Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

byronius

(7,395 posts)
Thu May 12, 2016, 04:16 PM May 2016

Skeleton Lake Explained.

Slate



In 1942 a British forest guard in Roopkund, India, made an alarming discovery. More than three miles above sea level, he stumbled across a frozen lake surrounded by hundreds of human skeletons. That summer, the melting ice revealed even more remains, floating in the water and lying haphazardly around the lake's edges.

Since this was the height of World War II, there were fears that the skeletons might belong to Japanese soldiers who had died of exposure while sneaking through India. The British government, terrified of a Japanese land invasion, sent a team of investigators to determine whether this was true. Upon examination they realized these bones weren't Japanese soldiers at all, but of a much much older vintage. But what killed them? Many theories were put forth, including an epidemic, landslide, and ritual suicide. For six decades, no one was able to shed light on the mystery of "Skeleton Lake."

In 2004 a scientific expedition offered the first plausible explanation of the mysterious deaths. The answer was stranger than anyone had guessed.

All of the bodies were dated to about 850 AD. DNA evidence indicated that there were two distinct groups of people killed near the lake: one a family or tribe of closely related individuals, and a second, shorter group. Rings, spears, leather shoes, and bamboo staves were found, leading experts to believe that the group was comprised of pilgrims heading through the valley with the help of local porters.

Analysis of skulls showed that, no matter their stature or position, all of the people died in a similar way: from blows to the head. However, the short, deep cracks in the skulls appeared to be the result not of weapons but of something round. The bodies had wounds only on their heads and shoulders, indicating the blows came from directly above. The scientists reached an unexpected conclusion: The hundreds of travelers all died from a sudden and severe freak hailstorm.

Hail is rarely lethal. But trapped in a valley without shelter, the 9th-century travelers could not escape the sudden barrage of rock-hard, cricket-ball-size spheres of ice. Twelve hundred years after the storm, the green-tinged bones of the hail victims still ring the lake, preserved alongside their tattered shoes.



The researchers estimated from the wounds that the largest ball of hail was at least nine inches in diameter. Awesomely spooky to imagine this event.
7 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Skeleton Lake Explained. (Original Post) byronius May 2016 OP
That is cool, weird, but cool n/t sharp_stick May 2016 #1
1942 fear that the skeletons belonged to Japanese soldiers trying to sneak through India? tanyev May 2016 #2
Japanese armies were in China and Burma at the time JHB May 2016 #3
Hail the size of canned hams! Brother Buzz May 2016 #4
Nowhere to run to baby, nowhere to hide. byronius May 2016 #5
(you answered your own question...) lastlib May 2016 #7
I got caught in a hailstorm ten years ago.... lastlib May 2016 #6

tanyev

(42,573 posts)
2. 1942 fear that the skeletons belonged to Japanese soldiers trying to sneak through India?
Thu May 12, 2016, 05:51 PM
May 2016

I guess that's the WW II version of fear that ISIS is sneaking in from Mexico. The more things change....

JHB

(37,161 posts)
3. Japanese armies were in China and Burma at the time
Thu May 12, 2016, 07:24 PM
May 2016

The lake is far enough away from the areas they controlled that moving a force through there would have been a longshot, but infiltrating spies and saboteurs that way isn't inconceivable.

And wasn't, so the Brits checked it out.

lastlib

(23,251 posts)
6. I got caught in a hailstorm ten years ago....
Sun May 15, 2016, 09:54 AM
May 2016

hiking in New Mexico mountains, at 11,000 feet (above treeline). Mostly pea-sized, some marble-sized. It was just like a cloud of hailstones exploded around us! Until we could get down about five hundred feet lower, and get under some trees, we took a **BEATING** none of us will ever forget!!

So I have no problem believing that some good-sized hailstones could be fatal. A nine-inch-diameter hailstone would be a pretty hefty chunk of ice; that's wider than most people can spread their hand! This IS pretty spooky!

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Science»Skeleton Lake Explained.