Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Passengers watched killing on Metro car. Should they have intervened? [View all]stevenleser
(32,886 posts)55. That's exactly what the bystander effect covers. Kitty Genovese was a prime example that
prompted this whole line of study
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bystander_effect
The case of Kitty Genovese is often cited and occasionally criticized as an example of the "bystander effect". It is also the case that originally stimulated social psychological research in this area. On March 13, 1964 Genovese, 28 years old, was on her way back to her Queens, New York, apartment from work at 3am when she was stabbed to death by a serial rapist and murderer. According to newspaper accounts, the attack lasted for at least a half an hour during which time Genovese screamed and pleaded for help. The murderer attacked Genovese and stabbed her, then fled the scene after attracting the attention of a neighbor. The killer then returned ten minutes later and finished the assault. Newspaper reports after Genovese's death claimed that 38 witnesses watched the stabbings and failed to intervene or even contact the police until after the attacker fled and Genovese had died. This led to widespread public attention, and many editorials.
According to an article published in American Psychologist in 2007, the original story of Genovese's murder was exaggerated by the media. Specifically, there were not 38 eyewitnesses, the police were contacted at least once during the attack, and many of the bystanders who overheard the attack could not actually see the event. The authors of the article suggest that the story continues to be misrepresented in social psychology textbooks because it functions as a parable and serves as a dramatic example for students
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
145 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
Passengers watched killing on Metro car. Should they have intervened? [View all]
mahatmakanejeeves
Jul 2015
OP
yes... i would... and i would expect some of those other dozen or so to help
ProdigalJunkMail
Jul 2015
#4
It's not a disturbing statement about our culture; its a phenomenon of being human.
Brickbat
Jul 2015
#5
We are a herd. When you're in a herd, it creates something called the diffusion of responsibility.
Brickbat
Jul 2015
#11
I'm sure that you'd reach right through the internet and grab the knife from his hand.
Orrex
Jul 2015
#19
Since his claims are contrary to my experience of reality, I require evidence to believe him.
Orrex
Jul 2015
#44
That's exactly what the bystander effect covers. Kitty Genovese was a prime example that
stevenleser
Jul 2015
#55
Yes, back in the 60s there was a case where an elderly man was murdered on the street while
jwirr
Jul 2015
#21
The attack took place between the Rhode Island Avenue and NoMa-Gallaudet U Metro stops.
mahatmakanejeeves
Jul 2015
#52
That's the right name, but the story is more complex than initially presented, I have heard.
mahatmakanejeeves
Jul 2015
#6
with a madman flailing away with a knife? I'd keep my distance. I value my carotid artery too much
geek tragedy
Jul 2015
#12
The linked article lists two of the witnesses as a 52 year old woman and her 76 year old father
Bluenorthwest
Jul 2015
#17
yes I did in fact ask you if you'd ever been on a subway because it seems your knowledge is limited
msanthrope
Jul 2015
#90
so there you are on the subway with a.22 sport gun that isn't made for self defense
msanthrope
Jul 2015
#114
And when you get within 5-10 feet in a shaky enclosed space, gun advantage is almost negated
stevenleser
Jul 2015
#115
I think she is asking because its often so shaky in a moving subway car you can't stand up without
stevenleser
Jul 2015
#92
"Almost always a gun is going to make the perp stop and run away if possible."
mahatmakanejeeves
Jul 2015
#139
Be 18+ yoa, get approved through "District of Columbia Self-Defense Spray Registration Form," and
Eleanors38
Jul 2015
#75
In DC watching is the most you can do since they've disarmed all but cops and criminals.
ileus
Jul 2015
#40
The truth. Once legally disarmed, does an atmosphere of impotence prevail....
Eleanors38
Jul 2015
#67
As someone who took public transportation in L.A. quite a bit, it's not anywhere that bad
AZ Progressive
Jul 2015
#71
There is cell service in the tunnels, but this part is above ground. NT
mahatmakanejeeves
Jul 2015
#57
It's probably hard to get a mob going when everyone just watched a man butcher another man
Rex
Jul 2015
#74
Then the suspect likely would have attacked whoever it was that swung the backpack.
LisaL
Jul 2015
#86
It's a classic ethical excercise - when does a bystander have responisbility to intervene?
haele
Jul 2015
#63
Connecticut congressman speaks out on slain American University graduate
mahatmakanejeeves
Jul 2015
#80
I intervened once in a mugging, because I thought the 20-30 people nearby would back me up.
bettyellen
Jul 2015
#77
I would have intervened, but I also worked as a bouncer in one of the roughest biker bars in
Ghost in the Machine
Jul 2015
#84
Not always... there were times that I would be a real a$$hole just because nobody could do anything
Ghost in the Machine
Jul 2015
#125
Thank you... I am so laid back now that I tell people that if I were any more laid back, I'd be like
Ghost in the Machine
Jul 2015
#127
I would hope if I was with several other healthy people, men and Women, that we would all
randys1
Jul 2015
#104
This would be a good time for people to read up on the "Good Samaritan" laws...
roamer65
Jul 2015
#105
Should they have intervened? Yes. Should they be condemned for not doing so? No. n/t
Gormy Cuss
Jul 2015
#121