Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
28 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
A good video of E Warren talking about how Hillary helped stop a bankruptcy bill. (Original Post) Snotcicles Jul 2015 OP
"As Senator Clinton, the pressures are very different," arcane1 Jul 2015 #1
Right on Elizabeth! Keep exposing the truth. InAbLuEsTaTe Jul 2015 #26
Her natural constituency - Wall$treet Bank$ter$ peacebird Jul 2015 #2
It's understandable...can't say I'm surprised. It's natural to stand up for your friends. InAbLuEsTaTe Jul 2015 #27
K & R !!! WillyT Jul 2015 #3
From your link "Clips: Elizabeth Warren Takes on Hillary Clinton and Alan Greenspan" slipslidingaway Jul 2015 #4
And than look what happened. How many families lost their homes. nt Snotcicles Jul 2015 #5
Exactly!!! Some people had a clue :( thanks for the link! n/t slipslidingaway Jul 2015 #6
So sad. InAbLuEsTaTe Jul 2015 #28
Bernie took on Greenspan also. Bernie and Elizabeth are the future of this country. sabrina 1 Jul 2015 #23
Bernie sure did ... slipslidingaway Jul 2015 #25
But THEN... wyldwolf Jul 2015 #7
Interesting ... "Clinton Slammed for Vote On 2001 Bankruptcy Bill slipslidingaway Jul 2015 #11
Would you post a link to this comment please ... slipslidingaway Jul 2015 #12
That bankruptcy law (BAPCPA) stole from the poor; DirkGently Jul 2015 #8
It was a did not vote, her first I believe. nt Snotcicles Jul 2015 #10
She did vote for it in 2001, it died in Congress. HooptieWagon Jul 2015 #16
in 2005, she did vote to filibuster it, but the Democrats karynnj Jul 2015 #24
K&R jwirr Jul 2015 #9
Thanks for this loveallserveall Jul 2015 #13
She actually didn't vote on the bill in 2005. but it did pass. Snotcicles Jul 2015 #14
But she did vote for a similar bill in 2001, which died in Congress. HooptieWagon Jul 2015 #17
probably another issue she's evolved on Doctor_J Jul 2015 #15
Clinton voted for the 2001 Bankruptcy bill, link to vote and another video with Warren ... slipslidingaway Jul 2015 #18
The last vote was 2/2005. Bill Clinton's quadruple bypass surgery was in 9/2004 if I'm not mistaken. Snotcicles Jul 2015 #19
Clinton definitely voted for the 2001 bankruptcy bill ... slipslidingaway Jul 2015 #20
Here is a good site to look at votes, better yet did not votes. I'm seeing theme here Snotcicles Jul 2015 #21
Thx, voting when you have the power to make a difference means more ... slipslidingaway Jul 2015 #22
 

arcane1

(38,613 posts)
1. "As Senator Clinton, the pressures are very different,"
Mon Jul 13, 2015, 06:53 PM
Jul 2015

"As Senator Clinton, the pressures are very different," Warren told Moyers. "She has taken money from the groups, and more to the point, she worries about them as a constituency."

slipslidingaway

(21,210 posts)
4. From your link "Clips: Elizabeth Warren Takes on Hillary Clinton and Alan Greenspan"
Mon Jul 13, 2015, 07:30 PM
Jul 2015
http://billmoyers.com/2014/09/05/clips-elizabeth-warren-takes-on-hillary-clinton-and-alan-greenspan/

full interview plus

"Elizabeth Warren on Alan Greenspan

Warren takes Greenspan to task for encouraging Americans short on cash to borrow against their homes. “That’s really scary financial advice for someone to be giving American families,” Warren said. “And what frightens me most is millions of American families have taken that advice.”


sabrina 1

(62,325 posts)
23. Bernie took on Greenspan also. Bernie and Elizabeth are the future of this country.
Tue Jul 14, 2015, 02:44 AM
Jul 2015

Across the globe, neo-liberal policies and their disastrous effects on the people, are being rejected. The Left is on the rise as people have had a good look at the policies that brought us forever, disastrous wars, economic collapse, corruption on Wall St, War Crimes, the collapse of the Middle/Working class, racism, inherrent in our Foreign Policies also, America diminished losing its moral authority.

Enough is enough! The people are ANGRY and those in power seem so out of touch with the reality of what they created and the rejection of that creation as they continue to deceive and deflect and support policies, see the TPP that are harmful to the people.

They ignore the people, and now the people are ignoring THEM and taking matters into their own hands, choosing their OWN candidates.

We are in a period of great change and those in the DC bubble appear to be the only ones who don't realize it.

slipslidingaway

(21,210 posts)
25. Bernie sure did ...
Fri Jul 17, 2015, 12:19 AM
Jul 2015

too many people turned a blind eye for years as to what was going on in our economy.

Bernie and Elizabeth have been consistent in their message about the shrinking middle class and people are angry ... the times are a changing.

Sorry for the late reply

wyldwolf

(43,869 posts)
7. But THEN...
Mon Jul 13, 2015, 08:07 PM
Jul 2015

It only took me 30 seconds of Googling to find this from a 2007 PBS interview between Maria Hinojosa and Elizabeth Warren

HINOJOSA: There's a story that I wanna share with our listeners that you actually shared when you were on Now—on our TV program and it's a fascinating story about Hillary Clinton. You said that when the credit card companies were pushing for legislation to tighten the bankruptcy laws, and this is when President Clinton was in office you were summoned by Hillary Clinton to discuss this legislation. And you sat down with her in this back room and you filled her in on what this new bankruptcy law was gonna mean.

And she at that moment said, "Oh my God. We have to stop this law. It's not gonna happen." It gets passed in Congress and Bill Clinton, because of Hillary's conversation with you more or less, vetoes that bill. Now we fast forward to Senator Hillary Clinton, bankruptcy law comes for a vote and she votes for it?

WARREN: Yes.


This excerpt was quoted and posted a lot at the time - not as any statement on Warren because none of us knew who she was back then. Rather, it was meant damning evidence of how Senator Clinton has changed.

But Warren made a clarification in that interview and gave, in my opinion, some very insightful information about working in Washington that we already know:

WARREN: ... So it was one thing for Mrs. Clinton to be First Lady and not running for office and tell President Clinton what she felt about this bill. And then very different for Senator Clinton who had to get political contributions and run her—her campaign—she voted differently. Now I wanna be fair in this story.

Mrs. Clinton, in a much more secure position—as Senator a couple of years later—when the bill came up once again—Senator Clinton was not there—the day of the vote. It was the day that President Clinton, you may remember, had heart surgery. But she issued a very strong press release condemning the bill and I assume if she had been there that she would have voted against it.
I—I tell my story not to try to thump Senator Clinton but the story is important because it's a reminder of how money talks in Washington.


Here is an excerpt from Clinton's statement on the bill:

This bankruptcy bill fundamentally fails to accord with the traditional purposes of bankruptcy, which recognize that we are all better off when hard-working people who have suffered financial catastrophe get a "fresh start" and a second chance to become productive and contributing members of society. With the passage of this legislation, which makes obtaining this fresh start more expensive and more difficult, we are ensuring that many responsible Americans will continue to be buried under mountains of debt, and unable to take back control and responsibility for their lives.


I also want to add Senator Clinton voted for every single amendment to add consumer protections to the bill - both times - each of which were rejected by both Republican majority and other Democrats. She voted against cloture in an attempt to keep the final bill from coming to a vote at all.

As a side note, Joe Biden not only voted for the 2005 bill, he rallied around it.

on edit:

Here's a great comment on the story:

This is a terrible article. The emphasis of this interview (either in broadcast and the exclusive online content) focuses mainly on Senator Warren's crusade to help the middle class and very, very little on Hillary Clinton. In fact, when Moyers presents the clip from the ten-year old interview and seems to seek new comments on Ms. Clinton from Warren the senator refocuses the conversation back to the issues. She avoids being placed in opposition to a fellow party member. Warren nearly excuses Clintons actions by talking about the pressures of being a senator versus a First Lady.

This interview is not about Hillary Clinton and is not about 2016 presidential issues. Sen. Warren is clearly frustrated with Moyers' desire to illicit some information about Warren's intentions in 2016 because she clearly believes that right now the emphasis should be on the 2014 election in which the balance of power in Congress is in question. While there may be some questions regarding Hillary Clinton's position as a progressive now is not the time and here, in front the Bill Moyers audience, is not the place.

Writing a headline and article about such a small and insignificant segment of this interview - most of which is based on comments made ten years ago - is misleading and irresponsible. It is typical of the kind of "click-bait" mentality blogs like this use to spike residuals for your advertisers, steer debate away from real issues that actually impact our lives and generally distort the meaning of what is and is not true discourse.

slipslidingaway

(21,210 posts)
11. Interesting ... "Clinton Slammed for Vote On 2001 Bankruptcy Bill
Mon Jul 13, 2015, 09:58 PM
Jul 2015
http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB120113997862512117

By
Damian Paletta

Updated Jan. 24, 2008 12:01 a.m. ET

"WASHINGTON -- Sen. Hillary Clinton is on the defensive for another vote aligned with President Bush early in her legislative career: this one for a measure to make it more difficult to erase personal debts through bankruptcy.

As the focus of debate for presidential candidates shifts from Iraq to the economy, Sen. Barack Obama has stepped up criticism of Sen. Clinton's 2001 bankruptcy vote, just as he has hammered her for her 2002 vote authorizing the Iraq War. The Illinois Democrat is citing Mrs. Clinton's bankruptcy vote as an example of why he is better-suited to protect consumers in an increasingly uncertain economic time.

And just as Mrs. Clinton has tried to distance herself from her Iraq vote, she has said she regrets her bankruptcy vote and wishes she could have it back.

The Bankruptcy Reform Act of 2001 that Sen. Clinton voted for eventually died in Congress, but a similar measure became law in 2005. Sen. Clinton has said she would have opposed the 2005 bill, but she missed the vote because she was with her husband during surgery.

The 2001 bill "had some things I agreed with and other things I didn't agree with, and I was happy that it never became law," Sen. Clinton said at a Jan. 15 debate in Las Vegas..."




slipslidingaway

(21,210 posts)
12. Would you post a link to this comment please ...
Mon Jul 13, 2015, 10:02 PM
Jul 2015

"Here's a great comment on the story:

This is a terrible article..."

Thx

DirkGently

(12,151 posts)
8. That bankruptcy law (BAPCPA) stole from the poor;
Mon Jul 13, 2015, 09:27 PM
Jul 2015

gave to credit card companies and no one else.

It was widely claimed by advocates of BAPCPA that its passage would reduce losses to creditors such as credit card companies, and that those creditors would then pass on the savings to other borrowers in the form of lower interest rates. These claims turned out to be false. After BAPCPA passed, although credit card company losses decreased, prices charged to customers increased, and credit card company profits soared

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bankruptcy_Abuse_Prevention_and_Consumer_Protection_Act

I remember seeing one of the bill's sponsors, an annoying Florida Republican named McCollum, address a group of bankruptcy lawyers about the bill. The debtors' lawyers tried to ask questions, at which point it became clear McCollum had a few talking points from the banks, and zero understanding of bankruptcy law.

It was a nearly pure example of how monied interests concoct schemes to put money in their pockets at ordinary peoples' expense. They even crafted in political cover -- it would reduce "fraud" in bankruptcy, which was not an issue on the scale suggested, nor were the suggested reforms a cure. And it was shot through with the premise that people who file bankruptcy must be irresponsible idiots. To this day, bankrupt people have to attend nonsense "financial counseling" in order to get relief from the crushing debt that is typically caused by a failed business or huge medical expenses.

This is a worry with Hillary. How can she stand against policy like that, when the financial industry gives her so much support? She may want to; she may intend to.

But those millions don't come with no strings attached.

karynnj

(59,504 posts)
24. in 2005, she did vote to filibuster it, but the Democrats
Tue Jul 14, 2015, 02:51 AM
Jul 2015

Could not stop the Republicans from getting the needed 60 votes. After this vote failed, she missed the vote on the bill itself which was not even close.

loveallserveall

(11 posts)
13. Thanks for this
Mon Jul 13, 2015, 10:49 PM
Jul 2015

Thanks for this Snotcicles...a wonderful firsthand illustration of HRC's questionable trustworthiness.

 

Snotcicles

(9,089 posts)
14. She actually didn't vote on the bill in 2005. but it did pass.
Mon Jul 13, 2015, 11:00 PM
Jul 2015

As far as I can tell it was her first missed vote, as Senator.

slipslidingaway

(21,210 posts)
18. Clinton voted for the 2001 Bankruptcy bill, link to vote and another video with Warren ...
Tue Jul 14, 2015, 12:39 AM
Jul 2015
http://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_lists/roll_call_vote_cfm.cfm?&congress=107&session=1&vote=00036

Warren Slams Democrats (Like Hillary/Biden) For Supporting Bankruptcy Bill (video and text)
https://www.americarisingpac.org/warren-slams-democrats-like-hillarybiden-supporting-bankruptcy-bill/

"Speaking at the JFK Library in Boston earlier today, Sen. Elizabeth Warren was asked about Democrats that supported a Bush-era bankruptcy bill that won bipartisan support. Warren began her impassioned 5-minute answer by saying, “God, it was awful,” before hammering Democrats, like Clinton and Biden, for surrendering to an “army of lobbyists” and inspiring her fight for consumer advocacy.

In her previous book, The Two Income Trap, Warren singled out Clinton for criticism among Democrats that supported the bankruptcy bill, saying she “could not afford such a principled position,” and noted the contributions she received from banking and industry executives:


In the spring of 2001, the bankruptcy bill was reintroduced in the Senate, essentially unchanged from the version President Clinton had vetoed the previous year. This time freshman Senator Hillary Clinton voted in favor of the bill. Had the bill been transformed to get rid of all those awful provisions that had so concerned First Lady Hillary Clinton? The bill was essentially the same, but Hillary Rodham Clinton was not. As First Lady, Mrs. Clinton had been persuaded that the bill was bad for families, and she was willing to fight for her beliefs. Her husband was a lame duck at the time he vetoed the bill; he could afford to forgo future campaign contributions. As New York’s newest senator, however, it seems that Hillary Clinton could not afford such a principled position. Campaigns cost money, and that money wasn’t coming from families in financial trouble. Senator Clinton received $140,000 in campaign contributions from banking industry executives in a single year, making her one of the top two recipients in the Senate. Big banks were now part of Senator Clinton’s constituency. She wanted their support, and they wanted hers—including a vote in favor of “that awful bill.”

During the 2008 Democratic primaries, Clinton under fire from President Obama, said she regretted her previous support for the bankruptcy bill:
..."

Clinton later said she was happy it did not pass.

http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB120113997862512117

"...As the focus of debate for presidential candidates shifts from Iraq to the economy, Sen. Barack Obama has stepped up criticism of Sen. Clinton's 2001 bankruptcy vote, just as he has hammered her for her 2002 vote authorizing the Iraq War. The Illinois Democrat is citing Mrs. Clinton's bankruptcy vote as an example of why he is better-suited to protect consumers in an increasingly uncertain economic time.

And just as Mrs. Clinton has tried to distance herself from her Iraq vote, she has said she regrets her bankruptcy vote and wishes she could have it back.

The Bankruptcy Reform Act of 2001 that Sen. Clinton voted for eventually died in Congress, but a similar measure became law in 2005. Sen. Clinton has said she would have opposed the 2005 bill, but she missed the vote because she was with her husband during surgery..."



 

Snotcicles

(9,089 posts)
19. The last vote was 2/2005. Bill Clinton's quadruple bypass surgery was in 9/2004 if I'm not mistaken.
Tue Jul 14, 2015, 12:47 AM
Jul 2015

So as far as I can tell these dates ain't lining up.

slipslidingaway

(21,210 posts)
20. Clinton definitely voted for the 2001 bankruptcy bill ...
Tue Jul 14, 2015, 01:00 AM
Jul 2015

and then later said she was glad it did not become law???

The 2005 bankruptcy bill passed the Senate in March 2005 with Clinton not voting, five months after his surgery???

An excuse to miss that vote.



http://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_lists/roll_call_vote_cfm.cfm?&congress=109&session=1&vote=00044

Bill Clinton had open heart surgery in early September 2004

Former President Clinton Undergoes Successful Open Heart Surgery

http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/white_house-july-dec04-clinton_9-6/

September 6, 2004 at 12:00 AM EDT

"REPORTER: When might he be released from the hospital and when might he be able to return to a normal schedule? As you know he had a very busy schedule for the next couple of weeks – months.

DR. CRAIG SMITH: That’s hard to give specific answers to, except I can answer you in generality based on experience with similar patients which is to say that it would be common for him to be ready to leave the hospital within four or five days.

Right now, based on how he’s doing, there’s no reason to think he wouldn’t fall within the same experience. After that, people are usually 70 percent or so back to baseline by around six weeks."



slipslidingaway

(21,210 posts)
22. Thx, voting when you have the power to make a difference means more ...
Tue Jul 14, 2015, 02:29 AM
Jul 2015

than some campaign speech.

I remember what Obama said when he was trying to gain support for the bailouts ' who could have known about the impending financial crisis?'

Well plenty of people had a clue including Sanders and Warren.

Very instructive to go back in time and to see who saw the problems at the time instead of looking in the rear view mirror. We need someone who has the foresight, not someone who jumps on the bandwagon when it is politically expedient.

Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»2016 Postmortem»A good video of E Warren ...