Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 06:01 PM Nov 2016

Your White "Pain" Can Go Fuck Itself

The Rude Pundit

American Eclipse, Part 4: Your White "Pain" Can Go Fuck Itself


It hasn't stopped yet, this constant thrum of voices telling us that we need to "understand" the "pain" and the "fear" of Trump voters. "We," in this case, are the ones who look at those Americans and see the most loathsome versions of ourselves, the ill-informed, the overly credulous, the willing patsies, the greedy marks, the covetous fools, and the racist shits. In order to move ahead, we must reach out to this group, we're told, that we, who supported the auto industry bailout and health care and food stamps and job retraining and addiction services, we whose liberal policies kept them from flat out dying, we are the ones who didn't get it. What a goddamned joke to tell us that we don't understand and those who tried to cut or prevent or get rid of all of those things do understand.

If a group of rabid dogs corners me in an alley in the middle of a city, the animals may take me out, but they are still dogs and I am still human. They won't let me survive because I try to pet them. (Am I comparing Donald Trump's voters to rabid dogs? Yes. Yes, I am.)

The other refrains of the weekend were the usual nonsense about what could have been done differently. Goddamn, I'm so sick of hearing about how Bernie Sanders could have beaten Trump. It's a waste of time because we have no idea how the public would have reacted to the inevitable reaming of Sanders. Hell, if we're playing Fantasy Election, you could make just as valid a bullshit argument that what really damaged Hillary Clinton was Sanders running in the first place. Think about it: most progressives might have coalesced early around Clinton and, instead of a bruising primary that ended up creating animosity among Democrats, we might have...See? It's an enormous waste of time. Do you feel any better? Of course not.

I'm gonna offer one wouldashouldacoulda that can point in a direction for Democrats: the biggest mistake that Hillary Clinton made was in choosing Tim Kaine as her running mate. Nothing against Kaine, and, yeah, yeah, the VP pick is not supposed to have that much of an effect. But it signals to groups of voters how you might end up leading. When Trump picked the odious dickscab, Mike Pence, he was telling evangelicals that they were cool with each other. Pence gave cover for a large contingent of Trump voters. By choosing Kaine, who, yeah, can speak Spanish, Clinton was mistakenly and symbolically whitening the White House.

It's time for Democrats to stop trying to appeal to a white demographic that constantly turns against it and to do everything possible to energize the non-white vote, and that means, in as many cases as it is possible, nominating and running non-white candidates. At the national level, Democrats haven't been ahead of Republicans on the white vote since 1996, when Bill Clinton got a plurality over Dole and Perot (although, you know, combined, the othertwo more conservative candidates got more of the white vote than Clinton).


snip//

More: http://rudepundit.blogspot.com/2016/11/american-eclipse-part-4-your-white-pain.html




187 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Your White "Pain" Can Go Fuck Itself (Original Post) sheshe2 Nov 2016 OP
Pain has no color.. whathehell Nov 2016 #1
Trash thread is your friend. sheshe2 Nov 2016 #89
Ignore is yours -- Feel free to use it. whathehell Nov 2016 #120
So you throw shade Stryst Nov 2016 #134
Bullshit melman Nov 2016 #135
you also seem to have missed my point Stryst Nov 2016 #141
Thank you. n/t whathehell Nov 2016 #155
What "shade"? I expressed an opinion -- Yes, we're allowed to do that whathehell Nov 2016 #153
Trollings not a good look. Stryst Nov 2016 #156
Lol..Name calling is always the last resort of losers whathehell Nov 2016 #161
Calling another poster a "troll" is against the TOS. nt cwydro Nov 2016 #187
What "shade"? I expressed an opinion -- We're allllowed to do that here.. whathehell Nov 2016 #154
Say what? whatthehell??? sheshe2 Nov 2016 #181
Post removed Post removed Nov 2016 #183
Recommended. Chasing the elusive white, working class liberal? guillaumeb Nov 2016 #2
I think we need some younger blood sheshe2 Nov 2016 #20
I disagree... Bernie transcends age. InAbLuEsTaTe Nov 2016 #61
Okie Dokie. sheshe2 Nov 2016 #66
sheshe, i think he will... my 2 kids, who are 20-somethings, and many of their friends absolutely LOVE Bernie!! InAbLuEsTaTe Nov 2016 #73
Cool for you and your 20 year olds. sheshe2 Nov 2016 #74
Yes, thanks! InAbLuEsTaTe Nov 2016 #77
No thanks sheshe2 Nov 2016 #79
Umm, no. Chemisse Nov 2016 #123
No one should be discriminated against because of age... the question we should be asking ourselves is whether a candidate can appeal to voters of ALL ages... InAbLuEsTaTe Nov 2016 #124
That's a pretty absurd statement. Chemisse Nov 2016 #130
Bernie has shown NO SIGNS of slowing down - unlike other Democratic candidates - and it is ageist to suggest otherwise! InAbLuEsTaTe Nov 2016 #132
Age differences are a biological reality. Chemisse Nov 2016 #142
I see what you're saying... fair point. I would simply say as long as a candidate, like Bernie, shows no signs of slowin down, I would judge him primarily on the issues... InAbLuEsTaTe Nov 2016 #144
After I posted, I thought about how we all need hope right now. Chemisse Nov 2016 #145
Thanks for that Chemisse... very kind of you to say (and, yes, it does give me hope.) InAbLuEsTaTe Nov 2016 #177
Thank you and goodbye to the Age Discrimiators.. whathehell Nov 2016 #158
"Pipe dreams"?.. whathehell Nov 2016 #160
Agreed. Younger blood is needed in all of our institutions. guillaumeb Nov 2016 #82
I am not sure how... sheshe2 Nov 2016 #109
Agreed on all four of the people you named. guillaumeb Nov 2016 #149
I agree younger rpannier Nov 2016 #107
MY grandfather was one of those. . .but he died in 1974 Feeling the Bern Nov 2016 #117
Exactly what demographic composes this 41%? Ligyron Nov 2016 #125
Exactly. Outreach is needed. eom guillaumeb Nov 2016 #150
"...the odious dickscab, Mike Pence..." Raster Nov 2016 #3
Loved that one! sheshe2 Nov 2016 #21
LOL funny!! InAbLuEsTaTe Nov 2016 #62
If we keep on the path of identity politics, we're going to get massacred in 2018 LittleBlue Nov 2016 #4
This.... Bob41213 Nov 2016 #5
Really? DURHAM D Nov 2016 #6
NO Cosmocat Nov 2016 #8
BS is the one who made it the headline. DURHAM D Nov 2016 #10
Hes right Cosmocat Nov 2016 #16
Are you talking Sanders???? sheshe2 Nov 2016 #99
Exactly. LisaM Nov 2016 #36
1000 momto3 Nov 2016 #133
1000 sheshe2 Nov 2016 #38
Class struggle is a winner LittleBlue Nov 2016 #12
1 progressoid Nov 2016 #17
Bernie was so popular that he got crushed by millions of votes Grey Lemercier Nov 2016 #81
Sorry No. sheshe2 Nov 2016 #100
So working for "every section of society" is hillarious to you LiberalLovinLug Nov 2016 #159
Obama didn't win on Class Struggle. he won because of his own personal appeal regardless of issues JI7 Nov 2016 #118
A lot of truth to that TexasMommaWithAHat Nov 2016 #148
1 CentralMass Nov 2016 #178
Abandon no, lower in importance and focus yes Amishman Nov 2016 #14
Correct Cosmocat Nov 2016 #18
I see you. I know who you are. DURHAM D Nov 2016 #22
You see a strawman? Cosmocat Nov 2016 #24
If you are saying this... sheshe2 Nov 2016 #28
Yeap... uponit7771 Nov 2016 #85
Agreed. n/t whathehell Nov 2016 #162
No. But diversity is only an asset (really) as long as jonno99 Nov 2016 #15
Middle aged white guys voted for Hillary. DURHAM D Nov 2016 #54
That would be me. GWC58 Nov 2016 #63
I can tell you that at my American Legion meetings Stryst Nov 2016 #139
YEP Cosmocat Nov 2016 #11
As if the alt right isn't emersed deep in their own shit ID politics. joshcryer Nov 2016 #34
Let them, it's a loser LittleBlue Nov 2016 #39
We're not throwing away decades of progress... joshcryer Nov 2016 #42
We can't make any progress if we don't win LittleBlue Nov 2016 #47
Their jobs are not coming back. joshcryer Nov 2016 #48
Aren't white people an identity? How is appealing to whites not identity politics? yardwork Nov 2016 #69
I don't think focusing on jobs, healthcare and education for everyone LittleBlue Nov 2016 #75
Healthcare? Education? radical noodle Nov 2016 #103
Oh, I agree. That's why I say Bernie has wide appeal. LittleBlue Nov 2016 #115
this DonCoquixote Nov 2016 #92
We won the pop vote by 2million that doesn't sound like the right strategy uponit7771 Nov 2016 #84
whyTF does it work for the repugs? mdbl Nov 2016 #96
"Identity politics" is French for "Get back to the back of the bus!" backscatter712 Nov 2016 #167
You "get" it. Seems nobody else does. Just keep splitting us apart ...... 7962 Nov 2016 #173
I disagree about Kaine mcar Nov 2016 #7
1! eom BlueMTexpat Nov 2016 #64
Right and wrong Cosmocat Nov 2016 #9
Are you a white male? nt DURHAM D Nov 2016 #13
Are you? Cosmocat Nov 2016 #25
Post removed Post removed Nov 2016 #94
Very true. And I don't usually like this guy.. boston bean Nov 2016 #19
There is that Cosmocat Nov 2016 #26
Agree about Comey sheshe2 Nov 2016 #29
It's a reasonable assumption though ultimately wrong forjusticethunders Nov 2016 #65
It wasn't Comey--the problem was early on with Zucker and CNN peddling 24/7 Trump. duffyduff Nov 2016 #95
How did that just work out for us? mythology Nov 2016 #23
No amount of suffering could ever make me vote for a vile sack of shit like Trump. BlueStater Nov 2016 #27
Sure would help if they actually understood what Trump actually stood for. sheshe2 Nov 2016 #37
We got more votes? uponit7771 Nov 2016 #86
Some people like a divided populace clearly. This piece is fucking horrible. Do you think that once JCanete Nov 2016 #30
Well said. n/t ms liberty Nov 2016 #46
Well, I think the article is great. sheshe2 Nov 2016 #49
The white middle class are afraid of this. The people who own everything, who happen to be JCanete Nov 2016 #58
Disagree. sheshe2 Nov 2016 #106
We got more votes right? uponit7771 Nov 2016 #87
An alternative opinion: jonno99 Nov 2016 #31
Excellent article.. whathehell Nov 2016 #165
Go Fuck Yourself is a definite winner for us in 2018 and beyond. Ace Rothstein Nov 2016 #32
If you do not like it trash the thread. sheshe2 Nov 2016 #83
Maybe you could realize melman Nov 2016 #110
Oh dear. sheshe2 Nov 2016 #111
LOL! sheshe2 Nov 2016 #112
If you don't like his posts, put him on Ignore.. whathehell Nov 2016 #157
LOL, no kidding. (n/t) SMC22307 Nov 2016 #91
I think the Tea Baggers practice identity politics as well. jalan48 Nov 2016 #33
personally, I think he was insulting rabid dogs. niyad Nov 2016 #35
Lol sheshe2 Nov 2016 #51
I'm listening to this and wondering myself Horse with no Name Nov 2016 #40
Obama tried to reach to the white working class. BlueStater Nov 2016 #52
Except for card check. dogman Nov 2016 #59
Yup.. whathehell Nov 2016 #166
I felt that was make or break for Unions. dogman Nov 2016 #184
First K&R ismnotwasm Nov 2016 #41
Yup, going to be a long slog for real progressives like Rude Pundit. joshcryer Nov 2016 #43
I am still trying to make my way down the thread. sheshe2 Nov 2016 #53
My thoughts exactly liquid diamond Nov 2016 #80
I see them as suckers for a sales pitch too.. Spitfire of ATJ Nov 2016 #44
As a white Democrat who voted for Clinton, I agree with this post Gothmog Nov 2016 #45
Hello my friend. sheshe2 Nov 2016 #55
Happy Thanksgiving to you Gothmog Nov 2016 #131
Confusing 'identity politics' with 'tokenism. yallerdawg Nov 2016 #50
Dayum fine link, yallerdawg. sheshe2 Nov 2016 #57
You know what I think. yallerdawg Nov 2016 #60
Yes they did! sheshe2 Nov 2016 #93
Yes, we need to court the deplorables mdbl Nov 2016 #97
Whoa!!! Right On heaven05 Nov 2016 #56
;) sheshe2 Nov 2016 #70
"They be crying crying... " melman Nov 2016 #108
Reality! 86derps Nov 2016 #67
Did you vote for Hillary? ismnotwasm Nov 2016 #76
They are 2 years....30 posts. sheshe2 Nov 2016 #90
"Your White "Pain" Can Go Fuck Itself" Elmergantry Nov 2016 #68
These are the deplorables. sheshe2 Nov 2016 #72
LOL whathehell Nov 2016 #163
I don't understand all this white pain. AgadorSparticus Nov 2016 #71
And the media in America feeds this whining uponit7771 Nov 2016 #88
I am white and I see it all the time radical noodle Nov 2016 #104
It must be nice to have an identity you can disregard when you vote gollygee Nov 2016 #78
White dudes are all about "their" identity. They think the world revolves around them. duffyduff Nov 2016 #98
Yes radical noodle Nov 2016 #105
The real "White" pain is fear of no longer being the dominant racial group in America Yavin4 Nov 2016 #101
Yes!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! sheshe2 Nov 2016 #102
exactly heaven05 Nov 2016 #137
Don't forget Hillary got more than 2 million more votes than Trump world wide wally Nov 2016 #113
It died Tuesday November 8 2016 sheshe2 Nov 2016 #114
The decline of heavy industry is a feature throughout the West. Bad Dog Nov 2016 #116
I think theyre smarter than we (at least at this blog) give them credit for.... jack_krass Nov 2016 #138
Coal is uneconomic. Bad Dog Nov 2016 #143
Yeah I know all that, but heres where optics and messaging come unto play jack_krass Nov 2016 #147
You're right. There was a vacuum. Bad Dog Nov 2016 #168
Your facts are wrong. Yavin4 Nov 2016 #146
You can nitpick all you want. Bad Dog Nov 2016 #169
It's not nitpicking. It's the truth. Yavin4 Nov 2016 #175
It is nitpicking. Bad Dog Nov 2016 #182
Your lecture can go F itself as well rumdude Nov 2016 #119
nope,Rude is not wrong!!!! heaven05 Nov 2016 #140
This is idioitic oberliner Nov 2016 #121
Yep, but its music to the ears of our ruling class here at DU jack_krass Nov 2016 #152
"Let them eat pain": A wonderful strategy for dems to lose every local, state, and national positio jack_krass Nov 2016 #122
Oh I'm so impressed with your advice....NOT!!!!!! heaven05 Nov 2016 #136
"think playing nice with the nazis and KKK" who said that??? jack_krass Nov 2016 #151
Great rant. sheshe2 Nov 2016 #174
I disagree. Chemisse Nov 2016 #126
More white people voted for Clinton than all non-whites combined. Buckeye_Democrat Nov 2016 #127
Your post doesn't fit the current narrative Red Oak Nov 2016 #176
Thank you for this, ... this should be its own OP !!! uponit7771 Nov 2016 #179
Yes! Let's split the party! Red Oak Nov 2016 #128
If we ever adopted a parliamentary government, it might work. Buckeye_Democrat Nov 2016 #129
Well, the OP seems to think pain comes in two colors.. whathehell Nov 2016 #170
A-fucking-men. The instant I hear racist/misogynistic/homophobic slurs out of white trash mouths... backscatter712 Nov 2016 #164
Right melman Nov 2016 #171
Jeeze the blame just never ends does it. Now calling people dogs. Fabulous. 7962 Nov 2016 #172
Sounds like a power struggle in the Democratic Party to me. jalan48 Nov 2016 #180
Good article. And as Charles Pierce wrote in response to a woman's reason for voting for Trump: Garrett78 Nov 2016 #185
So in other words white people are bad NobodyHere Nov 2016 #186

Stryst

(714 posts)
134. So you throw shade
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 11:35 AM
Nov 2016

but the other poster should just ignore you. This little exchange right here, of you coming into someone's thread just to be insulting and then telling that person that if they don't like it they can ignore you is like a microcosm of the whole election drama.

 

melman

(7,681 posts)
135. Bullshit
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 11:44 AM
Nov 2016

OP posted a deliberately inflammatory article, then acted like people should either agree or shut up.

btw, it's not "someone else's thread" - that's not how boards work. This isn't Facebook or a private blog. Everybody gets to comment.

Stryst

(714 posts)
141. you also seem to have missed my point
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 12:01 PM
Nov 2016

My point was telling someone to ignore you after you deliberately avoided the opportunity to ignore them comes of as hypocritical. Perhaps I could have expressed myself better when I should have said "The thread this person started but has now actual ownership over that you CHOSE to click on.

I hear you talking, and don't like what you're saying. So I walk up to you, and with a smile on my face say "you can fuck yourself, and if you don't like me telling you to fuck yourself, you can ignore me since I was unable to ignore you."

whathehell

(29,067 posts)
153. What "shade"? I expressed an opinion -- Yes, we're allowed to do that
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 01:31 PM
Nov 2016

The opinion was that pain has no color....Whoever thinks this is "insulting" is living in an alternate universe...The "other person" you

referred to, didn't, for some reason, like my opinion, and basically told me to shut up, by suggesting I trash the thread. I simply reminded her that

she was as free to put me on ignore as I was to "trash the thread"...Turnaround is fair play.

Stryst

(714 posts)
156. Trollings not a good look.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 02:31 PM
Nov 2016

Wow, you should read my first post, because you clearly do not understand what I said.

You come in here and insult someone, and when you get called out on it, you play the victim, good for you Troll.

Sorry we triggered you.

whathehell

(29,067 posts)
154. What "shade"? I expressed an opinion -- We're allllowed to do that here..
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 01:34 PM
Nov 2016

The opinion was that pain has no color....Whoever thinks this is "insulting" is living in an alternate universe...The "other person" you

mentioned, didn't, for some reason, like my opinion, and basically told me to shut up, by suggesting I trash the thread. I simply reminded her that

she was as free to put me on Ignore as I was to "trash the thread"...Turnaround is fair play.

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
181. Say what? whatthehell???
Fri Nov 25, 2016, 02:43 AM
Nov 2016
mentioned, didn't, for some reason, like my opinion, and basically told me to shut up, by suggesting I trash the thread. I simply reminded her that


Where did I tell you to shut up? I basically told you to shut up???? You don't like my thread. Fine, I never told you to shut up. You play the victim well.

Response to sheshe2 (Reply #181)

guillaumeb

(42,641 posts)
2. Recommended. Chasing the elusive white, working class liberal?
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 06:07 PM
Nov 2016

But white voters are still a big factor because white workers, especially older white workers, vote more consistently and at higher levels than do non-white workers.

Demographics might be on our side, but changing demographics only count if the demographic you are looking at actually votes and participates.

And I agree that energizing the 41% who do not vote is vital. The more difficult question is how do we energize them? If the prospect of a fascist in the White House was not enough to energize them, what would be?

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
20. I think we need some younger blood
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 06:28 PM
Nov 2016

we should be "grooming" them now for 4 years out. I agree with what they said, we need more non white people on our tickets. I truly believed that say, Julian Castro would have energized our base. We need to get young people in all offices.

InAbLuEsTaTe

(24,122 posts)
73. sheshe, i think he will... my 2 kids, who are 20-somethings, and many of their friends absolutely LOVE Bernie!!
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 09:40 PM
Nov 2016

Chemisse

(30,813 posts)
123. Umm, no.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 10:13 AM
Nov 2016

They are both important voices, but they are quite old. We need new blood rising through the ranks right now, to secure the party's future.

InAbLuEsTaTe

(24,122 posts)
124. No one should be discriminated against because of age... the question we should be asking ourselves is whether a candidate can appeal to voters of ALL ages...
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 10:23 AM
Nov 2016

I believe Bernie has shown that he DOES have such appeal.

Chemisse

(30,813 posts)
130. That's a pretty absurd statement.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 10:42 AM
Nov 2016

When people get old their bodies begin to fail them, they get sick, and they die. Oftentimes their minds fail as well. It's just a fact of life. It's ridiculous to pretend age is not a factor in someone's ability to do this very difficult job!

Nobody should be discriminated against due to age, if they are equally capable of doing the job. But being a president requires that someone be in top form, both physically and mentally, and also be statistically expected to survive the term. Personally, I'd prefer a candidate to be under 60 years of age.

We need good progressives to follow in the footsteps of Sanders and Warren, and to have the energy to stir the excitement of the populace.

Pipe dreams are pleasant, but we need to face reality and work very hard to get Trump out of office in four years.

InAbLuEsTaTe

(24,122 posts)
132. Bernie has shown NO SIGNS of slowing down - unlike other Democratic candidates - and it is ageist to suggest otherwise!
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 11:08 AM
Nov 2016

Chemisse

(30,813 posts)
142. Age differences are a biological reality.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 12:06 PM
Nov 2016

Believe me - I know! I am 62.

Naturally there is a lot of variation between individuals, but the statistics show a steady decline as we age (not to mention observed changes at the cellular level).

Nevertheless I voted for Bernie in the primaries. Age is not my number 1 criteria for voting, by any means. But if all else was equal, I would vote for a candidate in their 60s before one in his 70s.

InAbLuEsTaTe

(24,122 posts)
144. I see what you're saying... fair point. I would simply say as long as a candidate, like Bernie, shows no signs of slowin down, I would judge him primarily on the issues...
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 12:13 PM
Nov 2016

all things being equal, then, MAYBE, take age into consideration as a slight factor. That seems to me as being practical... so, I would agree with that.

Chemisse

(30,813 posts)
145. After I posted, I thought about how we all need hope right now.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 12:29 PM
Nov 2016

And it was kind of petty of me to insistently step on what you found to give you hope.

It doesn't hurt to think Sanders/Warren 2020, as long as we are also supporting the rise of a new crop of Dems while we're at it.

InAbLuEsTaTe

(24,122 posts)
177. Thanks for that Chemisse... very kind of you to say (and, yes, it does give me hope.)
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 07:18 PM
Nov 2016

... and, of course, I'm open to potential new candidates who might have their own appeal. We obviously need the best candidate who will have the greatest chance of defeating Mr. Tiny Hands in 2020 before he does permanent damage to our country and way of life.

whathehell

(29,067 posts)
160. "Pipe dreams"?..
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 03:24 PM
Nov 2016

A lot of people thought a 74 year old Jewish Socialist wining even one state in a primary was a "pipe dream"

Others thought the same for the presidential prospects a black man with the middle name of "Hussein" we're as well.

guillaumeb

(42,641 posts)
82. Agreed. Younger blood is needed in all of our institutions.
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 10:54 PM
Nov 2016

Unions as well. Far to many of the leaders are much older than the median age of US voters.

So, how do we attract them? It must be more than simply volunteering to make phone calls and send out mailings.

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
109. I am not sure how...
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 02:25 AM
Nov 2016

Yet our reps are in touch with many enthusiastic supporters. Hillary is one. Warren another Obama. Michelle. We need them to go out and ignite them, we need to help as well.

We the people need to start this. I want to see Julian Castro more in the spotlight. People like him need to be front and forward.

guillaumeb

(42,641 posts)
149. Agreed on all four of the people you named.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 01:07 PM
Nov 2016

The GOP is much more of a Parliamentary type party, where there is a specific platform that all must support.

The Democrats are far less organized, far more open to ideas.

Ligyron

(7,633 posts)
125. Exactly what demographic composes this 41%?
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 10:27 AM
Nov 2016

That's what we really need to find out - age, race, location, gender, etc. so we might effectively engage them.

Some of them we probably do not want to have voting against us - they're fine staying home and watching Fox, Oprah or whatever.

I've not seen any serious studies on exactly who these people are...

 

LittleBlue

(10,362 posts)
4. If we keep on the path of identity politics, we're going to get massacred in 2018
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 06:07 PM
Nov 2016

I said last year that identity politics is a loser. We lost. Are we going to learn or double down? I always thought of the Democrats as more clever than this, but it appears we're suicidal.

How many senate seats are we going to lose because of these hostile proclamations? Stop talking and listen before we hand Trump a filibuster-proof senate. We tried this way and it failed. Stahp!

DURHAM D

(32,610 posts)
10. BS is the one who made it the headline.
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 06:17 PM
Nov 2016

Talk to him. He needs to shut up and stop selling his damn book at our expense.

Grifters got to Grift.

Cosmocat

(14,566 posts)
16. Hes right
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 06:23 PM
Nov 2016

Look, standing up for the rights of all americans is the right thing, but we end up boxed into a corner by the rs when they play culture wars like trump did for the last year and a half.

No one is saying abandon civil rights. But, team hate wins if identity politics is the lead act.

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
99. Are you talking Sanders????
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 01:28 AM
Nov 2016

He never stood for all Americans. He never stood for me. Nor most of my friends.

LisaM

(27,813 posts)
36. Exactly.
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 07:32 PM
Nov 2016

Hillary was going for the complete opposite, the politics of non-identity. In the meantime, her opponent is endorsed by the KKK (and doesn't repudiate it, either).

But the candidate who wanted to bring together women, POC, the LGBT community, immigrants, and Latinos is somehow the person who is running on identity politics.

Of all the gaslighting techniques people have employed, this is about the worst one yet.

 

LittleBlue

(10,362 posts)
12. Class struggle is a winner
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 06:18 PM
Nov 2016

It's how we won with Obama in 2008. It's how we actually won a mid-term in 2006. This is why Bernie was so popular. He was talking about doing things for every section of society. It gave him more broad appeal than narrowly focusing on race.

Using language like what's used in the OP will just cause further exodus of whites from our party. Meaning you can look forward to a filibuster proof Trump. Fun!

Language like this is also completely unhelpful: "You really want to abandon that cause?" Accusatory straw-man language is why we morphed into an echo chamber and lost.

 

Grey Lemercier

(1,429 posts)
81. Bernie was so popular that he got crushed by millions of votes
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 10:53 PM
Nov 2016

in the goddamn PRIMARY!!!!!!

I am going to bloody well scream if this revisionist shit is continuously lathered up and spread about like some plazzy body scrub in a 20 quid "massage" parlour.

Between shitfuck tangerine plonker Trump, the nazi white trash scum who voted for him but NOW so many are beggin us to chase around like a 3-legged dog chasing a fucking bone on a string, and the baying, bleating "Sanders really won or would have" set, I swear I am gonna snap.

AND, of course, EVERY time I take a butcher's, who is getting gets tossed under the fucking bus? Us women or us people of colour or us LGBTQ folk!!!

Go on Democratic Party, chase after yer fucking racist hate-driven crackers, convince them you can hide us non white non straight non males a long enough time to get their short little fat fucking fingers to hold their nose and vote blue!!!

FUCK THIS SHIT

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
100. Sorry No.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 01:39 AM
Nov 2016
This is why Bernie was so popular. He was talking about doing things for every section of society.


Every section of society....



It gave him more broad appeal than narrowly focusing on race.



LiberalLovinLug

(14,174 posts)
159. So working for "every section of society" is hillarious to you
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 03:21 PM
Nov 2016

Pray tell, what "sections" would you leave out?

JI7

(89,252 posts)
118. Obama didn't win on Class Struggle. he won because of his own personal appeal regardless of issues
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 05:54 AM
Nov 2016

Amishman

(5,557 posts)
14. Abandon no, lower in importance and focus yes
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 06:19 PM
Nov 2016

We need less social justice emphasis and more economic justice

Our focus needs to be on wages, jobs, and the environment. We should spend more time talking about these subjects than everything else combined.

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
28. If you are saying this...
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 06:59 PM
Nov 2016
Abandon no, lower in importance and focus yes

We need less social justice emphasis and more economic justice


then by your standards Bernie would be President. He did not even win the Primary.

jonno99

(2,620 posts)
15. No. But diversity is only an asset (really) as long as
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 06:22 PM
Nov 2016

there is an underlying unity.

Unless you think you have nothing in common with an out-of-work middle-aged white guy...

GWC58

(2,678 posts)
63. That would be me.
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 08:26 PM
Nov 2016

I proudly voted for Hillary. This election made me realize this nation has a lot, a hell of a lot, of bigoted, racist, sexist, misogynistic, frightened, ignorant and overall stupid people. Many that voted for tRump are going to be pissed when he back peddles on what he said he'd do. Funny thing is they won't blame tRump. No, they'll blame Obama, or Hillary, the Democratic Party, or a combination of the three. 😠😡

Stryst

(714 posts)
139. I can tell you that at my American Legion meetings
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 11:56 AM
Nov 2016

Everyone I know who was going to vote Democrat talked about having to hold their nose to vote for Clinton. Everyone I know who planned on voting Republican was *stoked* to vote for Trump. This resulted in some bizarre justifications for Trump; for example, every service person I know (and I kinda know a lot) was unhappy having a leader in office who might command them to go into battle, but could be not bothered to serve themselves. Or were to cowardly, if they'd had some drinks. Their children couldn't be bothered to serve this nation. Oh, but Trump had an excuse. Remember those bone spurs?

Trump is a used car salesman who's learned the swindlers trick to turning defect into feature. The only way to deal with someone like that is to shine the light of day on them.

So maybe some recounts?

 

LittleBlue

(10,362 posts)
39. Let them, it's a loser
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 07:36 PM
Nov 2016

It only works if we do it too. Polarizing the electorate along racial lines is a loser when 67% of the country is white. Let them own that mess while we focus on bringing healthcare, education and jobs to people who need it. That is our path back. That is how we can win again.

Let's not be like Labour in the UK, where the party had an identity crisis, imploded and barely exists now. Same thing happened to the left in Israel.

I can 100% guarantee that in 2020, if we promote solutions that will help people and the alt-right can only produce Tila Tequila, Bannon, and Nazi salutes, we win.

 

LittleBlue

(10,362 posts)
47. We can't make any progress if we don't win
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 07:45 PM
Nov 2016

Progress is dependent on winning states and having a good electoral strategy, not just espousing general ideals or chastising racial groups.

Losing elections destroys progress.

Not trying to have a go at you, Josh. I just don't see how we make any progress if we've lost every branch of government.

joshcryer

(62,276 posts)
48. Their jobs are not coming back.
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 07:56 PM
Nov 2016

And they will see that their idealized vision isn't happening. We look at the futile attempt to make fossil fuels have a comeback, just not happening.

The white nationalism must be resisted, vanquished a and exposed for exactly what it is. Unfortunately it's going to have to come at great pain to whites most of all, for buying into the rhetoric in literally the very states who cannot and will not be blessed by it.

yardwork

(61,650 posts)
69. Aren't white people an identity? How is appealing to whites not identity politics?
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 09:04 PM
Nov 2016

I'm white. I've noticed that white is somehow the default - the normal, the standard - while every other ethnicity gets labeled as an "identity."

 

LittleBlue

(10,362 posts)
75. I don't think focusing on jobs, healthcare and education for everyone
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 09:54 PM
Nov 2016

is identity politics.

Class politics >>>> identity politics. Bernie knew but we didn't listen.

radical noodle

(8,003 posts)
103. Healthcare? Education?
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 01:57 AM
Nov 2016

Most of the people who voted for Trump are totally against healthcare for all. Many of them disdain education. They would have run from Bernie and his higher taxes and free-stuff-for-all.

 

LittleBlue

(10,362 posts)
115. Oh, I agree. That's why I say Bernie has wide appeal.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 04:12 AM
Nov 2016

But Bernie also opposed the TPP and he talked about stopping the outsourcing of jobs. That plays to every shade of the political spectrum, at least among working class people.

We need a candidate who can give something to everyone. We need broad appeal again. We can win by 85m votes in California, but it doesn't mean shit unless we can win Midwestern states.

DonCoquixote

(13,616 posts)
92. this
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 12:25 AM
Nov 2016

we have been spending 30 years trying to appease Reagan democrats. Of course ,we need to focus on the economy, but as long as civil rights can get kicked to the curb, you will have an economy that is weak as it cuts out many people that could otherwise help it.

Or maybe some "democrats" feel that as long as white older males get what they want, to hell with everyone else. I do not think Bernie feels that way, but it seems a lot that invoke him do. That must be how Jesus feels whenever he hears rich people gloss over that bit about how a rich man getting into heaven as is likely as a camel going through the eye of a needle.

backscatter712

(26,355 posts)
167. "Identity politics" is French for "Get back to the back of the bus!"
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 04:17 PM
Nov 2016

And it's the code word for Blue Dogs and DINOs whose only goal is "Get Blue Dog politicians elected" instead of "Fight for Democratic values." It's the battle cry for that faction of the party that got its way this election season, and gave the country a campaign of "We suck less!" Doesn't that make you fired up and ready to go?

Civil rights is a CORE DEMOCRATIC VALUE. And when people see the Quisling Democrats throw this core value aside just to pander for votes from racist pieces of shit that would never vote for them in the first place, it makes the entire party, and the entire country suffer.

Democrats need to return to the core values. They include fighting for poor and working people, and yes, they absolutely must include fighting for civil rights for black people, Latinos, LGBTQIA people, Muslims, women, and every other oppressed group.

When we stop doing what's right because it seems inconvenient and pisses off the assholes that write big checks, that's when we lose.

 

7962

(11,841 posts)
173. You "get" it. Seems nobody else does. Just keep splitting us apart ......
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 04:34 PM
Nov 2016

and we'll get more of the same

Response to Cosmocat (Reply #25)

boston bean

(36,221 posts)
19. Very true. And I don't usually like this guy..
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 06:27 PM
Nov 2016

but I have also said if I would have changed anything it would have been the choice of Tim Kaine.

We need to turn out the obama coalition. if we do that we win outright and they can't steal it.

But even with that said and done, it cannot be underestimated the harm Comey did to Hillary. I believe he is the one true reason she lost above and beyond anything else. And that is a fucking disgrace for our democracy. Interference from a federal law enforcement agency in our elections disgust me to my core.

 

forjusticethunders

(1,151 posts)
65. It's a reasonable assumption though ultimately wrong
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 08:35 PM
Nov 2016

Trump on the ballot would have turned out the Coalition by itself.

 

duffyduff

(3,251 posts)
95. It wasn't Comey--the problem was early on with Zucker and CNN peddling 24/7 Trump.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 01:07 AM
Nov 2016

It was literally tampering with the primaries by media for ratings and ad revenue. Trump was NOT a serious candidate and even a bigger joke than Sanders.

Now we have a batshit crazy person about to enter the White House thanks to this massive malfeasance by the media.

 

mythology

(9,527 posts)
23. How did that just work out for us?
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 06:34 PM
Nov 2016

It's a little hard to ask for somebody's vote when you're telling them to go fuck themselves.

If we can feel for the difficulties around issues other groups have, why can we not feel for the difficulty a poor or middle class white guy has? Is his loss of identity, or sense of self, or trouble paying the bills somehow less just because he was born white? If nothing else, finding a way to convince them that we care about their issues, makes it easier to put legislation in place to care about other groups. For example, think about the difference a Trump/Pence presiduncy is going to be like compared to Clinton/Kaine on gay rights.

BlueStater

(7,596 posts)
27. No amount of suffering could ever make me vote for a vile sack of shit like Trump.
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 06:56 PM
Nov 2016

I'm finding it extremely hard to be all that empathetic, especially since the white working class doesn't seem to give a damn about all the minorities that will suffer under this rancid excuse for a human being.

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
37. Sure would help if they actually understood what Trump actually stood for.
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 07:33 PM
Nov 2016
It hasn't stopped yet, this constant thrum of voices telling us that we need to "understand" the "pain" and the "fear" of Trump voters. "We," in this case, are the ones who look at those Americans and see the most loathsome versions of ourselves, the ill-informed, the overly credulous, the willing patsies, the greedy marks, the covetous fools, and the racist shits. In order to move ahead, we must reach out to this group, we're told, that we, who supported the auto industry bailout and health care and food stamps and job retraining and addiction services, we whose liberal policies kept them from flat out dying, we are the ones who didn't get it. What a goddamned joke to tell us that we don't understand and those who tried to cut or prevent or get rid of all of those things do understand.


They vote against their own best interest every time. So they vote for the team that will take away all that the Dems fought so hard to give them, gave all of us. You have to ask why a tRump supporter is in such pain and fear. First the Cons stoke the fear, " They will come for your guns. Build that wall. Keep America safe from anyone that happens to have a different skin color. They will take your jobs. They will plunder your homes. Move in next door to you and rape your daughters."

They are ill informed and welcome patsies and yes racist shits that fear losing their white privilege.

Trust me I sure as hell know the difference between T/P vs C/K and sure extends beyond gay rights. They will be taking away women's, POC, black, Jews, Muslim, all rights of those that are not like them. The right to healthcare, choice, voting, equality. All of it and that makes all our lives at risk, more now than ever before.
 

JCanete

(5,272 posts)
30. Some people like a divided populace clearly. This piece is fucking horrible. Do you think that once
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 07:10 PM
Nov 2016

minorities finally outnumber whites in America that our politics are going to look different? That there won't be people to discriminate against and point to for any strains on the new middle class(assuming we still have one)? Divisive politics work now and will work in the future because we aren't going to the heart of the issue. Sure, the news media has its head up its ass, and its analysis of white pain is mostly missing the boat, because it assumes that people are right about why they are suffering, not simply that they are suffering and as such are susceptible to bullshit.

We actually do need to court these voters, partly for the sake of educating them. I keep saying it, but I"ll repeat here again. We need a class warfare platform, because it breaks down walls between people that were artificial in the first place. The middle class shouldn't be looking at the poor and minority families as their enemies. We could give them a truer narrative about why they are experiencing financial insecurity. Not because the immigrants are taking their jobs or welfare is taking their tax dollars, but because they are getting screwed by the increasingly wealthier upper class, that loves it when we all fight over the scraps, because we're crawling around on the floor and not watching for the boot that's kicking us.

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
49. Well, I think the article is great.
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 07:57 PM
Nov 2016

You said:

"Some people like a divided populace clearly. This piece is fucking horrible. Do you think that once minorities finally outnumber whites in America that our politics are going to look different? That there won't be people to discriminate against and point to for any strains on the new middle class(assuming we still have one)?"


Why do you think they are so fearful? White American is on it's way out the door. Not soon enough for me, yet soon. As a white woman I embrace the diversity and do strongly believe that we will see a stronger more forgiving nation.
 

JCanete

(5,272 posts)
58. The white middle class are afraid of this. The people who own everything, who happen to be
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 08:04 PM
Nov 2016

predominantly white in this country, aren't afraid of this at all. They love this kind of mistrust. The sell it. Why do you believe that things are going to change out of diversity alone? You have to believe in your heart of hearts that people aren't people if you believe that...that there is something actually unique to white male humans on a genetic level, to think that the same bullshit doesn't infect people across the spectrum now and wont tomorrow. You are advocating, and so is the article, that we continue to fight for the scraps. We point at the racist white men, they point back at the immigrants and the poor. We slug it out. We all lose. The same people keep winning.

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
106. Disagree.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 02:12 AM
Nov 2016

All white men fear the change, all of them. The power is going to tip. They are not selling they are fearful.

My opinion and it is mine alone...

You have to believe in your heart of hearts that people aren't people if you believe that...that there is something actually unique to white male humans on a genetic level, to think that the same bullshit doesn't infect people across the spectrum now and wont tomorrow.


White men have held all the power for far to long. Slavery or over a woman's head. They have had far to much power over who we are and what we want to become. They are fearful. I truly believe most will be far kinder when times change. Send me a note when it happens, let me know if I was right I will be gone before 2043-2050.

whathehell

(29,067 posts)
165. Excellent article..
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 04:08 PM
Nov 2016

The OP should read it for this truism, if for nothing else. "If you want someone to listen to you, don't offend them".

 

melman

(7,681 posts)
110. Maybe you could realize
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 02:54 AM
Nov 2016

That not everyone is going to cheer and give 'recs' for this crap.

Your choice.

Horse with no Name

(33,956 posts)
40. I'm listening to this and wondering myself
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 07:38 PM
Nov 2016

why can't we appeal to the working class? Why specifically the WHITE working class? To me, that insinuates that whites are the ONLY ones that work--and I don't think that I am the only one that reads it as such.
Kaine was a horrible pick--I completely agree.
There were so many good choices and that one certainly didn't make me happy.

BlueStater

(7,596 posts)
52. Obama tried to reach to the white working class.
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 07:59 PM
Nov 2016

He offered things like job retraining to coal miners. They didn't want his help. They wanted a bunch of fairy tales and bullshit from a con man about their dangerous, environmentally-unfriendly jobs coming back.

dogman

(6,073 posts)
59. Except for card check.
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 08:15 PM
Nov 2016

Unions got screwed again and people wonder why the membership could not be sold on the Party. They know their jobs are not coming back. What jobs were they retrained for and what did those jobs offer compared to their lost jobs? It was a GOP agreement but it carried the Clinton signature.

whathehell

(29,067 posts)
166. Yup..
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 04:15 PM
Nov 2016

It would have helped a lot if he had done more for unions...I thought he really missed an opportunity when he didn't go to Wisconsin and stand with that huge union uprising.

 

liquid diamond

(1,917 posts)
80. My thoughts exactly
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 10:40 PM
Nov 2016

I'm sick of seeing posts here persuading us to reach out to these stupid and racists ass hats. Those making such a ridiculous plea are probably white too. Smdh. WTF happened to DU?

yallerdawg

(16,104 posts)
50. Confusing 'identity politics' with 'tokenism.
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 07:57 PM
Nov 2016
http://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2016/11/23/13715164/bernie-sanders-identity-politics-democrats-progressives

Vox is pointing out that Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton are not 'tokens.'

But to people who actually practice “identity politics,” Sanders is presenting a straw man. He’s describing tokenism — the idea that you need a certain quota of “token” members of marginalized groups for the sake of “diversity,” regardless of whether those members are actually qualified or actually represent their group’s interests.

The very idea of tokenism has some offensive implications, though. And it’s not at all what identity politics are really about.

Generally speaking, identity politics is about recognizing and acting on the fact that different groups can have different interests, goals, and policy needs. It doesn’t require pitting those groups against each other, although it’s often presented that way. Rather, it’s about acknowledging that American politics tends to treat the “white male” identity as the default — and every other identity as some sort of optional bonus feature.

We have to have a Big Tent or we'll continue to lose elections we shouldn't lose.

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
57. Dayum fine link, yallerdawg.
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 08:04 PM
Nov 2016

From your link...


Jose Vilson, NBCT
✔ ?@TheJLV

"Identity politics" is now used as a pejorative for "keep racism / sexism out of this." https://twitter.com/nhannahjones/status/801055179931938816

10:44 AM - 22 Nov 2016

yallerdawg

(16,104 posts)
60. You know what I think.
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 08:15 PM
Nov 2016

We had plenty of 'white working class' if those who supported Senator Sanders (I-VT) had actually voted for the Democratic nominee.

Instead, they did exactly what they warned us they would do. Yes, I remember.

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
93. Yes they did!
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 12:56 AM
Nov 2016

I am sure they are very proud.

Their medicare? Not so secure. I wonder what they are doing tonight.

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
70. ;)
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 09:06 PM
Nov 2016

Ouch...................................

They be crying crying...

Well they can kiss my lily white ass,

 

86derps

(44 posts)
67. Reality!
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 08:52 PM
Nov 2016

The reality is this election was "rigged". Our politics is "rigged" by establishment cronies. Rigged by the wealthy elites and the large corporations that donate large sums of money and lobby Washington. The Koch brothers, ALEC, etc as well. Voter suppression. Corporate media. Electronic voting. DNC. RNC. You name it. The fact is Hillary Clinton represents the political establishment and she couldn't counter Trumps attacks even though his attacks were really against Republican ideals.

Obamacare was the Republican alternative to Hillarycare implemented by Romney in Massachusetts.
NAFTA was a Republican agreement that Bush Sr had blocked by Democrates until Clinton one office and got it passed by Dems.
The deficit, caused by Republican Presidents.
Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act which overturned Glass-Steagall were all Republican Senators, but yes Bill Clinton got it pushed through.

Hillary was simply unable to defend the attacks because she is an establishment politician. To say that Bernie would not have done better is absolutely ridiculous. Trump might have hit him on being a socialist, but that's it. The fact is the country, democrats and republicans, are tired of establishment politics. This is to me, the main reason why Trump became the republican candidate in the first place. Establishment politics should now be over for good.

ismnotwasm

(41,989 posts)
76. Did you vote for Hillary?
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 10:09 PM
Nov 2016

And there is much more on Sanders besides Socialism that would have been dredged up. He is, after all, a career politician. Very much a part of the political establishment. To pretend otherwise is absolutely ridiculous.

 

Elmergantry

(884 posts)
68. "Your White "Pain" Can Go Fuck Itself"
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 08:57 PM
Nov 2016

Sounds like a winning slogan for the midterms! Its like a double down on "deplorables"...yea run with that! let me know how that works out!

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
72. These are the deplorables.
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 09:28 PM
Nov 2016
West Virginia Mayor Resigns After She and Another Official Called Michelle Obama an ‘Ape in Heels’ in Facebook Post

http://nymag.com/thecut/2016/11/west-virginia-officials-called-michelle-obama-ape-in-heels.html

Let me know how this works for you!

AgadorSparticus

(7,963 posts)
71. I don't understand all this white pain.
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 09:26 PM
Nov 2016

You automatically have an advantage just by the color of your skin. You are accepted in just about every situation and given the benefit of the doubt. The social scale is tipped in your favor.

It kind of reminds me of all these persecuted christians. Everything is Christian and white based. Everything. HOW is there persecution? I don't understand this pain when you are at the top of the laddeR and in the dominant social structure. It is not like there are SO MANY ethnic holidays that is nationally recognized to even threaten you. I bring up the Christian thing just because of this time of year and I am already seeing it on my Facebook newsfeed how the christians are going to fight all the anti christians and say, "merry Christmas!"

Because.....there is not enough Christmas? I mean, hell, it fucking starts in September now! You can't go anywhere and not see over the top Christmas displays. If I was a Christian and had to pick something to scream about, I would be screaming about the commercialization of Christmas. ...not because someone didn't say merry Christmas or xmas or whatever. These people are fucking clueless. But moreso, they are incredibly self absorbed and narcissistic. (Interestingly, all the people that post about saying merry Christmas are all Trump supporters.)

As for the future of the democratic party, I have always like the inclusive tone. It fits everyone. I am not sure about going after the color. I think if we stand for the ideals, then the color shouldn't matter. The white that aren't racist will be democrats and hold the same ideals. The angry whites that we hear about now are rascist assholes. I don't think that will ever change. I am not sure going after that vote will be productive. But I would love to have seen more women and poc represented in offices. Maybe the next POTUS or vp pick?

radical noodle

(8,003 posts)
104. I am white and I see it all the time
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 02:07 AM
Nov 2016

For the most part white pain is a result of them no longer feeling quite so superior. Christian pain is the same thing. Both see that their majorities are shrinking. When they are in the minority what will happen? Will they be treated like <gasp!> they treated minorities? They want to hang on to their overwhelming right to privilege.

gollygee

(22,336 posts)
78. It must be nice to have an identity you can disregard when you vote
Wed Nov 23, 2016, 10:17 PM
Nov 2016

But I am concerned about birth control access. And I have an LGBT kid. I can't ignore those identity issues. Heterosexual white men know their rights won't take any hits based on their identity, so they're happy to ignore it. Oh wait, I guess they didn't actually ignore their identity, as they've got a whole white nationalist government going now.

 

duffyduff

(3,251 posts)
98. White dudes are all about "their" identity. They think the world revolves around them.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 01:10 AM
Nov 2016

Minorities are stupid, gays are bad, and women have no place in the labor market taking "their" jobs away from them.

They are idiots, and you can't reach them, you can't fix them. That is why this nonsense of the "working class" has no basis in reality.

Yavin4

(35,442 posts)
101. The real "White" pain is fear of no longer being the dominant racial group in America
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 01:43 AM
Nov 2016

It has NOTHING to do with factory closings in the Rust Belt. That's all bullshit on toast. These folks fear that other groups will overtake them numerically. No out reach program is going to work with them.

 

heaven05

(18,124 posts)
137. exactly
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 11:52 AM
Nov 2016

bottom line to counter all the 'intellectualizing' and acceptance of the "normalization" of the racist bloc that voted in the New Nazi Party of AmeriKKKa, posing as house and senate reubliKKKans and their trumpfuhrer along with his Iron Booted anti-semite Bannnon racist

world wide wally

(21,744 posts)
113. Don't forget Hillary got more than 2 million more votes than Trump
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 03:21 AM
Nov 2016

Now ask yourself this: Why do Democrats have to win by more than 2 million votes and Republicans only need to win by 1 vote?…… or not even win at all?

Because the Electoral College is as bad as gerrymandering?
Because the original slave states always get to deal?
Why does one vote in Wyoming equal 3 in California?
Why is the "one man - one vote" just some hyped up bullshit?
When did our democracy die?

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
114. It died Tuesday November 8 2016
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 03:30 AM
Nov 2016

First woman won by over 2 million votes and then a Nazi won the election.

The day America died.

Bad Dog

(2,025 posts)
116. The decline of heavy industry is a feature throughout the West.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 04:17 AM
Nov 2016

It was a factor in the Brexit campaign too, and may have just been what handed the election to Trump. There is a group of people who feel that the recovery is something that happens to other people. There is some justification in that, financiers and bankers are making a lot of money while people living in places like Sheffield and Detroit are still badly off.

Trump spoke to them, he may have talked a load of old bollocks, and they may have bought a load of snakeoil, but the point remains, while certain members of the elite are perceived to be making a fortune off the backs of ordinary workers then people will listen to extremists peddling simple answers to complex solutions.

 

jack_krass

(1,009 posts)
138. I think theyre smarter than we (at least at this blog) give them credit for....
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 11:56 AM
Nov 2016

They instinctively know that a country with no (or a depleted) industrial/manufactiring base cannot remain a superpower. I happen to agree with this, though of course not the conclusion that Trump is the one to "fix" it.

Democrats should have been pushing this meme HARD. Hillarys statement about putting coal out of business was a catastrophic blunder (IMO, worse than the emails). I cannot tell you how many times I heard that repaeted, and extrapolated to other insustries like oil, or even manufacturing in general.

Bad Dog

(2,025 posts)
143. Coal is uneconomic.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 12:12 PM
Nov 2016

It's not just dirty, it's a lot more expensive than gas. Trump won't be able to fix that. I think that the people who will really miss out are those in the rustbelt who thought he'd be able to fix things.

The problem isn't free trade it's worker exploitation. If the rules were changed to ensure foreign workers making Western products had the same rights as their counterparts in the West then the difference in prices won't be so extreme.

 

jack_krass

(1,009 posts)
147. Yeah I know all that, but heres where optics and messaging come unto play
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 12:55 PM
Nov 2016

Last edited Thu Nov 24, 2016, 05:19 PM - Edit history (1)

As a politician, I wouldnt go and say Im gonna "put people out of business". It comes off as heavy handed and cruel (where do those workers go?), plus it leaves too much open to extrapolation (ie Ive heard people ask "what other industries does she want to put out of business&quot .

I dont think HRC planned to shut down coal production and coal fired power production... Honestly I think it was just a brainfart. But why not say that?

Yavin4

(35,442 posts)
146. Your facts are wrong.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 12:47 PM
Nov 2016

First heavy industry is not in decline. Rather, it's uses less and less workers as more processes are automated.

Yavin4

(35,442 posts)
175. It's not nitpicking. It's the truth.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 05:51 PM
Nov 2016
The U.S. has lost 5 million factory jobs since 2000. And trade has indeed claimed production jobs – in particular when China joined the World Trade Organization in 2001. Nevertheless, there was no downturn in U.S. manufacturing output. As a matter of fact, U.S. production has been growing over the last decades. From 2006 to 2013, “manufacturing grew by 17.6%, or at roughly 2.2% per year,” according to a report from Ball State University. The study reports as well that trade accounted for 13% of the lost U.S. factory jobs, but 88% of the jobs were taken by robots and other factors at home.

If not China, what then explains these jobs losses? It’s simple: factories don’t need as many workers as they used to, because robots increasingly do the work.


http://fortune.com/2016/11/08/china-automation-jobs/

Bad Dog

(2,025 posts)
182. It is nitpicking.
Fri Nov 25, 2016, 04:57 AM
Nov 2016

I had to look up Ball State University, not exactly Ivy League. There is a decline, quite a substantial one.

With the exception of a few brief periods, America’s contribution to the global economy has been falling. In 1960, U.S. GDP represented 40% of global GDP. By 2014, America’s economic contribution had been cut in half.


http://www.forbes.com/sites/mikepatton/2016/02/29/u-s-role-in-global-economy-declines-nearly-50/#20bf527259c1

That's not increased mechanisation, it's global competition.
 

heaven05

(18,124 posts)
140. nope,Rude is not wrong!!!!
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 11:58 AM
Nov 2016

trying to intellectualize white hate by dismissing the open hate that is being generated, agitated against non-whites? That is painfully wrong, literally for many.

 

jack_krass

(1,009 posts)
122. "Let them eat pain": A wonderful strategy for dems to lose every local, state, and national positio
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 10:01 AM
Nov 2016

I'm flabbergasted that anyone on our side could see this outburst of idiocy as helpful. Is this guy a RW plant?

As for Identity politics: It is POISON, and also a loser politically. Besides being built on a philosophical foundation of jello, it is by nature divisive and just plain evil and wrong.

United we stand, divided we fall. The Democratic party must stand for ideals, and for working people no natter what their color. I pray that the new generation of our leadership will RUN from the ideas of identity politics as fast as they can.

RP: my suggestion os to take your own advise.

 

heaven05

(18,124 posts)
136. Oh I'm so impressed with your advice....NOT!!!!!!
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 11:46 AM
Nov 2016

We are divided and it's not the Democratic Party's fault really. It's the oh so sensitive that don't want to face the very real racist and crude ameriKKKa that the reubliKKKans found a way to embolden and who, by the way, have been agitating white racist reaction to 64-65 Voting and Civil Rights Acts, since atwater, to finalize their status as the breakers of promises to all who are not white males, and might even get back to land owning white males. Maybe 25,000 acres or more? No fucking joke.

There is a place for intellectualizing reality but can't intellectualize white, racist hate from 21st century nazis and the KKK brownshirt cohorts. The Democratic Party leadership on the late night, early morning Nov 8-9 were looking like Rove in the 2012 when Romney was expected to win. He blustered that night, we folded quietly on the night of our defeat to the NNPA and really haven't been heard from since. My current POTUS is the only one really saying what needs to be said about the white racist pig, that is trumpfuhrer. . IDEALS????!!!! Where? When? White people in large numbers are on the march blatently shouting, "I'm white, I'm in pain because their are no manufacturing jobs in amerikkka anymore. The N***** andF***** has equal rights, and I can't use my rights to hate them and "put them in their place". They whined and cried for the last 44 years and used "reverse fucking racism", "the race card". Now apply that truth to explain the size of the racist army that has, either by stealth or now openly is trying to put the AA underfoot, again. Rude is not wrong and it is not "idiocy" to face the harsh truth. AmeriKKKa and it's ameriKKKan citizens has ALWAYS been racist, sexist and this last election has shown the numbers, finally.

I'm flabbbergasted that people actually think playing nice with the nazis and KKK will get us anywhere. We better find a fucking identity to counter the identity that will be foisted on all of us Jan20, 2017. That being the white supremacists identity shown to the whole world. There is a place for intellectualizing our dilema, but that comes after the grunt work of turning back the racist, sexist hordes on the march again. You know what, there are places I have to avoid when driving, again. A white person sped up on a friend and his wife in the parking lot of a major store's parking lot and gave the finger when passing. Thee coward didn't stop when a full cup of coffee was thrown against his car. THIS is what is going on out here. How do we deal with it???? I need an answer. Why is Rude seen as a RW plant by saying play rough, take no shit and you cannot be seen as the same saying essentially, play nice? Rude, I love his reality and truth, not some playland somewhere with white picket fence and huge southern columns on the mansion, hiding the 'cotton fields' behind and denying that they hate n****** and f******!!!!!

 

jack_krass

(1,009 posts)
151. "think playing nice with the nazis and KKK" who said that???
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 01:20 PM
Nov 2016

the working class people (including around 20% of black men) in the rust belt who voted for Trump ARE NOT RACIST (OR NAZI FFS). im getting sick and tired of hearing this. I live in Michigan and know many, many of these people, have many like this in my family and in-laws, as well as friends, neighbors, and coworkers, white, brown, and black. These are people we never should have let vote for Trump. And with the right message and candidate, can be won back. With divisive, false messaging like the OP however, more will be lost.

These people just want good jobs, are alarmed that the industrial base is shrinking. And for whatever reason, they see Trump as the one who will "fix" it. What I hear most is that he can do this because hes a "businessman". Maybe these people ate misguded, but they are not racists.

sheshe2

(83,791 posts)
174. Great rant.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 05:24 PM
Nov 2016

I am so sorry for what happened to your friends and to you, heaven. The man that was elected has made it okay to hate anyone openly. I have no idea what we are going to be facing in the next four years. I can only see a storm coming, I just hope we can minimize the casualties. Stay safe.

Chemisse

(30,813 posts)
126. I disagree.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 10:28 AM
Nov 2016

Yes, we should energize the non-whites. But we should not leave out the white Trump-types. (And please keep in mind that there were many, many whites who voted for Clinton, so watch out with the broad swath).

The Trump voters made up a huge segment that we should NOT be ignoring! We just have to appeal to them. I'm not talking about those excited by his racism, but those excited because he would bring "change" and jobs to them. Many live in rural areas that are economically desolate. That pain is real when your kids can't get jobs and can't afford college, and turn to drugs and drug addiction. It's real and it's awful, no matter what color you are.

Obviously Trump isn't the answer, but they thought he was. Next time around they need to think the Dem candidate is the one who will pull them out of it.

Buckeye_Democrat

(14,855 posts)
127. More white people voted for Clinton than all non-whites combined.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 10:30 AM
Nov 2016

At least if the exit polls from the election were accurate.
http://edition.cnn.com/election/results/exit-polls

Yes, I'm aware that even MORE white people voted for Trump!

It still provides some perspective, though. Let's not push away white people (like me) at this point because that's a losing battle given the numbers.

Red Oak

(697 posts)
176. Your post doesn't fit the current narrative
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 06:27 PM
Nov 2016

We are the "aggrieved" party now and must face our misogynistiic, bigoted, homophobic battles before turning to winning elections and fighting Trump.

We are not one, obviously, not even close.

My friend is now my enemy.

Makes me sick.

Red Oak

(697 posts)
128. Yes! Let's split the party!
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 10:34 AM
Nov 2016

-Sarcasm-

Maybe we need to split into two (losing) parties

The Aggrieved party

The White (Pain) party

That should help us win!

Buckeye_Democrat

(14,855 posts)
129. If we ever adopted a parliamentary government, it might work.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 10:38 AM
Nov 2016

I personally don't like our "winner take all" system of government (which makes it harder for various third parties to arise that represent various groups), but it won't be going away unless we have a truly chaotic collapse someday.

I'd probably join a "Science Party" if such a thing existed. Lol. I'm all-Democrat in our current system, however.

backscatter712

(26,355 posts)
164. A-fucking-men. The instant I hear racist/misogynistic/homophobic slurs out of white trash mouths...
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 03:56 PM
Nov 2016

...my sympathy for them dies.

They can wallow in their own shit for all I care. It's what they deserve.

No sympathy for bigots.

 

7962

(11,841 posts)
172. Jeeze the blame just never ends does it. Now calling people dogs. Fabulous.
Thu Nov 24, 2016, 04:32 PM
Nov 2016

Funny how Trump got twice as many black & hispanic votes than Romney.
This place is looking more and more like a bad imitation of freeperville

jalan48

(13,870 posts)
180. Sounds like a power struggle in the Democratic Party to me.
Fri Nov 25, 2016, 02:35 AM
Nov 2016

If we kick one group out there will be more room in the Party for other groups to grow or increase their own power. Identity politics indeed.

Garrett78

(10,721 posts)
185. Good article. And as Charles Pierce wrote in response to a woman's reason for voting for Trump:
Sun Nov 27, 2016, 05:05 AM
Nov 2016
There literally is no innovative political strategy, and there is no creative policy prescription, that would have convinced that woman to vote for Hillary Rodham Clinton. She is so deeply sunk in the mire of misinformation that she never will be pulled out again. Who is it, precisely, that doesn't care about her, and how was that manifested in her daily life? How, precisely, would Donald Trump care about her? The piece is replete with these kind of moments. What should the Democrats do to meet halfway the guy who believes the nation is being "pussified"? What's precisely the political outreach strategy that will bring back a guy who says this?


We must accept that a large chunk of eligible voters (at least 20%, I'd say) simply can't be reached by the Democratic Party. They live in an alternate reality from which there's no return.
 

NobodyHere

(2,810 posts)
186. So in other words white people are bad
Sun Nov 27, 2016, 12:11 PM
Nov 2016

Got it.


Sometimes I have to wonder if it's even worth it to be a democrat anymore.

Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»2016 Postmortem»Your White "Pain" Can Go ...