Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

RandySF

(58,835 posts)
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 06:47 PM Jan 2016

I don't think Bernie knows how he plans to pay for a single-payer health plan.

At the heart of the debate between Clinton and Sanders over taxes is the question of what programs the federal government should be willing to pay for. Sanders has long supported a single-payer healthcare system in the style of European countries and Canada that he calls “Medicare for all,” saying the program would guarantee healthcare for all Americans and greatly reduce healthcare bills.

But Sanders has never firmly answered how as president he would pay for the proposal, which many have estimated to cost upwards of $15 trillion over 10 years. Legislation he has repeatedly introduced in the past has indicated he would raise taxes on the middle class, including a 2.2% income tax and a 6.7% tax on employers.

Since then, Sanders has walked back his earlier proposals, saying that he would only be willing to raise taxes on the middle class to pay for paid family leave. Sanders’ policy advisor, Warren Gunnels, told TIME last month that the government could pay for single-payer healthcare without raising taxes on the middle class.

A Facebook post by Sanders supporter and former President Bill Clinton advisor Robert Reich indicated Sanders was planning to release his healthcare plan today.

http://time.com/4183856/bernie-sanders-middle-class-taxes-health-care/

66 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
I don't think Bernie knows how he plans to pay for a single-payer health plan. (Original Post) RandySF Jan 2016 OP
Republican talking points! Aproper single payer will cost half of what health care costs today... Human101948 Jan 2016 #1
That's a claim and not details, people don't believe that claim... so why not show the numbers in.. uponit7771 Jan 2016 #7
Or you could, you know, LOOK IT UP HerbChestnut Jan 2016 #11
I have, Sanders plan is not out there yet even though he said he'd release it today. There are no... uponit7771 Jan 2016 #19
Okay, two things. HerbChestnut Jan 2016 #26
No, I'm asking for Sanders plan not on how US compares... and Sanders will have taxpayers paying uponit7771 Jan 2016 #42
No. Just...no. HerbChestnut Jan 2016 #47
Simple? Costing an entire universal healthcare system for 300m people? Kentonio Jan 2016 #12
tort reform enid602 Jan 2016 #46
They got tort reform in Florida Kelvin Mace Jan 2016 #50
ABA enid602 Jan 2016 #65
Again, Florida Kelvin Mace Jan 2016 #66
How is he going to pay for the world's largest military? stone space Jan 2016 #2
So you question if he knows how to pay, but then say he is going to release a PLAN today? JonLeibowitz Jan 2016 #3
It's nearly 3pm on the West Coast. RandySF Jan 2016 #6
Then he has 9 hours left? JonLeibowitz Jan 2016 #8
What's he going to do? Wait 'til we're all in bed? RandySF Jan 2016 #9
My goodness, Randy. HerbChestnut Jan 2016 #14
Then he cam simply say that RandySF Jan 2016 #24
He has, multiple times. HerbChestnut Jan 2016 #28
You think you have the right to sit demanding Bernie releases his plan right now Kentonio Jan 2016 #15
Yes, voters have the right to know before voting or did that escape you? leftofcool Jan 2016 #22
He said he'll release it before the primary Kentonio Jan 2016 #37
Well, JonLeibowitz seems to think it's coming out today. RandySF Jan 2016 #23
No, Jon said that YOU said it was coming out today Kentonio Jan 2016 #39
And in the end it DID come out today so RandySF's complaining was all for naught. JonLeibowitz Jan 2016 #52
Yeah, I laughed. Kentonio Jan 2016 #53
Or how he's going to get anything passed a historically gerrymandered GOP congress even if he could uponit7771 Jan 2016 #4
Hillary solves that question easily PeoViejo Jan 2016 #5
Yeap, no need in promising unicorns uponit7771 Jan 2016 #10
Yeah, why strive for progress, right? HerbChestnut Jan 2016 #16
We can progress and not proffer unicorns at the same time no? tia uponit7771 Jan 2016 #17
He should do what Hillary would do, ask his friends in the Insurance Lobby for help.... Indepatriot Jan 2016 #13
You need to do some fucking research jkbRN Jan 2016 #18
Awwwwwwwwwwww! Did someone disagree with Bernie? leftofcool Jan 2016 #20
Classy RandySF Jan 2016 #21
I did some fucking research. RandySF Jan 2016 #25
we are already paying for it questionseverything Jan 2016 #40
lol!!! I love this place uponit7771 Jan 2016 #43
cnn just got their copy hot off the presses. (7:15pm EST) babylonsister Jan 2016 #44
I don't care how he wants to get there.... daleanime Jan 2016 #27
I am convinced, the Democratic party has been infiltrated by republicans and they cant hide it. litlbilly Jan 2016 #29
Where is Clinton's plan Dretownblues Jan 2016 #30
We have Hillary's plan. It's called the ACA leftofcool Jan 2016 #31
So her plan is Dretownblues Jan 2016 #36
In a similar fashion to every other country that has it? Schema Thing Jan 2016 #32
We cannot evaluate this plan until we see the details Gothmog Jan 2016 #33
I don't think Hillary wants to change the status quo at all. She just wants to be President. nt thereismore Jan 2016 #34
You also didn't think he had a chance in the primary Android3.14 Jan 2016 #35
the notion that the richest country in the world somehow has difficulty finding the money... mike_c Jan 2016 #38
The tax increase will be way more than offset by savings ... bvar22 Jan 2016 #41
According to the release: Fawke Em Jan 2016 #48
His plan just came out. Agschmid Jan 2016 #45
Well seems we can put this Hillary thread where it belongs...nighty night. libdem4life Jan 2016 #49
This was a fun thread. One last gasp of desperation before he releases the plan. JonLeibowitz Jan 2016 #54
Desperation is right. kath Jan 2016 #56
Not to worry, fresh memes will be distributed tonight. n/t JonLeibowitz Jan 2016 #58
It's the smell of desperation in the aftermath. n/t libdem4life Jan 2016 #59
Oh I can't wait for that fight! This is where we reveal who the Republicans in our midst are! n/t JonLeibowitz Jan 2016 #60
Got a point, there. n/t libdem4life Jan 2016 #62
+10,000 nt Live and Learn Jan 2016 #55
Oopsie! cherokeeprogressive Jan 2016 #51
you never ask how the government pays for all these wars Rosa Luxemburg Jan 2016 #57
That's because we feel so much safer from the Muslims attacking us with their bottle rockets libdem4life Jan 2016 #61
Is that right, Randy? DisgustipatedinCA Jan 2016 #63
So it looks like he has just gone back to the earlier ideas he proposed? Lucinda Jan 2016 #64
 

Human101948

(3,457 posts)
1. Republican talking points! Aproper single payer will cost half of what health care costs today...
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 06:51 PM
Jan 2016
What a goddamn strawman...This entire argument about paying for healthcare is based on the idea that U.S. costs are necessarily sky high to provide good care. They are not!

The United States health care system is the most expensive in the world, but this report and prior editions consistently show the U.S. underperforms relative to other countries on most dimensions of performance. Among the 11 nations studied in this report—Australia, Canada, France, Germany, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Sweden, Switzerland, the United Kingdom, and the United States—the U.S. ranks last, as it did in the 2010, 2007, 2006, and 2004 editions of Mirror, Mirror. Most troubling, the U.S. fails to achieve better health outcomes than the other countries, and as shown in the earlier editions, the U.S. is last or near last on dimensions of access, efficiency, and equity.


http://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/fund-reports/2014/jun/mirror-mirror

Even Cuba with a very, very poorly funded system does better!

Figures from the World Health Organization clearly show that The United States lags behind 36 other countries in overall health system performance ranging from infant mortality, to adult mortality, to life expectancy.

20 countries in Europe and four countries in Asia have a better life expectancy than the U.S. If you are a male between the ages of 15 and 59, your chances of dying are higher in the U.S. (140 per thousand) than in Canada, 95, Costa Rica 127, Chile 134, and Cuba, 138.


http://www.huffingtonpost.com/blake-fleetwood/cuba-has-better-medical-c_b_19664.html

It is not about having enough money, it's about capitalists sucking the blood out of the populace like the slimey leeches they are.

uponit7771

(90,339 posts)
7. That's a claim and not details, people don't believe that claim... so why not show the numbers in..
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 06:55 PM
Jan 2016

...totality?!

Should be simple, he's had time and got staff now

 

HerbChestnut

(3,649 posts)
11. Or you could, you know, LOOK IT UP
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 07:01 PM
Jan 2016

Don't rely on other people to do your work for you. It is a well known fact that the U.S. pays more for healthcare than any other country. If you don't know that then it's on you to find the information.

uponit7771

(90,339 posts)
19. I have, Sanders plan is not out there yet even though he said he'd release it today. There are no...
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 07:07 PM
Jan 2016

... proposed numbers on replacing the for profit system and no placing it on the backs of the tax payer or the employer.

NOT ONE

 

HerbChestnut

(3,649 posts)
26. Okay, two things.
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 07:21 PM
Jan 2016

First, my comment responded to your claim that nobody is providing numbers on where the United States compares to other countries in terms of spending on healthcare.

Second, Bernie proposed legislation in 2013 for a single payer system. It is my understanding that his current plan will be similar to that one with small differences due to changes in the ACA that will end up making the overall plan cheaper than it would have been previously.

Thirdly (as a bonus), healthcare is paid for by the taxpayer and employers already. It's called insurance premiums. Single payer systems simply cost less and will save the average person money. Period.

uponit7771

(90,339 posts)
42. No, I'm asking for Sanders plan not on how US compares... and Sanders will have taxpayers paying
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 07:54 PM
Jan 2016

... for both ACA and single payer?

He needs to put out some details with numbers so folk can gut check it themselves

enid602

(8,620 posts)
46. tort reform
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 08:27 PM
Jan 2016

Most interesting. All of the countries mentioned in the articles have one thing the US does not. Tort reform. We will NEVER have per capita health expenses in line with other countries until we have tort reform. The Bern knows this, yet he's voted AGAINST tort reform at least twice. Bowing to the influence of the powerful ABA? Doesn't sound like our Bernie.

 

Kelvin Mace

(17,469 posts)
50. They got tort reform in Florida
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 09:08 PM
Jan 2016

And it made ZERO difference in insurance premiums.

The purpose of tort reform is to protect corporations from paying for their negligence.

enid602

(8,620 posts)
65. ABA
Mon Jan 18, 2016, 12:21 AM
Jan 2016

And they also have it in France, the UK, Canada and EVERY developed country that has universal healthcare. I guess the US is exceptional. Malpractice insurance is a BIG part of each doctor's budget. Much of what they do is defensive medicine, and not needed for treatment. This is a big component of why our healthcare is so expensive.

 

Kelvin Mace

(17,469 posts)
66. Again, Florida
Mon Jan 18, 2016, 12:45 AM
Jan 2016

got tort reform under Jeb and malpractice premiums continued to go up. All tort reform did was improve insurance company profit margins.

 

stone space

(6,498 posts)
2. How is he going to pay for the world's largest military?
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 06:51 PM
Jan 2016

That what we're interested in here in Iowa.

My suggestion would be to hold a Bake Sale.


RandySF

(58,835 posts)
9. What's he going to do? Wait 'til we're all in bed?
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 06:57 PM
Jan 2016

He's been in Congress for 15 years. He should have an idea by now.

 

HerbChestnut

(3,649 posts)
14. My goodness, Randy.
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 07:03 PM
Jan 2016

He released a bill in 2013. You even mentioned it in your OP, I believe. Of course he has an idea of how he's going to pay for it.

 

HerbChestnut

(3,649 posts)
28. He has, multiple times.
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 07:24 PM
Jan 2016

In fact he's on record saying this new plan will be similar to the 2013 version but with minor tweaks due to updates in the ACA which will make it more cost effective. I suspect the campaign will release the details of the plan within an hour or so of the debate so Hillary and her team don't have time to rummage through it. The rest of us, however, will have all the time in the world to look it over once it comes out.

 

Kentonio

(4,377 posts)
15. You think you have the right to sit demanding Bernie releases his plan right now
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 07:03 PM
Jan 2016

Based on what a supporter of his implied that he might do today?

You're funny.

 

Kentonio

(4,377 posts)
37. He said he'll release it before the primary
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 07:42 PM
Jan 2016

If he fails to do so, then you have every right to criticize him for that.

 

Kentonio

(4,377 posts)
39. No, Jon said that YOU said it was coming out today
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 07:44 PM
Jan 2016

Which it seems was based on nothing more than an implication you drew from a tweet.

uponit7771

(90,339 posts)
4. Or how he's going to get anything passed a historically gerrymandered GOP congress even if he could
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 06:54 PM
Jan 2016

... pay for it.

I'm starting to become disillusioned at his offering of unicorns... thought he'd do better

 

HerbChestnut

(3,649 posts)
16. Yeah, why strive for progress, right?
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 07:04 PM
Jan 2016

I mean, it's not like he calls himself a Progressive or anything...

RandySF

(58,835 posts)
25. I did some fucking research.
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 07:21 PM
Jan 2016

And I can't find his fucking health care plan on his fucking 'How Bernie Plans To Pay For His Proposals Page'. Can you fucking help me find it if I am just fucking missing it?

questionseverything

(9,654 posts)
40. we are already paying for it
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 07:46 PM
Jan 2016
http://www.democraticunderground.com/10027538997

we just are not getting it yet

//////////////////////////////////

my spouse and i do not have ins because when i checked it out under the aca it would be about 28% of our estimated income to actually use it......and it would not cover some of our main medical expenses,chiropractor,vision and dental

8% on the premium and 10% each for the 6 grand out of pocket

<shrugs>

i am not concerned about how to pay for it, the details will change no matter what is said during campaign

but i am concerned about establishing healthcare as a human right,not a privilege for the well to do

Gothmog

(145,242 posts)
33. We cannot evaluate this plan until we see the details
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 07:35 PM
Jan 2016

Vermont tried to adopt single payer and was unable to do so. The ACA is not perfect but it is far better than the old system

mike_c

(36,281 posts)
38. the notion that the richest country in the world somehow has difficulty finding the money...
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 07:44 PM
Jan 2016

...to provide health care on par with that already provided by most other first world nations with significantly smaller budgets is just ludicrous. There is no shortage of money to pay for single payer health care. The only shortage is in the will to make it a national priority and to get it done.

bvar22

(39,909 posts)
41. The tax increase will be way more than offset by savings ...
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 07:49 PM
Jan 2016

...to every American family that no longer has to BUY questionable "Insurance" from the For Profit maggots.

Why do so many in the Democratic Party insist on subsidizing a parasitic Industry that:

*Manufactures NOTHING

*Provides NO useful service

*Creates NO Value Added Wealth ?

We get rid of the Health Insurance Industry, we save 15% right off the top.
More savings when we can use our combined voices for Collective Bargaining with the Health Care Providers and BIG PHARM.

Our money will go to actual Health Care,
not private jets, yachts, and new Summer Homes in Aspen for Insurance Execs and Lobbyists.

If that doesn't explain it,
I can't help you.
Please think this through before jerking a knee or repeating old Republican talking points.

(BTW, maggots provide a useful service,
so it is not fair to the maggots to compare them to the For Profit "Insurance" scammers)

Fawke Em

(11,366 posts)
48. According to the release:
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 08:32 PM
Jan 2016


Basically, the average family saves about $2,500 a year over premiums and that doesn't consider deductibles.

I don't pay premiums as it's a perk of my job, so my taxes WILL go up, but I'm fine with about $500 a year because I still won't have deductibles and the boss probably would take the savings and pay us more. We do it to attract good candidates.
 

libdem4life

(13,877 posts)
59. It's the smell of desperation in the aftermath. n/t
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 09:25 PM
Jan 2016

Now all we can hear is the loud clamor of "Payroll Taxes" over and over and over. People earning over $10 million a year...will practically be living in poverty.

 

libdem4life

(13,877 posts)
61. That's because we feel so much safer from the Muslims attacking us with their bottle rockets
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 09:30 PM
Jan 2016

and such. We've built those 800+ foreign airbases and by god we're going to keep the reasons going to justify them. I mean, think of all the wasted money if we just, gasp, closed some of them.

It's actually the full employment plan for the formerly middle class who can't make a living wage because the unions have faded. Oh, and forget getting employed stateside...wounded, PTSD, lousy job market, etc.

Thanks for mentioning it. Guess I did rant on a bit. Oh well, beats screaming and cursing.

 

DisgustipatedinCA

(12,530 posts)
63. Is that right, Randy?
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 09:42 PM
Jan 2016

Do tell me more about how Sanders doesn't know how he'll pay for his plans? Full disclosure: the timing of my post makes you look like a political newcomer; this was not unintentional.

Lucinda

(31,170 posts)
64. So it looks like he has just gone back to the earlier ideas he proposed?
Sun Jan 17, 2016, 10:12 PM
Jan 2016

I've just skimmed the announcement, but it looks, on the surface, to be exactly what you mentioned...

Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»2016 Postmortem»I don't think Bernie know...