Religion
Related: About this forumJewish atheism and Jewish theism in America
April 12, 2013 | 9:46 am
Posted by Roger Price
American Judaism has a God problem. Actually, and paradoxically, it seems to have two God problems. One is Jewish atheism. The other is Jewish theism. Here we will look at the data and the dilemma.
At the outset, we have to recognize that there is something odd about the concept of Jewish atheism. Is there really such a thing? Can there be a Judaism without God, however you want to define it. What are the People of the Book without the Hero of the story? How can there be commandments without a Commander? Doesnt a Covenant with God require a Party of the First Part as well as a party of the second part? What do you do with prayer? Can there even be a place for atheism within Judaism?
The questions recall the story about President Harry Truman being asked whether he believed in baptism. Believe in it? the crusty president responded, Hell, Ive seen it done!
And so it is with atheism and Judaism. Most of us have seen it done. We have seen Jews who are atheists, that is, Jews who do not believe in any god, much less God, but who do social work and philanthropy in and through Jewish federations and community organizations. We have seen them performing what we and they can fairly call mitzvot in the real world. And we have even seen them participating in synagogue life.
http://www.jewishjournal.com/judaismandscience/item/jewish_atheism_and_jewish_theism_in_america
backscatter712
(26,355 posts)Two different things. Thus, you can have Jewish atheists, or even Jewish Christians (what, you've never met Jews for Jesus?)
Phillip McCleod
(1,837 posts)seems like less of a big deal. i can't imagine going to my childhood church, now.. not even to talk to old friends. maybe especially not to talk to old friends.