Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Nonhlanhla

(2,074 posts)
40. They were misdiagnosed
Mon Jan 6, 2014, 12:37 PM
Jan 2014

From what I've read, both of those individuals were misdiagnosed. Steven Thorpe, for example, was in a chemically induced coma, and you cannot really declare someone brain dead when they're in a chemically induced coma (why would he even be in a chemically induced coma if he was brain dead?). According to media reports, his CT scans showed "almost irreversible" injury, which is not the same as brain death, since someone can survive an irreversible injury. Also, it does happen occasionally that people recover from traumatic brain injuries (like Steven Thorpe's, which was the result of car accident), but usually not in victims of brain injury due to lack of oxygen or blood flow in the brain (e.g. heart attack victims like Jahi). And no one who has ever met ALL the criteria for brain death (like Jahi does and Steven Thorpe did not) has ever woken up.

The mother should be allowed to do what she wishes bigwillq Jan 2014 #1
Her daughter is already dead. AtheistCrusader Jan 2014 #3
Agreed. ScreamingMeemie Jan 2014 #26
I watched the mother exactly once Scairp Jan 2014 #32
Is she going to try to take the child out to the New York hospital without medical support. NYC_SKP Jan 2014 #2
"Judge Grillo...not(ed) the girl could be moved with the ventilator she is now using." rocktivity Jan 2014 #4
I hope she has an attorney. Wait Wut Jan 2014 #5
TRULY heartbreaking! Bigmack Jan 2014 #9
According to this update, a death certificate has been issued rocktivity Jan 2014 #6
California must have public health laws.... tomp Jan 2014 #22
The certificate doesn't have a CAUSE of death, of course, because an autopsy hasn't been done rocktivity Jan 2014 #24
I understand, but.... tomp Jan 2014 #25
Now that she's "officially" dead, disposing of Jahi properly is all the family CAN do rocktivity Jan 2014 #28
but that is apparently NOT what the family intends to do. tomp Jan 2014 #37
This means some needy child will be without a ventilator cosmicone Jan 2014 #7
The family probably did not 840high Jan 2014 #8
I hope not, since they still think she is alive... Thor_MN Jan 2014 #11
Corpses cannot "survive" anything. Just sayin'. kestrel91316 Jan 2014 #10
You mean "clear to take her CORPSE from hospital" Codeine Jan 2014 #12
Stakes are Higher for Schiavo Supporters ninjanurse Jan 2014 #13
I would have agreed with you until Julie our Sr bldg President in 2008 kickysnana Jan 2014 #14
My total sympathy is with the family. I don't 840high Jan 2014 #17
This case is not that Scairp Jan 2014 #33
You also have to wonder if this had been a blond blue eyed girl if opinions would be different. Violette_Crime Jan 2014 #43
Here's an interesting post on the case Nonhlanhla Jan 2014 #15
That is an excellent blog post, thank you for sharing that. n/t Butterbean Jan 2014 #18
Terrific blog post. That was no "simple tonsillectomy" as the MSM describes it over and over.... Hekate Jan 2014 #21
The writer believes shite in the SFGate message board comments? Gormy Cuss Jan 2014 #29
True, but... Nonhlanhla Jan 2014 #31
You are incorrect JohninPA Jan 2014 #38
They were misdiagnosed Nonhlanhla Jan 2014 #40
It's really "organ support", not life support...n/t PasadenaTrudy Jan 2014 #16
It's not even that Nonhlanhla Jan 2014 #19
I agree, quite creepy n/t PasadenaTrudy Jan 2014 #23
Let her go awoke_in_2003 Jan 2014 #20
To move her from one coast to the other... Historic NY Jan 2014 #27
they have. magical thyme Jan 2014 #30
an anonymous doctor has volunteered to do it. warrant46 Jan 2014 #34
I wouldn't be surprised... magical thyme Jan 2014 #35
Wow warrant46 Jan 2014 #36
Heartbreaking case, but the parents should let her go. Beacool Jan 2014 #39
They are religious people, and I hope that their god will soon help them accept their daughter's Sheldon Cooper Jan 2014 #41
Yes, it is. Beacool Jan 2014 #42
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Jahi McMath's mom clear t...»Reply #40