2016 Postmortem
Related: About this forumObama didn't play the Sensata card. What does the final push look like?
I was a little surprised by that, as there were 3 or 4 really good times to do that during last night's debate.
I can only surmise that the Obama campaign knows this is a potent issue and they wanted to:
1) Save it for the last debate -- there will be ample opportunity to discuss that, as the final debate is 90 minutes of foreign policy
2) Let the story develop a few more days -- Ed is doing a special on that Friday night
3) Make Romney stew in his juices, wondering when he is going to get clocked with that one
4) Bring it up as part of a much bigger, harder hitting final pitch that really hammers on Romney's ethics
BTW, has Romney actually released his 2011 tax return yet? I think he only released a summary. Is he waiting for 11:39 PM the night before the election?
It seems to me, the final debate is the last big opportunity to launch major issues. What else do you think might be hanging out there that the campaign has saved for the final push?
tk2kewl
(18,133 posts)Last edited Wed Oct 17, 2012, 02:39 PM - Edit history (1)
and i cant wait
grasswire
(50,130 posts)He has mutual funds that include Sensata. That's why Romney went after him last night asking about Obama's pension and leering at him.
bigdarryl
(13,190 posts)grasswire
(50,130 posts)From the NYT article:
For many sophisticated and wealthy investors, as well as for ordinary workers invested in pension funds, China is a part of any diversified investment strategy. President Obama, a former Illinois state senator, has as much as $100,000 in a state retirement plan that contains shares of Sensata Technologies, the same auto parts company controlled by Bain that is closing its Illinois factory.
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/10/10/us/politics/as-romney-repeats-trade-message-bain-maintains-china-ties.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0
BlueStreak
(8,377 posts)Bain has the lion's share. Various mutual funds have a small stake, so many of us might have a few pennies worth of Sensata stock.
That should not stop Obama from going after him. I think most people understand that if you have a Vanguard mutual fund, for example, you have nothing to say about what the Vanguard manager buys in that fund, and the fund composition changes every day.
Bain holds 89,626,932 out of 178,612,907 shares -- a clear controlling interest.
I have heard the claim that Romney personally is the holder of that Bain share, but I don't see any data that confirms that.
BlueStreak
(8,377 posts)"Romney has $8 million in the Bain funds that control Sensata". That doesn't necessarily mean that Romney owns $8M worth of Sensata because that Bain fund might be spread across multiple properties.
This would all be much more clear if Romney would release his tax returns -- and that is how Obama can get to Romney's tax returns in the final debate that is ostensibly about foreign policy. He can argue that what we do in shipping jobs overseas is fundamental to our foreign policy. Indeed you cannot understand how Romney would deal with China without seeing his tax returns.
global1
(25,272 posts)Sensata was a profitable U.S. company. Anybody would be proud to own shares in a company like that. The fact that Bain took it over and is now shipping it and the jobs overseas is damning to Rmoney - not Obama.
BlueStreak
(8,377 posts)We'll see if the investors, other than Bain, actually make any money in this deal. I'm betting Bain has rigged it so they extract the profits before they shut it down.
I would never personally invest in any company that has a majority stake (or ANY significant stake) held by one of the vulture companies. But when you are in a mutual fund (or a retirement plan as in the case of Obama) you have no control over that.
begin_within
(21,551 posts)with this remark:
"...keep in mind that Governor Romney invested in companies that were pioneers of outsourcing to China..."
However it went by pretty fast and didn't linger in your mind. A hint that he still holds that card to play, if he feels like it's effective.
BlueStreak
(8,377 posts)That was a company that Romney personally invested in that operates out of China and makes its business the off-shoring of American jobs. They have sucked jobs from lots of American companies.
Sensata is a little different. It was a profitable company that Bain acquired for the purposes of sucking the life out of it. That is the Bain way.
It is the difference between "push" and "pull", if you will.
They are both valid examples, and I expect to see a heavy dose of this next week when the debate focused entirely on foreign policy.