Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

rug

(82,333 posts)
Sat Nov 22, 2014, 12:37 AM Nov 2014

Instead of hating on social justice, atheists should tackle STEM segregation

Chris Stedman | Nov 21, 2014

Today’s guest column is written by Sikivu Hutchinson, founder of the Women’s Leadership Project and author of Moral Combat: Black Atheists, Gender Politics, and the Values Wars.

One of the most evocative images from the protests in Ferguson, Missouri this summer was that of demonstrator Angela Jaboor wielding an “I Am a Woman” sign.

Jaboor’s sign was modeled after the historic “I Am a Man” signs displayed by male civil rights activists in the 1960s. By centering black women’s agency, she challenged traditional narratives associating liberation with heroic masculinity.

Paying tribute to the invisible black women who’ve been victimized by state violence, feminists of color continue to push back against civil rights movement orthodoxies that privilege the plight of young men of color while ignoring the impact race, gender, sexuality and class-based oppression has on cis, straight, lesbian, bi and trans women of color. To paraphrase African Americans for Humanism director Debbie Goddard, “intersectionality is our lives.”

As a racially polarized nation awaits the grand jury decision on the officer who killed unarmed teen Michael Brown, some atheists and Humanists are still hating on “mission creep,” intersectionality, and the “corruption” of white bread secularism by so-called “social justice warriors” who apparently just don’t get why the U.S. is the world’s greatest beacon of freedom and justice.

http://chrisstedman.religionnews.com/2014/11/21/atheists-social-justice-stem/#sthash.iMaG1lpr.dpuf

57 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Instead of hating on social justice, atheists should tackle STEM segregation (Original Post) rug Nov 2014 OP
Not all atheists are STEM workers Fumesucker Nov 2014 #1
Racist atheists are ... guess what? immoderate Nov 2014 #2
Yes, I've noticed. (nt) stone space Nov 2014 #50
I think this is a valuable cause for anyone. MADem Nov 2014 #3
"The pursuit of a STEM major in college requires extensive preparation in high school ..." Jim__ Nov 2014 #4
I agree. The class paths start very early in life. rug Nov 2014 #5
So the debasement of science education edhopper Nov 2014 #6
Oh I'm pretty sure Sikivu Hutchinson knows the difference between atheism and humanism. rug Nov 2014 #7
Then why did she edhopper Nov 2014 #8
She did not. rug Nov 2014 #9
So you don't think humanist groups edhopper Nov 2014 #10
Not necessarily. rug Nov 2014 #11
You haven't looked very hard edhopper Nov 2014 #12
If they're as active as you suggest, it shouldn't be necessary. rug Nov 2014 #13
You could start with edhopper Nov 2014 #14
I could. You could also post a link. rug Nov 2014 #15
Or you could edhopper Nov 2014 #16
I could but it's your point. rug Nov 2014 #17
Am I mistaken about your opinion of Humanist groups edhopper Nov 2014 #18
Yes, you are. In principle I like humanism. rug Nov 2014 #19
Yes there are, edhopper Nov 2014 #20
Some more than others. rug Nov 2014 #21
Yes edhopper Nov 2014 #22
She's pretty heavily involved and I beieve she's addressing her felolow activists. rug Nov 2014 #23
I agree edhopper Nov 2014 #24
So you like Secular humanism better when it includes religious privilege as well? Lordquinton Nov 2014 #42
That would be an oxymoron wrapeed in an assumption. rug Nov 2014 #47
Atheism doesn't hate on social justice... MellowDem Nov 2014 #25
Are you saying atheists should not criticize other atheists? rug Nov 2014 #27
aol.com? Eeek n/t Goblinmonger Nov 2014 #29
I knew someone here would complain about that. rug Nov 2014 #30
Well it's just embarrassing. Goblinmonger Nov 2014 #31
And an iphone3. rug Nov 2014 #34
So your sense of humor dial is set at zero? Goblinmonger Nov 2014 #35
It's much higher than your sense of inequality. rug Nov 2014 #36
I have no idea what that means. Goblinmonger Nov 2014 #44
If you read her article instead of snarking over her AOL email, you might. rug Nov 2014 #45
Now you are just typing buzzwords. Goblinmonger Nov 2014 #48
And you are precisely demonstrating that they're not. rug Nov 2014 #49
She's not "Internet savvy," rug. okasha Nov 2014 #53
This is just a non sequitur. rogerashton Nov 2014 #26
. . . . who? rug Nov 2014 #28
Why atheists in particular? LeftishBrit Nov 2014 #32
She's addressing fellow atheists. rug Nov 2014 #33
No this is about humanist edhopper Nov 2014 #37
Wut? rug Nov 2014 #38
Damn auto correct tablet edhopper Nov 2014 #39
Do you know any atheists that are not nonbelievers? rug Nov 2014 #40
Nevermind edhopper Nov 2014 #41
"He." okasha Nov 2014 #51
read my next reply edhopper Nov 2014 #52
I think it's a pivotal issue okasha Nov 2014 #54
True edhopper Nov 2014 #55
I didn't say that humanist groups in particular okasha Nov 2014 #56
And my question stands edhopper Nov 2014 #57
Why don't you dig up some stories about Catholics telling other Catholics what to do? Lordquinton Nov 2014 #43
Read the Catholic Group. rug Nov 2014 #46

MADem

(135,425 posts)
3. I think this is a valuable cause for anyone.
Sat Nov 22, 2014, 01:58 AM
Nov 2014

The segregation isn't just racial, either--it's gender based.

Jim__

(14,078 posts)
4. "The pursuit of a STEM major in college requires extensive preparation in high school ..."
Sat Nov 22, 2014, 05:51 AM
Nov 2014

It really doesn't sound like an easy issue to even get your arms around, never mind tackle. From the article:

In low income communities of color, high incarceration rates mean fewer job opportunities, less access to college and housing and the potential for lifelong economic instability. The pursuit of a STEM major in college requires extensive preparation in high school, but college preparation classes are in short supply in many high poverty schools. As a result of this disparity, the U.S. Department of Education found that the majority of African American students who pursue college STEM majors either wind up dropping out of school or switching to non-STEM majors.


I'm not sure this should be labelled as STEM segregation. Resolving the issue of lack of opportunity, and especially educational opportunity, addresses many of the issues of poverty and segregation in this country.

edhopper

(33,595 posts)
6. So the debasement of science education
Sat Nov 22, 2014, 12:00 PM
Nov 2014

is fetishizing? The separation of Church and State aren't important issues?
I actually get Congressional alerts from a Humanism organization about many social justice issues. Including Gay marriage and voting rights.
The writer also makes the big mistake of equating atheism with humanism.
The truth is, any organization has to make decisions on which problems to tackle, given limited resources. There is usually an ongoing internal debate about such things. And going outside the mandate is always at issue.
So this condescending, error ridden article, is just an insult.

 

rug

(82,333 posts)
7. Oh I'm pretty sure Sikivu Hutchinson knows the difference between atheism and humanism.
Sat Nov 22, 2014, 12:02 PM
Nov 2014

As well as the many extant types of privilege.

edhopper

(33,595 posts)
10. So you don't think humanist groups
Sun Nov 23, 2014, 02:48 PM
Nov 2014

Are concerned with science in the classroom and it's impact on future STEM majors.

Because I see so many churches involved in this issue.

edhopper

(33,595 posts)
14. You could start with
Sun Nov 23, 2014, 03:19 PM
Nov 2014

Amicus briefs for the various creationism court cases, including a pivitol one in Dover.
Or the work against changes in text books.
But the media ignoring humanist groups? Are you surprised when it's not the atheist"church" meeting in bars?

edhopper

(33,595 posts)
16. Or you could
Sun Nov 23, 2014, 03:27 PM
Nov 2014

Google it.
But posting this shows your opinion of Humanist groups, so not worth my time to do your research.

 

rug

(82,333 posts)
17. I could but it's your point.
Sun Nov 23, 2014, 03:32 PM
Nov 2014

I suppose making a personal insult is easier than a three minute google.

edhopper

(33,595 posts)
18. Am I mistaken about your opinion of Humanist groups
Sun Nov 23, 2014, 03:38 PM
Nov 2014

I thought you considered them a bastion of white priveldge?
You also seem to agree with this article's condemnation of these groups.
You think my saying so is insulting?

There is also the problem that I am on a tablet, and linking is very difficult.

You might start here;

https://www.secularhumanism.org/index.php


 

rug

(82,333 posts)
19. Yes, you are. In principle I like humanism.
Sun Nov 23, 2014, 05:13 PM
Nov 2014

In practice I like it despite the class and race privilege it often enjoys.

There's a reason the CSH uses the adjective "secular"; there's also religious humanism.

http://huumanists.org/about/religious-humanism

There are even notable Christian humanists.

http://huumanists.org/about/religious-humanism

edhopper

(33,595 posts)
20. Yes there are,
Sun Nov 23, 2014, 05:22 PM
Nov 2014

no one said different.

You should then know that these org.s are involved with social justice.
And just because they are not active enough in this one cause (which I have shown they are active in) can be leveled at any organization that picks one issue over another.

Why isn't the WWF addressing intercity poverty?

Looks like the article author just wants another way top bash atheists, even though this has nothing to do with them.

 

rug

(82,333 posts)
21. Some more than others.
Sun Nov 23, 2014, 05:28 PM
Nov 2014

Her point, though, is that there are long-standing barriers in the science, technology, engineering, and mathematics fields, which particularly impacts women and people of color.

edhopper

(33,595 posts)
22. Yes
Sun Nov 23, 2014, 05:32 PM
Nov 2014

and why are humanists groups in particular singled out with not doing enough?

What are all the Catholic and Christian schools doing? What is the NEA or the AAAS doing?
Obviously not enough.

 

rug

(82,333 posts)
23. She's pretty heavily involved and I beieve she's addressing her felolow activists.
Sun Nov 23, 2014, 07:35 PM
Nov 2014

When that happens, it's worth listening to. More Catholics and other members of religion should do the same.

edhopper

(33,595 posts)
24. I agree
Sun Nov 23, 2014, 07:53 PM
Nov 2014

It is an important issue for everyone. Seems like the writer just has an ax to grind. Why even mention atheists?

MellowDem

(5,018 posts)
25. Atheism doesn't hate on social justice...
Mon Nov 24, 2014, 03:58 PM
Nov 2014

And it's stupid and offensive to tell atheists what pet issue they should or shouldn't address, it betrays an ignorance of what atheism even is and is non-sensic and arrogant.

I wish all atheists also were progressive secular humanists active in the issues I care about, who wouldn't care?

Now, here's a suggestion that makes sense, "Catholics should work on making their dogma less misogynistic"

 

rug

(82,333 posts)
27. Are you saying atheists should not criticize other atheists?
Mon Nov 24, 2014, 05:25 PM
Nov 2014

Because that's what she is and that's what the article is about.

Maybe you should send her an email and tell her to sit down and STFU.

Here it is: shutch2396@aol.com

http://womenleadershipproject.blogspot.com/

 

Goblinmonger

(22,340 posts)
44. I have no idea what that means.
Tue Nov 25, 2014, 09:48 AM
Nov 2014

Unless it is some Ferguson reference in which case get over yourself.

 

rug

(82,333 posts)
45. If you read her article instead of snarking over her AOL email, you might.
Tue Nov 25, 2014, 09:39 PM
Nov 2014

Note, I typed might.

Get over your privilege.

 

Goblinmonger

(22,340 posts)
48. Now you are just typing buzzwords.
Wed Nov 26, 2014, 08:23 AM
Nov 2014

I can't see my privilege because I think AOL sucks for email and Explorer for a browser? Gmail and Chrome are free and far superior products. I use Android phones because of their open system and lack of elite control like Apple.

But, sure, it's my privilege concerning free tech apps that's causing me to make the offhand remark about using an AOL email.

 

rug

(82,333 posts)
49. And you are precisely demonstrating that they're not.
Wed Nov 26, 2014, 09:14 AM
Nov 2014

Completely ignoring what this woman is saying about minorities and STEM, you're going on about browsers and apps. Your reaction is a smug comment about outdated technology rather than the human beings who are systemically excluded from the field.

Nope, not a whiff of privilege here. Even though it manifests itself most commonly in offhand, unthinking remarks.

So, how do you like the latest WoW? Awesome!

okasha

(11,573 posts)
53. She's not "Internet savvy," rug.
Wed Nov 26, 2014, 08:02 PM
Nov 2014

That practically makes her a Stone Age living fossil. (Or maybe a goatherder.)

rogerashton

(3,920 posts)
26. This is just a non sequitur.
Mon Nov 24, 2014, 04:51 PM
Nov 2014

And there is no evidence that atheists, even conservative ones, are "hating on" anything. If anyone is "hating on," ...

LeftishBrit

(41,208 posts)
32. Why atheists in particular?
Mon Nov 24, 2014, 06:10 PM
Nov 2014

I agree it's an important issue; but seems to me to be an educational issue, not an atheist one.

edhopper

(33,595 posts)
39. Damn auto correct tablet
Mon Nov 24, 2014, 11:36 PM
Nov 2014

Fixed now.

You know humanists and atheist aren't the same. So should the author, but he has an agenda to bash atheist.

 

rug

(82,333 posts)
40. Do you know any atheists that are not nonbelievers?
Mon Nov 24, 2014, 11:40 PM
Nov 2014
Expecting nonbelievers of color to hew to a limited secular agenda that fetishizes creationism and the separation of church and state, they seem to ask, “Why aren’t you people who come from woefully religious ghettos content with our table scraps?”

Some may be humanists as well but she is talking to nonbelievers.

edhopper

(33,595 posts)
41. Nevermind
Mon Nov 24, 2014, 11:53 PM
Nov 2014

Thought that was him. It's her.
Not sure if this is a problem that atheists need to address, other than calling for better science education for all.

Why doesn't PETA deal with this, what about the ACLU? Why is prejudice in STEM education an atheist issue.
Not that atheist can't also work for social justice, as the do.

Didn't we hash this out already?

edhopper

(33,595 posts)
52. read my next reply
Wed Nov 26, 2014, 04:42 PM
Nov 2014

Do you agree that inequality in lower economic school districts is a pivotal issue for atheists?

Do you think it is more so than for other groups?

okasha

(11,573 posts)
54. I think it's a pivotal issue
Wed Nov 26, 2014, 08:14 PM
Nov 2014

for society as a whole. Liberals, such as Ms. Hutchinson, need to raise the issue with any group where they have a respected voice and consequent leverage.

edhopper

(33,595 posts)
55. True
Wed Nov 26, 2014, 08:33 PM
Nov 2014

but, why single out atheist for this?
And by the way, strong and true science education is very much an issue for atheist and humanist groups.
The teaching of scientific method is as well. As is combating the religious forces that want to water down science or teach things that are wrong (creationism, GCC denial).
Why do you think humanist groups in particular are not doing enough, rather than all of us a s society.

okasha

(11,573 posts)
56. I didn't say that humanist groups in particular
Wed Nov 26, 2014, 08:44 PM
Nov 2014

aren't doing enough. That's Ms. Hutchinson's contention, and she's a humanist speaking to other humanists about issues she considers vital to the future of low-income youth. It's her own area of experience and expertise.

edhopper

(33,595 posts)
57. And my question stands
Wed Nov 26, 2014, 10:09 PM
Nov 2014

In the context of this article.
Why else would be talking about it in this forum?

Do you think I said this issue overall is not important?

Lordquinton

(7,886 posts)
43. Why don't you dig up some stories about Catholics telling other Catholics what to do?
Tue Nov 25, 2014, 12:46 AM
Nov 2014

instead of scouring every day for articles about atheists and pretending that you posting them has absolutely nothing to do with the article?

Latest Discussions»Issue Forums»Religion»Instead of hating on soci...