Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

amborin

(16,631 posts)
Fri Jun 3, 2016, 04:20 PM Jun 2016

Top UN Advisor: Hillary Clinton and the Syrian Bloodbath

Hillary Clinton and the Syrian Bloodbath

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jeffrey-sachs/hillary-clinton-and-the-s_b_9231190.html


"This is the kind of compulsive misrepresentation that makes Clinton unfit to be President. Clinton's role in Syria has been to help instigate and prolong the Syrian bloodbath, not to bring it to a close.

In 2012, Clinton was the obstacle, not the solution, to a ceasefire being negotiated by UN Special Envoy Kofi Annan. It was US intransigence - Clinton's intransigence - that led to the failure of Annan's peace efforts in the spring of 2012, a point well known among diplomats. Despite Clinton's insinuation in the Milwaukee debate, there was (of course) no 2012 ceasefire, only escalating carnage. Clinton bears heavy responsibility for that carnage, which has by now displaced more than 10 million Syrians and left more than 250,000 dead. "
48 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Top UN Advisor: Hillary Clinton and the Syrian Bloodbath (Original Post) amborin Jun 2016 OP
Wow, the UN thinks she's unfit to be president DebDoo Jun 2016 #1
Refugee crisis = Hillary for me. Bull in a china shop, only this "china" bleeds and dies. senz Jun 2016 #2
Yes, me too. mmonk Jun 2016 #19
Uh, the Secretary of State works for the President and at their direction. tonyt53 Jun 2016 #3
there goes her foreign policy expertise Press Virginia Jun 2016 #5
They can't have it both ways. NWCorona Jun 2016 #8
Oh how they try Press Virginia Jun 2016 #13
suggest you read the facts about her actions in the ME: amborin Jun 2016 #7
Read Hillary's book Hard Choices and get back to me NWCorona Jun 2016 #9
read her emails, read the ny times reports, etc. She bears heavy responsibility for the amborin Jun 2016 #32
it's absolutely disturbing, and in a sane world, she wouldn't be our main choice to beat Trump Fast Walker 52 Jun 2016 #4
she can't beat Trump; only Bernie can beat Trump in the GE amborin Jun 2016 #6
she can beat Trump... he's a walking disaster and she's not nearly as bad Fast Walker 52 Jun 2016 #18
Oh come on. That just shows how much Clinton loves women and children. HUGE sarcasm. Skwmom Jun 2016 #10
Well in her "experience" (Iraq, Libya) it was just business as usual Betty Karlson Jun 2016 #11
The title reads like part of an ongoing series Fumesucker Jun 2016 #12
Hillary Clinton and the Haiti distaster GuestCheck Jun 2016 #14
Hillary Clinton and the Chamber of Secrets Raster Jun 2016 #16
Hillary Clinton and the Colombian Right Wing Anti-Union Militias amborin Jun 2016 #20
Yes! trudyco Jun 2016 #21
No fiction editor in his right mind would accept such an unlikely and absurd premise Fumesucker Jun 2016 #23
President Obama Demsrule86 Jun 2016 #15
Why is criticism "tearing down?" David__77 Jun 2016 #28
You wouldn't say that if a MAN turned the entire middle east into chaotic bloodbath Doctor_J Jun 2016 #17
With a little fleshing out you have an amusing OP there Fumesucker Jun 2016 #22
K&R -- important topic senz Jun 2016 #24
Those who vote for Hillary are complicit in her bloodthirsty tragedies Arazi Jun 2016 #25
It's just part of Hillary's inner Kissinger coming out. Uncle Joe Jun 2016 #26
I do believe she supporting ramping up insurgency. David__77 Jun 2016 #27
Isn't that exactly how she is treating Bernie supporters? She does not want peace. She pdsimdars Jun 2016 #30
Everything she touches turns to sh*t. pdsimdars Jun 2016 #29
The situation is Syria was dire well before the US got involved oberliner Jun 2016 #36
Dead refugee babies washing up on the beaches... riderinthestorm Jun 2016 #31
Hillary Clinton is not responsible for the fighting in Syria oberliner Jun 2016 #35
sad that so many Democrats are choosing this person Cheese Sandwich Jun 2016 #33
Bernie Sanders has the exact same positions on Syria as Hillary Clinton oberliner Jun 2016 #37
absolutely not. Cheese Sandwich Jun 2016 #39
"first priority must be the destruction of ISIS. Our second priority must be getting rid of Assad" oberliner Jun 2016 #40
I'm not really too impressed with Bernie's statements on Syria but it's better than Hillary's Cheese Sandwich Jun 2016 #41
Fair enough oberliner Jun 2016 #42
I'd have to say they are pretty different, especially on the posture toward Russia. Cheese Sandwich Jun 2016 #43
Do you think Russia has been a positive influence on the situation in Syria? oberliner Jun 2016 #46
Is this a trick question? Cheese Sandwich Jun 2016 #47
No, I mean the question sincerely oberliner Jun 2016 #48
This Jeffrey Sachs article is from February oberliner Jun 2016 #34
Truth telling is not bashing. farleftlib Jun 2016 #44
Agreed oberliner Jun 2016 #45
But I thought Obama was President in 2012? Jitter65 Jun 2016 #38
 

senz

(11,945 posts)
2. Refugee crisis = Hillary for me. Bull in a china shop, only this "china" bleeds and dies.
Fri Jun 3, 2016, 04:33 PM
Jun 2016

From the OP link:

Despite Clinton’s insinuation in the Milwaukee debate, there was (of course) no 2012 ceasefire, only escalating carnage. Clinton bears heavy responsibility for that carnage, which has by now displaced more than 10 million Syrians and left more than 250,000 dead.
 

tonyt53

(5,737 posts)
3. Uh, the Secretary of State works for the President and at their direction.
Fri Jun 3, 2016, 04:39 PM
Jun 2016

So, I guess that guy is saying that Obama is not fit to be President. Sounds like Trump saying that.

 

Press Virginia

(2,329 posts)
5. there goes her foreign policy expertise
Fri Jun 3, 2016, 04:50 PM
Jun 2016

If all she was doing is flying on planes and meeting heads of state, she's going to have to stop pretending she did anything substantial

amborin

(16,631 posts)
7. suggest you read the facts about her actions in the ME:
Fri Jun 3, 2016, 05:10 PM
Jun 2016


http://www.nytimes.com/video/us/politics/100000004216623/hillary-clintons-legacy-in-libya.html

http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/28/us/politics/hillary-clinton-libya.html?_r=0


Hillary Clinton and the Syrian Bloodbath

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jeffrey-sachs/hillary-clinton-and-the-s_b_9231190.html



"This is the kind of compulsive misrepresentation that makes Clinton unfit to be President. Clinton's role in Syria has been to help instigate and prolong the Syrian bloodbath, not to bring it to a close.

In 2012, Clinton was the obstacle, not the solution, to a ceasefire being negotiated by UN Special Envoy Kofi Annan. It was US intransigence - Clinton's intransigence - that led to the failure of Annan's peace efforts in the spring of 2012, a point well known among diplomats. Despite Clinton's insinuation in the Milwaukee debate, there was (of course) no 2012 ceasefire, only escalating carnage. Clinton bears heavy responsibility for that carnage, which has by now displaced more than 10 million Syrians and left more than 250,000 dead. "




Email from Blumenthal to HRC, Concerning Toppling Assad
Everyone is probably well aware that HRC accepted continual emails from Sidney Blumenthal, an employee of the Clinton Foundation with business interests in Libya, all the while she was SOS.

This is from one of the emails he sent her, in which he forwards or mentions a viewpoint concerning the consequences of toppling the Assad regime in Syria. HRC valued this email enough to seemingly forward it to Jake Sullivan:




7. One particular source states that the British and French Intelligence services believe that their Israeli

counterparts are convinced that there is a positive side to the civil war in Syria; if the Assad regime topples, Iran

would lose its only ally in the Middle East and would be isolated. At the same time, the fall of the House of

Assad could well ignite a sectarian war between the Shiites and the majority Sunnis of the region drawing in
Iran, which, in the view of Israeli commaders would not be a bad thing for Israel and its Western allies. In the

opinion of this individual, such a scenario would distract and might obstruct Iran from its nuclear activities for a

good deal of time. In addition, certain senior Israeli intelligence analysts believe that this turn of events may

even prove to be a factor in the eventual fall of the current government of Iran.


https://wikileaks.org/clinton-emails/emailid/12172#efmBbqBf9

amborin

(16,631 posts)
32. read her emails, read the ny times reports, etc. She bears heavy responsibility for the
Sun Jun 5, 2016, 11:46 AM
Jun 2016

carnage; she pressured Obama to intervene and was instrumental in much
of the decision making regarding Syria including attempts to forge a peace accord

 

Fast Walker 52

(7,723 posts)
4. it's absolutely disturbing, and in a sane world, she wouldn't be our main choice to beat Trump
Fri Jun 3, 2016, 04:42 PM
Jun 2016

but yet, there it is. Trump is still worse.

 

Betty Karlson

(7,231 posts)
11. Well in her "experience" (Iraq, Libya) it was just business as usual
Fri Jun 3, 2016, 05:11 PM
Jun 2016

Her friend Henry Kissinger advised her to be such an obstacle, probably. Why else would she embrace the old obstacle to Vietnam's peace over and over again.

Fumesucker

(45,851 posts)
12. The title reads like part of an ongoing series
Fri Jun 3, 2016, 05:12 PM
Jun 2016

Hillary Clinton and the Syrian Bloodbath

Hillary Clinton and the Iraq Quagmire

Hillary Clinton and the Honduran Coup

trudyco

(1,258 posts)
21. Yes!
Sat Jun 4, 2016, 01:17 PM
Jun 2016

Wish it was only fiction.

Hillary Clinton and the Convoluted Columbian Connection
Hillary meets Mr Guistra

Hillary: To Russia with Love and Uranium

Hillary Clinton and the Libya Domino War Debacle

(Disaster was already used LOL)

Fumesucker

(45,851 posts)
23. No fiction editor in his right mind would accept such an unlikely and absurd premise
Sat Jun 4, 2016, 01:41 PM
Jun 2016

Former First Lady and primary candidate is appointed SoS and goes on a worldwide graft and violence spree then comes back to the US and wins the Presidency on a slogan of Love and Kindness.

I can hear the eyes roll and the manuscript levitate to the circular file from here.

Demsrule86

(68,576 posts)
15. President Obama
Fri Jun 3, 2016, 05:47 PM
Jun 2016

made policy no matter how many of these stupid posts appear. And I would add there are no good options in Syria...but go ahead tear down the dem nominee...most of you want Trump anyway.

David__77

(23,402 posts)
28. Why is criticism "tearing down?"
Sat Jun 4, 2016, 04:31 PM
Jun 2016

I consider criticism of her standpoint on Syria to be valid as a matter of discussion. I'm hopeful that Clinton will not advocate for the US to support regime change. I'm hopeful that she will adopt a different position going forward.

 

Doctor_J

(36,392 posts)
17. You wouldn't say that if a MAN turned the entire middle east into chaotic bloodbath
Fri Jun 3, 2016, 07:12 PM
Jun 2016


I beat the hillarians to the punch.

David__77

(23,402 posts)
27. I do believe she supporting ramping up insurgency.
Sat Jun 4, 2016, 04:28 PM
Jun 2016

I don't believe she was interested in a negotiated settlement that involved something other than the effective surrender of the Syrian government and state. I find that unfortunate.

 

pdsimdars

(6,007 posts)
30. Isn't that exactly how she is treating Bernie supporters? She does not want peace. She
Sat Jun 4, 2016, 06:32 PM
Jun 2016

doesn't want to negotiate. She only wants surrender. To batter the "enemy" until they surrender. And "the enemy" is anyone who doesn't do exactly as she wants.

She acts in the campaign just as she did in the world.

 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
36. The situation is Syria was dire well before the US got involved
Sun Jun 5, 2016, 04:07 PM
Jun 2016

What exactly do you think the US policy should be with respect to Syria?

 

riderinthestorm

(23,272 posts)
31. Dead refugee babies washing up on the beaches...
Sat Jun 4, 2016, 06:54 PM
Jun 2016

She is responsible for so much bloodshed. I am having a hard time reconciling anyone supporting her, thus ensuring we get even more of this.



 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
37. Bernie Sanders has the exact same positions on Syria as Hillary Clinton
Sun Jun 5, 2016, 04:11 PM
Jun 2016

BERNIE SANDERS ON SYRIA
Bernie has described the civil war in Syria as a “quagmire in a quagmire” and his policy on Syria has three facets: address the humanitarian crisis created by the war; end ISIS; and phase-out Assad, the main party responsible for starting and continuing the war.

http://feelthebern.org/bernie-sanders-on-syria/

 

Cheese Sandwich

(9,086 posts)
39. absolutely not.
Sun Jun 5, 2016, 04:19 PM
Jun 2016

Hillary has been pushing for a 'no fly zone' that could bring the US into direct conflict with Russian forces and their allies.

Bernie stands with President Obama in opposing such a wreckless aggressive measure.

Hillary wants to fight an impossible two-front war of trying to overthrow the Syrian government while at the same time claiming to fight ISIS. Bernie wants to focus on defeating ISIS and other terrorist groups that pose a real threat to the United States.

Hillary has consistently pushed President Obama toward more and more aggressive posture in Syria and she was an early advocate of trying to forcibly overthrow the Syrian government by arming supposedly "moderate" rebel groups. Well they were armed, and they did manage to turn Syria into a failed state with large parts of the country overrun by ISIS and Al Qaeda. If President Obama had followed all of her advice the situation would be even worse, with nothing left of the Syrian state and ISIS would be running the whole thing.

 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
40. "first priority must be the destruction of ISIS. Our second priority must be getting rid of Assad"
Sun Jun 5, 2016, 04:29 PM
Jun 2016

That was what Sanders said on the subject, which is exactly the same position that Hillary has.

It is true that they differ on a no-fly zone, but I do not think that Sanders has presented a comprehensive plan to address the situation in Syria. It certainly does not come up much in his stump speeches or at rallies.

In his foreign policy speech, he did not really outline any particular plan with respect to Syria.

 

Cheese Sandwich

(9,086 posts)
41. I'm not really too impressed with Bernie's statements on Syria but it's better than Hillary's
Sun Jun 5, 2016, 05:24 PM
Jun 2016

Her plan revolves around arming the "moderate" syrian rebels to overthrow the government and fight ISIS at the same time, while possibly bringing the US military into direct conflict with Russia. This is an incredibly dangerous path to go down that would probably just result in either a never ending quagmire, or else a consolidated ISIS nation state, or possibly a chaotic failed state where rival terrorist gangs compete for dominance.

Bernie says he wants to arm the "Mooslim" nations to fight ISIS, including Saudi Arabia which sounds completely nuts to me, but still not as nuts as Hillary's plan. He has also mentioned the need to treat the Russians as partners in Syria, not as enemies, which is where we are right now truth be told. Bernie's plan is basically a variation of what President Obama is already quietly doing. Hillary's stated plans are much more aggressive, a much bigger US footprint and projection of US national power, particularly in the hostile posture toward Russia, which is totally counterproductive if your goal is peace and stability.




 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
42. Fair enough
Sun Jun 5, 2016, 05:57 PM
Jun 2016

Can we agree that they are basically in the same ball park on the issue? I'll concede that maybe their policies are not exactly the same, but, there's not really a major difference between the two on this subject.

 

Cheese Sandwich

(9,086 posts)
43. I'd have to say they are pretty different, especially on the posture toward Russia.
Sun Jun 5, 2016, 06:16 PM
Jun 2016

Bernie would continue President Obama's strategy as far as I can tell, which is pretty good. Hillary has a much more aggressive posture that goes well beyond trying to achieve peace and stability, and is focused more on trying to assert US dominance, which is framed as trying to trying to prevent the meddling foreign influences of Russia and Iran.

Unfortunately Bernie doesn't always express himself very clearly on the issue. Hillary is outstandingly clear on it though.

 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
46. Do you think Russia has been a positive influence on the situation in Syria?
Sun Jun 5, 2016, 07:08 PM
Jun 2016

I would argue that they have not.

 

Cheese Sandwich

(9,086 posts)
47. Is this a trick question?
Sun Jun 5, 2016, 08:51 PM
Jun 2016

I feel like if I say yes then I'm going to be labeled a Putin humper.

But hey they are fighting ISIS, they are a known element, a stabilizing factor, we know how to deal with them. I think their interests and ours are greatly overlapping to they extent that both countries would benefit from peace and stability in Syria.

The interests are different in some respects though. Russia is obviously trying to defend their client state for all the traditional reasons and they have their own internal political reasons.

 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
48. No, I mean the question sincerely
Sun Jun 5, 2016, 09:33 PM
Jun 2016

I appreciate you sharing your perspective. It's a complicated situation to be sure. I would argue that stepping away and leaving it for the Russians to sort out could have even worse consequences than what we are seeing now.

 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
34. This Jeffrey Sachs article is from February
Sun Jun 5, 2016, 04:05 PM
Jun 2016

He has been bashing Hillary since the election season began.

 

farleftlib

(2,125 posts)
44. Truth telling is not bashing.
Sun Jun 5, 2016, 06:29 PM
Jun 2016

HRC supporters routinely call it bashing when the truth isn't to their liking.

She accomplished nothing as SoS except massive loss of life and endangering our national security.

 

oberliner

(58,724 posts)
45. Agreed
Sun Jun 5, 2016, 07:07 PM
Jun 2016

But that's not really what this article is doing, in my opinion.

I think there is a lot of blame to go around with respect to the crisis in Syria. I do not think it is reasonable to ascribe so much of it to Hillary Clinton.

It's also not entirely clear what Bernie Sanders's policy is with respect to Syria. He has said (like Clinton) that he believes ISIS needs to be defeated and that Assad needs to go. Beyond there, they has not been much detail in terms of how to accomplish those goals.

 

Jitter65

(3,089 posts)
38. But I thought Obama was President in 2012?
Sun Jun 5, 2016, 04:13 PM
Jun 2016

Did SOS's stop taking orders from Presidents? I thought Powell and Iraq showed us differently?

Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»2016 Postmortem»Top UN Advisor: Hillary ...