Religion
Related: About this forumA Muslims Advice To American Christians
From the article:
The book doubtlessly will stick in the craws of Americans who persist in believing, contrary to both evidence and common sense, that Islam is a monolithic cult of hatred and violence. It will also infuriate ISIS thugs besotted by their violence-soaked vision of a resurrected caliphate.
To read more;The opening week of 2017 saw the publication of a remarkable book, Letters to a Young Muslim, written by Omar Saif Ghobash, the United Arab Emirates ambassador to Russia. Letters is a series of reflections about Islam explicitly addressed to the authors teenage son but also, implicitly, to the entire Muslim Ummah, or worldwide community.
The book doubtlessly will stick in the craws of Americans who persist in believing, contrary to both evidence and common sense, that Islam is a monolithic cult of hatred and violence. It will also infuriate ISIS thugs besotted by their violence-soaked vision of a resurrected caliphate:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/a-muslims-advice-to-american-christians_us_5874dab1e4b0eb9e49bfbf47?section=us_religion
And this excerpt is also interesting:
trotsky
(49,533 posts)The key word here is 'distortions." Like so many other moderate believers, the author simply puts on blinders and REFUSES to see how his own religion, his own holy book, actually DOES contain elements that support these "distorted" interpretations. He just ignores or dismisses them.
In other words, he becomes just like the Islamists he condemns, insisting that HE has the only true interpretation of his religion, and they are wrong.
Figures.
guillaumeb
(42,641 posts)A universal tendency.
And unlike the violent ones, the author does not engage in violent conversion.
trotsky
(49,533 posts)But I understand why.
Act_of_Reparation
(9,116 posts)Which, if not a universal tendency, is pretty widespread around these parts.
Local mythology has it people are just assholes, and they do bad things because assholes do bad things. And then, for reasons not fully explained, these assholes are deeply concerned about how people perceive them, and vigorously obscure their inherent assholishness behind fake religious motivations.
The trouble is we don't apply this principal to anything but cases of religious violence. If a racist says he killed fourteen black people because he hates black people, no one questions whether he's using racism to a hook from which he hangs his inherent violent tendencies. When some right wing fanatic detonates a bomb in a government building, no one questions whether he's using his libertarianism or his collection of cocked up conspiracy theories as excuses to kill people. Hell, we don't even question it whenever some self-absorbed fuckrag says he shot a commuter to death over a minor traffic offense.
But whenever someone says they kill, injure, or otherwise harm their fellow beings because their religion commands it, they're fucking liars. Because reasons.
Give it a rest, already. This bullshit argument is so full of holes it isn't even worth defending.
guillaumeb
(42,641 posts)But since the vast majority of people do not commit violence, it is far too simplistic to blame the claimed source rather than the person actually committing the violence.
Act_of_Reparation
(9,116 posts)Igel
(35,317 posts)Is it a variety of Christianity that isn't Christian?
Define "Christian"? Huguenots and others were killed because one Xian sect rejected the other's self-definition. Now many such groups are "mainstream" and are doing the same.
Meanwhile, the entire "we don't allow bid'ah" and "we don't allow fitna" tends to be deep-rooted in many--not a hundred, not a thousand, not just a hundred thousand or even a mere million--Muslims' minds.
In fact, the entire advocacy movement for Muslims for a decade tended to assert that there was one Islam. Instead of decrying the false Islam of the 9/11 hijackers, many Muslim "authorities" did everything possible to discount that they could even be Muslim. There are 4 pillars of Islam; anyone who says the shehada is Muslim; etc. You don't hear this talk these days because it simply didn't work. Now, did those now insisting that there's a variety of Islams suddenly change their minds and admit they were pathetically wrong, or is it just another attempt to say, "Hey, don't judge me, bro."
This is a deep-rooted problem in most communities. It keeps them from facing internal problems and maximizes the number of people on one's own side.
trotsky
(49,533 posts)Let's say I'm a Christian. A "distortion" of Christianity is anything that I don't believe. Ta da! Works for liberals, conservatives, and everyone in between.