Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search
 

Vattel

(9,289 posts)
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 01:37 PM Jul 2015

Advice: When you speak truth to power, make sure the power is not an ally in your struggle.

Reagan had been failing miserably to address the AIDS epidemic when Act Up disrupted his speech. That was speaking truth to power at its finest.

As chief executive President Obama bore responsibility for the unsafe conditions at INS detention centers that led Jennicet Gutiérrez to interrupt Obama's Pride Month reception address. That too was a respectable attempt to speak truth to power.

But Sanders is an ally in the struggle to end institutional racism, to reform police departments that threaten the lives of black men and women, and to bring equality of opportunity to blacks. Therefore he was not the right target for speaking truth to power in relation to those issues.

He was even a worse target because shouting at him could be used to further the bullshit meme that he doesn't really care about issues of racial justice. Clinton, whose record on issues of race is inferior to Sanders' record, ends up benefitting politically.

There is a lot of righteous anger that motivated the shouting at Sanders at the Netroots event. I don't really blame the BLM people for what happened. But I do think it was an understandable mistake to go after Sanders the way they did.

49 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Advice: When you speak truth to power, make sure the power is not an ally in your struggle. (Original Post) Vattel Jul 2015 OP
Amen. HooptieWagon Jul 2015 #1
Why would they be burning bridges? gwheezie Jul 2015 #3
Good question, it's a perplexing strategy... HooptieWagon Jul 2015 #5
We are witnessing negative campaigning at its worst. This is what the money they sabrina 1 Jul 2015 #2
Black Lives Matter was founded by 3 black feminists. Skwmom Jul 2015 #4
Who funds them, and what candidate do they support? HooptieWagon Jul 2015 #6
There is this... Maedhros Jul 2015 #15
FACT: when you're candidate is running for POTUS he's got media around him KittyWampus Jul 2015 #7
OMG, stop it! Just stop it! scarletwoman Jul 2015 #8
I don't have a problem with them trying to push people to address this issue. Skwmom Jul 2015 #12
So what? It's a simple fix - take on the message of the protestors and help amplify it. scarletwoman Jul 2015 #14
This message was self-deleted by its author Maedhros Jul 2015 #16
If I disagree with someone, I show them the respect of telling them why. Vattel Jul 2015 #23
If you read my post I told you exactly what I thought was wrong about your OP. scarletwoman Jul 2015 #30
So I am not allowed to disagree with how BLM conducts a protest? Okay, got it, I will try to behave Vattel Jul 2015 #31
Poor you. scarletwoman Jul 2015 #39
No need for sympathy, I was being sarcastic. Vattel Jul 2015 #40
AMEN! missingthebigdog Jul 2015 #34
If someone is drowning, all the more reason not to engage in self-defeating behavior. Vattel Jul 2015 #43
Absolutely. missingthebigdog Jul 2015 #45
Exactly. It's NOT about Sanders. It's NOT about Hillary. It's NOT about O'Malley. LISTEN and LEARN. Metric System Jul 2015 #47
What troubles me... 99Forever Jul 2015 #9
could you post a link to your conversations with members of BLM? KittyWampus Jul 2015 #11
Well, lucky for BLM that they have a good supporter like you to tell them how scarletwoman Jul 2015 #21
I'm not telling them how to do anything. 99Forever Jul 2015 #35
Here's a quote from your post: scarletwoman Jul 2015 #37
So what? 99Forever Jul 2015 #46
If you're that easily dissuaded, maybe you're not really a solid ally? Or, worse, an ally of Metric System Jul 2015 #48
For someone who doesn't know me... 99Forever Jul 2015 #49
IOW... Bobbie Jo Jul 2015 #10
If only those black people would just listen to the white people tell them what to do... tammywammy Jul 2015 #13
Typical unfair response Vattel Jul 2015 #17
So unfair Bobbie Jo Jul 2015 #18
It was totally right on. It was totally accurate. scarletwoman Jul 2015 #19
No, go yell at the people who aren't actually talking about it. jeff47 Jul 2015 #20
Good thing those poor confused protestors have folks like you to set them straight. nt scarletwoman Jul 2015 #22
You should have more respect for the protestors. Vattel Jul 2015 #24
Oh, like you have respect for them? I'm sure they treasure your "advice" about their tactics. scarletwoman Jul 2015 #28
I do have respect for them. They are fighting for a good cause. Vattel Jul 2015 #36
Yell at anyone and EVERYONE. Bobbie Jo Jul 2015 #25
The only "you should be grateful" is in your head. jeff47 Jul 2015 #27
Apparently Bobbie Jo Jul 2015 #32
I know why. There's plenty of ratfucking going on. jeff47 Jul 2015 #38
Excellent demonstration. Bobbie Jo Jul 2015 #42
It's always effective to declare yourself the winner and then leave jeff47 Jul 2015 #44
Bullshit. nt LWolf Jul 2015 #29
Not clear, but I think... HassleCat Jul 2015 #26
Just saw this on my Facebook feed 10 minutes ago tkmorris Jul 2015 #33
Wouldn't it make more sense to get in the face of the President? truebrit71 Jul 2015 #41

gwheezie

(3,580 posts)
3. Why would they be burning bridges?
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 01:46 PM
Jul 2015

You may be underestimating your candidate. If Bernie is the person you think he is, he of all people may recognize this for what it is. Why would you think Bernie would not attempt to address these concerns because he got shouted down at one event? Your feelings are hurt, don't put that on Bernie

 

HooptieWagon

(17,064 posts)
5. Good question, it's a perplexing strategy...
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 01:57 PM
Jul 2015

...unless there's parties behind the curtain who will benefit from driving a wedge between progressives and minorities, who are natural allies.

sabrina 1

(62,325 posts)
2. We are witnessing negative campaigning at its worst. This is what the money they
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 01:46 PM
Jul 2015

take buys. Lies, deceptions, the politics of personal destruction.

But times have changed since they were able to get away with this kind of despicable campaigning.

Social Media is all over them the minute they start.

Bernie continues to soar, and the harm they hoped would stop his rise is resulting in a backlash on their own candidate. Her numbers continue to drop, while his continue to rise.

Skwmom

(12,685 posts)
4. Black Lives Matter was founded by 3 black feminists.
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 01:49 PM
Jul 2015

They were honored by the New York Women's Foundation (women helping women) in May of this year. http://www.nywf.org/2015-cwb-honorees/

So which candidate do you think they support?


 

HooptieWagon

(17,064 posts)
6. Who funds them, and what candidate do they support?
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 01:59 PM
Jul 2015

Who benefits from driving a wedge between progressives and minorities?

 

Maedhros

(10,007 posts)
15. There is this...
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 02:35 PM
Jul 2015
http://www.nywf.org/tag/secretary-clinton/

Secretary Clinton Delivers the Keynote Address and Receives the Century Award at the New York Women’s Foundation Breakfast

 

KittyWampus

(55,894 posts)
7. FACT: when you're candidate is running for POTUS he's got media around him
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 02:01 PM
Jul 2015

and protestors seeking to get their word out are going to try and get that media exposure.

scarletwoman

(31,893 posts)
8. OMG, stop it! Just stop it!
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 02:04 PM
Jul 2015

It was NOT a mistake to do what BLM did yesterday! NOBODY has the right to tell the people who are being MURDERED just because of their skin color how and when it's appropriate to express their anger about it!

My god, this is NOT about Bernie, it's about people who are crying out and need to be heard! So what, that his little speech got messed up? What the hell IS the priority here? Not to inconvenience us nice white progressives with loud, messy direct action?

If Bernie is all that - and I'm certainly hoping that he will prove himself to be so - then he will take protestors' message to heart and reach out to them and open a real dialogue with them and place for them in his campaign.

Pressing for radical change is NOT about being polite. It's not about observing customary niceties. It's not about not discomfitting anyone. It's about disruption, it's about transgression, it's about letting your outrage be known - especially where there are others who would hopefully "get it"! You give those who claim to be on your side a chance to really prove it!

And dammit, it's just blowing my mind and breaking my heart to see all the posts since yesterday from all the people who love to claim they're on the side of POC, doing all this tut-tutting about how the BLM behaved badly and how it wasn't fair to Bernie.

And then, even worse, those that have been ginning up a bunch of conspiracy shit that absolutely DISMISSES and DEVALUES the very real pain and suffering that motivated the BLM people to take the action they did - as if there were no higher value to defend than a political campaign! A political campaign! More important than people who are actually dying?!?!

I feel deeply ashamed and embarrassed to be identified as a white progressive when I see all this shit.

Advice: don't fucking give advice to people who have been living through shit you will never have live through. Just shut up and listen and then ask what you can do.

Skwmom

(12,685 posts)
12. I don't have a problem with them trying to push people to address this issue.
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 02:11 PM
Jul 2015

Their concerns are extremely valid. What I have a problem with is the blatant misleading spin which took place afterward.

scarletwoman

(31,893 posts)
14. So what? It's a simple fix - take on the message of the protestors and help amplify it.
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 02:32 PM
Jul 2015

You want to be a civil rights hero today, here and now? Then up your game and include them.

No amount of spin can hurt you if you're acting in integrity.

Frankly, the worst spin I've been seeing has been self-inflicted. Instead of embracing and welcoming the righteous message of the protestors, too many are getting defensive and paranoid. It's pathetic, it's disgusting.

Stand up, stand with the protestors, have faith in what you claim your guy believes in.

Response to scarletwoman (Reply #14)

 

Vattel

(9,289 posts)
23. If I disagree with someone, I show them the respect of telling them why.
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 03:24 PM
Jul 2015

If I am wrong, they are free to tell me that I am wrong. I defended Guttierez when she disrupted Obama's celebration even though she was roundly condemned on DU. I am all for direct action. In this case I thought the target was ill-chosen. If I am wrong, show me I am wrong. But don't tell me that I have no right to even express an opinion.

scarletwoman

(31,893 posts)
30. If you read my post I told you exactly what I thought was wrong about your OP.
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 03:49 PM
Jul 2015

You are apparently operating under the misconception that POC have any reason to want or need your opinion of how they conduct their protest.

I think that's incredibly condescending and arrogant of you, and you ought to be embarrassed.

 

Vattel

(9,289 posts)
31. So I am not allowed to disagree with how BLM conducts a protest? Okay, got it, I will try to behave
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 03:58 PM
Jul 2015

like a good little white boy.

missingthebigdog

(1,233 posts)
34. AMEN!
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 04:04 PM
Jul 2015

People who are drowning don't politely raise their hands and wait their turn in hopes that someone will notice or get around to helping them.

Black Americans are dealing with an emergency. Their children are being killed in the streets. They are being attacked in places of worship. They are dying suspiciously in jails. They are disproportionally targeted by law enforcement, and disproportionally represented in the prison population.

ANYTHING that brings more light to their plight is an appropriate action. People that are arguing that they should have waited, been polite, had a dialogue, do not understand the urgency of the situation.

missingthebigdog

(1,233 posts)
45. Absolutely.
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 04:49 PM
Jul 2015

Makes more sense to die quietly so as not to inconvenience anyone.

I hope the sarcasm tag is unnecessary.....

99Forever

(14,524 posts)
9. What troubles me...
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 02:07 PM
Jul 2015

... is that I completely support BLM and what they are trying to achieve. I would be less than honest not say that this incident has left a very bad taste in my mouth.

You don't build support or get things done by crapping on your allies. I've asked several times for someone from BLM to please explain their strategy in doing this in this manner. I've yet to hear a reasoned answer.

 

KittyWampus

(55,894 posts)
11. could you post a link to your conversations with members of BLM?
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 02:11 PM
Jul 2015

Where exactly is your conversation happening. I'm curious.

Cause I don't think it's members spend much time on DU looking for your posts to answer your questions.

But maybe you are on another forum asking people who can answer you.

99Forever

(14,524 posts)
35. I'm not telling them how to do anything.
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 04:09 PM
Jul 2015

But thanks ever so much for the snark, it's so very becoming.

Bless your heart.

scarletwoman

(31,893 posts)
37. Here's a quote from your post:
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 04:16 PM
Jul 2015
You don't build support or get things done by crapping on your allies.

99Forever

(14,524 posts)
46. So what?
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 05:12 PM
Jul 2015

I stated my opinion. If you don't like, that's not my problem. Nor I am I going to argue with you about it.

Metric System

(6,048 posts)
48. If you're that easily dissuaded, maybe you're not really a solid ally? Or, worse, an ally of
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 05:30 PM
Jul 2015

convenience.

99Forever

(14,524 posts)
49. For someone who doesn't know me...
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 05:33 PM
Jul 2015

... you certainly are very quick to make a lot of false assumptions.

I'll take the exact same liberties with you.

Bless your heart.

tammywammy

(26,582 posts)
13. If only those black people would just listen to the white people tell them what to do...
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 02:16 PM
Jul 2015

This board has gone fucking nuts.

Bobbie Jo

(14,341 posts)
18. So unfair
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 03:13 PM
Jul 2015

Please read the other responses in this thread. Apparently you skipped past those to get to mine.

jeff47

(26,549 posts)
20. No, go yell at the people who aren't actually talking about it.
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 03:20 PM
Jul 2015

If the goal is to get people to talk about your issues, stopping the people who are already talking about them is not productive.

 

Vattel

(9,289 posts)
24. You should have more respect for the protestors.
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 03:29 PM
Jul 2015

I am sure most of them can handle honest disagreement.

 

Vattel

(9,289 posts)
36. I do have respect for them. They are fighting for a good cause.
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 04:11 PM
Jul 2015

You don't seem to realize that I can disagree with them and still respect them.

Bobbie Jo

(14,341 posts)
25. Yell at anyone and EVERYONE.
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 03:30 PM
Jul 2015

If this board is any indication of the dismissive attitude that exists among "our own," then "yell" at them FIRST and LOUDEST.

This off-putting attitude of "you should be grateful" is about as non-productive as it gets.

jeff47

(26,549 posts)
27. The only "you should be grateful" is in your head.
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 03:40 PM
Jul 2015

Text is not a perfectly expressive medium. Thus you injected "You should be grateful" into the post. It wasn't there.

Here's Sanders in 1991, in the middle of the "tough on crime" bullshit, under a Republican president, saying that massive incarceration of blacks was bad.

It's been a consistent issue with Sanders for a very long time. The meme that he only cares about older whites is not actually true. And BLM's efforts helped to continue the falsehood.

So how did shouting down Sanders help them, when he was already on-board with their cause?

Bobbie Jo

(14,341 posts)
32. Apparently
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 03:58 PM
Jul 2015

They didn't feel "on-board" in the least. Instead of asking WHY, we get this STFU attitude, and absolutely NO listening. None.

These dismissive posts reek of "you should be grateful" and "don't bite the hand that feeds you."

Feet to fire, etc...

jeff47

(26,549 posts)
38. I know why. There's plenty of ratfucking going on.
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 04:17 PM
Jul 2015

Sanders's civil rights record is a strength, so anyone who doesn't want Sanders on the ballot is attacking him on it. (Note that this is not saying the Clinton campaign did it. There's many more that want a nice giant fracture in the Democratic party going into the general election). Since he started out more-or-less unknown, his opponents in both parties had a chance to define him before he did. And BLM went with what "everyone knows" instead of looking it up for themselves.

I am not saying STFU. I'm saying do basic research before you attack.

jeff47

(26,549 posts)
44. It's always effective to declare yourself the winner and then leave
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 04:32 PM
Jul 2015

It even avoids pesky things like talking about something you don't want to talk about.

Hey...that sounds familiar....

 

HassleCat

(6,409 posts)
26. Not clear, but I think...
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 03:37 PM
Jul 2015

The people who harangued the candidates have a different idea of how to address racism. They feel government programs such as fair housing, equal employment opportunity, job training, etc. have done nothing. The believe talk about better policing, prison reform, etc. is just more of the same. They say racial justice I not tied to economic justice, that we must eliminate structural racism, which may or may nit be the same as institutional racism. I'm not clear on what that means, or what they propose to do. They don't seem to clear, either. As far as I can tell, they are quick to say, "What you're doing is wrong." But they have difficulty explaining what would be right.

tkmorris

(11,138 posts)
33. Just saw this on my Facebook feed 10 minutes ago
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 04:03 PM
Jul 2015


It seemed relevant. Also notice he used the hashtag #BlackLivesMatter versus the more generic #AllLivesMatter.
 

truebrit71

(20,805 posts)
41. Wouldn't it make more sense to get in the face of the President?
Sun Jul 19, 2015, 04:21 PM
Jul 2015

You know, the guy in charge???? Or does he get a pass???

Latest Discussions»Retired Forums»2016 Postmortem»Advice: When you speak tr...