Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

The DU Lounge

In reply to the discussion: What do you hear? [View all]

mia

(8,363 posts)
3. It's the audio version of "The Dress".
Wed May 16, 2018, 05:51 AM
May 2018
A Linguist Explains Why 'Laurel' Sounds Like 'Yanny'
It’s the audio version of The Dress.

Late Monday night, this tweet was posted by a 20-year-old Instagram “influencer” named Cloe Feldman. It appears to be a screengrab of a poll that also appears on Feldman’s Instagram account (although the Instagram version was posted after the Twitter one, but the poll design is clearly Instagram-original, don’t ask me). On Feldman’s Instagram, yanny was in the lead as of press time with 51 percent of the vote. (If you can’t hear it, it sounds like yeah knee.) Another Instagram account, @KFCRadio, also added the poll to their Instagram story. As of press time, laurel was winning that one with 53 percent.

Having read this far, you may be outraged, and/or concerned about hearing loss. Because neither @CloeCouture nor @KFCRadio has responded to my request for comment yet (and neither has @Yanni), I can’t say anything about how or why the clip was made. But I do have a degree in linguistics, so I can hazard a guess about why this two-syllable recording is driving everyone bonkers.


When you speak, you’re producing sound waves that are shaped by the length and shape of your vocal tract, which includes your larynx, throat, vocal folds (vocal cords is a misnomer), mouth, and nose. Linguists can study these sound waves and separate them out into their component frequencies, and display them in something called a spectrogram. Here’s the spectrogram for the yanny/laurel recording....




https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/05/dont-rest-on-your-laurels/560483/
What do you hear? [View all] mia May 2018 OP
I DESPISE stuff like this being misused by the MSM implying its an example of how divided we are and populistdriven May 2018 #1
It's the audio version of "The Dress". mia May 2018 #3
Yes, and like the DRESS it is subject to interpretation BUT it is not an example of populistdriven May 2018 #4
Never knew that that "the dress" was used to show how Americans are divided. mia May 2018 #6
they said verbatim that the yanny was an example of this on CNN this morning populistdriven May 2018 #7
Reminds me of this. mia May 2018 #8
Which for some strange reason reminds me of this (why is the grass green?) populistdriven May 2018 #9
Starts with a Y clearly but sounds like YeRRy to me underpants May 2018 #2
Can you be sure that it isn't BOTH and the words have been superimposed? no_hypocrisy May 2018 #5
I hear both, but not at same time, I have to concentrate and then Exotica May 2018 #10
I hear Yanny at first but can hear the end of Laurel in a lower tone. NightWatcher May 2018 #11
I tried to switch it, but I couldn't. Iggo May 2018 #12
I hear Laurel only... Phentex May 2018 #13
Yanny. I can't even frogmarch May 2018 #14
Laurel and only Laurel. Ron Obvious May 2018 #15
Boy, me too. Laffy Kat May 2018 #17
I keep trying to think Laurel and dhol82 May 2018 #27
This morning heard the higher-pitched Yanny, and now only hearing the lower-pitched Laurel Donkees May 2018 #16
I just heard it on the radio on NPR and it was clearly Laurel underpants May 2018 #18
I just listened again, and it's back to Yanny, Yanny, Yanny :) Donkees May 2018 #19
Do You Hear "Yanny" or "Laurel"? (SOLVED with SCIENCE) mia May 2018 #20
I heard Yanny at a low volume, and Laurel at a high volume. demmiblue May 2018 #21
It was bound to happen LostOne4Ever May 2018 #22
It's going to be fun times for those named Laurel. mia May 2018 #23
That's my new favorite website. Iggo May 2018 #24
Yanny, but I heard Laurel once when I turned up the volume. demmiblue May 2018 #25
I would have voted, but you failed to include ashling May 2018 #26
Yesterday I only heard, "Yammy" and today I only hear Laurel LeftInTX May 2018 #28
What do you see? sl8 May 2018 #29
Good one! mia May 2018 #30
Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»What do you hear?»Reply #3