Jewish Group
Related: About this forumAnyone else creeped out by Orange Hitler declaring Judaism a nationality?
I find it eerily similar to the Nuremberg Laws.
CincyDem
(6,378 posts)It feels like being excluded from the freedom of religion protections. It also feels like the first step in "registration".
I don't understand all the organizations who are talking about this as such a wonderful thing.
IMHO, most jewish organizations are seriously concerned about the "under 30" generations and their weakening relationship with Israel. Again, IMHO, there is a perception that relationship is being driven by the BDS campus movement and this is being pitched as a way to curtail that. There's no consideration of the possibility that the weakening relationship is due, in part (possibly large part) by the way Israel's right wing government is being perceived among younger US Jews.
I don't like this one bit.
elleng
(131,052 posts)kimbutgar
(21,174 posts)And mf45s nazi base to get a list.
Behind the Aegis
(53,973 posts)I suggest this: Trumps executive order protecting Jewish students (and the controversy), explained.
I see this two-fold; it is an attempt to curb BDS (which, personally, I hate, but should be protected speech...up to a point), and this is basically a slap against Obama, again, by indicating his policy "wasn't enough."
ETA: The actual Executive Order
ETA: The 2010 Department of Education Declaration
This is, IMO, a way to attack university funding if said university does not "fall into line".
OilemFirchen
(7,143 posts)but that would protect Muslims, Hindus, Buddhists, et al. Probably would have led to adding gender / sexual orientation as well.
Their actual intent is clear, despite the bullshit justification.
Behind the Aegis
(53,973 posts)I honestly didn't know religion wasn't protected by that law. I am not surprised that sexual orientation isn't covered. However, I think too many are making a mountain out of a molehill.
Gothmog
(145,479 posts)This is a very dumb idea. As a MOT, I am very disturbed by this plan
stopdiggin
(11,336 posts)And .. it's still a sh*tty idea, and confusing mess. The administration is going to try to establish "discrimination" against Jewish students (under Title VI) by institutions that entertain or enact any form of BDS actions. This would seem to be a stretch as far as the real world and real discrimination goes .. but welcome to civil rights enforcement under your current administration.