)rug
(82,333 posts)AtheistCrusader
(33,982 posts)In other cases, that might be a valid objection. Not this one.
rug
(82,333 posts)AtheistCrusader
(33,982 posts)Those are the four pillars of her community, in her own words.
They are inseparable, in this case.