Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
34 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Hillary just said: "Single payer health care will never, ever happen" (Original Post) dixiegrrrrl Jan 2016 OP
No, We Can't. The Velveteen Ocelot Jan 2016 #1
especially when she hollers it AtomicKitten Jan 2016 #27
That's why she isn't going to win. n/t Avalux Jan 2016 #2
Of course, she couldn't make it happen when she had her chance in the 90s Jarqui Jan 2016 #3
She argued AGAINST it in the 90s. thesquanderer Jan 2016 #16
No, she didn't. NanceGreggs Jan 2016 #4
So, did she not say this or does it not mean what it appears to mean? Goblinmonger Jan 2016 #6
She has said ... NanceGreggs Jan 2016 #13
Let's break it down, shall we? ljm2002 Jan 2016 #15
HRC has said ... NanceGreggs Jan 2016 #17
I know you are a strong advocate... ljm2002 Jan 2016 #20
Good post. Luminous Animal Jan 2016 #25
Yes I am aware of where she lives... ljm2002 Jan 2016 #26
So the, no point in bothering to argue with someone with no skin in the game, either. dixiegrrrrl Jan 2016 #31
So what form of single payer does she think WILL happen? Goblinmonger Jan 2016 #23
Argue with the link. n/t dixiegrrrrl Jan 2016 #7
The Hillary Scream !!! libdem4life Jan 2016 #5
She even admits it's a better idea. JeffHead Jan 2016 #8
So the US is incapable of achieving something other countries have already done. Ever. winter is coming Jan 2016 #9
Nice creative use of quotations. tarheelsunc Jan 2016 #10
So is she afraid of that debate? sadoldgirl Jan 2016 #11
Argue with the link. n/t dixiegrrrrl Jan 2016 #14
Headline is: 'Hillary Clinton: Single-payer health care will "never, ever" happen' nilram Jan 2016 #18
So what is she talking about with the "theoretical debate"? Goblinmonger Jan 2016 #24
It sure as hell won't if she is the Nominee Ferd Berfel Jan 2016 #12
I love a lot about you, Hillary. But on this one thing? kestrel91316 Jan 2016 #19
Ever happen? It's going to happen Rosa Luxemburg Jan 2016 #21
"I know how much money influences the political decision-making..." Ino Jan 2016 #22
Or maybe most poor people aren't convinced Sanders is for them? Most of the poor aren't uponit7771 Jan 2016 #29
This is false on its face, you can not quote HRC saying these words one bit uponit7771 Jan 2016 #28
I did not quote her, CBS did..you can tell by the...quotation marks. dixiegrrrrl Jan 2016 #33
She never said single payer... the fact that this statement is being pulled out of context like "you uponit7771 Feb 2016 #34
Don't dump the ACA. Hill said it's harder to get a better oasis Jan 2016 #30
That means she wont even try for public option ErikJ Jan 2016 #32

Jarqui

(10,126 posts)
3. Of course, she couldn't make it happen when she had her chance in the 90s
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 09:23 PM
Jan 2016

so she's given up.

Time to get out of the way, Hillary.

Go home and broker some more arms deals for Kuwait.

thesquanderer

(11,990 posts)
16. She argued AGAINST it in the 90s.
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 10:07 PM
Jan 2016

See http://www.democraticunderground.com/12511103341

She basically said that if her plan were NOT passed, we would probably end up with single payer. And of course, nobody wants that. So, friends at Lehman Bros, Hillary's plan is the one you want to support.

 

Goblinmonger

(22,340 posts)
6. So, did she not say this or does it not mean what it appears to mean?
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 09:29 PM
Jan 2016

"People who have health emergencies can't wait for us to have a theoretical debate about some better idea that will never, ever come to pass."

I guess, yeah, she said "theoretical debate" instead of "single payer," but are you really going to spin so hard to try and convince us that she isn't talking about single payer? I mean, maybe she's talking about time travel!

NanceGreggs

(27,815 posts)
13. She has said ...
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 09:43 PM
Jan 2016

... that Bernie's plan for single payer will never happen, not that single payer will never happen.

And in what universe does the term "theoretical debate" mean "single payer"?

As I said, I understand why certain people need to believe that HRC said that single payer would never happen.

ljm2002

(10,751 posts)
15. Let's break it down, shall we?
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 09:57 PM
Jan 2016

She said:

"People who have health emergencies can't wait for us to have a theoretical debate about some better idea that will never, ever come to pass."

Now first of all, one has to ask, in what way does having a debate about health care have anything at all to do with people who are experiencing health emergencies? You and I both know the answer to that: it does not.

Secondly, why does she not want to have a debate about a "better idea"? Whether she is referring to Bernie's plan or to some other way of achieving universal health care, she appears unwilling to discuss it. And that's her biggest misstep, since it removes any credibility she may have had for her previous advocacy on the matter of single payer health care (hint: she used to be for it).

If she is referring to Bernie's single payer plan, she just admitted it's a "better idea".

If she is not referring to Bernie's plan, then she is saying that single payer and/or universal health care will never, ever happen.

Either way, she loses. Not to mention the rest of us, but I digress.

NanceGreggs

(27,815 posts)
17. HRC has said ...
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 10:35 PM
Jan 2016

... that she wants to build on the foundation of Obamacare - which is already in place. Bernie's plan includes dismantling Obamacare in order to replace it with his plan for single payer. What happens to people with medical emergencies while Bernie's plan is being debated?

Do you honestly think that the GOP, who have voted to repeal Obamacare over 50 times, are going to suddenly embrace single payer? In what universe?

The "theoretical debate" comes about when congress debates the "theoretical" idea that Bernie's plan IS the better idea - not only better, but workable, affordable, and above all acceptable enough to be passed into law.

DU has been full of posts about how Hillary said "Single payer will never, ever pass". But she never said that. She said that Bernie's plan for single payer will never pass - and it wouldn't.

It's sad to see the FOX-News-like insistence that she said something she clearly didn't say. But for some here, specific details as to what was actually said - by HRC or anyone who doesn't worship Bernie - are regularly dismissed as irrelevant.

ljm2002

(10,751 posts)
20. I know you are a strong advocate...
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 10:39 PM
Jan 2016

...and I respect that. I did not expect dishonesty though:

Bernie's plan includes dismantling Obamacare in order to replace it with his plan for single payer. What happens to people with medical emergencies while Bernie's plan is being debated?


That is dishonest and you know it. I know you know it, because you are obviously a very intelligent person. And this is exactly the framing that Chelsea Clinton got reamed for, even by the MSM. Anyone who has followed this election cycle, or has followed Bernie for any part of his career, knows he would not start by dismantling Obamacare and then start a debate on what to replace it with. AND YOU KNOW THAT.

I will not engage further with you in this thread. You should be ashamed of yourself. TTFN

Luminous Animal

(27,310 posts)
25. Good post.
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 10:56 PM
Jan 2016

I don't know if you are aware, but that poster lives in Canada and has access to a wonderful healthcare system.

dixiegrrrrl

(60,010 posts)
31. So the, no point in bothering to argue with someone with no skin in the game, either.
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 11:58 PM
Jan 2016

Saves me some time, then.

 

Goblinmonger

(22,340 posts)
23. So what form of single payer does she think WILL happen?
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 10:51 PM
Jan 2016

And how is it going to happen if she is not going to debate it?

That's a lot of spin you are doing. I hope you have a strong focal point as you rotate.

tarheelsunc

(2,117 posts)
10. Nice creative use of quotations.
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 09:36 PM
Jan 2016

Too bad that it makes your post dishonest.

The actual quote. for people who care:
"People who have health emergencies can't wait for us to have a theoretical debate about some better idea that will never, ever come to pass."

nilram

(2,888 posts)
18. Headline is: 'Hillary Clinton: Single-payer health care will "never, ever" happen'
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 10:36 PM
Jan 2016

Is there really much difference?

Ino

(3,366 posts)
22. "I know how much money influences the political decision-making..."
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 10:46 PM
Jan 2016

....a Hillary quote from the OP. Yes Hillary, we know you know!

uponit7771

(90,347 posts)
29. Or maybe most poor people aren't convinced Sanders is for them? Most of the poor aren't
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 11:43 PM
Jan 2016

... afraid of Wall Street but more afraid of bad schools and high premiums... which doesn't look like they'll change under Sanders plan

uponit7771

(90,347 posts)
34. She never said single payer... the fact that this statement is being pulled out of context like "you
Mon Feb 1, 2016, 02:28 AM
Feb 2016

... didn't build that" lets people no Sanders position on his plan is weak at best.

oasis

(49,389 posts)
30. Don't dump the ACA. Hill said it's harder to get a better
Sun Jan 31, 2016, 11:47 PM
Jan 2016

health care bill when you start from zero, than it is if you start from 90%.

Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»2016 Postmortem»Hillary just said: "Singl...