Atheists & Agnostics
Related: About this forumTold my sister-in-law I was an Atheist. She nearly had a stroke....
Last edited Mon Jul 14, 2014, 08:45 PM - Edit history (1)
So Mr. Heddi is the youngest with 2 older sisters. This is the middle sister, and she is the most typical MARSHA MARSHA MARSHA middle child EVERRRRRRrrrr. I swear to Gods that her world ceases to exist every time she closes her eyes....Very self-involved. Has actually interrupted conversations to say "You guys! no one is talking about me. Let's talk about me for a while." Very serious.
So this week we were at dinner with her and her husband(they've been divorced twice and married twice. To each other)/fiancee/boyfriend/common-law/whatever and some of her friends who are just as needy and self-centered than she is. It was a great exercise in "how to stop yourself from committing Hari Kari while in a posh restaurant."
So, just so you know, she's TOTES SMART because she has this very elusive degree called a MASTERS DEGREE That she got in GRADUATE SCHOOL. Now, I don't know if any of you Dumbos have ever heard of a MASTERS DEGREE or GRADUATE SCHOOL but it's very elite and only, like, 8 people in the history of the world have a MASTERS DEGREE That they got from GRADUATE SCHOOL. So she's totally, like, rare in that regard. THat also means that she's TOTALLY THE SMARTEST PERSON, YOU GUYS! And if you think about forgetting that she has a MASTERS DEGREE That she got at GRADUATE SCHOOL, she'll be happy to remind you. Often.
So, as usual, the conversation was dominated by her, and concerned her, her thoughts, her epiphanies, the things she found surprising in life, and the things she found disappointing. Just as I was about to pluck my eye out with the seafood fork, she begins to wax poetic on her religious struggles. Her spiritual journey from growing up in a Strict Catholic Family to High Holiday Catholic to very very Catholic to not really Catholic but kind of Catholic to Really Really Catholic to....zzzzz
Now, remember, she's my husband's sister. Grew up in the same household. She's going on about what a Strict Catholic Upbringing she had and how she grew up in a Strict Catholic Family and my husband's like "Uh bullshit. we went to mass on Christmas eve and Easter and once we went through confirmation we never went except if someone was dead or getting married. I don't know what household YOU grew up in but there was no Strict Catholic Nothing."
So that made her angry, and made her go on for even longer about her spiritual distress upon her parent's separation THIRTY YEARS AGOoOooooo and how she's still going to counseling to "reconcile her feelings about mom and dad and hell" THIRTY YEARS LATERRRRRRrrrrr. And how her poor kids will never know the joy of a pair of Grandma and Granpa on each side...now they have Step-Grand-Parents-In Law. How horridly pedestrian! All the kids at the private school secretly scoff at her progeny because of this, she is certain.
Twenty minutes on and everyone is either asleep or dead, and her quite dim husband/boyfriend/fiancee says "Yeah, well I"m pretty Agnostic myself. I mean, I believe in God and heaven and hell but I'm not a church person."
I groan at his complete inability to understand simple words.
Sister in law then pounces on the "agnostic" label and goes with that for another 15 minutes, about how Good without God is short-sighted, how EVERYONE believes in God, and how when she was in GRADUATE SCHOOL (the place she got her MASTERS DEGREE) she knew someone who was an Atheist, but had read the bible so, ya know. Whatever.
As dessert is being placed, I say "Well, I'm an Atheist. Don't believe in God. Never have. Probably never will."
That shut her up.
She refused to talk to me for the rest of the week.
And that, my friends, is how I converted to believing in God this week
Warren Stupidity
(48,181 posts)Heddi
(18,312 posts)whatever you do, DON'T tell her she looks 'Just like that actor guy." that really pisses her off.
ChairmanAgnostic
(28,017 posts)On one side, my grandparents were firm non-believers. On the other gramps could care less but grandma was a routine catholic church goer. Despite that disability, she practiced what was preached, and was one of the most empathic, sweet and concerned persons around. My parents instituted me into a religious grade school K-5. The day that I first stepped into a public school, I felt this feeling . this amazing, wonderful feeling of F R E E D O M. Many years later, I can still bring that memory to mind.
Warren Stupidity
(48,181 posts)progressoid
(49,991 posts)Wow. I've heard tales of such things. To be in the presence of someone with one must have been awe inspiring.
I'm soooo jealous.
Heddi
(18,312 posts)and she argued with me for an HOUR that there really wasn't such a thing. Despite being accepted to the MSN program at my school, I must be wrong. Is it a Masters? a REAL master's degree? Or is it a certificate? Do I have to take the GRE? Have I taken the GRE? what was my GRE score. Are you SURE there are Master's Level Nurses? Because she's never heard of that. And I guess once you get one Master's Degree then that makes you a, uh, MASTER in OTHER Master Degrees. The word MASTER looks weird after typing it out a lot of times.
progressoid
(49,991 posts)People like that frustrate the hell out of me. I usually end up saying something unpleasant or leaving.
BTW, my wife has two MASTERS and she never took the GRE.
Heddi
(18,312 posts)that, of course, means that it's a LESSER Master's Degree in her eyes. Amazingly enough, my Master's is actually something I'd use in my field, and is something that is greatly desired in my field. Her Masters was a 60k waste of time, money, and energy, as it is nothing more than a title that allows her to be underpaid in an administrative position that she is "vastly overqualified" for (according to her).
Not that I'm being pedantic, but I make about $30k more a year with ~ 10 years experience and a 2-year RN degree than she has with a BS, MS, and 20 years experience. That REALLY chaps her hide.
Heather MC
(8,084 posts)Makes me want to step outside for smoke,
AND I DON'T SMOKE!!!
raccoon
(31,111 posts)ChairmanAgnostic
(28,017 posts)the capture of fish. Say Master Baiter will be the degree, and watch the haze of confusion descend within her itty bitty skull.
Heddi
(18,312 posts)Q: what do you call the worlds best fisherman
A: A master baiter
pretty clever, I think
ChairmanAgnostic
(28,017 posts)Assuming a wide margin of error.
dhill926
(16,347 posts)thanks...
more of us need to come out of the woodwork. Thanks for the chuckle.
IkeRepublican
(406 posts)Discussing heavy matters with in-laws, particularly a bonkers one, is asking for trouble.
Remember, those who spout off their religious values are not about spreading their logic - they are about serving as a lightening rod to fuel their humps to cause trouble or fish for other fruitcakes to build a personal army of more whackadoodles. Logic and reason is irrelevant.
intaglio
(8,170 posts)Over here it is no big thing but in the States ...
Auggie
(31,174 posts)Old Codger
(4,205 posts)SIL asked if I had been baptized, told her no and ended up on the receiving end of 45 min. lecture on how I have put my "soul" in dire jeopardy and will go to hell for sure. Stopped her cold in her tracks when I told her I was an atheist and did not believe in hell anyway... wish I could have taken a pic of her face..But at least she doesn't talk to me anymore so makes my visits a lot better.
ca3799
(71 posts)LoisB
(7,206 posts)libodem
(19,288 posts)In The New Yorker or Vanity Fair or some place. I'm glad I didn't miss it.
I heard talk of a place here for original writing. I loved this story
.
BlueJazz
(25,348 posts)A HERETIC I AM
(24,371 posts)Too funny.
FWIW, I never tell people "I don't believe in god"
I say "I'm Atheist. There is no god". Tends to piss them off a bit more!
If they press, I'll say something like "There is no more reason to believe in the god of Abraham and Isaac than there is to believe in Zeus and Apollo. It isn't that I don't "believe". It is more than I KNOW all gods are mythical constructs. You don't tell people, or are surprised to learn that they "Don't believe in Unicorns". You know Unicorns are mythical."
Same with your baby killing god thingy.
SeattleVet
(5,477 posts)They don't believe in the thousands of other gods that other religions have believed in throughout history. I just lack a belief in one additional god than they do!
Sort of a paraphrase of:
I contend we are both atheists, I just believe in one less god than you do. When you understand why you dismiss all the other possible gods, you will understand why I dismiss yours. Stephen F Roberts
A HERETIC I AM
(24,371 posts)awoke_in_2003
(34,582 posts)sounds like it was worth it
stillwaiting
(3,795 posts)FailureToCommunicate
(14,014 posts)"Twenty minutes on and everyone is either asleep or dead.."
Hilariously conveyed, Heddi! Inlaws, where you know you have to make an effort, and anything untoward WILL come back to haunt you, are such an interesting challenge are they not?
You done good.
hue
(4,949 posts)You surely went through enough blaaablaaaing during that meal (hope the food was good)!
And it was all about ME, MYSELF & I for her!! I'm surprised she has room for god in her life (doesn't sound like she does)!
Divernan
(15,480 posts)Among the worst I've run into are people with Ph.D.s in education, who did their thesis on fairy tales or the like. Then I occasionally had to deal with the most arrogant woman I've ever known who had a Ph.D. in social work, and believed that said degree made her the world's expert on every known subject. Some gullible reporter once even interviewed her about nuclear power, for god's sake. There was NO subject on which she was unwilling to share her brilliant insights with anyone with hearing distance. Not much better were a whole slew of princess-types who got masters in social work, had never dealt with a real-world problem in their own lives, but got off on lecturing desperate clients how to live their lives by offering solutions which were completely unrealistic and unattainable.
My older brother got a degree in bioelectrical engineering from Purdue, but never used his "doctor" title (I have found that classy Ph.D.'s don't - they say doctor refers to medical doctor). In his considered opinion, having a Ph.D. made one an expert on an extremely narrow topic, and that ANYONE with enough time and money could get a Ph.D. I have a master's in sociology and completed all the course work for a Ph.D. in same. What simplistic class topics and course materials! And there were NO jobs availlable. That was a 6 year waste of my life, but at least I had teaching/research fellowships so was getting paid to waste my time.
Anyhoo, loved your post - very well written and funny - you really captured the essence of an insecure narcissist!
RedSpartan
(1,693 posts)after my elementary school Principal got her PhD in Education, the Vice Principal personally went to every class to stress to all teachers and, especially, students that we MUST MUST MUST call her "Doctor" from then on. Honestly, it was borderline scary for us kids, we were so afraid to insult her if we forgot.
I actually have my doctorate. Doctor of Law. However, in my humble view, there is a special place reserved for lawyers who call themselves "Doctor." (I knew one high school teacher who had his JD and did so; my uncle -- also a lawyer and who does not speak ill of anyone -- couldn't contain his contempt when I told him.)
SHRED
(28,136 posts)"The only difference between a cult and a religion is the amount of real estate they own. "
Curmudgeoness
(18,219 posts)I love the story, and the conclusion was hilarious. I am just surprised that she didn't already know that you were an atheist. But I suppose it is because she never shuts up long enough to hear from anyone else.
Good for you.....for telling her, and for her reaction.
sammythecat
(3,568 posts)That was fun.
Spitfire of ATJ
(32,723 posts)I've met people who believe you either believe in God or the Devil and THAT'S IT.
Then they go on to mention the Devil is a fallen angel,....as if that makes them a fucking scholar.
theHandpuppet
(19,964 posts)... you're missing a calling.
klook
(12,157 posts)- from the Landover Baptist Gift Shop
Outstanding story -- love your writing, and your wicked sense of humor! If it turns out there is a hell, I'll see you there!
Manifestor_of_Light
(21,046 posts)You certainly have a lot of patience!
I think women who get education degrees are just going to college to do something easy until they snag a man and get their MRS degree, as it's called.
At one state school I attended, everybody in the education department had an A average. And that probably included the Ph.D. students as well.
I think people with paper doctorates (not M.D.s) who insist on being called Doctor socially are just snotty as hell. I had a former FIL who had a Ph.D. in chemistry and insisted on being called "Doctor" socially. It's OK to be called Doctor if you are a Ph.D. and are a professor.
Or a celebrity lecturer talking to the public like we had with Carl Sagan and now have with Neil deGrasse Tyson.
Lo these thirty-some odd years later, I myself have a Juris Doctor, a law degree, and NEVER introduce myself as a doctor and don't talk about it very often.
When I called my aunt to tell her my mother (her older sister) had died, she gave me a commercial for Jesus and said "I urge you to believe" and said "When you have a funeral I want to be there." I told her that her sister, her mother and stepfather were all atheists when they died, believed there was no afterlife, and they were down with it. Perfectly content with being nothing after death.
I guess Auntie Good Christian would rather they had all died in terror of going to hell. I was so mad that I didn't have a funeral for my mom. Because I didn't want to have to deal with Auntie Good Christian.
eridani
(51,907 posts)--"doctor." The attitude being that if you are doing a certain kind of work, of course you have a PhD. If you don't, you have equivalent ezperience.
RedSpartan
(1,693 posts)And would never call myself "Doctor." I even think "Esq." is a bit much, even on legal documents. Anyway, as I posted above, I knew of one high school history teacher with a JD who insisted he be called Doctor. My uncle is a lawyer and just a great guy, have never heard him speak ill of anyone, but could not hide his contempt when I told him that.
You've got talent - and patience! There's no way I could sit for that without dying laughing, which would probably make things just a bit worse. But congrats on your short-lived conversion lol.
Hissyspit
(45,788 posts)LOL
AtheistCrusader
(33,982 posts)ROFL
I have totally been there, but on slightly different topics.
Edit: Damn, I'm not the only one that found that hilarious.
gwheezie
(3,580 posts)I felt like I was there.
I'm an atheist. I actually work for a catholic healthcare organization. People I work with are very concerned about me. It doesn't bother me, they mean well. I usually tell them if i start believing in god I'm going to start small and become a jew and work my way up to the trinity and wind up a hindu.
TBF
(32,068 posts)her head might actually explode right then and there!
You can thank me later
Worried senior
(1,328 posts)One of the best things I've ever read.
I have a sister-in-law that likes to remind everyone she is a nurse with a degree; I feel your pain.
A Simple Game
(9,214 posts)He, She, It, Whatever works in mysterious ways.
deucemagnet
(4,549 posts)Great story, BTW!
Heddi
(18,312 posts)Luckily, throughout dinner, her vapid-brained friends slowly trickled away one by one "oh uh yeah um I think the uh sitter is oh wait...I think the sitter is calling gotta go..." "oh is that my car alarm going off? I think that's my car alarm going off. See ya later..." until it was just Mr. Heddi and I. I have never had such a burning yen for a short rope and a high beam in all my life.
rhett o rick
(55,981 posts)she finds out differently, your silent treatment is over.
eShirl
(18,494 posts)"oh For Fuck's Sake"
onager
(9,356 posts)"If you invoke god one more time, I shall move you closer to him."
Or Charles Bronson from "Death Wish:"
Bronson: "Do you love Jesus?"
Bad Guy: "Yes I do."
Bronson: "Good. You're about to meet him."
Neither really appropriate for an atheist, but they still crack me up.
Funny story, thanks. I have the same kind of "conversations" with my relatives back in East Jesus when I visit.
Talking to them is a lot like visiting The Other Group: "Let's have a dialogue about religion. Now shut up and listen."
hamsterjill
(15,222 posts)Your post made me crack up!!! I think we've all come in contact with the types like your sister-in-law. They drive most people nuts.
In my opinion, we are all free to believe (or not believe) that which we choose is right for us. To refuse to associate with those who believe (or don't believe) in a manner different from our own, well that sure would make for a boring planet.
RebelOne
(30,947 posts)Last Xmas, I was at my son's house. His wife has three sons by a previous marriage. One of the boys' wives started preaching about the rapture. I listened politely, and then my 17-year-grandson piped up and said, "Nana, aren't you an atheist?" I replied and said yes. Well, the Rapture Ready idiot immediately shut up.
homegirl
(1,429 posts)My mother was visiting one of her nieces she hadn't seen for a long time. With great enthusiasm this niece told my mother that her life was wonderful since she found Jesus. My savvy mother replied-"oh, I didn't know he was missing." End of that line of conversation.
AlbertCat
(17,505 posts)Fuddnik
(8,846 posts)Most of it was just shit she thought was in there. I don't think she ever actually read it.
She started one morning when I had a screaming hangover, and was in no mood for it. I asked her "Just what does a bunch of Bronze Age mythology, superstitions, and fairy tales have to do with anything?"
She was shocked. I've known her since my teens. She said you don't believe the bible?
Nope, I'm an atheist, and don't believe in any of that crap.
beam me up scottie
(57,349 posts)I feel your pain, bf's mother is a nurse who advised me to see a male OB/Gyn because men are just "more knowledgeable".
I avoid family gatherings for the sake of everyone involved.
AlbertCat
(17,505 posts)Loved that